Homosexuality
동성애
A sexual orientation of sexual and emotional attraction to people of the same sex, or relationships of that kind. Women who are homosexual are commonly called lesbians, and men gay. The word Homosexualität was first used by the Hungarian writer Karl Maria Kertbeny in a letter of 1868 and put before the public in his pamphlets of 1869 against the Prussian sodomy law. From the late nineteenth century many states punished same-sex acts under criminal law and psychiatry classed homosexuality as an illness; the American Psychiatric Association removed it from its list of mental disorders in 1973 and the World Health Organization in 1990.
In depth
What is homosexuality?
Homosexuality is a sexual orientation of sexual and emotional attraction to people of the same sex. Attraction to the other sex is heterosexuality, attraction to both is bisexuality. Homosexual women are commonly called lesbians and homosexual men gay.
Homosexuality is a different matter from gender identity, which is about what gender a person is. Being transgender and being homosexual are therefore separate concepts: a transgender person may be homosexual or heterosexual. Today scientific research and the clinical literature regard same-sex attractions, feelings and behaviours as normal and positive variations of human sexuality.
When did the word "homosexuality" appear?
Love between people of the same sex is old, but naming it as a person's innate disposition began in the German-speaking world of the nineteenth century. First the jurist Karl Heinrich Ulrichs in 1864 called men attracted to men "Urnings", arguing that their love was inborn and therefore could not be punished.
"Homosexuality" came a few years later. The Austrian-born Hungarian writer Karl Maria Kertbeny first used the word "homosexual" in a letter of 6 May 1868 to Ulrichs, calling people attracted to the other sex "heterosexual". In 1869 he argued in two anonymous pamphlets that Paragraph 143 of the Prussian penal code, which punished sex between men, violated "the rights of man": consensual private acts were no business of the criminal law, and the law delivered homosexuals to blackmailers and drove them to suicide. He held the sexual drive to be "innate and unchanging", against the prevailing view that men committed "sodomy" out of mere wickedness.
It was not Kertbeny who spread the word. The psychiatrist Richard von Krafft-Ebing borrowed "homosexual" and "heterosexual" from Gustav Jäger's book, which used Kertbeny's terminology, and as his Psychopathia sexualis (1886) became the standard work, the two terms displaced Ulrichs's "Urning" as standard vocabulary. In that book, however, Krafft-Ebing defined homosexuality as an innate, hereditary nervous disorder. On that ground he argued that homosexuals were not responsible and should not be punished, but homosexuality thereby became a pathology. A name made to fight punishment spread as the name of a disease.
How was homosexuality punished?
In many countries same-sex acts were crimes. Paragraph 175 of the German penal code, in force from 1871, punished sex between men; West Germany kept the version widened under the Nazis until 1969 and abolished the paragraph only in 1994. Magnus Hirschfeld's Scientific-Humanitarian Committee, founded in 1897 to repeal it, was the first homosexual rights organisation.
In Britain the Labouchère Amendment of 1885 punished "gross indecency" between men, and the trials of Oscar Wilde in 1895 are its best-known case. After the Wolfenden report of 1957 recommended that consensual private acts between adults should no longer be crimes, England and Wales decriminalised them in 1967. Nazi Germany widened Paragraph 175 greatly in 1935, set up the Reich Central Office for the Combating of Homosexuality and Abortion, and made homosexual prisoners in the concentration camps wear the pink triangle.
In the Cold War United States gay people were cast, together with communists, as threats to national security and purged from government service: the "lavender scare".
How has medicine regarded homosexuality?
Late nineteenth-century psychiatry treated homosexuality as an inborn nervous disease or mental illness. Against this Hirschfeld put forward the theory of sexual intermediaries, explaining homosexuality as an inborn variation between the sexes. In the mid-twentieth century research by Alfred Kinsey and Evelyn Hooker suggested that homosexuality is normal and non-pathological.
Under pressure from activists after the 1969 Stonewall riots, and faced with this research, the board of trustees of the American Psychiatric Association voted in December 1973 to declassify homosexuality as a mental disorder, and the full membership confirmed this in 1974. The World Health Organization, which had listed homosexuality in the ICD-9 in 1977, removed it from the ICD-10 endorsed by the 43rd World Health Assembly on 17 May 1990. Russia removed homosexuality from its list of mental illnesses in 1999, on adopting the ICD-10.
