JNR 1,047 Dismissals Issue
국철 1047명 해고 문제
The 23-year dispute over the 1,047 workers, most of them members of Kokuro and the rest of Zendoro and Doro-Chiba, who were not hired by the JR companies at the 1987 breakup of the Japanese National Railways, were sent to the JNR Settlement Corporation and were dismissed in 1990. Prefectural and central labour commissions found unfair labour practices and ordered relief, but in 2003 the Supreme Court ruled that the JR companies bore no responsibility. A political settlement on 28 June 2010 paid about 19.9 billion yen to 904 households, including bereaved families, without reinstatement.
In depth
The lists of workers to be hired were drawn up by JNR and handed to the JR companies. JNR's criteria included having been suspended twice or more between fiscal 1983 and 1986, and many who were rejected in Hokkaido and Kyushu had asked to be hired only locally. Sources put the number of Kokuro members not hired at between 5,009 and 5,049, most of them in Hokkaido and Kyushu. In February 1987 the founding congress of Tetsudo Roren resolved that "bad employees who shed neither sweat nor tears" must not be hired, which the Labour Year Book of Japan described as practically an invitation to unfair labour practices by a union.
The dismissed workers formed 36 Kokuro struggle groups and lived by selling goods while they fought. In 1998 the Tokyo District Court annulled the relief orders on the ground that JNR and the JR companies were separate entities, and on 22 December 2003 the Supreme Court upheld it. In 2005 the Tokyo District Court found that the successor of the Settlement Corporation had discriminated against the union and ordered 5 million yen in damages per person. After the 2010 settlement the seven JR companies refused the government's request in 2011 to hire the workers, and Kokuro ended its "24-year struggle" that year. Doro-Chiba rejected the settlement as legitimizing "unfair labour practice by the state."