The Cost the Season Raised
In the early hours of November 20, Kang In-seok, chair of the Geoje-Tongyeong-Goseong Shipbuilding Subcontractors' Branch, slipped on the roof of the pre-outfitting plant. It was a frozen floor during his 52nd day of a high-altitude sit-in. His finger was torn, and because the wound could not be treated on the roof and he was on a hunger strike, he came down by aerial work platform around 7:30 a.m. By past midnight that same day, he had still not eaten. The hunger strike that began on the 16th is still ongoing.
Another fact is attached to the same article. At the 7th round of negotiations with the primary contractor held on the 19th, differences over the scope of the agenda were not narrowed. The union demands 36 clauses covering wages, employment, welfare, and union activities. The company repeated its answer that only 6 clauses on workplace facility improvements and labor safety could be negotiated. And from this round of negotiations, the company downgraded its negotiating representative from executive vice president to senior managing director.
The two events overlap in a single sentence. The reason the person on the roof came down is that his body could no longer endure, and the reason the demands were not accepted in the conference room is that they were not a body but a procedure. 52 days was not a short time. That the person who went up on the roof on September 30 slipped on ice on November 20 means the season has changed. Winter raises the cost of the push-through approach every day. And while winter came, the company left the same 6 clauses in place.
The numbers needed to understand this structure are already out. Subcontract workers' wages are about half those of regular workers at the primary contractor, and what sets those wages is not bargaining at the subcontractor's workplace but the labor cost item that the primary contractor calculates and inserts into the contract amount. Employment is the same. In the case of one subcontractor branch, contract renewal is set for next April, and the counterpart to that contract is the primary contractor. Wages and employment are both determined by the primary contractor's decisions, yet the primary contractor's decisions are left out of the negotiating agenda. This is why the Yellow Envelope Act defines the employer as 'a person who substantively and concretely controls or determines working conditions.' Applying that definition, wages and employment cannot be excluded from the negotiating agenda. If they are excluded, that is not an interpretation of the law but a reduction of the law.
On top of this, one must read together the fact that management downgraded its negotiating representative from executive vice president to senior managing director. The rank of the negotiating representative tells us what rank of meeting this is within the company's own organization. Sending an executive vice president was a sign that top management held the matter; downgrading to a senior managing director was a sign that the matter had been reclassified as a practical matter that could be handled. Reclassification is more sophisticated than rejection. Rejection defines the other as an enemy, while reclassification makes the other's demands into something that cannot even be placed on the agenda of a meeting of that level in the first place. The union's statement that it would discuss suspending collective bargaining if formal negotiations continue is a response to this reclassification.
During the same period, far from Geoje, a different kind of ledger was made public. On November 19, Anthropic listed on Nasdaq. The offering price was $83 per share, and the amount raised was $81.3 billion, the largest IPO in history. The first-day closing price was $97.17, 17 percent above the offering price, and the market capitalization was $1.77 trillion, surpassing Meta and Broadcom. It rose to $115 during the session before being pushed down to $95. More than 100 million shares were traded right after the open, so those who bought at the opening price ended the day with a 13 percent unrealized loss from the first day.
The number to read in this listing is not the share price but revenue. According to the listing prospectus, revenue for the nine months through the end of September was $33.24 billion, up 1,200 percent from the same period the previous year. The enterprise value, which was $61.5 billion in March 2025, became 24 times that. The number of customer companies spending more than $100,000 annually grew from 1,500 to 11,900. Whether a company calls itself a public benefit corporation or brands itself on safety, the price of that branding is converted into a revenue growth rate and charged on the stock market. And the computing infrastructure commitments this company carries amount to about $900 billion. The $81.3 billion raised does not even cover one-tenth of those commitments. The companies selling chips and cloud services separately bought $26 billion worth at the same price as the offering, and the structure in which that money flows back into those companies' revenue is explicitly stated next to the prospectus. The reason the market narrowed its gains on the first day of listing is not that it does not know this structure. It buys because it knows, and it sells because it knows.
On one side, labor's share is determined as a contract amount item and excluded from the negotiating agenda. On the other side, the value created by labor is converted into a 24-fold enterprise value and marked by a 17 percent fluctuation on the first day of listing. Neither ledger is a secret. One is disclosed through the numbers 36 clauses and 6 clauses, and the other through the prospectus and the offering price.
