Pak Yol Incident
박열 사건
The case in which the Korean anarchist Pak Yol and his Japanese comrade Kaneko Fumiko, taken into custody in Tokyo just after the Great Kanto Earthquake of September 1923, were tried for high treason on the charge of planning to kill the emperor and the crown prince with bombs. The Great Court of Cassation sentenced both to death on 25 March 1926; the sentences were commuted to life imprisonment on 5 April. Kaneko died in prison that July, and Pak was held until October 1945. No bomb was ever obtained and no act was carried out. The case is widely judged to have been inflated to serve the authorities after the massacre of Koreans.
In depth
Who were Pak Yol and Kaneko Fumiko?
Pak Yol (1902-1974), from Mungyeong in North Gyeongsang, was expelled from his higher common school in Seoul for taking part in the March First Movement and went to Tokyo in 1919. He studied while working at jobs such as delivering newspapers, and became an anarchist through contact with Japanese activists such as Osugi Sakae and Sakai Toshihiko. He took the lead in founding the Black Wave Society in 1921 and, after it split, led the anarchist Black Friends Society (Heukuhoe). Kaneko Fumiko (1903-1926) met Pak in 1922, lived with him and joined both societies. About November 1922 they began a magazine, Futoi Senjin, later renamed Gen Shakai (Present Society). The title they had wanted was Futei Senjin ("unruly Koreans"); made to change it, they chose the like-sounding futoi ("brazen").
In April 1923 the two formed the Futeisha in their rented house in Yoyogi, Tokyo, with fifteen Koreans and six Japanese, twenty-one in all. The Futeisha was a circle for studying and spreading anarchism and took no visible direct action. Pak, meanwhile, unknown to his other comrades, asked several people to get him bombs, but never obtained any.
How did it become a case?
When the Great Kanto Earthquake struck on 1 September 1923, rumours spread that Koreans were rioting, and the army, the police and vigilante groups killed great numbers of Koreans (the Kanto Massacre). On 3 September, under martial law, Pak and Kaneko were taken in under the name of protective custody, and the members of the Futeisha were arrested one after another over the following month. The prosecution indicted all of them, describing the Futeisha as a secret society aiming at direct action by violence. Under interrogation Niiyama Hatsuyo, a member, stated that Pak had tried to obtain bombs for use at the crown prince's wedding. On 15 February 1924 the examining judge, Tatematsu Kaisei, indicted the two under the Explosives Control Penal Regulations. Pak declared that the bomb plan had nothing to do with the Futeisha, and all the members except Pak, Kaneko and Kim Jung-han were released when the preliminary examination ended in June 1924.
The judicial authorities then changed the charge to high treason: Article 73 of the Criminal Code, which punished with death anyone who harmed or attempted to harm the emperor, the crown prince and other members of the imperial family, and which had been used in the Kotoku Incident of 1910. In the preliminary examination Pak took the attitude of admitting that he had meant to attack the emperor and the crown prince at the wedding of Crown Prince Hirohito, planned for the autumn of 1923. Kaneko for her part argued against the emperor system. The indictment for high treason came in 1925; sources give either May or July.
How did the trial end?
The trial before the Great Court of Cassation opened on 26 February 1926 and was over within a month. The defence was led by Fuse Tatsuji, a Japanese lawyer who took many cases arising from the Korean independence movement. The two registered their marriage just before sentence. On 25 March the court sentenced both to death, and on 5 April the sentences were commuted to life imprisonment in the name of imperial clemency. Pak is said to have declared that he refused the clemency, and Kaneko to have torn up the certificate in front of the prison governor. Kaneko was moved to the Tochigi branch of Utsunomiya Prison, where she died on 23 July. The authorities announced that she had hanged herself; her family and Fuse did not believe it, and how she died was never established.
How did the case shake Japanese politics?
On 29 July 1926, just after Kaneko's death, a photograph of the two sitting affectionately together during the preliminary examination was circulated with a document among politicians and the press: the so-called mysterious photograph affair. It had been obtained and released by Nishida Mitsugi, acting for Kita Ikki, to bring down the cabinet of Wakatsuki Reijiro. Amid the outcry that traitors had been treated too indulgently, Judge Tatematsu was dismissed, and the opposition Rikken Seiyukai used the affair to attack the cabinet, tabling a motion of impeachment in January 1927. As the Taisho Emperor had just died, the leaders of the three parties agreed on a political truce and the affair subsided. The photograph had in fact been taken in May 1925, under the preceding cabinet of Kato Takaaki.
Why is it called a manufactured case?
No attack took place and there was no bomb. The Japanese Wikipedia notes that an affair short even of an attempt ended in a conviction for high treason largely because of what the two said in the preliminary examination and in court and because of the calculations of the officials in charge. The police and the judicial authorities presented Pak, who had long been active for Korean independence, as having plotted a riot and a bombing, meaning to use this as a justification against the condemnation at home and abroad that the killing of Koreans would bring. The Encyclopedia of Korean Culture likewise judges that Japan, having massacred more than six thousand Koreans, tried to escape responsibility by making the Futeisha out to be a secret society planning an uprising.
Afterwards
Pak remained in prison for more than twenty-two years, until his release on 27 October 1945. He then served as the first head of the Korean Residents' Union in Japan (Mindan), returned to Korea, was taken to the North during the Korean War and died in 1974. Kaneko's remains were buried in Mungyeong, Pak's home, and in 2018 the government of the Republic of Korea posthumously awarded her the Order of Merit for National Foundation. It was a case in which a young man from colonial Korea and his Japanese comrade were punished for high treason for standing together against the emperor system.