The Split of the Japanese Communist Party and the Armed Struggle Line
Why did the Cominform's criticism of 1950 split the Japanese Communist Party into the Shokan and Kokusai factions, and how did the party, driven underground, take up an armed struggle line and then abandon it at the Sixth National Conference of 1955?
When the Cominform organ attacked Sanzō Nosaka's theory of "peaceful revolution under the occupation" in January 1950, the party mainstream around Kyuichi Tokuda answered with a statement of "Views" (the Shokan faction), while Kenji Miyamoto, Yoshio Shiga and others insisted that the criticism be accepted (the Kokusai or Internationalist faction). After MacArthur ordered the purge of the entire Central Committee in June and the Korean War broke out, the Shokan faction set up a Provisional Central Leadership without the Internationalists and went underground, and Tokuda and Nosaka crossed to Beijing. In 1951, backed by the Soviet and Chinese parties, the Shokan faction forced the Internationalists to dissolve and adopted the 1951 Programme, which defined Japan as an American colony, together with a military line. The Shiratori Incident, Bloody May Day, the Suita Incident and the Ōsu Incident followed in 1952; the government enacted the Subversive Activities Prevention Act, and the Communists lost every seat in that year's election. After Stalin's death and the armistice, the Sixth National Conference of July 1955 condemned the armed struggle as "ultra-left adventurism" and reunited the party.
Why did the Cominform attack Sanzō Nosaka?
Re-established as a legal party after the defeat, the Japanese Communist Party raised its strength in the January 1949 general election from four seats before the dissolution to thirty-five. Its public face at the time was Sanzō Nosaka, back from Yan'an since 1946. He had argued that the party could approach power through the Diet, and that if mass struggle grew, a democratic government could be formed even under American occupation and hasten the occupiers' withdrawal. As he later summarised it himself, this view had underrated the hold of international monopoly capital over Japan and assumed that the struggle against state power could always be waged by peaceful means. 1 2
On 6 January 1950 the organ of the Cominform (the Information Bureau of the Communist and Workers' Parties), For a Lasting Peace, For a People's Democracy!, carried a commentary titled "On the Situation in Japan". It argued that the United States meant to make Japan its main base for military adventures against the Soviet Union and the democratic movements of Asia, and condemned Nosaka's "theory" as "a theory glorifying the imperialist occupiers of Japan, a theory praising American imperialism". On 12 January the JCP Politburo issued its "Impressions" (Shokan): Nosaka's shortcomings, it said, were already being overcome, and if foreign comrades criticised the party without taking its conditions into account, "it is clear that this will do serious harm to the people and to our party". 3
The tide turned on 17 January, when the Chinese Communist Party's People's Daily, in an editorial titled "The Road to the Liberation of the Japanese People", openly declared the Politburo's attitude wrong. The Eighteenth Enlarged Central Committee, which opened the next day, adopted a resolution recognising the "positive significance" of the Cominform commentary, and Nosaka admitted that his theory had been "erroneous in principle". On 6 February he published "My Self-Criticism" in Akahata. Accounts of the motive behind the attack differ. The Japanese Wikipedia article on the Shokan faction presents it as following Stalin's intentions ahead of the Korean War; today's JCP regards it as the start of Soviet and Chinese "interference" aimed at imposing an armed-struggle line, and holds that singling out Nosaka was a signal to pass the new line to him, as a man then secretly linked to Soviet intelligence. 3 4 2 5 6
How did the Shokan and Kokusai factions come apart?
