The Bill Where the Exception Disappeared

Minister of Employment and Labor Kim Young-hoon met with the leadership of the Korean Confederation of Trade Unions (KCTU) on the 3rd and reaffirmed that he would push for legislation based on what was agreed in social dialogue. But what was confirmed on the 9th is that the promise is already surrounded by a square. The special committee was formed at the plenary session on the 5th. Its members are 10 from the Democratic Party of Korea, 6 from the People Power Party, and 2 from non-negotiating groups, totaling 18, and its activity period runs until January 31 of next year. And the subject of review is not just one. The bill proposed by Representative Park Sang-hyuk on the 20th of last month includes exceptions to the 52-hour workweek, expansion of the settlement period for the selective working hours system, and extension of the period for using fixed-term workers. The bill proposed by Representative Choi Ki-sang the next day does not contain those provisions. A bill containing labor exceptions and a bill without them were placed side by side in the same committee. It is not that the provisions demanded by capital were withdrawn, but that the withdrawn version is placed next to it and it is decided which one to bring out depending on public opinion and the results of consultations. At the 8th working-level consultative body on the 13th, the Ministry of Labor said it is highly likely that discussions on settlement support, not industrial safety and working hours, will continue once more. The order was set by the vice-ministerial operating consultative body on the 2nd. Basic goals and settlement support, then industrial safety and health and working hours and health rights, then employment types and worker protection, and finally labor-management relations and participation. The meeting dealing with the main issues sits at the very back within the special committee's deadline.

On top of that order table, what each side demands was also revealed this week. The Korea Enterprises Federation proposed white-collar exemption, expansion of the flexible and selective working hours system, extension of the period for using fixed-term workers, and expansion of the use of dispatched workers. Added to this is the sentence that the scope of exception application needs to be expanded beyond the special zones. With that one sentence, the Special Zones Act ceases to be a law about special zones. The KCTU's demands point in the opposite direction. It calls for first introducing a 35-hour workweek and a 4.5-day workweek in the special zones, increasing regular youth employment, and applying the same safety and health management system to second- and third-tier subcontract workers in semiconductors and secondary batteries. The Federation of Korean Trade Unions demands a 4.5-day workweek, a 48-hour weekly cap, and wage preservation accompanying the reduction in working hours. One side seeks to expand the scope of regulation and the other seeks to lower the upper limit on working hours. The two demands collide at different points.

On the 7th in front of Sungnyemun Gate, that understanding emerged in numbers. Lee Jae-jin, chair of the KCTU emergency committee, defined the mega-regional special zones act as a law that fattens the bellies of conglomerates under the fine name of balanced regional development. Lee Young-chul, chair of the Construction Industry Federation, said the reality is deplorable eight months after the revised labor law took effect in March. Of the roughly 600 workplaces affiliated with the KCTU that demanded bargaining with the original contractor, fewer than 10 percent responded to bargaining. His diagnosis is that the government's enforcement decree and the Ministry of Employment and Labor's interpretive guidelines are serving as a shield for that avoidance. Subcontract workers go back and forth between the Labor Relations Commission and the courts, paying time and cost to have their status as employers recognized. The law opened the door, but procedures have been set up in front of it. The exception bill seeks to lower the threshold further, and the interpretive guidelines keep the already opened door half closed. One is made in the National Assembly and the other is made in a single document from a ministry. To workers, both are the same law.

So what must be confirmed in the meeting room on the 13th is not the order of the agenda. It is the fact that the fact that fewer than 10 percent of the roughly 600 workplaces demanded by the KCTU responded to bargaining is not written as a number anywhere in the minutes. If that number does not become an agenda item, social dialogue ends as a procedure for coordinating how far to expand the scope of regulation. Between the promise the labor minister says he will keep and the two bills placed in the special committee, what determines which bill will be brought out is not the sincerity of agreement but whether the vote comes before the consultations end.