People of the Revolution and the USSR

Charles Bettelheim

Charles Bettelheim

French Marxist economist who theorized the USSR as state capitalism and shaped Third World development economics

'Control by the producers over their conditions of existence requires the development of entirely new social relations.' — Economic Calculation and Forms of Property (1971)

French Marxist economist. Founder of CEMI, he pioneered Soviet planning studies and served as economic advisor to Nasser, Nehru, and Ben Bella. In the 1963 Cuban 'Great Debate' he opposed Che Guevara's centralized industrialization, arguing for decentralized planning with market elements. Drawn to Maoism, he collaborated with Althusser to critique Marxist 'economism,' insisting socialism requires active political reshaping of social relations, not mere state ownership. His Class Struggles in the USSR (1974–1982) theorized the Soviet Union as state capitalism; Le Monde (1972) called him 'the most visible Marxist in the capitalist world.'

Career timeline
  • 1933Joined Jeunesses communistes, then French Communist Party
  • 1936Five months in Moscow, witnessed purges, excluded from PCF
  • 1944–1948Official at Ministry of Labor, Director of Studies at EPHE
  • 1950sEconomic advisor to Egypt, India, Algeria; UN expert for India's Second Five-Year Plan
  • 1958Founded CEMI at EHESS
  • 1963Cuban 'Great Debate': opposed Che Guevara's centralized industrialization
  • 1966–1977President of Franco-Chinese Friendship Association
  • 1974–1982Published Class Struggles in the USSR (3 vols.), theorizing USSR as state capitalism

Karel Kosík

Karel Kosík
Western Marxist theorists Czechoslovakia Czech 1926–2003 ○ Natural causes

A non-dogmatic Marxist who reflected on the Prague Spring

He argued that the Prague Spring was buried again after 1989, following its burial under the Husák regime.

Karel Kosík was a Czech philosopher who reworked Marxism as a philosophy of human praxis and concrete historicity. His major work, Dialectics of the Concrete (1963), placed Marx in dialogue with Heideggerian phenomenology and earned international recognition. A leading intellectual of democratic socialism during the Prague Spring, he was expelled from the Communist Party and excluded from university life during normalization. After 1989, he argued that the memory and emancipatory promise of the reform had been buried first by the Husák regime and again by the neoliberal order, making him central to debates over the event’s legacy.

Career timeline
  • 1943–1944Joined the left-wing underground resistance Předvoj and edited an illegal journal
  • 1944–1945Arrested by the Gestapo and imprisoned in Theresienstadt concentration camp
  • 1953–1968Researcher at the Czechoslovak Academy of Sciences Institute of Philosophy
  • 1963Published Dialectics of the Concrete
  • 1968–1969Professor of philosophy at Charles University and member of the Communist Party Central Committee
  • 1970–1989Dissident intellectual, excluded from university life after expulsion from the Communist Party
  • 1990–1992Lectured in philosophy at Charles University
  • 1992–2003Researched and wrote at the Czech Academy of Sciences Institute of Philosophy