The party mainstream that backed the "Impressions" (General Secretary Kyuichi Tokuda, Nosaka, Shigeo Shida, Ritsu Itō and others) came to be called the Shokan faction after that statement, while those who wanted to accept the Cominform's criticism, among them Kenji Miyamoto and Yoshio Shiga, were called the Kokusai (Internationalist) faction, for deferring to the international communist movement. On 10 January the Control Commission expelled Kō Nakanishi, a member of the House of Councillors, for anti-party activity. Politburo member Shiga's written objections to the draft report of the Eighteenth Enlarged Central Committee were not adopted, yet some members circulated them to party organisations across the country. Etsurō Shiino, who replaced Miyamoto as chairman of the Control Commission on 26 January, published an account of this "manoeuvre" in Akahata in April. 5 7 8
The general report of the General Secretary to the Nineteenth Central Committee plenum, held over three days from 28 April, included a heading calling on "the whole party to smash the factionalists", and declared that the conflict with them could not be settled by compromise and allowed no neutral stance. In a statement of 19 April Miyamoto argued that factional organisations should be dissolved and every internal question returned to the track of regular activity based on inner-party democracy. The Kokusai side protested that the Shokan faction answered with demotions, sending Miyamoto off to Kyushu. Within the Kokusai camp, Shigeo Kamiyama went his own way in what became known as the Kamiyama faction. 8 7 9
How did the purge and the Korean War drive the party underground?
On 3 May 1950 MacArthur accused the JCP of submitting to foreign control. After the House of Councillors election of 4 June, he ordered Prime Minister Shigeru Yoshida in a letter of 6 June to purge all twenty-four members of the Central Committee, General Secretary Tokuda among them, from public life, and the next day seventeen Akahata editors were purged as well. On 7 June the Control Commission, "recognising the need to create a provisional central leadership until the coming party congress", appointed a Provisional Central Leadership chaired by Shiino. The Japanese Wikipedia article on the Mountain Village Operation Squads states that Tokuda and his circle set up this leadership without convening the Politburo or the Central Committee, by a procedure not in the party rules, and shut out seven Central Committee members who disagreed with them, Miyamoto among them. 10 11 12
When the Korean War broke out on 25 June, the party's position in Japan, the main American base for the war, narrowed further. MacArthur suspended Akahata for a month on 26 June and indefinitely on 18 July. On 15 July arrest warrants were issued for nine leaders, among them Tokuda, Nosaka, Itō, Shida, Yojirō Konno and Shōichi Kasuga, for refusing summonses under the Organisation Control Ordinance, and they went underground. Kasuga was arrested in Nagoya on 7 October. On 10 August the government promulgated the National Police Reserve Order in response to MacArthur's letter. That autumn (late August, September or October, depending on the account) Tokuda slipped out of Japan by boat to China, where he and Nosaka set up what came to be called the "Beijing apparatus". 10 13 14 15 16 7
The Kokusai members who remained above ground formed the "JCP National Unification Committee" on 1 September, rallying the Kansai regional committee and others. Shiino, in an article of the same period, branded them factionalists whose "fundamental idea is that Japan's rulers have no relative independence whatsoever". But a People's Daily editorial of 5 September declared "the unity of the Japanese Communist Party" the highest task of the moment, urging the dissenters to unite with the leadership and urging the provisional leadership not to deal hastily with loyal members holding different views by organisational measures. 17 14
Where did the peace and security treaties leave Japan?
When MacArthur was dismissed in April 1951, Matthew Ridgway became Supreme Commander for the Allied Powers for the last year of the occupation. The architect of the settlement on the American side was John Foster Dulles. The peace treaty was signed in San Francisco on 8 September. The Soviet Union attended but did not sign, and India and Burma stayed away. Under the treaty Japan recognised the independence of Korea and renounced all rights over it, while the Nansei Islands, Okinawa included, were placed under an article (Article 3) by which Japan agreed to any American proposal for trusteeship. Through the Security Treaty signed the same day, the United States secured, in Dulles's words, the right "to station as many troops as it wants, where it wants, for as long as it wants". 18 19 20 21
The JCP demanded an "overall peace" including the Soviet Union and China, and opposed a "separate peace" with the American-aligned countries alone. The General Secretary's report of January 1950 had already put forward the slogans "Oppose a separate peace that leads to war" and "Immediate withdrawal of all occupation forces once a peace treaty is concluded". The Japan Socialist Party, divided between a left wing opposed to both treaties and a right and centre that accepted the peace treaty but opposed the security pact, split at its extraordinary convention of 23 October. The two treaties were ratified by the Diet and took effect on 28 April 1952, ending the Allied occupation. 4 22
For Koreans in Japan the peace settlement meant losing their nationality. The government told the Diet that "after the peace treaty takes effect, Koreans and Taiwanese will leave Japanese nationality and come under the Immigration Control Order as foreigners", and the Alien Registration Law was promulgated on 28 April. The United Democratic Front of Koreans in Japan (Minjeon), formed in January 1951 as successor to the dissolved League of Koreans in Japan, worked legally in alliance with the JCP, while illegal activity was left to the Fatherland Defence Corps, formed in 1950. In November 1951 the Tokyo Fatherland Defence Committee sent an open letter to Ridgway and the Yoshida government protesting the planned forced deportation of Koreans under a Potsdam ordinance. 23 24 25 26
What did the 1951 Programme and the military line demand?
