Paranoid reading and reparative reading
편집증적 읽기와 회복적 읽기
Two critical stances set out by the American literary theorist Eve Kosofsky Sedgwick in a 1997 essay. "Paranoid reading" seeks out and exposes hidden violence and falsehood in advance so as never to be surprised by bad news; Sedgwick held that under the name of the hermeneutics of suspicion it had become nearly synonymous with criticism itself. "Reparative reading," borrowing a concept from the psychoanalyst Melanie Klein, gathers fragments and reassembles them into something that can nourish the self. Sedgwick offered it as another way of knowing, no less acute or realistic than the paranoid one, and the essay became one of the starting points of the later "postcritique" debate.
In depth
If the conspiracy were true, what would we know?
Sometime in the middle of the first decade of the AIDS epidemic, the American literary theorist Eve Kosofsky Sedgwick was picking the brains of her friend, the activist scholar Cindy Patton, about the natural history of HIV. Rumours were everywhere that the virus had been deliberately engineered or spread, that it was a US military plot or experiment gone out of control. After hearing a lot from Patton about the global traffic in blood products, Sedgwick asked what she thought of these sinister rumours. Patton said that any of the early steps could have been accidental or deliberate, but that she had trouble getting interested: suppose we were sure that the lives of Africans and African Americans are worthless in the eyes of the United States, that gay men and drug users are held cheap or hated, that the military researches ways to kill noncombatants it sees as enemies, that people in power look calmly on catastrophe.
Supposing we were ever so sure of all those things — what would we know then that we don’t already know?
Sedgwick brooded over the reply for years. Having an unmystified, angry view of large, systemic oppressions, she concluded, does not necessarily oblige anyone to spend their energies tracing and exposing such a plot; the choice is ethically fraught but strategic and local, not a categorical imperative. The anecdote opened a way from the question "Is this piece of knowledge true, and how can we know?" to the question "What does knowledge do?"
The essay first appeared in 1997 as the introduction to Novel Gazing, a collection Sedgwick edited, and was revised as chapter 4 of her book Touching Feeling (2003). Its subtitle is "You're So Paranoid, You Probably Think This Essay Is About You."
What marks paranoid reading?
The critical habits Paul Ricœur called the "hermeneutics of suspicion," Sedgwick argued, had become nearly synonymous with criticism in the United States, and the concept of paranoia had become privileged along with them. Queer studies had a particular intimacy with paranoia, since Freud traced paranoia to repressed same-sex desire. Looking back at her own writing of the 1980s and that of other critics, she asked how paranoia passed from being an object of antihomophobic theory to being its uniquely sanctioned method. She sketched five features.
Paranoia is anticipatory: its first imperative is "There must be no bad surprises," and bad news must always already be known. Paranoia is reflexive and mimetic: like setting a thief to catch a thief, it is understood only by imitation and understands only by imitation. Paranoia is a strong theory, in the psychologist Silvan Tomkins's term, organising a very wide domain of phenomena, and its reductive force makes it prone to tautology. Paranoia is a theory of negative affects, bent on avoiding humiliation and pain rather than on increasing joy. And paranoia places its faith in exposure: it acts as if its work would be done once its story was truly known, hardly considering that a fully informed listener might remain indifferent or hostile.
As an example of this faith she cited the final pages of Judith Butler's Gender Trouble, where drag and gender parody repeatedly "reveal" and "expose" the imitative structure of gender. She also asked what a hermeneutics of exposure has to say where visibility itself is much of the violence: the chain gangs reinstated in several Southern states aim at public shaming more than hard labour, and today it is death-penalty enthusiasts who want executions on television. Where no one is surprised to learn that ideologies contradict themselves, the "news" of exposure no longer has the force it had in the 1960s.
What did Klein's idea of "positions" change?
Sedgwick found an alternative in the psychoanalyst Melanie Klein, who described mental life in terms of "positions" rather than ordered stages. In the paranoid-schizoid position, marked by hatred, envy and anxiety, one is terribly alert to the dangers of the hateful part-objects one has projected into the world. The depressive position is an anxiety-mitigating achievement that one only sometimes, and often only briefly, manages to inhabit; from it one can use one's own resources to assemble or "repair" the murderous part-objects into something like a whole, though not necessarily like any preexisting whole. Once assembled, the object can be identified with and can offer nourishment and comfort in turn. Among Klein's names for this reparative process is love.
Sedgwick welcomed "position" because it names a changing relational stance rather than a fixed personality type: it is not people but mutable positions, or practices, that divide into paranoid and reparative. Patton's calm reply, she noted, itself drew on much paranoiacally structured research. The two positions are intertwined, and paranoid knowledge is sometimes necessary.
What is it to read reparatively?
To read from a reparative position, Sedgwick wrote, is to surrender the knowing, anxious paranoid determination that no horror shall ever come to the reader as new; to a reparatively positioned reader it can seem realistic and necessary to experience surprise. Because there can be terrible surprises, there can also be good ones. Hope is among the energies with which such a reader organises the fragments she meets or makes. A reader with room to realise that the future may differ from the present can also entertain the painful, relieving possibility that the past could have happened differently.
Her example was the last volume of Proust's In Search of Lost Time, where the narrator, back in society after a long absence, first thinks the guests at a party are wearing costumes to look old, then realises they are old, and so is he, and is assailed by joyous "truths" about writing and time. She also spoke of herself and three friends: for her, living with advanced breast cancer, and for younger friends living with cancer or HIV, the "normal" timetable of generations did not apply. Such queer disruptions of time, she suggested, can ground reparative knowing.
She saw camp as a prime reparative practice. Through paranoid lenses that see only parody and exposure, one cannot account for camp's displays of excess erudition, its "over"-attachment to waste and leftovers, its juxtapositions of past and present, popular and high culture (see "Camp (aesthetics)"). The vocabulary for reparative motives has long sounded sappy, anti-intellectual or reactionary, she wrote, so few critics admit to them; but the problem lies in the limits of theoretical vocabulary, not in the reparative motive. The reparative position is no less acute, no less realistic, no less attached to a project of survival than the paranoid. The essay ends:
What we can best learn from such practices are, perhaps, the many ways selves and communities succeed in extracting sustenance from the objects of a culture—even of a culture whose avowed desire has often been not to sustain them.
How did the essay shape later criticism?
In the essay Sedgwick needled Fredric Jameson's slogan "Always historicize!", asking what could have less to do with historicising than the commanding, atemporal adverb "always" (see "Hermeneutics of suspicion"). She also wrote that the link between queer thought and paranoia might be less necessary than earlier writing, "very much including my own," had assumed: a look back by the author of Epistemology of the Closet (1990), a founding text of queer theory (see "Epistemology of the Closet").
The essay became one of the starting points of the twenty-first-century "postcritique" debate. Rita Felski read reparative reading as calling for a stance that looks to a work of art for solace and replenishment rather than as something to be interrogated and indicted. Bruce Robbins replied that for marginalised groups facing systemic injustice paranoia is a legitimate language, and Merve Emre held that Felski and others had misunderstood Sedgwick. Touching Feeling, the last book Sedgwick published and the one that reprinted the essay, maps her interest in affect, pedagogy and performativity.