1956.05.15–1961.05.16

The Progressive Party Affair, the April Revolution and the Defeat of the Reformist Left

Why did the Progressive Party end in an execution and a ban, and why was the reformist left that revived in the space opened by the April Revolution crushed within a year?

After winning 2.16 million votes in the 1956 presidential election, Cho Bong-am founded the Progressive Party on a platform of democratic socialism and peaceful unification. In 1958 the Rhee government arrested its leaders under the National Security Law, abolished the party and in 1959 executed Cho. When students and citizens rose against the rigged election of March 1960 and forced Rhee out in the April Revolution, reformist parties, a teachers' union and a unification movement revived, only to be dissolved by the May 16 coup of 1961, which also executed Cho Yong-su of the newspaper Minjok Ilbo.

How did the Rhee government entrench itself in the mid-1950s?

After the Korean War, power in the Republic of Korea was concentrated in President Syngman Rhee and the Liberal Party, the ruling party he had created at the end of 1951. The man who actually ran it was Lee Ki-poong, Rhee's former secretary, who had been mayor of Seoul and minister of defence. Chairman of the party's central committee from December 1953, he was its second man; after the May 1954 election he drew in independents to secure 137 seats, more than two-thirds of the assembly, and became speaker. 1

That year the Liberal Party introduced an amendment lifting the two-term limit "for the first president only". In the vote of 27 November 1954 it won 135 votes, one short of the 136 needed for two-thirds of the 203 members, and the deputy speaker declared it defeated. Two days later the party reversed the result by "rounding off": two-thirds of 203 was 135.33, which it said rounded to 135. This "rounding-off" (sasaoip) amendment let Rhee run for a third term. 2 1

The amendment also pushed the opposition together. A new-party movement grew around the anti-Liberal "Constitution Protection Comrades' Association", but the conservative right balked at including Cho Bong-am, who had helped found the Communist Party of Korea under Japanese rule and, as the first minister of agriculture after 1948, had carried out land reform. On 18 September 1955 the conservatives founded the Democratic Party without him, and Cho, Seo Sang-il and veterans of the reformist camp went their own way toward a progressive party. "Reformist" (hyeoksin) then meant the political current that stood between the capitalist right and communism for democratic socialism and peaceful unification. 3 4 5

Why did Cho Bong-am become a threat in the 1956 presidential election?

On 22 December 1955 twelve founders, among them Cho Bong-am, Seo Sang-il and Park Gi-chul, issued a prospectus and draft platform for a Progressive Party. Its first plank was to reject "communist dictatorship and also the dictatorship of capitalists and corrupt elements" and to "establish a democratic system and realise responsible reformist politics"; the others called for nurturing national capital through rational control of production and distribution and for a reunification won by democratic forces. 6

Ahead of the presidential election of 15 May 1956 the party's organisers named Cho for president and Park Gi-chul for vice-president and negotiated a joint ticket with the Democratic Party. On 5 May the Democratic candidate Shin Ik-hee died suddenly on the campaign trail, leaving Cho as in effect the only opposition candidate for president. The Progressives withdrew Park and endorsed the Democrat Chang Myon for vice-president, but the Democrats refused to back Cho, saying they had given up on changing the government and would concentrate on the vice-presidency. Progressive campaigners were beaten by political thugs and detained by police in several provinces. 3

Rhee received about 5.04 million votes and Cho 2,163,808. Korean Wikipedia gives Cho 23.86 per cent; the Encyclopedia of Korean Culture gives 30 per cent of the valid vote. The gap comes from some 1.85 million memorial votes cast for the dead Shin, which were counted as invalid. Cho won nearly three times Rhee's vote in Daegu, while in some counties of Gangwon Province he was credited with only around 180 votes; Choi In-gyu, who later became interior minister, admitted in his memoirs that Rhee's 90 per cent in Gangwon had been fabricated. In the vice-presidential race the Democrat Chang Myon beat the Liberal Lee Ki-poong. On the strength of his vote Cho formally founded the Progressive Party on 10 November 1956, and it built up provincial branches aiming at twenty or more seats in the 1958 election, enough for its own parliamentary group. 3 6 7 1 8

What did the Progressive Party stand for?