How did socialists view homosexuality?
The socialist movement was not of one mind. In the 1860s Ulrichs sent Karl Marx several of his books, and in 1869 Marx passed one of them on to Friedrich Engels, who mocked it in a letter to Marx of 22 June 1869, remarking that only in Germany could such a fellow appear, turn the filth into a theory and issue the invitation "introite":
Übrigens auch nur in Deutschland möglich daß so ein Bursche auftritt, die Schweinerei in eine Theorie umsetzt & einladet introite usw.
The surrounding passages can be read in the full letter.
August Bebel of the German Social Democratic Party showed two faces. His Woman and Socialism (1879), the work on sexuality most widely read by party members, called same-sex love a "crime against nature" and depicted it as an upper-class, metropolitan and foreign vice. Yet in 1898 he took the petition gathered by Hirschfeld's committee to repeal Paragraph 175 to the Reichstag and urged colleagues to sign it, and on 13 January 1898, in open session, he became the first known politician to support homosexual emancipation openly.
After the 1917 revolution Soviet Russia repealed the whole tsarist penal code, and the Russian republic's criminal codes of 1922 and 1926 did not punish consensual same-sex relations. Some see this as the sexual liberation the revolution brought. Grigory Batkis, director of the Moscow Institute for Social Hygiene, wrote in reports of 1923 and 1925, The Sexual Revolution in Russia, that homosexuality was "perfectly natural" and should be legally and socially respected. The context matters, however. Decriminalisation applied only to the Russian and Ukrainian republics; Azerbaijan criminalised sodomy in 1923, Uzbekistan in 1926 and Turkmenistan the year after. In the late 1920s Batkis and others repudiated their earlier views, and in 1933 Stalin's government recriminalised homosexuality: from 7 March 1934 a new article punished male homosexuality throughout the Union with up to five years' hard labour (see Soviet sodomy law). Assessments therefore differ. Some studies hold that the early Soviet Union practised a degree of toleration until 1929–1933, while others judge that decriminalisation was the result of discarding the old code wholesale and that the medical view of homosexuality as illness remained.
In Cuba the Military Units to Aid Production (UMAP), set up in 1965 as an alternative to military service, held many gay men until they closed in 1968. The 1979 penal code decriminalised private, consensual same-sex relations between adults, and in a 2010 interview Fidel Castro called the persecution of homosexuals "a great injustice" and said, "If anyone is responsible, it's me." A new Family Code passed by referendum in 2022 recognised same-sex marriage.
In the Cold War West the gay movement grew, if anything, on the left. Harry Hay, a Communist Party member and labour activist, founded the Mattachine Society in Los Angeles in 1950 and, with a concept of the "cultural minority" drawn from his Marxist studies, argued that gay people were not just individuals but a group. The Gay Liberation Front, formed in New York right after the Stonewall riots of 1969, took its name in allusion to the Algerian and Vietnamese National Liberation Fronts and adopted an anti-capitalist stance with support for the Black Panthers; a London GLF followed in 1970. Theorists from the New Left after May 1968, such as Guy Hocquenghem in France and Mario Mieli in Italy, saw gay liberation as part of a wider emancipation, and some were inspired by Herbert Marcuse's Eros and Civilization.
What do South Korean law and courts say?
South Korea's criminal code does not punish same-sex acts between civilians. The Military Criminal Act, however, punishes them between soldiers: Article 92-6 provides that a person who commits anal intercourse or any other indecent act against a person under Article 1(1) to (3) shall be imprisoned for up to two years.
제92조의6(추행) 제1조제1항부터 제3항까지에 규정된 사람에 대하여 항문성교나 그 밖의 추행을 한 사람은 2년 이하의 징역에 처한다.
The Constitutional Court upheld the earlier form of this provision on 28 July 2016 (2012Hun-Ba258). On 21 April 2022 the Supreme Court sitting en banc (2019Do3047) acquitted male soldiers who had had consensual sex in their single quarters on a holiday or after hours, holding that the provision does not apply where acts between soldiers of the same sex take place by free mutual agreement in a private space and cannot be seen as directly and concretely harming the sound life and discipline of the military community:
위 규정은 동성인 군인 사이의 항문성교나 그 밖에 이와 유사한 행위가 사적 공간에서 자발적 의사 합치에 따라 이루어지는 등 군이라는 공동사회의 건전한 생활과 군기를 직접적, 구체적으로 침해한 것으로 보기 어려운 경우에는 적용되지 않는다고 봄이 타당하다.
