Published Contracts, Closed Decisions
One decision by the National Labor Relations Commission that became known to the labor community on November 12 carries the weight of this week all by itself. When Gyeonggi Expressway entrusted maintenance and operations to subcontractors such as Ido, at the bidding stage it had them itemize base pay and allowances at lower amounts in the labor cost calculation, and required them to submit annual wage increase rates to be applied over the next five years. In the calculation, a 3 percent increase over the previous year was reflected in the total base pay each year. On September 23, the NLRC recognized the company as an employer, saying it effectively controls at what level and how the wages of the subcontractor's workers are determined, and this became the first case recognizing the prime contractor's bargaining obligation on the wage agenda after the revised Trade Union Act took effect in March. About ten employees determine the wages of over two hundred people through a single entrustment contract.
The way a prime contractor controls subcontractor workers' wages is not through orders but through contracts. It sets the contract amount, creates labor cost items within it, and pins down even the next year's increase rate. Then wage bargaining appears to take place at the subcontractor's workplace, but the actual decision is already finished in the prime contractor's conference room. The proposition that wages are determined through bargaining between the union and the employer is merely formal unless it is settled who the employer is. What the Yellow Envelope Act expanded was not the concept of the employer, but by moving into statutory text the employer status that case law had already recognized, it blocked the path by which companies used to sidestep it, saying "that's just case law, not the law." The work of recreating that path is now underway.
In Geoje, that path stands in the form of contract clauses. The 7th prime contractor bargaining session will be held at 10:10 a.m. on November 19 at the Hanwha Ocean West Gate Finance Center. The union submitted 36 clauses, and the company recognized only 6 related to industrial safety as subjects for bargaining. The three people who began a hunger strike on the 16th are on their fourth day as of that day. Hanwha Ocean's cumulative operating profit through the third quarter exceeds 1.6 trillion won. It is not that they cannot set wages because there is no profit. There is a decision not to sit in the place where wages are set, and there is a configuration of power that makes that decision accepted. What the NLRC recognized was the fact of wage control, and what the company rejects is the consequence of that fact.
In the direct election for the 5th-term officers of the Korean Confederation of Trade Unions (KCTU), to be held from November 19 to 25, the order and conditions of social dialogue have emerged as an issue. Whichever side wins, the next task remains to remove the enforcement decree and interpretive guidelines of the Trade Union Act that obstruct prime contractor bargaining, and the labor exceptions of the Megacity Special Zone Act. Those documents already have drafts and are already on the legislative track.
The contents of the Megacity Special Zone Act are specific. The bill sponsored by Assemblymember Park Sang-hyuk includes exemptions from the 52-hour workweek for some R&D and professional workers, expansion of the settlement period of the selective working hours system to six months, and extension of the permitted period for fixed-term employment from two years to four years. Labor and civil society demand the withdrawal of the entire bill, saying that removing the labor exceptions is not enough, and the KCTU has continued a sit-in in front of the National Assembly from October 23 to December 1 and held an expanded executive resolution rally on the 18th. A joint action involving 134 organizations announced a march in front of the National Assembly at 2 p.m. on the 21st. The special committee's activity deadline is the end of January 2027. Since the resolution to form the special committee passed on the 5th of last month, only about three months remain.
In the same week, the Federation of Korean Trade Unions (FKTU) moved. At its standing executive committee on the 18th, it discussed a struggle plan against the Lee Jae-myung government and the Democratic Party and decided to form a struggle situation room soon. The trigger was the extension of the retirement age. The promise to legislate within last year was not kept, and the National Assembly Special Committee on Retirement Age Extension stopped on January 23 when, at its second plenary committee meeting, the Democratic Party presented a plan to postpone drafting the bill until after the local elections and the FKTU secretary-general stormed out. That special committee will resume with a subcommittee meeting on the 27th. The bill that the Democratic Party postponed until after the local elections in January returns to the conference room in November, after the elections are over. Meanwhile, the labor exceptions of the megacity special zone are being pushed through at speed. The causal link between delaying the retirement age extension and rushing the special zone act has not been confirmed. But the fact remains that the two issues are moving at different speeds under one government.
The FKTU's pushback matters because they are not the opposition party. It is an organization that signed a policy agreement with this government, and its chairman has said he will tear up that agreement in public. The basis for the pushback is not ideology but implementation. An agreement is a condition, and if the condition is not implemented, the nature of the relationship changes. The KCTU's dispute over social dialogue is ultimately also a matter of these conditions. Sitting at the bargaining table and what is decided at that table are separate matters, and what determines the latter is power outside the table.