The Provisional Central Leadership, run by the Shokan faction, held the Fourth National Conference, ranking just below a party congress, for five days from 23 February 1951. Its "General Line of Struggle" called for "the political and organisational development and expansion of workers' self-defence corps", it adopted a decision "On the Military Line", and it resolved to give the remaining factionalists a "final warning" and to leave the firm punishment of anyone who refused to comply to the Provisional Central Leadership. On 10 August the Cominform organ endorsed that resolution, saying it "will undoubtedly play an important part in strengthening and uniting the ranks of the party". Once Radio Moscow broadcast the endorsement, the Kokusai organisations dissolved one after another and their members rejoined; Shōjirō Kasuga and others submitted written self-criticisms first, Miyamoto last. 27 7 12
The Fifth National Conference of 16 and 17 October adopted "The Present Demands of the Japanese Communist Party: A New Programme", known as the 1951 Programme. It described Japan as a semi-feudal colonial country subordinated to American imperialism, set the task of a "national-liberation democratic revolution" joining national liberation to democratic revolution, and declared: "It is wrong to think that the liberation and democratic transformation of Japan can be achieved by peaceful means" (translated from the Japanese). The military line issued with it, "We Must Begin Preparing for and Taking Up Arms", put forward the Core Self-Defence Squads as "the most elementary and basic form of military organisation". Japanese Wikipedia says the draft was worked out in August 1951 at a meeting near Moscow attended by Stalin, Tokuda, Nosaka and others; its article on Satomi Hakamada adds that he did not take part in the discussion itself. 28 29 30
Following the Chinese revolution's example, the Fourth National Conference ordered the creation of "liberated zones" in the countryside, and Mountain Village Operation Squads made up of students and activists went into the hill villages. Their activities, such as picture-card plays attacking landlords, found no acceptance among the villagers; only the touring clinics of the medical teams in doctorless villages were welcomed. The standing of the Fifth National Conference is still disputed. The JCP holds that the armed struggle was the action of one side of a divided party and that no regular party body ever adopted a policy of "violent revolution". The Public Security Intelligence Agency replies that the JCP itself, in the Central Committee report to its Seventh Congress in 1958, conceded that the Fifth National Conference "was, at any rate, a meeting of a party that had been made one". 12 6 31
What happened in Sapporo, Tokyo, Suita and Nagoya in 1952?
