Chongsan-ri Method
청산리방법
Method of guidance formulated in the DPRK after Kim Il Sung spent about two weeks giving on-the-spot guidance at the Chongsan-ri cooperative farm in Kangso County, South Phyongan, in February 1960. Its principles are that higher bodies help lower ones and superiors help subordinates, and that leading officials go down to the spot, learn the actual situation and put political work first to draw out the enthusiasm of the masses. First applied to agricultural guidance, it was carried into industry as the Taean work system in 1961.
In depth
Guidance at Chongsan-ri
When farm output lagged amid the disorder caused by the Chollima speed campaigns of 1959, Kim Il Sung went to Kangso County, South Phyongan, in February 1960 with deputy directors of the Organisational and Information Departments of the Central Committee and its instructors. One group took the Chongsan-ri party organisation and the other the county committee; Kim stayed at Chongsan-ri and talked with ri party committee members and the secretaries of the work-team primary organisations. The Encyclopedia of Korean Culture gives the guidance as fifteen days, English Wikipedia as two months. In his speech to the Chongsan-ri party membership on 8 February he rebuked the management board for assigning only about half its labour to grain teams the year before and scattering its efforts over side work such as oil-pressing and fish-breeding teams.
On an agricultural cooperative all work should be subordinated to farming.
Because the leadership had already visited Onchon and other counties of South Phyongan the previous autumn, this time it chose to go deep into every level of one county, from the ri party organisations up to the county committee. On 23 February, at an enlarged meeting of the Presidium of the Central Committee, Kim said that the lessons of the Kangso guidance were not confined to that county but were shortcomings common to all rural and factory party organisations, and generalised them to the whole party.
Content
The core of the method is that higher bodies help lower ones; that leading officials do not merely issue orders from their offices but go down to the spot and learn the real situation; that the causes of problems are sought in ideology and guidance rather than technique; and that political work comes first to draw out the initiative of the masses. The response of the farmers to the method was called the "Chongsan-ri spirit", and the Chongsan-ri cooperative became a model farm. English-language studies note that alongside the attack on bureaucratism and formalism came greater use of material incentives such as paid holidays, bonuses and honorific titles. On-the-spot guidance by senior officials became a regular practice.
Tasks set by the meeting
The Chongsan-ri meeting and the guidance that followed listed the tasks to be solved in agriculture: strict observance of the socialist principle of distribution, better planning and mechanisation, stronger communist education, higher echelons helping lower ones, and precise assignments for party members. Kim praised the meeting for criticising the defects of the management board from the ideological point of view rather than dwelling on technical matters such as fertiliser and close planting, and likened constant criticism and correction of defects to washing one's face each morning:
Regularly criticizing defects in our work is like washing our faces every morning.
The Chongsan-ri cooperative farm, a lowland farm of about 1,000 chongbo of which 70 percent is paddy, 13 percent dry fields and 15 percent orchards, became a model farm after the guidance. After the Fourth Party Congress of 1961 Kim boasted that even fraternal parties said they would learn from the Chongsan-ri method, the method of re-educating people on communist lines by giving priority to political work.
Extension to industry and assessment
In December 1961, guiding the Taean Electrical Machinery Plant, Kim said that the defects of industrial management came down to one thing, and set out the new Taean work system:
the Chongsanri spirit and Chongsanri method have not yet been adopted in the industrial sector.
Russian-language accounts see the method as a logical continuation of Chollima, relying on the enthusiasm and creativity of the masses, with the difference that it placed on the leadership the task of inspiring collectives to meet production targets. Some assessments add that heavy-handed drives to amalgamate farms into ever larger units undercut the method, and that real improvement in agriculture came instead from the subteam contract system, which shrank the working unit and adjusted individual incentives. The practice of on-the-spot guidance passed to Kim Jong Il and Kim Jong Un.