A person who was not seated where wages and employment are decided stood on the roof for 52 days toward that seat, and what he gained in return was the fact that the rank of the negotiating representative was lowered by one step and a finger that slipped on the frozen floor. When demands are not received as procedure, what remains is not procedure but only the body. What should be added this time is that the procedure must last through winter. When the season changes, the owner of the cost changes. The reason the person who endured 52 days could not endure the 53rd was not will but temperature.
Another fact is attached to the same article. At the 7th round of negotiations with the primary contractor held on the 19th, differences over the scope of the agenda were not narrowed. The union demands 36 clauses covering wages, employment, welfare, and union activities. The company repeated its answer that only 6 clauses on workplace facility improvements and labor safety could be negotiated. And from this round of negotiations, the company downgraded its negotiating representative from executive vice president to senior managing director.
The two events overlap in a single sentence. The reason the person on the roof came down is that his body could no longer endure, and the reason the demands were not accepted in the conference room is that they were not a body but a procedure. 52 days was not a short time. That the person who went up on the roof on September 30 slipped on ice on November 20 means the season has changed. Winter raises the cost of the push-through approach every day. And while winter came, the company left the same 6 clauses in place.
The numbers needed to understand this structure are already out. Subcontract workers' wages are about half those of regular workers at the primary contractor, and what sets those wages is not bargaining at the subcontractor's workplace but the labor cost item that the primary contractor calculates and inserts into the contract amount. Employment is the same. In the case of one subcontractor branch, contract renewal is set for next April, and the counterpart to that contract is the primary contractor. Wages and employment are both determined by the primary contractor's decisions, yet the primary contractor's decisions are left out of the negotiating agenda. This is why the Yellow Envelope Act defines the employer as 'a person who substantively and concretely controls or determines working conditions.' Applying that definition, wages and employment cannot be excluded from the negotiating agenda. If they are excluded, that is not an interpretation of the law but a reduction of the law.
On top of this, one must read together the fact that management downgraded its negotiating representative from executive vice president to senior managing director. The rank of the negotiating representative tells us what rank of meeting this is within the company's own organization. Sending an executive vice president was a sign that top management held the matter; downgrading to a senior managing director was a sign that the matter had been reclassified as a practical matter that could be handled. Reclassification is more sophisticated than rejection. Rejection defines the other as an enemy, while reclassification makes the other's demands into something that cannot even be placed on the agenda of a meeting of that level in the first place. The union's statement that it would discuss suspending collective bargaining if formal negotiations continue is a response to this reclassification.
During the same period, far from Geoje, a different kind of ledger was made public. On November 19, Anthropic listed on Nasdaq. The offering price was $83 per share, and the amount raised was $81.3 billion, the largest IPO in history. The first-day closing price was $97.17, 17 percent above the offering price, and the market capitalization was $1.77 trillion, surpassing Meta and Broadcom. It rose to $115 during the session before being pushed down to $95. More than 100 million shares were traded right after the open, so those who bought at the opening price ended the day with a 13 percent unrealized loss from the first day.
The number to read in this listing is not the share price but revenue. According to the listing prospectus, revenue for the nine months through the end of September was $33.24 billion, up 1,200 percent from the same period the previous year. The enterprise value, which was $61.5 billion in March 2025, became 24 times that. The number of customer companies spending more than $100,000 annually grew from 1,500 to 11,900. Whether a company calls itself a public benefit corporation or brands itself on safety, the price of that branding is converted into a revenue growth rate and charged on the stock market. And the computing infrastructure commitments this company carries amount to about $900 billion. The $81.3 billion raised does not even cover one-tenth of those commitments. The companies selling chips and cloud services separately bought $26 billion worth at the same price as the offering, and the structure in which that money flows back into those companies' revenue is explicitly stated next to the prospectus. The reason the market narrowed its gains on the first day of listing is not that it does not know this structure. It buys because it knows, and it sells because it knows.
On one side, labor's share is determined as a contract amount item and excluded from the negotiating agenda. On the other side, the value created by labor is converted into a 24-fold enterprise value and marked by a 17 percent fluctuation on the first day of listing. Neither ledger is a secret. One is disclosed through the numbers 36 clauses and 6 clauses, and the other through the prospectus and the offering price.
A person who was not seated where wages and employment are decided stood on the roof for 52 days toward that seat, and what he gained in return was the fact that the rank of the negotiating representative was lowered by one step and a finger that slipped on the frozen floor. When demands are not received as procedure, what remains is not procedure but only the body. What should be added this time is that the procedure must last through winter. When the season changes, the owner of the cost changes. The reason the person who endured 52 days could not endure the 53rd was not will but temperature.