1970.11.13–1979.10.26

Jeon Tae-il and the Democratic Union Movement of the 1970s

How did the democratic union movement of women workers, set off by one garment cutter's self-immolation, survive under the Yushin system, and how did it help bring that system down?

After the Peace Market cutter Jeon Tae-il set himself alight on 13 November 1970 demanding that the Labour Standards Act be observed, women workers in Seoul and Incheon overturned company-friendly unions and built democratic unions, beginning with the Cheonggye Garment Workers' Union. The October Yushin of 1972 and the emergency decrees crushed opposition and sent eight defendants in the People's Revolutionary Party case to the gallows, but within church industrial missions and small study groups the unions at Dongil Textile, Wonpoong Wool and YH Trading fought on. In August 1979 the police assault on the YH workers' sit-in at the opposition headquarters and the expulsion of Kim Young-sam fed into the Bu-Ma uprising in October, and when Kim Jae-gyu killed Park Chung Hee on 26 October the Yushin system ended.

What was life like for workers in 1970?

In the 1960s the Park Chung Hee government pushed export-led industrialisation. Between 1962 and 1975 some 7.5 million people left the countryside for the big cities and became workers, and light industry grew on their cheap labour. The Encyclopedia of Korean Culture sums up the period this way: because development rested on a supply of "good, cheap and plentiful labour", low wages and long hours marked wage work in these years. 1 2

The only organisation meant to speak for workers was the Federation of Korean Trade Unions (FKTU). Rebuilt from above by the military government after it dissolved the unions in the coup of 16 May 1961, the federation did not represent workers squeezed by low wages under the export drive. In December 1971 the government declared a "national emergency" and passed the Act on Special Measures for National Security, narrowing workers' room for collective action further. 3 4

In the Peace Market by the Cheonggye stream in Seoul, small garment workshops were packed in down to the lofts. Helpers (sida) there worked fourteen hours a day; tuberculosis spread in the unventilated rooms, and workers took pills or injections to stay awake. Jeon Tae-il worked in this market as a helper and then a cutter from 1965. 5 6

Why did Jeon Tae-il burn the Labour Standards Act?

Jeon learned of the Labour Standards Act in 1968 and was angered that even the minimum conditions it set were ignored. In June 1969 he founded the Fool's Association, a circle of Peace Market cutters, surveyed working conditions and petitioned the Labour Office; the petition went nowhere and he lost his job. Back at the market in September 1970 he formed the Samdong Friendship Society, surveyed conditions again and appealed to the government and the press, but nothing changed. 7 5

On 13 November 1970, when police broke up a picket at which Samdong members were to hold a "burning of the Labour Standards Act" in the Peace Market, Jeon doused himself in petrol and set himself alight. He fell shouting "Observe the Labour Standards Act!", "We are not machines!" and "Let us rest on Sundays!", and a comrade threw a copy of the act into the flames to complete the ceremony. Before he died that night he told his mother, Lee So-sun, "Do not let my death be in vain." The Encyclopedia of Korean Culture writes that he had prepared the act long in advance without telling his family or friends. 7 8 5

His death shook the country. Lee So-sun refused to take her son's body until his demands were met, and on 27 November she and the market workers founded the Cheonggye branch of the National Federated Trade Union, the Cheonggye Garment Workers' Union, which named her its adviser. Jang Gi-pyo, a Seoul National University law student, proposed a student funeral, and Cho Yeong-rae, then preparing for the bar examination, drafted the statement read at the university's memorial on 20 November that accused five "murderers": the Park government, the employers, the pro-government union federation, the intellectuals and society at large. Church and student vigils and fasts followed, and newspapers ran special features on labour. 8 9 10 11 7

How did the Yushin system bind workers and dissenters?