On the night of 21 January 1952, Inspector Kazuo Shiratori, head of the security section of the Sapporo city police, was shot from behind and killed as he cycled home. Having led the arrests of Communists, he was regarded as an enemy by party members. The men named as the gunmen fled abroad; Kuniji Murakami, chairman of the party's Sapporo committee and of its military committee, was arrested that October, and in 1963 his conviction for conspiracy to murder and a twenty-year sentence became final. The JCP campaigned that he had been framed, and suspicions of fabricated evidence persisted. In 1975 the Supreme Court rejected his petition for retrial, while ruling that the principle "when in doubt, for the accused" applies to retrials as well (the Shiratori decision). 32 33
On 1 May, three days after the occupation ended, the twenty-third central May Day rally in the Outer Gardens of the Meiji Shrine in Tokyo resolved against rearmament and for opening the "People's Plaza", the plaza in front of the Imperial Palace. After the march some columns entered the plaza and clashed with the police, who used tear gas and pistols. Deaths among the demonstrators numbered one according to the police and two according to the organisers; 832 police officers were injured. The number arrested is given as about 1,200 or as 1,232, and the number indicted for riot as 258 or 261, depending on the source. According to the Labour Year Book of Japan, of the 232 defendants in the joint trial, 70 were day labourers, 30 Koreans and 17 students. In 1972 the Tokyo High Court threw out the riot charge. 34 35
On the night of 24 June about a thousand people (estimates range from 800 to 3,000), students, workers and Koreans in Japan among them, gathered at Osaka University's Toyonaka campus for an "Evening to Smash the Itami Base, against War and for Independence", and marched through the night to the national railways' Suita marshalling yard, where supply trains for the UN forces in Korea were made up (the Suita Incident). Of 111 people indicted for riot, all were acquitted of that charge. The same night in Hirakata, equipment at a former army arsenal was blown up with a time bomb. On 7 July about 7,000 people, including about a thousand Koreans, gathered at Ōsu stadium in Nagoya; after a clash in which firebombs were thrown, 152 were indicted, and in 1978 the Supreme Court upheld their conviction for riot. Japanese Wikipedia states that the Fatherland Defence Corps, the underground organisation of Koreans in Japan, took part in such incidents together with the Communist Party's clandestine units. 36 37 38 25
What did the Subversive Activities Prevention Act and the 1952 election leave behind?
The Yoshida cabinet pressed for security legislation to replace the Organisation Control Ordinance, an occupation-era decree, and the Bloody May Day Incident drove it forward. The outline the Attorney General's Office settled in March 1952 provided that an organisation which had engaged in violent subversive activity could have its collective activities and its publications suspended for up to six months, or be dissolved, on the decision of a new Public Security Examination Commission. The Right Socialists sought to strike out the "incitement" clause, while the Left Socialists and the Labour-Farmer Party opposed the bill in the name of free expression. It passed the Diet on 4 July and took effect on 21 July. On the day it passed, the Communist members of the Diet called for "patriotic resistance": "No freedom without resistance, no peace without resistance." 39 40 41
In the general election of 1 October 1952 every JCP candidate was defeated, and the party lost all thirty-five seats it had won in 1949. In the same election, politicians freed from the purge returned to the Diet in large numbers. The firebomb struggle subsided from around the summer of 1952, but the military line was not formally withdrawn and the rural work went on. Japanese Wikipedia attributes the wipe-out to the support the party lost through the split and the illegal actions that followed the 1951 Programme. 42 1 12
What did the Sixth National Conference end, and what did it leave?
Stalin died in March 1953, the Korean War armistice was signed in July, and on 14 October Tokuda died in Beijing; his death was kept from Japan until 1955. In the Beijing apparatus, Ritsu Itō was placed under isolated investigation at the end of 1952 (decided in late October or announced to him in December, depending on the account) and expelled as a "spy", and the statement announcing it appeared in Akahata on 15 September 1953. From around 1954, with Soviet encouragement, the Shokan and Kokusai factions drew closer, and in the summer of 1954 a six-man delegation including Nosaka and Konno drafted the resolutions of the Sixth National Conference in Moscow together with representatives of the Soviet and Chinese parties. On 1 January 1955 the party criticised the armed struggle as "ultra-left adventurism". 7 43 44 16 12
