Vorlesungen über die Ästhetik · 1818–1835 (From Hegel's first lectures in Heidelberg (1818) and Berlin (1820/21, 1823, 1826, 1828/29) to the edition his pupil Hotho compiled in 1835.)

Hegel's aesthetics

헤겔 미학

The philosophy of art in the lectures on aesthetics Hegel gave in Heidelberg and Berlin between 1818 and 1829, compiled after his death by his pupil Heinrich Gustav Hotho as the Lectures on Aesthetics (1835). It defines beauty as "the sensuous shining of the Idea" and tells the history of art as a sequence of symbolic (architecture), classical (sculpture) and romantic (painting, music, poetry) forms of art. Its statement that art, in its highest vocation, has become "a thing of the past" for us is known as the "end of art" thesis, though Hegel himself never said that art was dead.

In depth

Why paint when there are cameras?

In an age when a phone camera can copy anything exactly, why do people still paint pictures and go to look at them? If copying were the aim, painting could never beat photography. Hegel put his finger on the problem before the camera existed. Mere imitation, he said, can never win a contest with nature, and art that tries will look like "a worm trying to crawl after an elephant". What, then, is art for?

Hegel's answer starts from the claim that art does not copy nature but is something spirit makes. He accepted the name "aesthetics" because it had already passed into common use, but said the proper name of the science was "philosophy of art", or more precisely "philosophy of fine art". He therefore excluded natural beauty from his subject and argued that artistic beauty stands higher than nature, being "beauty born and born again of the spirit".

Der eigentliche Ausdruck jedoch für unsere Wissenschaft ist „Philosophie der Kunst,“ und bestimmter „Philosophie der schönen Kunst.“

What does "the sensuous shining of the Idea" mean?

In Hegel's philosophy the Idea is the rational order that moves the whole world, truth itself. Philosophy grasps that truth in concepts, religion holds it in images, and art shows it in sensuous materials such as stone, colour, sound and words. Hence his statement: "The beautiful is thereby determined as the sensuous shining of the Idea." Scheinen means both appearance and the shining-through of light. In a beautiful work the sensuous gives up its independence and becomes a window through which spirit shines.

Das Schöne bestimmt sich dadurch als das sinnliche Scheinen der Idee.

From this definition follows a history of art. Three forms of art arise according to how well the Idea and its sensuous shape fit. In the symbolic form the Idea is still vague and abstract and fails to fit its shape; architecture is its basic type, and Hegel treats symbolic art such as the Egyptian pyramids at this stage. In the classical form the Idea is "freely and adequately embodied" in a shape that suits it, culminating in the Greek sculpture of the gods. The romantic form begins with Christianity: the inwardness of spirit has grown so deep that no sensuous shape can hold it, so romantic art is "art going beyond itself". Painting, music and poetry, the most spiritual of the arts, belong to this stage.

What does the "end of art" say?

At the end of this sequence Hegel wrote his famous lines. The spirit of our time, Christianity and modern rational culture, has gone beyond the stage at which art was the highest way of becoming conscious of the absolute. We no longer worship works of art as gods, and "thought and reflection have overtaken fine art". Hence his conclusion: "In all these respects art, considered in its highest vocation, is and remains for us a thing of the past."

In allen diesen Beziehungen ist und bleibt die Kunst nach der Seite ihrer höchsten Bestimmung für uns ein Vergangenes.

The sentence is often summed up as "Hegel declared the death of art", but Hegel nowhere says that art is dead. What has ended is art's role as the bearer of an age's highest truth, as when a Greek statue of a god was the god for the Greeks. Hegel speaks mostly of art's "dissolution" (Auflösung); the word "end" (Ende) is Hotho's heading for the last section on the romantic form.

This connects with a textual problem. Hegel never published his lectures on aesthetics. Hotho combined Hegel's lecture manuscripts with students' notes into the 1835 book, which remained the standard text for nearly two hundred years. Annemarie Gethmann-Siefert's research, however, has shown that Hotho's text contains a good deal of material absent from the student notes and that Hegel's views changed from course to course. In 2022 Hegel's biographer Klaus Vieweg found more than 4,000 pages of notes from Hegel's Heidelberg lectures in the library of the Archdiocese of Munich and Freising, new material that may help settle the question.

What did Marxists take from Hegel's aesthetics, and what did they discard?

Marx and Engels were heirs of Hegel's philosophy and knew his aesthetics well. In an 1885 letter to the novelist Minna Kautsky, Engels wrote that each character in a good novel should be "a type, but at the same time a definite individual, a 'this one', as old Hegel puts it" (see typicality). He transplanted Hegel's idea of the universal and the particular united in one figure into the theory of realism.

jeder ist ein Typus, aber auch zugleich ein bestimmter Einzelmensch, ein „Dieser“, wie der alte Hegel sich ausdrückt, und so muß es sein.

The question Marx asked in 1857, why Greek art still counts as "a norm and an unattainable model", likewise touches Hegel's account of the classical form. Marx, however, looked for the answer not in the self-unfolding of the Idea but in a stage of social development, the "historical childhood" of humanity. Where Hegel told the history of art as a history of spirit, Marxism tried to rebuild it on the history of material production and class relations.

In Russia, Chernyshevsky confronted Hegel more directly. In his 1855 dissertation he summarised the Hegelian definition, "the beautiful is the perfect correspondence, the perfect identity, of idea and image", judged that the concepts it rested on no longer withstood criticism, and replied that beauty is not an idea but life. Conversely, the twentieth-century Soviet aesthetician Mikhail Lifshitz, developing the theory of reflection from Lenin's metaphor of the mirror, understood reflection as "the development of the concept of reflection in Hegelian dialectics". Whether to "turn Hegel's aesthetics on its feet" on a materialist basis or discard it altogether was a long-standing fork in Marxist aesthetics.

How is the "end of art" read today?

In the late twentieth century the American philosopher Arthur Danto revived Hegel's thesis in the face of works such as Andy Warhol's Brillo Box. His claim was not that no one makes art any more, nor that no good art is made. It was that after an era of imitation, and an era of ideology in which each style tried to drive out the others, a "post-historical" era had arrived in which there are no stylistic or philosophical constraints on what art must look like. A certain history of Western art, he thought, had come to an end in roughly the way Hegel suggested.

Hegel's sentence keeps being quoted because the diagnosis that art can no longer speak for a society's highest truth is the starting point for every discussion of art's place in modern society. For Western Marxists such as Adorno it led to the crisis of art in commodity society; for Soviet aestheticians such as Lifshitz, to the crisis of modernism (see The Crisis of Ugliness).

Related people

Sources

  1. archive.org
  2. Wikipedia (EN)
  3. Wikipedia (EN)
  4. Wikipedia (EN)
  5. Wikipedia (EN)
  6. ru.wikisource.org
  7. marx-wirklich-studieren.net
  8. Wikipedia (RU)
  9. web.archive.org