Trial of Pak Hon-yong (1955)
박헌영 재판 (1955)
Part of Trial of the Workers' Party of South Korea leaders (1953)
The trial before the Special Tribunal of the Supreme Court in Pyongyang on 15 December 1955 that sentenced Pak Hon-yong, former leader of the Workers' Party of South Korea and North Korea's vice-premier and foreign minister, to death for spying for the United States and plotting to overthrow the state. Choe Yong-gon presided, and Pak was not allowed a defence lawyer. The trial was over within a day. The date and place of his execution are not confirmed: accounts range from December 1955 to July or December 1956. The Soviet Union and China are said to have tried to stop the execution.
In depth
What were the charges?
Pak Hon-yong was arrested in the 1953 purge of the WPSK group but was not tried with Yi Sung-yop and the others; he was held for more than two years. On 15 December 1955 he was charged with the same crimes: spying for the United States, attempting a coup and obstructing unification. The judgment claimed that he had acquired pro-American ideas through his friendship with the missionary Underwood around 1919, had betrayed the movement to the Japanese after his arrest in 1925, and after liberation had made a secret pact with the US commander Hodge and handed over party secrets. The trial record survives under the title "Trial documents of the plot by the American imperialist hired spies, the Pak Hon-yong and Ri Sung-yop clique, to overthrow the DPRK government, and their espionage case."
How was the trial conducted?
Choe Yong-gon presided, flanked by Kim Il Sung's confidants including Kim Ik-seon and Pang Hak-se. Pak was not allowed a lawyer, and the trial began at 10 in the morning and ended that night. The prosecution called nine witnesses. In his final statement Pak is reported to have said that his contacts with Americans had served liberation and unification, while taking all responsibility on himself and asking that the WPSK cadres be spared.
When was he executed?
The date is not confirmed. English Wikipedia gives December 1955, the Encyclopedia of Korean Culture 19 July 1956. Korean Wikipedia notes that the diary of Soviet ambassador Ivanov records him still alive in April 1956, cites testimony that Kim Il Sung ordered Pang Hak-se to execute him after the August faction incident of 1956, and lists 15 or 19 December and 19 July as possible dates. The Soviet Union repeatedly asked for Pak to be sent to the USSR, and Mao Zedong is also said to have tried to save him.
How is it judged?
Through this trial North Korea laid the blame for the defeat in the Korean War on Pak. Korean Wikipedia concludes that there is no objective evidence that he was an American spy. The historian Park Myung-lim called his death "the greatest mystery of modern North Korean history." In the South he was long denied recognition as an independence activist because he was a communist.