After a narrow victory over Kim Dae-jung in the 1971 presidential election, Park dissolved the National Assembly and suspended political activity by emergency measures on 17 October 1972 (the October Yushin). The Yushin Constitution, approved by referendum in November, had the National Conference for Unification elect the president indirectly, lengthened the term to six years and removed any limit on re-election. The Encyclopedia of Korean Culture counts among Yushin's motives the anger of those left behind by industrialisation, which had begun to break out in events such as Jeon's self-immolation and the Gwangju Housing Complex riot of 1971. 12 13

The core instrument of the Yushin system was the emergency decree. Article 53 of the Yushin Constitution let the president take emergency measures across all affairs of state whenever he judged that national security was threatened "or might be threatened", and placed such measures beyond judicial review. Park issued nine decrees, from No. 1 on 8 January 1974 to No. 9 on 13 May 1975. Decree No. 9 banned opposition to the Yushin Constitution itself, student assemblies and demonstrations, and criticism of the decrees. In 2010 the Supreme Court ruled Decree No. 1 unconstitutional. 14 15

Labour was bound by the same frame. With the October Yushin the labour laws were revised so that the right to strike was effectively closed off, and the FKTU issued a statement backing Yushin and threw its support behind the New Village Movement. The new unions of the 1970s therefore remained formally branches of FKTU industrial federations but went an entirely different way in how they were run and how they fought; people called them "democratic unions". 4 3 1

How did Yushin punish dissenting students and the reformist left?

Yushin pictured opposition as communist conspiracy. On 13 November 1971 the Korea Central Intelligence Agency (KCIA) announced a "Seoul National University students' plot" to overthrow the government, and Jang Gi-pyo and Cho Yeong-rae were arrested. The Encyclopedia of Korean Culture judges the case a fabricated charge of communist sympathy, meant to strike student leaders in advance and prepare the emergency that preceded Yushin. On 3 April 1974 Emergency Decree No. 4 was issued together with the announcement of the National Democratic Youth and Student Federation (Mincheong Hangnyeon) case; some 180 people were indicted, and former president Yun Po-sun and the Rev. Park Hyeong-gyu were convicted. A retrial acquitted the defendants in 2009. 16 17 18

The government named an "Inhyeokdang (People's Revolutionary Party) Reconstruction Committee" as the hidden hand behind the student federation. The accused included Do Ye-jong, jailed after the first People's Revolutionary Party case of 1964, Seo Do-won and Song Sang-jin of the reformist youth movement after the April Revolution of 1960, and Yeo Jeong-nam of Kyungpook National University, charged with plotting to overthrow the government and set up a communist regime. In July 1974 the emergency court-martial sentenced eight of them to death; the Supreme Court confirmed the sentences on 8 April 1975, and they were hanged the very next day, 9 April. The International Commission of Jurists called it a "dark day in the history of the judiciary". 19 20 21

In 2002 the Presidential Truth Commission on Suspicious Deaths declared the case a KCIA fabrication, and in 2005 the National Intelligence Service's own truth committee acknowledged the torture and fabrication. On 23 January 2007 the Seoul Central District Court acquitted Do Ye-jong and the seven others on retrial. Do had testified as early as the 1964 case that he had been tortured with electricity at the KCIA and had confessed falsely. 19 20

How did women workers build the democratic unions?

The backbone of the 1970s democratic union movement was young women working in the textile, garment and electronics plants of Seoul and Incheon. After the Cheonggye union of 1970, the unions at Wonpoong Wool (then Hanguk Mobang) and Dongil Textile threw out their company-friendly leaderships in 1972, and new unions were formed at Control Data in 1973, Bando Sangsa in 1974 and YH Trading in 1975. At Dongil Textile, where most workers were women, men had always led the union until on 10 May 1972 Ju Gil-ja became the first woman branch chair in the history of the FKTU. 1 22

The democratic unions held together through small groups and education. The Cheonggye union had circles such as the Acacia and Torch societies and a workers' classroom opened in 1973; at Wonpoong the officers kept small groups going so that more than half the members took part; the YH union ran the Nokji night school. With strikes effectively barred under Yushin, they won wage rises and better conditions through sit-ins, demonstrations, go-slows and work-to-rule. The Cheonggye union's sit-in for shorter hours in 1975 and its defence of the workers' classroom in 1977 are the best-known examples. 1 11 8

The unions also helped one another. In 1978 some thirty workers from Dongil, Wonpoong and Haitai Confectionery occupied the Christian Broadcasting System, and workers from several companies demonstrated together at a joint church service. Lee So-sun ran the Cheonggye workers' classroom and turned up at countless disputes, earning the name "mother of workers". 1 8 23

Why did the churches stand beside factory workers?