The Progressive Party proclaimed a "third way" that was neither capitalism nor communism: democratic socialism or social democracy. At its founding Cho said the party's road was "to reject both communist dictatorship and capitalist dictatorship, to grasp the truth of progressivism, mankind's new ideal, and to build a welfare society in which everyone can live peacefully and happily." The policies it had asked the Democrats to adopt in the 1956 talks were responsible government, an economic system without exploitation, and peaceful unification. 6 3

The sharpest issue was unification. The Rhee government and the Liberal Party treated "marching north" to unify the country almost as state doctrine, and Progressive leaders such as vice-chairman Kim Dal-ho countered with peaceful unification. At the time merely speaking of peaceful unification invited suspicion of echoing North Korean propaganda. The platform was drafted by Lee Dong-hwa, and secretary-general Yun Gil-jung and vice-chairmen Park Gi-chul and Kim Dal-ho led the party with Cho. 9 7 10 11

How was the Progressive Party case built?

Four months before the National Assembly election of May 1958, the Seoul police charged under the National Security Law that the party had been founded "to reform the country into a socialist system and overthrow the government" and was answering North Korea's peaceful-unification campaign. Leaders including Yun Gil-jung, Kim Dal-ho and Lee Dong-hwa were arrested on 12 January; Cho was seized on 13 January on his way to give himself up (the Encyclopedia of Korean Culture's article on the case gives the 14th). Police searched the party offices and seized its membership lists, paralysing it, and on 25 February, before any trial, the Office of Public Information cancelled the party's registration. 7 12 6

On 16 February prosecutors indicted Cho for espionage, violating the National Security Law and illegal possession of arms, and the other leaders under the National Security Law. The indictment held that peaceful unification was a device for communising the South and that planks such as "an economic policy without exploitation" matched the line of North Korea's Workers' Party. On 20 February, four days later, the Army Counter Intelligence Corps announced the Yang I-seop case: Yang (also known as Yang Myeong-san), a trader who crossed between South and North as an agent of the army intelligence unit HID, had allegedly passed North Korean funds to Cho. Yang had shared Sinuiju Prison with Cho under Japanese rule and had given him campaign money in 1956. 7 13

At first instance the Seoul District Court, presided over by Judge Yu Byeong-jin, found on 2 July 1958 that all the police's espionage allegations were untrue. It convicted Cho and Yang under the National Security Law only for the money Yang had given, sentenced each to five years and acquitted the other leaders, and it found no basis for the charge that peaceful unification violated the constitution. Young men calling themselves an anti-communist youth corps then stormed the courthouse shouting "Down with the pro-communist judge Yu Byeong-jin!" On appeal Yang retracted his confession, saying the Counter Intelligence Corps had extracted it by inducements and threats to make him cooperate with "the state's decision to eliminate Cho Bong-am", but the Seoul High Court ignored this and on 25 October sentenced both men to death. 7

On 27 February 1959 the Supreme Court confirmed the death sentences on Cho and Yang and, as at first instance, acquitted the other leaders. Cho's petition for a retrial was rejected on 30 July. The government hanged Yang on 29 July, the day before the decision, and Cho on 31 July, the day after it. With the Progressive Party destroyed, open debate on unification policy, peaceful unification above all, fell silent. 7 13

How was the Progressive Party case judged later?