The movement of Koreans in Japan was reorganised along with this turn. Amid the February 1955 statement of North Korean Foreign Minister Nam Il and the JCP's change of line, the General Association of Korean Residents in Japan (Chongryon) was founded on 25 and 26 May 1955, and Minjeon was dissolved. Japanese Wikipedia writes that a rift opened between a Communist Party now turning towards defence of the constitution and peace, and Korean organisations that meant to keep to a national line, and that the ties between them were cut. 45 24 25
The Sixth National Conference, held from 27 to 29 July, announced Tokuda's death and elected Nosaka first secretary, with Konno, Shida and Miyamoto in the Secretariat. Criticising the old line as ultra-left military adventurism, it wrote that "in assessing the domestic political situation the party overestimated its own strength and underestimated the enemy" (translated from the Japanese), and it resolved that responsibility for the 1950 split lay with the leadership of the time. On 11 August Nosaka, Shida and Konno appeared in public for the first time in five years. The Seventh Congress in 1958 abolished the 1951 Programme and elected Miyamoto general secretary. 46 5 47 48
Assessments of the period remain divided. The JCP calls it the "1950 Problem": in its account Stalin, together with the Chinese Communist Party, interfered to impose a Chinese-style armed-struggle line, and Tokuda, Nosaka and others formed a faction and split the party. The Public Security Intelligence Agency, citing the armed struggle under the 1951 Programme and the military line, still keeps the JCP on its list of organisations under investigation under the Subversive Activities Prevention Act. The Japanese Wikipedia article on the Sixth National Conference reports the criticism that the party laid the blame for the armed struggle on Tokuda alone, and the view that student members disillusioned with the new leadership went on to form the Communist League and other New Left groups. The despair of students who had joined the Mountain Village Operation Squads became the background of Shō Shibata's novel Saredo warera ga hibi. 49 31 46 12
Consequences
The Sixth National Conference elected Nosaka first secretary and abandoned the armed struggle line, and the Seventh Congress of 1958 abolished the 1951 Programme and made Miyamoto general secretary, establishing a leadership centred on the former Internationalists. The JCP describes the period as the "1950 Problem", produced by Soviet and Chinese interference and the factional conduct of Tokuda's group, but the Public Security Intelligence Agency still cites it in keeping the party on its list of organisations under investigation under the Subversive Activities Prevention Act. Some of the student members who had thrown themselves into the armed struggle, disillusioned with the new leadership, went on to the Communist League and other New Left groups. The movement of Koreans in Japan left the JCP's direction and was reorganised in 1955 as Chongryon.
Timeline & Map
- 11950.01.06Cominform criticises Nosaka
The Cominform organ attacked Sanzō Nosaka's theory of peaceful revolution under the occupation in the commentary "On the Situation in Japan".
- 21950.01.12The Politburo's "Views"
The JCP Politburo published its "Views on 'On the Situation in Japan'" in reply; the name Shokan faction comes from this statement.
- 31950.01.18Nosaka's self-criticism
After the Chinese Communist Party's People's Daily joined the criticism, Nosaka made a self-criticism and accepted the Cominform's criticism.
- 41950.06.06Central Committee purged
In a letter to Prime Minister Yoshida, MacArthur ordered the purge of all twenty-four members of the JCP Central Committee; the next day the Shokan faction set up a Provisional Central Leadership without the Internationalists.
- 51950.06.25Korean War breaks out
The Korean War broke out. MacArthur suspended Akahata the next day, and when arrest warrants were issued on 15 July for Tokuda and eight other leaders, they went underground.
- 1951.02.23Fourth National Conference
The Provisional Central Leadership held the Fourth National Conference, which set a military line and branded the Internationalists a faction.
- 61951.09.08Treaty of San Francisco signed
Japan signed the peace treaty with forty-eight nations and, the same day, the Security Treaty with the United States; the Soviet Union did not sign.
- 1951.10.16–
17 Fifth National Conference and the 1951 ProgrammeThe Fifth National Conference adopted a new programme defining Japan as a semi-feudal American colony, together with a military line.
- 71952.01.21Shiratori Incident
Kazuo Shiratori, head of the security section of the Sapporo police, was shot dead on his way home; Kuniji Murakami, the party's Sapporo chairman, was later convicted.
- 81952.04.28Peace treaty takes effect
The peace treaty and the US-Japan Security Treaty took effect, ending the occupation.
- 91952.05.01Bloody May Day Incident
Part of the May Day march entered the Imperial Palace Plaza and clashed with the police; demonstrators were killed and more than 1,200 people were arrested.
- 101952.06.24–
25 Suita IncidentAbout a thousand students, workers and Koreans in Japan marched through the night to the Suita marshalling yard against munitions transport for the Korean War.
- 111952.07.07Ōsu Incident
A clash with firebombs followed a rally at the Ōsu stadium in Nagoya, and 152 people were indicted.