Behind the democratic unions stood the churches. The Protestant Urban Industrial Mission began in the late 1950s, led by American missionaries, as factory evangelism, and around 1968 turned to "industrial mission" aimed at changing workers' conditions. The Yeongdeungpo Urban Industrial Mission, founded in 1958 as the Yeongdeungpo Industrial Evangelism Society, backed, under its first general secretary the Rev. Cho Ji-song, the struggles at Wonpoong Wool, Bangrim Spinning, Haitai Confectionery and other plants in the Yeongdeungpo industrial district; the Rev. In Myung-jin also served as its general secretary for twelve years from 1972. At the Incheon mission, the Rev. Cho Hwa-sun took a job on the Dongil Textile line in 1966 and nurtured the women workers' circles there. 24 25 26 27 28

On the Catholic side the Young Catholic Workers (JOC), launched in Seoul in 1958 as the Korean branch of a movement begun in Belgium, did the same work. In the 1960s and 1970s it helped workers form unions, win pay rises and run labour classes, and after Jeon's death it took on a strongly human-rights character and came under government pressure. When the FKTU backed Yushin, the Urban Industrial Mission broke with the federation and turned openly to supporting the democratic unions. 29 24

The government and employers branded this solidarity as red infiltration. In 1978 Dongil Textile and the textile union's head office claimed that "subversive red groups called the Urban Industrial Mission and the Korean Young Catholic Workers are behind it", and after the YH incident the government investigated the mission and set up a special team on "infiltration of outside forces into industry". Pastors, staff and workers of the Incheon and Yeongdeungpo missions were arrested, tortured and fired. 22 30 24

What did the "excrement incident" at Dongil Textile reveal?

As women kept winning the union leadership at Dongil Textile in Incheon, the company and male workers tried to overturn it. On 23 July 1976 branch chair Lee Yeong-suk was taken away and male delegates elected their own chair, and some 800 members began a sit-in. When police moved in on 25 July the women stripped off their work clothes in protest, but 72 were detained and about fifty fainted. On 4 April 1977 Lee Chong-gak was elected branch chair. 22

Before dawn on 21 February 1978 male workers threw excrement over the women members preparing the delegate election. On 6 March the textile union's head office declared the branch "in trouble" and expelled Lee Chong-gak and three others. On 10 March, 76 women workers shouted "We cannot live eating shit!" at the live-broadcast Workers' Day ceremony, and the rest fasted for fourteen days in Myeongdong Cathedral. On 1 April the company fired 124 of them, and textile union chief Kim Yeong-tae circulated the names of 126 dismissed workers as a blacklist that kept them out of other factories. 22 31

In 2001 the Commission on Democratisation Movement Honour Restoration and Compensation found that the KCIA had intervened in the Dongil affair and recognised 74 people as democratisation activists. The company refused to rehire them, and in 2018 the Seoul High Court ordered the state to pay damages to the dismissed workers. The Encyclopedia of Korean Culture judges the struggle the groundwork for the Incheon labour movement of the 1980s. 22

How did the YH workers' sit-in at the opposition headquarters become a crisis for the regime?

YH Trading, a wig exporter, had some 4,000 employees in the early 1970s, but as the wig trade declined its owner moved money abroad and ordered layoffs and sham shutdowns. When the company again announced its closure on 6 August 1979, 187 women of the YH union, founded in 1975, entered the headquarters of the opposition New Democratic Party before dawn on 9 August and began a sit-in. Party leader Kim Young-sam visited them and encouraged them. 30 32

At 2 a.m. on 11 August between 1,000 and 1,200 police stormed the building and broke up the sit-in; a 21-year-old worker, Kim Gyeong-suk, died. Police announced that she had cut her wrist and jumped before the raid, but in 2008 the Truth and Reconciliation Commission found that the wound was not self-inflicted, that she fell while fleeing the assault and that she had been struck on the head before the fall. The same inquiry found that the forced eviction had been decided at a Blue House meeting led by KCIA director Kim Jae-gyu and approved by Park. On 17 August police arrested union branch chair Choi Sun-young, the Rev. In Myung-jin of the Yeongdeungpo mission, the Rev. Moon Dong-hwan, the poet Ko Un and others. 30 33 34

The YH incident turned a labour dispute into a head-on clash between the regime and the opposition. Kim Young-sam called on Park to resign; the government had a court suspend him as party leader and then, citing an interview he gave The New York Times, had the National Assembly strip him of his seat on 4 October. Every New Democratic Party deputy submitted a resignation. The Encyclopedia of Korean Culture calls the YH sit-in the fuse of the chain of events that brought down the Park regime. 34 30 35

Who rose in the Bu-Ma uprising?