In September 2007 the Truth and Reconciliation Commission found the case to be "an inhumane, anti-human-rights violation and an act of political repression", driven by the Rhee regime's wish to keep the Progressive Party out of the 1958 election and to eliminate Cho after he had won more than two million votes in 1956. It also noted that the Counter Intelligence Corps, which had no authority to investigate civilians, had run the espionage inquiry. On 20 January 2011 the full bench of the Supreme Court unanimously acquitted Cho on retrial, holding that the law had been misapplied and that Yang's confession, the only evidence, had been obtained through confinement and drugging and could not be considered voluntary. 7 12

A different claim also circulates. In 2020 the weekly Jugan Chosun published an article citing a Soviet document in which Kim Il Sung allegedly told a Soviet deputy premier in 1968 that he had supported the Progressive Party. Korean Wikipedia notes that no scholarly paper has examined the document and that Kim's remarks in it contain wrong dates and figures, so it hardly meets the standard of evidence. Either way, the espionage conviction on which Cho was hanged in 1959 was overturned by the courts themselves in 2011. 12

How was the rigged election of 15 March 1960 carried out?

In January 1959 Rhee went back on an earlier statement that he would not stand and announced a bid for a fourth term. The Liberal Party nominated Rhee and Lee Ki-poong in June; in November the Democrats chose Chough Pyung-ok of their Old Faction for president and Chang Myon of the New Faction for vice-president. Interior minister Choi In-gyu reshuffled police chiefs to their home districts and, between November 1959 and February 1960, secretly instructed local officials to raise the Liberal vote to 85 per cent through "40 per cent advance voting, open voting in groups of three or five, armband squads and the ejection of opposition observers." The party raised close to 7 billion hwan in campaign funds from banks and companies. 14

Chough died suddenly in the United States on 15 February, settling the presidency, so the contest turned on the vice-presidency, which would inherit the presidency if Rhee could not serve: Chang against Lee. The Democrats exposed the police instructions, and on 9 and 10 March Democratic officials were killed in attacks in Yeosu and Gwangsan. On 15 March the party declared the vote void, calling it "not an election but an armed robbery of popular sovereignty carried out in the name of an election." When the count gave Rhee and Lee 95 to 99 per cent in district after district, the party told Choi to bring the figures down; the final tally gave Rhee 88.7 per cent and Lee 79 per cent. 14

How did the protests spread from Daegu to Seoul?

The first protest came before the election, from high-school students. The Liberal Party's North Gyeongsang branch ordered schools to keep students in class on Sunday 28 February so they could not attend the Democrats' rally in Daegu, and the schools invented exams, rabbit hunts and extra lessons. At midday on the 28th some 800 students of Kyungpook High School marched into the city shouting "Do not make our schools a political tool", and students of Daegu High School, Kyungpook Girls' High School and others followed, about 1,500 in all, as far as the provincial government office. This February 28 Daegu student protest, organised by the students themselves rather than mobilised by the government, is regarded as the first spark of the April Revolution. On 8 March high-school students in Daejeon who were stopped by police from going to Chang Myon's rally also demonstrated. 15 16

On the evening of election day, 15 March, protesters in Masan denounced the fraud, and police fire left dead and wounded. Kim Ju-yeol, who had just sat the entrance examination for Masan Commercial High School, went missing in that protest. When his body surfaced off Masan's central pier on 11 April with a tear-gas shell lodged in his right eye, the city rose again and attacked police stations and the Liberal Party office. The revelation that police had dumped the body in the sea carried the protests across the country. 8 17 16

On 18 April some 3,000 Korea University students, returning from a sit-in outside the National Assembly, were attacked by thugs of the Korean Anti-Communist Youth Corps. The next day, 19 April, university and high-school students and citizens of Seoul marched on Gyeongmudae, the presidential residence, shouting "Hold the 15 March election again" and "Rhee must resign", and the police opened fire. At 3 p.m. the government declared martial law in Seoul, then in Busan, Daegu, Gwangju and Daejeon. Korean Wikipedia counts 186 dead and 6,026 wounded nationwide on that single day; English Wikipedia says about 180 were killed on 19 April and 186 in the two weeks of protest as a whole. 16 18

How did Rhee fall, and what replaced him?