- 121952.07.21Subversive Activities Prevention Act in force
The Subversive Activities Prevention Act, passed by the Diet on 4 July, took effect and the Public Security Intelligence Agency was created.
- 1952.10.01Election wipe-out
Every JCP candidate was defeated in the House of Representatives election, and the party lost all thirty-five of its seats.
- 131953.10.14Death of Kyuichi Tokuda
Tokuda died in Beijing; his death was announced only at the Sixth National Conference in 1955.
- 1955.01.01Self-criticism of ultra-left adventurism
The JCP criticised the armed struggle as "ultra-left adventurism".
- 141955.05.25–
26 Chongryon foundedThe General Association of Korean Residents in Japan was founded and Minjeon was dissolved.
- 151955.07.27–
29 Sixth National ConferenceThe Sixth National Conference announced Tokuda's death, elected Nosaka first secretary and abandoned the armed struggle line.
Related people 19
Leadership3
Resisted the Cominform with the "Views", went underground after the purge and directed the armed struggle line from Beijing until his death in 1953.
Leader of the Kokusai factionKenji Miyamoto1908–2007Urged acceptance of the Cominform criticism and was shut out of the leadership; joined the Secretariat at the Sixth National Conference and became general secretary in 1958.
Chairman of the Provisional Central LeadershipEtsurō Shiino1911–1993Became chairman of the Provisional Central Leadership formed without the Internationalists in June 1950.
Implementers & commanders1
Participants9
The target of the Cominform's criticism, he recanted, worked in the Beijing apparatus and became first secretary at the Sixth National Conference.
Kokusai faction leaderYoshio Shiga1901–1989Sided with Miyamoto in the Kokusai faction.
Shokan faction leaderRitsu Itō1913–1989Went to the Beijing apparatus, was isolated in 1952 and expelled as a "spy".
Shokan faction leaderYojirō Konno1910–1977Went underground in 1950, helped draft the Sixth National Conference resolutions and joined the Secretariat.
Kokusai faction leaderSatomi Hakamada1904–1990Went to China for the Kokusai faction to seek Soviet and Chinese intervention, and later submitted a self-criticism to Tokuda.
Leader of the Kokusai National Unification CommitteeShōjirō Kasuga1903–1976Led the Kokusai organisation and recanted and rejoined in 1951.
Theorist on the Kokusai sideShigeo Kamiyama1905–1974Led his own "Kamiyama faction" within the Kokusai camp and was expelled in 1954.
Shokan faction leaderShōichi Kasuga1907–1995Went underground in 1950 and was arrested; became chairman of the Provisional Central Leadership in 1954.
Soviet leaderJoseph Stalin1878–1953Seen as behind the Cominform criticism; he is reported to have joined the discussion of the 1951 Programme.
Opposition & resistance4
Ordered the purge of the entire JCP Central Committee and the suspension of Akahata.
Supreme Commander for the Allied PowersMatthew Ridgway1895–1993Succeeded MacArthur in 1951 and led the last year of the occupation.
Prime MinisterShigeru Yoshida1878–1967Signed the peace treaty and the Security Treaty, and pushed through the Subversive Activities Prevention Act.
US special envoy for the Japanese peace treatyJohn Foster Dulles1888–1959Led the negotiation of the peace treaty and the Security Treaty.
Targets & victims2
Clashed with the leadership in the line dispute just after the Cominform criticism and was expelled in January 1950.
JCP Sapporo committee chairmanKuniji Murakami1923–1994Was convicted as a conspirator in the Shiratori Incident but maintained he had been framed.
Related terms
Sources: reference 1reference 2reference 3reference 4reference 5reference 6reference 7reference 8reference 9reference 10reference 11reference 12reference 13reference 14reference 15reference 16reference 17reference 18reference 19reference 20reference 21reference 22reference 23reference 24reference 25reference 26reference 27reference 28reference 29reference 30reference 31reference 32reference 33reference 34reference 35reference 36reference 37reference 38reference 39reference 40reference 41reference 42reference 43reference 44reference 45reference 46reference 47reference 48reference 49