In 1979 the South Korean economy fell into crisis from overlapping heavy-industry investment and the second oil shock. Consumer prices rose 18.3 percent that year, and in Busan, crowded with small makers of shoes, clothing and plywood, the bankruptcy rate reached 2.4 times the national figure. The New Democratic Party had outpolled the ruling Democratic Republican Party in the December 1978 general election; with the YH incident and Kim Young-sam's expulsion on top of that, discontent erupted in Busan and Masan, Kim's political home ground. 36 34

On 16 October several hundred Pusan National University students began demonstrating with the slogan "Down with the Yushin regime", and their numbers swelled to about 5,000 as they marched into the city. From the 17th, workers, shopkeepers, bar and restaurant staff, high-school pupils and the unemployed joined in, crowds reached tens of thousands, and police boxes, tax offices, broadcasters and the ruling party's office were attacked. The government declared martial law in Busan from midnight on the 18th; the protests spread to Masan that evening, and on the 20th a garrison decree sent troops into Masan and Changwon. Figures for arrests and military trials vary by source: the Korean Wikipedia says 66 people in Busan and 59 in Masan were sent before military courts, while the English Wikipedia says the military arrested 1,058 people, 87 of whom were tried. 36 37 38

Even a Busan police analysis noted that citizens applauded the students and handed them drinks. The Encyclopedia of Korean Culture judges the Bu-Ma uprising, together with the YH sit-in, the decisive blow that brought down the Yushin system from below. A law on restoring the honour of and compensating participants in the uprising was enacted in 2013. 36

How did the 26 October incident end Yushin, and what became of the democratic unions?

The response to Bu-Ma split the regime. Presidential security chief Cha Ji-cheol demanded a hard crackdown, while KCIA director Kim Jae-gyu took a relatively moderate line. At about 7.40 p.m. on 26 October 1979, at a dinner in a KCIA safe house in Gungjeong-dong, Seoul, Kim Jae-gyu shot dead Park Chung Hee and Cha Ji-cheol; with his subordinates Park Seon-ho, Park Heung-ju and others he also killed the bodyguards. On 28 October Chun Doo-hwan, commander of the Defence Security Command and head of the joint investigation headquarters, arrested him. 34 39 40

His motive is still disputed. Kim claimed that he had struck down a dictator out of a wish for liberal democracy. The author of the Encyclopedia of Korean Culture entry on the incident treats this as an after-the-fact justification and sees the killing as closer to an unplanned act born of his rivalry with Cha, while granting that it was set off by the democratic Bu-Ma uprising and became the occasion for Yushin's collapse. Sentenced to death for murder with intent to commit insurrection, Kim was executed on 24 May 1980; on his family's petition the Seoul High Court opened a retrial in 2025. 34 39 40 41

Prime Minister Choi Kyu-hah became acting president and declared martial law across the country except Jeju; elected president on 6 December, he lifted the emergency decrees. But on 12 December Chun Doo-hwan's new military faction seized command of the army in a mutiny, and under the "purification" measures that followed, the Cheonggye union was ordered dissolved in 1981 and the Wonpoong union forcibly broken up in 1982, ending every democratic union of the 1970s. Dismissed workers from Wonpoong, Dongil and Cheonggye regrouped in 1984 in the Korean Workers' Welfare Council. Since 1988 a national workers' rally honouring Jeon Tae-il has been held every November. 34 39 42 1 8 31 6

Consequences

The Yushin system fell, but democracy did not follow at once. The new military faction that seized power in the mutiny of 12 December 1979 used "purification" measures from 1980 to dissolve the Cheonggye union (1981) and the Wonpoong union (1982), wiping out the democratic unions of the 1970s. Dismissed workers regrouped in 1984 in the Korean Workers' Welfare Council, and the movement's experience carried into the labour struggles of the 1980s. The defendants in the People's Revolutionary Party case were acquitted on retrial in 2007 and those of the student federation case in 2009, and state intervention in the Dongil and YH affairs was confirmed by official inquiries in the 2000s. Whether the 26 October killing was a stand for democracy or an unplanned act inside the ruling circle is still disputed.