On 25 April university professors issued a declaration and marched with students and citizens, and the martial-law troops did not attack the crowds; the martial-law commander Song Yo-chan refused police requests to use the army against them. On 26 April Rhee announced his resignation. On 28 April Lee Ki-poong and his family, hiding in a residence at Gyeongmudae, were shot dead by his eldest son Lee Kang-seok, who then killed himself; Rhee went into exile in Hawaii on 29 May. 16 18 1

A caretaker government under foreign minister Heo Jeong took over, and on 15 June the National Assembly passed an amendment establishing a parliamentary system with two chambers. The Democratic Party swept the election of 29 July; the Assembly chose Yun Po-sun of the Old Faction as president on 12 August (13 August in English Wikipedia) and Chang Myon of the New Faction as prime minister on 18 August. But the Democrats split, the Old Faction leaving to found the New Democratic Party on 22 September 1960, and Chang's government reshuffled its cabinet every few months. When the trial of those behind the rigged election ended on 8 October with a single death sentence, for the officer responsible for the shootings, and light sentences for the rest, students wounded in the April Revolution occupied the Assembly, which on 29 November amended the constitution to allow retroactive punishment of election riggers and illicit fortunes. 19 20 21 22

What did the reformist left and social movements do after the April Revolution?

The reformist left, silenced under Rhee, rebuilt its parties. Veterans of the Progressive Party, the Democratic Reform Party, the Working People's Party and the League for National Self-Reliance met on 13 May 1960 as founders of the Socialist Mass Party and declared that "the April democratic revolution must be a true democratic revolution in name and in fact"; Seo Sang-il became its chief executive member and Yun Gil-jung its secretary-general. In the election of 29 July, however, the reformists ran divided among the Socialist Mass Party, the Korea Socialist Party and the Reformist Comrades' League, and won only five or six of the 233 seats in the lower house, depending on the source (the Socialist Mass Party alone took four, plus one in the upper house). Afterwards the party split between Kim Dal-ho's Progressive faction and the rest, and the non-Progressive groups founded the Unified Socialist Party in January 1961. 23 5 21 24

Students, youth and labour showed more strength than the parties. On 22 May 1960 some 300 teachers and professors founded the Korean Teachers' Union Federation; by July it had 83 unions and 19,883 members, 22 per cent of all teachers. Its legality was disputed within the Heo Jeong caretaker government, and the anti-communist law and demonstration-control law that the Chang government proposed, dubbed the "two evil laws", were fought by the reformists, students and the teachers' union. On 3 September 1960 the reformists launched the Central Council for National Independent Unification, calling for "independent and peaceful national unification", and on 13 February 1961 the reformist daily Minjok Ilbo was founded to argue for North-South negotiations and neutral unification. In May 1961 a student group proposed a North-South student conference at Panmunjom. 25 21 26 27 19

How much of a force this was is disputed. The Encyclopedia of Korean Culture's article on the May 16 coup judges that the reformists were a party of notables, won only five seats on 29 July, and that the unification movement can hardly be said to have had broad popular support, while noting that conservatives and the coup-makers made it the target of an anti-communist offensive. The same encyclopedia's article on the reformist movement adds that its forces never produced a shared political vision and were built around prominent individuals, yet broadly opposed both right-wing and left-wing dictatorship and saw independent, peaceful unification as the most urgent task. 21 5

How did the May 16 coup happen?

After the April Revolution a "purify the army" movement arose among officers who wanted generals tainted by corruption removed. In May 1960 Major General Park Chung-hee, commander of the Busan logistics base, demanded the resignation of the chief of staff Song Yo-chan, and Kim Jong-pil and other officers of the eighth class of the military academy circulated a petition. When the purge petered out they resolved in September 1960 to stage a coup, and recruited officers of the units near Seoul that would be mobilised under "Operation Dove", the Chang government's plan for suppressing riots. After a plan to exploit protests on the first anniversary of the revolution and a 12 May attempt both fell through, marines, paratroopers and artillery crossed the Han River before dawn on 16 May 1961 and seized the main government buildings and the broadcasting station in Seoul. 21

