April 6 Incident (Taiwan)
4·6 사건 (대만)
The mass arrest of students on 6 April 1949, when soldiers and police acting on orders from Chen Cheng, Taiwan's provincial chairman and garrison commander, surrounded the dormitories of the Provincial Normal College and National Taiwan University in Taipei. After student protests against a police beating had forced the police to apologise in March, the authorities saw communist infiltration and decided to crush the student movement. Of the six students named for arrest, only one was actually a Communist Party member. Together with the declaration of martial law that May, it is counted as the start of the White Terror.
In depth
The April 6 Incident took place in the spring of 1949, as the Nationalist government was being driven from the mainland: the military authorities in Taiwan burst into university dormitories and carried students off. From this case on, the Garrison Command could write to a school and have students handed over, or enter a campus and seize them directly, and it is therefore counted as the opening of the Taiwanese White Terror of the 1950s. On one side of it was the wave of the mainland student movement, on the other the fear of a government that was losing the civil war.
At the time the universities of Taiwan had many students who had come over from the mainland and local intellectuals who leaned towards socialism. On the mainland the assault on a Beijing student by an American serviceman at the end of 1946 and the "anti-hunger, anti-civil-war" movement of 1947 had turned students against the government, and in Taiwan many students moved to the left after the February 28 Incident of 1947. The Student Work Committee of the Taiwan Provincial Work Committee of the Communist Party of China was rapidly extending its organisation in National Taiwan University and the Teachers College in these years.
In 1948 students of the Provincial Normal College (today's National Taiwan Normal University), joined by National Taiwan University, waged an "anti-hunger struggle" for better public stipends. On the night of 20 March 1949 a university student and a Normal College student riding one bicycle were stopped by a policeman for a traffic violation, beaten and detained. Several hundred students from both schools surrounded the police sub-station and freed the two, and the next day more than a thousand students and townspeople surrounded the police headquarters and extracted an apology. The authorities concluded that the campuses had been subjected to Chinese Communist united-front work and infiltration.
When students at a campfire of the university's law school on 29 March sang revolutionary songs and planned an island-wide student assembly for 4 May, Chen Cheng ordered the deputy garrison commander Peng Meng-chi to arrest the "ringleaders". On 6 April the Garrison Command named six students for arrest, of whom only Cheng Hung-hsi was a Communist Party member. When students resisted, barricading the stairs with tables and chairs and throwing crockery, soldiers and police surrounded the dormitories of both schools, stormed them and took the students away in trucks. Fu Ssu-nien, president of National Taiwan University, protested against the arrest of students on campus without legal procedure and demanded that arrests require his approval, while the Normal College cooperated with the authorities and set up a committee to rectify the school's conduct.
Events across the sea raised the tension further. On 1 April 1949 a march in Nanjing of more than ten thousand students, who were demanding that the government accept the Communists' peace terms, was put down with several killed and injured. When the news reached Taipei, the fear spread through the colleges that repression would come there too. Five days later it did.
From 8 April the Garrison Command released the arrested students in batches, and in the end 19 were detained and tried. Chang Kwang-chih, later a well-known archaeologist, was among those jailed. The provincial government ordered the Teachers College closed and all its students to register again, and 36 were struck off. Of the six named in the warrant, Chou Shen-yuan, chairman of the Teachers College student council, escaped and then joined the Communist Party, and Cheng Hung-hsi and Chu Shang-yi crossed to the mainland and joined the People's Liberation Army.
Accounts conflict on how the heads of the two institutions behaved. In the familiar story Fu Ssu-nien, president of National Taiwan University, protected the students and warned Peng Meng-chi, "If students bleed, I will fight you to the death", while Hsieh Tung-min, head of the Teachers College, went with the soldiers and police to arrest students. But the content of the university's open course "Postwar History of Democracy in Taiwan: the White Terror and National Taiwan University", as reported by the Chinese Wikipedia, says the opposite: Fu cooperated actively with the government and had staff take the list into the dormitories to point students out, and Hsieh, unwilling to cooperate in the purge, resigned on the spot. The NTU student association points out, citing Chen Cheng's memoirs, that what Fu actually said was three conditions: "do it quickly, do it thoroughly, and no bloodshed".
The incident was the threshold of what followed. In May of that year martial law was declared and the Act for the Control and Punishment of Rebellion was made. When the Work Committee's underground newspaper was uncovered in August and its secretary Cai Xiaoqian gave up the organisation the next year, many students and graduates who had been underground party members in the two institutions, among them Yeh Cheng-sung and Guo Xiucong, were shot at the Machangding execution ground in Taipei.
Reassessment came after democratisation. In 1995 eight student groups of the two universities began a campaign for rehabilitation, and in June 1997 the report of National Taiwan University's document-collection group affirmed the students' engagement with society. In December 2000 the compensation statute was amended to cover the victims of the April 6 Incident, and on 11 January 2001 the Minister of Education, Ovid Tzeng, apologised on behalf of the government and stated that the incident had nothing to do with Communist infiltration and arose from demands for social justice.