Timeline & Map

Seoul Peace Market, Seoul Incheon Masan Busan 12 Gungjeong-dong safe house, Seoul 1 Peace Market 2 Peace Market 3 Peace Market 7 New Democratic Party headquarters, Mapo, Seoul 8 New Democratic Party headquarters, Mapo, Seoul 4 Dongil Textile, Manseok-dong, Incheon 5 Dongil Textile, Manseok-dong, Incheon 6 Dongil Textile, Manseok-dong, Incheon 9 Pusan National University 11 Masan 10 Busan
  1. 11969.06South Korea
    Fool's Association founded

    Jeon Tae-il founded the Fool's Association of Peace Market cutters, surveyed working conditions and petitioned the Labour Office.

  2. 21970.11.13South Korea
    Jeon Tae-il's self-immolation

    When police broke up a Peace Market protest, Jeon Tae-il set himself alight shouting "Observe the Labour Standards Act!" and died that night.

  3. 31970.11.27South Korea
    Cheonggye Garment Workers' Union founded

    Lee So-sun and the market workers founded the Cheonggye branch of the National Federated Trade Union, with Lee as adviser.

  4. 1971.11.13South Korea
    Seoul National University "plot" announced

    The KCIA announced a plot by Seoul National University students and a trainee lawyer to overthrow the government; Jang Gi-pyo and Cho Yeong-rae were jailed.

  5. 41972.05.10South Korea
    First woman branch chair at Dongil Textile

    Ju Gil-ja was elected chair of the Dongil Textile branch, the first woman branch chair in FKTU history.

  6. 1972.10.17South Korea
    October Yushin

    Park Chung Hee dissolved the National Assembly and suspended political activity by emergency measures.

  7. 1972.12.27South Korea
    Yushin system inaugurated

    Park, elected by the National Conference for Unification, took office as eighth president.

  8. 1974.01.08South Korea
    Emergency Decree No. 1

    Park issued the first emergency decree, banning calls to revise the Yushin Constitution.

  9. 1974.04.03South Korea
    Decree No. 4 and the student federation case

    Emergency Decree No. 4 put those linked to the National Democratic Youth and Student Federation before courts-martial.

  10. 1975.04.09South Korea
    Eight executed in the People's Revolutionary Party case

    The day after the Supreme Court confirmed their sentences, Do Ye-jong, Yeo Jeong-nam and six others were hanged.

  11. 1975.05.13South Korea
    Emergency Decree No. 9

    Decree No. 9 banned all opposition to the Yushin Constitution, student protest and criticism of the decrees.

  12. 51976.07.25South Korea
    Dongil Textile sit-in crushed

    Police broke up the women's sit-in at Dongil Textile and detained 72.

  13. 61978.02.21South Korea
    Excrement incident at Dongil Textile

    Male workers threw excrement over women members preparing the delegate election.

  14. 1978.04.01South Korea
    124 fired at Dongil Textile

    The company fired 124 women who refused to sign union withdrawal pledges; a blacklist followed.

  15. 71979.08.09South Korea
    YH workers occupy the opposition headquarters

    187 women of YH Trading began a sit-in at New Democratic Party headquarters against the closure.

  16. 81979.08.11South Korea
    YH sit-in crushed; Kim Gyeong-suk dies

    About a thousand police stormed the building; worker Kim Gyeong-suk died.

  17. 1979.10.04South Korea
    Kim Young-sam expelled from the Assembly

    The National Assembly stripped opposition leader Kim Young-sam of his seat over an interview with The New York Times.

  18. 91979.10.16–20South Korea
    Bu-Ma uprising begins

    Pusan National University students began protesting against Yushin; townspeople joined from the next day.

  19. 101979.10.18South Korea
    Martial law in Busan

    The government declared martial law in Busan; protests spread to Masan.

  20. 111979.10.20South Korea
    Garrison decree in Masan and Changwon

    A garrison decree sent troops into Masan and Changwon.

  21. 121979.10.26South Korea
    The 26 October incident

    At a dinner in the Gungjeong-dong safe house, KCIA director Kim Jae-gyu shot dead President Park and security chief Cha Ji-cheol.

Related people 17

Related terms

Sources: reference 1reference 2reference 3reference 4reference 5reference 6reference 7reference 8reference 9reference 10reference 11reference 12reference 13reference 14reference 15reference 16reference 17reference 18reference 19reference 20reference 21reference 22reference 23reference 24reference 25reference 26reference 27reference 28reference 29reference 30reference 31reference 32reference 33reference 34reference 35reference 36reference 37reference 38reference 39reference 40reference 41reference 42