At 5 a.m. the coup forces announced on the radio that a Military Revolutionary Committee had taken legislative, judicial and executive power, and read out a six-point "revolutionary pledge" whose first point was "to make anti-communism the first principle of the state and to rebuild and strengthen the anti-communist system, which until now has been a matter of form and slogans." Chang Myon hid in the Carmelite convent at Hyehwa-dong. The First Army commander Lee Han-lim was willing to crush the coup, but the ambiguous stance of the United States and President Yun Po-sun's position that Korean soldiers must not shed each other's blood prevented it. Chang left the convent on 18 May and had his cabinet resign, and on 19 May the committee renamed itself the Supreme Council for National Reconstruction. Chang Do-yong was its chairman, but real power lay with the vice-chairman Park Chung-hee and Kim Jong-pil, director of the new Central Intelligence Agency. 21 28 29

What did the military government do to the reformist left?

Immediately after the coup the military government arrested reformists and other left-wing politicians en masse as communist sympathisers. Proclamation No. 6 of the Supreme Council on 22 May 1961 dissolved reformist parties such as the Socialist Mass Party and the Unified Socialist Party, along with the Central Council for National Independent Unification. Some 1,500 people connected with the teachers' union were arrested, and Kim Mun-sim, head of the North Gyeongsang teachers' union, was sentenced to life. The revolutionary court gave Kim Dal-ho fifteen years, and Yun Gil-jung served seven years until 1968. On 4 July the Anti-Communist Law was enacted. 21 23 24 26 25 9 10

Minjok Ilbo was closed by order of the martial-law command on 19 May, three months after its founding. Its president Cho Yong-su, arrested on 18 May, was sentenced to death under the Special Law on the Punishment of Special Crimes for producing the paper with money from the pro-Pyongyang Chongryon and spreading North Korea's line of peaceful unification. Two others sentenced to death with him, the auditor An Sin-gyu and the editorial writer Song Ji-young, had their sentences commuted to life after appeals at home and abroad, but Cho was hanged on 21 December 1961. Choi In-gyu, who had directed the 1960 election fraud, was executed the same day. In 2006 the Truth and Reconciliation Commission declared Cho's death sentence unlawful, and on 16 January 2008 the Seoul Central District Court acquitted him on retrial. 27 30 31 32 18

From the Progressive Party case to the Minjok Ilbo case, the Rhee government and Park's military government used the National Security Law and special laws to punish political forces that spoke of peaceful unification and democratic socialism. In the space opened by the April Revolution the reformists, the teachers' union and the unification movement briefly revived, but the May 16 coup crushed them within a year, and open progressive party politics did not recover in South Korea for a long time afterwards. The Encyclopedia of Korean Culture assesses the coup as the start of more than thirty years of military rule. 7 27 21 5

Consequences

Cho Bong-am (1959) and Cho Yong-su (1961) were executed, and the Progressive Party, the Socialist Mass Party, the Unified Socialist Party, the teachers' union and the unification council were dissolved. The military government enacted the Anti-Communist Law and opened more than thirty years of military rule. Cho Yong-su (2008) and Cho Bong-am (2011) were acquitted on retrial.

Timeline & Map

Seoul Daegu Masan 1 Seoul 2 Seoul 3 Seoul 4 Seoul 5 Seoul 9 Seoul 10 Seoul 11 Seoul 12 Seoul 13 Seoul 14 Seoul 15 Seoul 16 Seoul 6 Daegu 7 Masan 8 Masan
  1. 1956.05.05South Korea
    Democratic candidate Shin Ik-hee dies

    The Democratic presidential candidate Shin Ik-hee died suddenly while campaigning, leaving Cho Bong-am as in effect the only opposition candidate.

  2. 1956.05.15South Korea
    Presidential election of 1956

    Syngman Rhee was re-elected; Cho Bong-am won 2,163,808 votes. The Democrat Chang Myon defeated the Liberal Lee Ki-poong for vice-president.

