Über Jazz · 1936

Adorno's critique of jazz

재즈 비판 (아도르노)

Theodor W. Adorno's critique of jazz, which he repeated from the 1930s throughout his life. In "On Jazz", published in 1936 in the Zeitschrift für Sozialforschung under the pseudonym Hektor Rottweiler, he defined jazz as "a commodity in the strict sense", and this critique became the starting point of his later theory of the culture industry. It is also the part of his work most often criticised as a misjudgement made without real knowledge of jazz.

In depth

Why did music good for dancing become a philosopher's target?

We rarely really listen to the music playing in a café. It is the background to conversation, a device to lift the mood. That kind of listening is exactly what Theodor W. Adorno took issue with when he wrote about jazz in the 1930s. Around 1937 he wrote that jazz, used "as accompaniment to dancing or as a background to conversation", makes no claim to be grasped as a synthetic unity from beginning to end, and therefore has an essentially unconscious function. Music, instead of keeping people awake, makes them listen with half an ear.

First, what "jazz" meant. The word was first printed in Germany in 1919, and throughout the Weimar years jazz spread as the dance music of the big cities. The jazz Adorno spoke of was less the improvisation-centred art music we think of today than the commercial dance music of Europe at the time. He included everyone from Louis Armstrong to Bing Crosby under the word and used jazz as his example of what was wrong with popular music as a whole.

What was the 1933 "Farewell to Jazz"?

Soon after coming to power the Nazi regime banned so-called "Negro jazz" from the radio. In "Farewell to Jazz", published in the Europäische Revue in 1933, Adorno wrote that the decree merely confirmed after the fact what had already happened in music: what was disappearing with jazz was "a piece of bad applied art". He saw two reasons for jazz's success: it could be consumed without effort and made people dance, and it had a progressive image born of playing with the foreign. Jazz syncopation, he complained, was borrowed from art music but never worked through as thoroughly as in Brahms, and a militarily played basic beat had taken the place of syncopation and prevented variety.

The text later became a burden. In 1934 he also praised male-voice choral settings of poems by the Hitler Youth leader Baldur von Schirach. When the Frankfurt student paper Diskus brought these texts up in the winter semester of 1962–63, he expressed regret in an open letter for his "stupidly tactical sentences", attributing them to the foolishness of someone for whom the decision to emigrate had been infinitely hard.

What did "On Jazz" argue?

His full account of jazz is "On Jazz", written during his years in Oxford. It appeared in 1936 in the Institute's Zeitschrift für Sozialforschung under the pseudonym Hektor Rottweiler and provoked the fiercest reactions, even after Adorno's death. Its central thesis is:

Der Jazz ist Ware im strikten Sinn

"Jazz is a commodity in the strict sense." With this thesis Adorno formulated his first polemic in principle against the rising entertainment industry, which would later be named the "culture industry" in Dialectic of Enlightenment.

What he saw in jazz was a contradiction between an appearance of freedom and a rigid frame. In another text he wrote that its characteristic syncopation merely creates the feeling of new metres within a "mechanically rigid basic beat". The charm of stepping out of regularity and returning to it is jazz's appeal, but the basic beat and the simple dance-derived structure remain a corset that only simulates freedom. Improvisation was not real freedom for him either, since its starting point was already a hit-song melody and arranged "rhythm numbers" had pushed out the improvised passages. Adorno later called this structure "pseudo-individualisation": small differences added to a standardised commodity so that it appears tailored to each consumer.

Did he change his mind later?

He did not. The culture industry chapter of Dialectic of Enlightenment names jazz, along with film, radio and magazines, as media that uniform people's actions, thoughts and feelings, and gives the example of jazz arrangers who make Mozart deliberately more dissonant and automatically syncopate Beethoven. "Timeless Fashion: On Jazz" (1953) repeated the negative judgements of the 1936 essay, dismissing jazz as part of commercial popular music and a "false liquidation of art"; it was included in Prisms in 1955.

In his Introduction to the Sociology of Music (1962) he described jazz fans as sect-like protesters against official culture. They criticise the classical-romantic ideal of music and want to replace aesthetics with technique and a sporting character, yet as long as their starting point is the hit song they cannot escape commercial music. He concluded:

Die Entfremdung von der sanktionierten musikalischen Kultur schlägt in diesem Typus in ein vorkünstlerisch Barbarisches zurück, das umsonst als Aufbruch von Urgefühlen sich affichiert.

"In this type, alienation from sanctioned musical culture relapses into a pre-artistic barbarism that vainly advertises itself as an eruption of primal feelings." As the German Wikipedia puts it, Adorno never fundamentally changed his view of jazz in any later publication.

What has been criticised?

The criticism is nearly unanimous. Martin Jay, historian of the Frankfurt School, notes that Adorno did not know jazz at first hand when he wrote "On Jazz". Richard Klein, co-editor of the Adorno-Handbuch, speaks of Adorno's "notoriously uncomprehending remarks on jazz". The Marxist historian and jazz critic Eric Hobsbawm said his writings contain "some of the stupidest pages ever written about jazz". Critics also point out that he missed the role jazz played in the African American movement.

There are other readings. The pop theorist Diedrich Diederichsen grants that Adorno described the musical phenomena of jazz precisely but drew the wrong conclusions from them. A related point is that his target was the commercial dance music of 1930s Europe rather than the genre as a whole. The sociologist Heinz Steinert examined the question in his 1992 book The Discovery of the Culture Industry, or: Why Professor Adorno Could Not Stand Jazz. The 1953 dispute with the jazz critic Joachim-Ernst Berendt, and Steinert's reply that the frame of "culture industry versus autonomous art" itself does not fit jazz, are covered under "Culture industry". Adorno's view of music as a whole can be found under "Philosophy of New Music".

Related people

Sources

  1. de.wikipedia.org
  2. Wikipedia (EN)
  3. literaturtheorien.uni-wuppertal.de
  4. de.wikipedia.org
  5. de.wikipedia.org
  6. Wikipedia (EN)