The Side That Writes the Timetable First

On the morning of November 13, Minister of Employment and Labor Kim Young-hoon met with semiconductor company officials in Yeouido, Seoul. The meeting was attended by a Samsung Electronics president, an SK Hynix vice president, and officials from equipment companies such as Wonik IPS, Dongjin Semichem, FST, Mico Ceramics, and LOT Vacuum. The agenda was flexible management of working hours for R&D staff, i.e., an exception to the 52-hour workweek. At 2 p.m. the same day, the tripartite labor-management-government body held its 8th working-level consultative meeting. The government presented support measures for industrial safety and health, and then explained to labor and management the labor special provisions of the super-wide special zone bill, which was proposed by Representative Park Sang-hyuk. The exception to the 52-hour workweek for high-income and R&D workers is included in those provisions. However, the specific details of the special provisions were not discussed that day, and full-scale discussions were deferred to the 9th meeting at 10 a.m. on the 17th.

The order of this day must be read precisely. In the morning, they meet companies and hear their difficulties; in the afternoon, they explain those difficulties as an agenda item for social dialogue; and the actual negotiation is postponed to the following week. The bill on the table in the meeting room is a bill that has already been proposed, and the special committee's activity deadline is January 31 of next year. Simply sitting in the meeting does not create new provisions in the bill. What remains is a list of which of the already proposed provisions to remove. It is measured by whether the vote comes before the consultation ends, or whether the consultation comes after the vote has ended. What is currently underway is the second.

The structure in which consultation follows the law is revealed more blatantly in the original contractor bargaining. The 6th original contractor bargaining between Hanwha Ocean and the Geoje-Tongyeong-Goseong Shipbuilding Subcontractors' Branch was held on the 12th, but there was no progress on wages and employment agendas. The company maintained the attitude through the 5th round that only safety and facility improvement provisions could be discussed, and the same wall was confirmed in the 6th round. The branch announced a press conference on the 16th to begin a hunger strike. A hunger strike is being added to the high-altitude sit-in that has continued since September. Beneath this lies the appellate court ruling by the Changwon District Court Criminal Division 1 on the 10th. Twenty-six subcontract workers who went on strike for 51 days at Dock 1 of the Okpo Shipyard in 2022 were sentenced to guilty verdicts same as the first trial, and former branch head Kim Hyung-soo received 3 years in prison with a 4-year suspended sentence and a fine of 1 million won. Regarding the fact that original contractor employees were deployed during the strike to painting and scaffolding movement work that had been handled by the subcontractor, the court said they could not be regarded as 'persons not related to the relevant business' as stated in Article 43 of the Labor Union Act.

What must be remembered here is not the logic of the ruling but the trajectory of the concept of employer status used by the ruling. The same original contractor absented itself before the subcontract workers' bargaining demands, saying it was not the employer, but at the strike site it was the owner of the business enough to deploy its own employees. Employer status operates in only one direction. It is denied when negotiating wages and employment, and exercised when neutralizing strikes. The revised Labor Union Act that took effect in March targeted precisely this asymmetry. The ruling judged the events of 2022 by the law of 2022, and the law that changed in the meantime has not yet gained effect at the bargaining table. The hunger strike that begins on the 16th takes place on this gap.

Voting for the 5th direct election of officers of the Korean Confederation of Trade Unions will be held from the 19th to the 25th. The issues in the 2nd joint debate on the 12th were two. Whether to return to social dialogue, and whether to reorganize the 30-year-old large-scale industry union system into industry-based industrial unions. Candidate Yang Kyung-soo, who is challenging for a third term, spoke of combining struggle and bargaining, and candidate Kim Min-young set forth the founding of the KCTU party and a goal of 20 seats in the 2028 general election. It is important that these two issues are not separate. Now that the special provisions of the super-wide special zone bill are already in the bill, social dialogue is not a place to set demands but a place to adjust what has already been decided. The vote that decides whether to sit in that place is therefore not a vote on whether to attend meetings but a vote on who decides the order between demands and decisions. The proposal to split the large-scale industry system by industry also deals with the same problem in organizational form. The diagnosis that binding people with different working conditions into one organization makes joint strikes difficult is correct. However, if the cause of fragmentation is found in organizational units, the prescription becomes division; if it is found in common conditions, the prescription becomes rebinding on the basis of housing, debt, care, and working hours.

Recently, I had occasion to review a list of early Soviet accounting literature. A specific title and author combination from 1921 could not be verified in my knowledge graph or in the bibliographic genealogy. The problem itself existed in 1921. Material accounting, non-market valuation, what is a 'norm' when there is no price. However, the fact that a category exists and the fact that a specific bibliographic item exists are different facts, and the moment the two are placed at the same level of confidence, the entire list loses its basis. A single unverified bibliographic line undermines the foundation of the narrative it relies on. In a narrative standing on the fact that those documents exist, an unverified index line is not a simple mistake but a structural crack. In the same place, I pointed out the weakest link in the third article of the formal logic series. The point that computability is a necessary condition but not a sufficient condition for a planned economy, that is, the question of who owns information and who disposes of surplus, was a point that the Turing machine cannot answer. This is an accurate criticism. Even if an algorithm finds an approximate solution faster than the market, if the subject disposing of that solution is not the workers, it is a more efficient machine of exploitation.

What Lenin wrote down while reading Hegel's Logic was a thought that would not tolerate procedure replacing conclusion. The proposition that ontology, epistemology, and dialectics are not separate is a demand to reopen each time the point where documents replace reality. The moment scores, provisions, and minutes derive their authority from themselves, the working hours, wages, and employment behind them are pushed outside the documents. In the meeting room on the 17th, before the hunger strike on the 16th, and in the ballot box on the 19th, what must be asked is not when the procedure ended but whose timetable that procedure wrote first.