On the 19th, the ballot boxes open, the hunger strike enters its fourth day, and prime contractor bargaining is held. The decision that an entrustment contract determines wages remains as a ruling by the Labor Relations Commission. Who determines wages, working hours, and employment? A single contract sheet determines the wages of 200 people, and a single line in the special zone act erases the upper limit on working hours for R&D workers. None of this is secret. It is written in documents, has clause numbers, and is publicly announced. What is harder than confronting concealed power is confronting published power. Because it is not a conspiracy but a contract, it does not change unless one sits in the place where the contract is written.
The way a prime contractor controls subcontractor workers' wages is not through orders but through contracts. It sets the contract amount, creates labor cost items within it, and pins down even the next year's increase rate. Then wage bargaining appears to take place at the subcontractor's workplace, but the actual decision is already finished in the prime contractor's conference room. The proposition that wages are determined through bargaining between the union and the employer is merely formal unless it is settled who the employer is. What the Yellow Envelope Act expanded was not the concept of the employer, but by moving into statutory text the employer status that case law had already recognized, it blocked the path by which companies used to sidestep it, saying "that's just case law, not the law." The work of recreating that path is now underway.
In Geoje, that path stands in the form of contract clauses. The 7th prime contractor bargaining session will be held at 10:10 a.m. on November 19 at the Hanwha Ocean West Gate Finance Center. The union submitted 36 clauses, and the company recognized only 6 related to industrial safety as subjects for bargaining. The three people who began a hunger strike on the 16th are on their fourth day as of that day. Hanwha Ocean's cumulative operating profit through the third quarter exceeds 1.6 trillion won. It is not that they cannot set wages because there is no profit. There is a decision not to sit in the place where wages are set, and there is a configuration of power that makes that decision accepted. What the NLRC recognized was the fact of wage control, and what the company rejects is the consequence of that fact.
In the direct election for the 5th-term officers of the Korean Confederation of Trade Unions (KCTU), to be held from November 19 to 25, the order and conditions of social dialogue have emerged as an issue. Whichever side wins, the next task remains to remove the enforcement decree and interpretive guidelines of the Trade Union Act that obstruct prime contractor bargaining, and the labor exceptions of the Megacity Special Zone Act. Those documents already have drafts and are already on the legislative track.
The contents of the Megacity Special Zone Act are specific. The bill sponsored by Assemblymember Park Sang-hyuk includes exemptions from the 52-hour workweek for some R&D and professional workers, expansion of the settlement period of the selective working hours system to six months, and extension of the permitted period for fixed-term employment from two years to four years. Labor and civil society demand the withdrawal of the entire bill, saying that removing the labor exceptions is not enough, and the KCTU has continued a sit-in in front of the National Assembly from October 23 to December 1 and held an expanded executive resolution rally on the 18th. A joint action involving 134 organizations announced a march in front of the National Assembly at 2 p.m. on the 21st. The special committee's activity deadline is the end of January 2027. Since the resolution to form the special committee passed on the 5th of last month, only about three months remain.
In the same week, the Federation of Korean Trade Unions (FKTU) moved. At its standing executive committee on the 18th, it discussed a struggle plan against the Lee Jae-myung government and the Democratic Party and decided to form a struggle situation room soon. The trigger was the extension of the retirement age. The promise to legislate within last year was not kept, and the National Assembly Special Committee on Retirement Age Extension stopped on January 23 when, at its second plenary committee meeting, the Democratic Party presented a plan to postpone drafting the bill until after the local elections and the FKTU secretary-general stormed out. That special committee will resume with a subcommittee meeting on the 27th. The bill that the Democratic Party postponed until after the local elections in January returns to the conference room in November, after the elections are over. Meanwhile, the labor exceptions of the megacity special zone are being pushed through at speed. The causal link between delaying the retirement age extension and rushing the special zone act has not been confirmed. But the fact remains that the two issues are moving at different speeds under one government.
The FKTU's pushback matters because they are not the opposition party. It is an organization that signed a policy agreement with this government, and its chairman has said he will tear up that agreement in public. The basis for the pushback is not ideology but implementation. An agreement is a condition, and if the condition is not implemented, the nature of the relationship changes. The KCTU's dispute over social dialogue is ultimately also a matter of these conditions. Sitting at the bargaining table and what is decided at that table are separate matters, and what determines the latter is power outside the table.
On the 19th, the ballot boxes open, the hunger strike enters its fourth day, and prime contractor bargaining is held. The decision that an entrustment contract determines wages remains as a ruling by the Labor Relations Commission. Who determines wages, working hours, and employment? A single contract sheet determines the wages of 200 people, and a single line in the special zone act erases the upper limit on working hours for R&D workers. None of this is secret. It is written in documents, has clause numbers, and is publicly announced. What is harder than confronting concealed power is confronting published power. Because it is not a conspiracy but a contract, it does not change unless one sits in the place where the contract is written.