Emperor Organ Theory Incident
천황기관설 사건
The affair of 1935 in which the constitutional scholar Minobe Tatsukichi's emperor organ theory was attacked as a disloyal doctrine contrary to the national polity and banned. The theory held that sovereignty belonged to the state as a legal person and that the emperor was its highest organ, exercising that sovereignty with the advice of his ministers; since the Taishō era it had been the officially accepted reading of the constitution. The military, the ultranationalist right and the opposition Rikken Seiyūkai used it to shake the Okada cabinet, and the government repudiated the theory in two statements on the clarification of the national polity.
In depth
How did it spread?
In the House of Peers on 18 February 1935 Kikuchi Takeo, a retired lieutenant-general, called the organ theory "slow-motion treason" and denounced Minobe as a "bandit of learning." Minobe calmly explained the theory in a "personal vindication" speech on 25 February, but the government banned three of his books, including Kenpō Satsuyō, under the Publication Law. As a campaign against the theory led by the reservists' associations spread across the country, the Okada cabinet issued statements on the clarification of the national polity on 3 August and 15 October. Minobe resigned from the House of Peers on 18 September.
What changed?
The education minister and Prime Minister Okada at first answered that questions of doctrine should be left to scholars, but they gave way. The ground on which the cabinet could claim a say in the emperor's military prerogatives was gone, and constitutional interpretation and education were thereafter unified under the "national polity" doctrine that the emperor himself was the subject of sovereignty.