  3. 11956.11.10South Korea
    Progressive Party founded

    Cho Bong-am, Park Gi-chul, Kim Dal-ho, Yun Gil-jung and others formally founded the Progressive Party in Seoul.

  4. 21958.01.12South Korea
    Progressive Party leaders arrested

    Seoul police arrested Yun Gil-jung, Kim Dal-ho, Lee Dong-hwa and other Progressive Party leaders under the National Security Law; Cho Bong-am was seized on the 13th (the 14th in the Encyclopedia of Korean Culture).

  5. 1958.02.25South Korea
    Progressive Party deregistered

    The Office of Public Information cancelled the Progressive Party's registration before any trial had opened.

  6. 31958.07.02South Korea
    First-instance verdict in the Progressive Party case

    The Seoul District Court under Judge Yu Byeong-jin sentenced Cho Bong-am and Yang I-seop to five years and acquitted the other leaders.

  7. 41958.10.25South Korea
    Death sentences on appeal

    The Seoul High Court ignored Yang I-seop's retraction and sentenced him and Cho Bong-am to death.

  8. 51959.07.31South Korea
    Cho Bong-am executed

    Cho Bong-am was hanged the day after his petition for a retrial was rejected; Yang I-seop had been hanged on 29 July.

  9. 61960.02.28South Korea
    February 28 Daegu student protest

    Protesting orders to attend school on a Sunday, about 1,500 Daegu high-school students, starting with 800 from Kyungpook High School, demonstrated in the city.

  10. 71960.03.15South Korea
    Rigged election and the Masan protest

    The Liberal government ran the election with advance voting, open voting and a rigged count; that evening protesters in Masan denounced the fraud and police opened fire.

  11. 81960.04.11South Korea
    Kim Ju-yeol's body found

    Kim Ju-yeol's body surfaced off Masan with a tear-gas shell in his eye, and the city rose again.

  12. 91960.04.19South Korea
    Protests and shootings of 19 April

    Students and citizens of Seoul marched on the presidential residence; police opened fire and the government declared martial law in Seoul and other cities.

  13. 101960.04.26South Korea
    Rhee resigns

    The day after the professors' march, President Syngman Rhee announced his resignation.

  14. 111960.05.22South Korea
    Teachers' union federation founded

    Some 300 teachers and professors met at Seoul National University and founded a national federation of teachers' unions.

  15. 1960.07.29South Korea
    General election of 29 July 1960

    The Democratic Party won a landslide; the Socialist Mass Party and other reformists took only five or six seats in the lower house.

  16. 121960.08.18South Korea
    Chang Myon elected prime minister

    The House of Representatives elected Chang Myon of the Democrats' New Faction prime minister.

  17. 131960.09.03South Korea
    Unification council launched

    Reformists, joining as individuals, launched the Central Council for National Independent Unification.

  18. 141961.02.13South Korea
    Minjok Ilbo founded

    The reformist daily Minjok Ilbo was founded with Cho Yong-su as president.

  19. 151961.05.16South Korea
    May 16 coup

    Troops led by Major General Park Chung-hee seized Seoul and announced that a Military Revolutionary Committee had taken all state power.

  20. 1961.05.22South Korea
    Reformist parties dissolved

    Proclamation No. 6 of the Supreme Council for National Reconstruction dissolved the Socialist Mass Party, the Unified Socialist Party and other groups.

  21. 161961.12.21South Korea
    Cho Yong-su and Choi In-gyu executed

    Cho Yong-su, president of Minjok Ilbo, and Choi In-gyu, the former interior minister who directed the 1960 election fraud, were executed.

Related people 16

Related terms

Sources: reference 1reference 2reference 3reference 4reference 5reference 6reference 7reference 8reference 9reference 10reference 11reference 12reference 13reference 14reference 15reference 16reference 17reference 18reference 19reference 20reference 21reference 22reference 23reference 24reference 25reference 26reference 27reference 28reference 29reference 30reference 31reference 32