Justices Jo Jae-youn and Lee Dong-won dissented, criticising this reading as going beyond the possible meaning of the text and amounting to legislation. On 26 October 2023 the Constitutional Court (2017Hun-Ga16) again upheld the provision. The majority, citing the military's hierarchy and closed communal life, held that punishing consensual acts between soldiers of the same sex, at least where they take place at the place of duty or during duties, is not an excessive restriction because they risk serious harm to the preservation of the armed forces' fighting power:
동성 군인 사이의 합의에 의한 성적 행위라 하더라도 그러한 행위가 근무장소나 임무수행 중에 이루어진다면, 이는 국군의 전투력 보존에 심각한 위해를 초래할 위험성이 있으므로, 이를 처벌한다고 하여도 과도한 제한이라고 할 수 없다.
Justices Kim Ki-young, Lee Mi-son and Chung Jung-mi dissented, writing that now that the traditional view of same-sex acts as contrary to good sexual morals can no longer be accepted as a universally valid norm, there is no reason to judge consensual acts between soldiers of the same sex differently from consensual acts between soldiers of different sexes; Justice Moon Hyung-bae joined the dissent that the provision is unclear.
동성 간의 성적 행위가 선량한 성적 도덕관념에 반하는 행위라는 종래의 평가를 이 시대 보편타당한 규범으로 받아들이기 어렵게 된 현 시점에서, 동성 군인 간의 합의에 의한 성적 행위와 이성 간의 합의에 의한 성적 행위를 규범적으로 달리 평가해야 할 이유가 없다.
On 18 July 2024 the en banc Supreme Court (2023Du36800) held unlawful the National Health Insurance Service's withdrawal of a same-sex partner's status as a dependant. The Service recognised opposite-sex partners in de facto marriage as dependants but not same-sex partners, and the majority held that this treatment discriminates between essentially identical groups on the ground of sexual orientation:
이러한 취급은 성적 지향을 이유로 본질적으로 동일한 집단을 차별하는 행위에 해당하며
In a separate opinion Justices Lee Dong-won, Noh Tae-ak, Oh Seok-jun and Kwon Young-joon accepted only the procedural defect, holding that same-sex partners and persons in de facto marriage do not belong to essentially the same group and that classifying same-sex partners as regional subscribers was not arbitrary discrimination:
‘동성 동반자’와 ‘사실상 혼인관계에 있는 사람’은 본질적으로 동일한 집단에 속한다고 볼 수 없고, 동성 동반자를 피부양자에서 제외하여 지역가입자로 분류한 것을 합리적 근거 없는 자의적 차별이라고 하기도 어렵다.
The National Human Rights Commission Act of 2001 lists "sexual orientation" among the grounds of discrimination, but there is still no comprehensive anti-discrimination law generally prohibiting it. An anti-discrimination bill submitted by the Ministry of Justice in 2007 was abandoned in the face of an opposition movement, and later bills in the National Assembly have not passed. Objections have come chiefly from conservative Protestants, while the National Human Rights Commission and United Nations human rights bodies have repeatedly recommended a law.
Related people
Related historical events
Sources
- Wikipedia (EN)
- Wikipedia (EN)
- Wikipedia (EN)
- Wikipedia (EN)
- de.wikipedia.org
- Wikipedia (EN)
- de.wikipedia.org
- de.wikipedia.org
- Wikipedia (EN)
- Wikipedia (EN)
- Wikipedia (EN)
- Wikipedia (EN)
- megadigital.bbaw.de
- Wikipedia (EN)
- Wikipedia (EN)
- Wikipedia (EN)
- Wikipedia (EN)
- Wikipedia (EN)
- Wikipedia (EN)
- Wikipedia (EN)
- Wikipedia (EN)
- law.go.kr
- law.go.kr
- law.go.kr
- law.go.kr
- law.go.kr
- law.go.kr