The Rank of the Negotiation Representative

November 19 was filled with several developments. In Geoje, the 7th round of main-contractor negotiations between Hanwha Ocean and the subcontractor branches took place; nationwide, voting began in the Korean Confederation of Trade Unions (KCTU) executive election; and the hunger strike in front of the Gyeongnam Provincial Government building entered its fourth day. Then, in the early hours of the 20th, the chair of the Geoje-Tongyeong-Goseong Shipbuilding Subcontractor Branch, who had endured 52 days of high-altitude protest on the roof of the pre-painting shop, slipped on the frozen surface, injured his hand, and was lowered to the ground by a boom lift and taken to the hospital. More than the fact that negotiations broke down, this injury is the real coordinate of the current situation.

Let me accurately record the results of the 7th negotiation first. There was no agreement. The biggest issue remains the scope of the negotiation agenda. The union demands 36 clauses covering wages, employment, welfare, and union activities, while the company responds that, based on the National Labor Relations Commission ruling, only 6 clauses concerning industrial safety and workplace facility improvements can be negotiated. However, one new fact emerged in this negotiation: starting with the 7th round, Hanwha Ocean changed its management representative from Executive Director to Managing Director. The union read this as a signal of no real willingness to negotiate and, immediately after the negotiation, held a negotiation committee meeting to discuss whether to suspend collective bargaining. They tentatively decided not to suspend immediately, and the 8th round is scheduled for the 26th.

Why does the rise and fall of the rank of the negotiation representative matter? Who the company sends out says what rank of meeting this is within the company. Sending an Executive Director was a sign that this matter was of interest to top management; downgrading to a Managing Director is a sign that this interest is being lowered by one level. The union's interpretation is not an exaggeration. But one more point must be pushed here. The rank change is both a signal of negotiation suspension and a revelation of what kind of meeting the company has treated this negotiation as from the start. With the agenda cut to 6 clauses, keeping the representative at Executive Director level is not negotiation but management. There is no reason to seat an Executive Director in a meeting that does not deal with wages and employment, so the change to Managing Director is not cooling but an accurate self-classification.

Reading this classification backwards reveals the pretext of the law. The Yellow Envelope Act opened the door to negotiation, not the agenda. Article 2 of the Labor Union Act defines as an employer anyone who substantially and concretely controls or determines working conditions. Applying that definition as written, the conclusion that Hanwha Ocean is the employer—the one that determines wages, workforce size, and contract renewals—is unavoidable. It is not only the company that denies what anyone working at the Geoje shipyard knows; the company's way of reading the ruling's wording is narrow. Opening the 6 safety clauses is an acknowledgment of the margins, not the core, of employer responsibility. Safety is the item the main contractor finds hardest to claim is outside its control, and wages are the item with the greatest profit. It is not order but choice.

The broader landscape of the labor movement moved on a different axis the same day. The 12th KCTU executive election began at 8 a.m. on the 19th and runs until 6 p.m. on the 25th. The electorate is 975,279, with mobile voters overwhelmingly at 883,632. As of 4 p.m. on the 19th, turnout was 12.52 percent. There are four candidate slates: Eom Gil-yong, Yang Kyung-soo, Kim Min-young, and Choi Jun-sik. The issues are participation in social dialogue and strategies for negotiations and struggle with the government, and they diverge on details. Candidate Yang Kyung-soo proposed expanding industry- and sector-level bargaining through social bargaining, a four-day workweek, and 2 million members. Candidate Kim Min-young is critical of government-led social dialogue and speaks of founding a "KCTU Party" by the 2028 general election and reorganizing into industrial unions. Candidate Eom Gil-yong proposed strategic legislation to respond to AI industrial transformation and expansion of supra-enterprise bargaining, while candidate Choi Jun-sik proposed social bargaining premised on sufficient preparation and member consent, and a collective agreement coverage rate of 50 percent by 2035.

What is noteworthy here is not the turnout but what the turnout measures. 970,000 people elect their leadership by mobile over seven days. Yet the majority of those 970,000 are not covered by collective agreements at their own workplaces. This gap is a contradiction the KCTU has long harbored. The organized minority defends its wages and employment through agreements, while the unorganized majority is handled through individual contracts. This is why main-contractor bargaining matters. It is a system that gives bargaining rights to already organized subcontract workers, and at the same time it is almost the only channel through which the scope of collective agreements can be extended beyond the organized. If negotiations cut to 6 clauses are repeated, that channel will not open. Whatever bargaining strategy the leadership chooses, the condition for that strategy to have meaning is whether the agenda expands on the ground.

The injury news adds the variable of time to this calculation. 52 days is not short. That the person who went up on the roof on September 30 slipped on the frozen ground on November 20 means the season has changed, and that the cost of pushing forward rises every day. The union decided to end the high-altitude sit-in because treatment is difficult up there and health can deteriorate due to the hunger strike. Reading this as a retreat would be wrong. A struggle that holds the body as collateral has a limit point, and setting that point by one's own judgment is keeping control of the struggle in one's own hands. That the decision is not the end of the struggle is shown by the fact that the union still holds the cards for a joint strike and the 8th negotiation. If the 6 clauses are presented again in the meeting room on the 26th, then the character of this situation will be revealed not by the court's ruling or the Labor Commission's decision but elsewhere.

The Welliv branch represents workers at a company contracted for food services, commuter buses, and facility management, and their contract renewal is due next April. Contract renewal is a negotiation that conditions their very existence, not a wage increase rate. In a structure where subcontract workers worry about employment instead of wages, it was this law's achievement to make it possible to ask the main contractor directly about that worry. While the company pushes that question outside the 6 clauses, the question does not disappear; it remains on the roof and in the tent.