First USSR People's Commissar for Health, a founder of Soviet preventive medicine
Memoirists report that at the June 1937 plenum he criticised the NKVD and Beria, but the sessions were not stenographed, so the wording of his remarks is not documentarily confirmed.
Born on 20 October (Old Style) 1895 in Ekaterinoslav into a Jewish blacksmith's family; English-language scholarship gives only 1 November 1895. He joined the Bolsheviks in 1913, founded the newspaper Kommunar in Tula and led its city and provincial soviets and Military Revolutionary Committee, and was sent to Azerbaijan in 1920. He led agricultural cooperatives and Kolkhozsentr and drove collectivisation, though in 1925 he opposed barring kulaks from co-operatives. At the June 1937 plenum he criticised the NKVD and submitted material on Beria; he was arrested on 25 June and shot on 10 February 1938, and rehabilitated in 1955.
Also known as: Hoffman · Gofman
Activities and affiliations
-
1913–
Soviet Communist Party and Bolsheviks
Political and party leadership -
1921–1930
Soviet Union state institutionsDeputy Chairman of the Agricultural Union, Chairman of KolkhoztsentrMain
Agriculture and land policy
Career Timeline
- 1913–1917Joined the Bolsheviks; distributed Pravda in Minsk; entered Moscow University medical faculty in 1915 (completed two courses); secretary of the Tula Bolsheviks
- 1917–1920Chairman of Tula Military Revolutionary Committee, Tula Soviet executive committee; political commissar 2nd Army; first editor of Kommunar
- 1920–1921First Secretary of the Azerbaijan Communist Party CC, chairman of Baku Soviet
- 1922–1929Deputy chairman of the Agricultural Cooperatives Union, chairman of Vserabotzemles and of Kolkhozsentr; drove collectivisation
- 1929–1930Head of the CC Agitation and Mass Campaigns Department
- 1930–1934Secretary of Moscow Party Committee, Second Secretary, chairman of Moscow Oblast Executive Committee
- 1934–1937RSFSR People's Commissar for Health (Feb 1934 – Mar 1937), USSR Chief Sanitary Inspector from 1935, and first USSR People's Commissar for Health (Jul 1936 – Jun 1937)
Related historical events
- 1917.10–1918.01The October RevolutionChairman of Tula Military Revolutionary Committee
- 1918–1922The Civil War and Foreign InterventionMilitary Revolutionary Committee chairman
- 1920.11–1936.06.27The Soviet Legalisation and Ban of Abortion and the Recriminalisation of SodomyCommissar of Health of the RSFSR and the USSRSubmitted a broad list of grounds for legal abortion to the 1936 drafting commission to preserve safe abortion, meeting Stalin’s disapproval; arrested in June 1937, he was shot in 1938.
- 1928–1937The Five-Year Plans and the Soviet TransformationPeople's Commissar of Health
- 1937–1938The Great PurgeOpposed NKVD arrests at the June 1937 plenumAt the 25 June 1937 CC plenum he openly denounced the NKVD's mass arrests, telling Stalin 'the NKVD is still arresting honest people,' and also revealed that Beria had worked for Musavatist counterintelligence. Stalin replied: 'They are enemies of the people, and you are a bird of the same feather.' Kaminsky was arrested that day and shot on 10 February 1938.
Commissar for Health and the June 1937 Plenum
Kaminsky became People's Commissar for Health of the Russian republic in February 1934, added the post of USSR Chief Sanitary Inspector in 1935, and on 20 July 1936 became the first People's Commissar of the newly created USSR Commissariat of Health. Though not a physician, having completed only two years of medical school, he is counted with Nikolai Semashko among the founders of the preventive line in Soviet medicine. Under him the decisions on training doctors (September 1934), on raising medical workers' pay and the health budget (March 1935), and on training mid-level medical, dental and pharmaceutical staff (September 1936) were carried out; he built up the production of medicines and ran the campaign against malaria. At the end of 1934 he set up a rural commission to supervise the village medical network. He was close to scientists such as Ivan Pavlov and Solomon Levit, and Pavlov called him "a clever Bolshevik; everyone works with him gladly." On 23 June 1936 the Sverdlovsk Medical Institute was named after him.
When the Politburo set up a commission on 9 March 1936 to draft the law banning abortion, Kaminsky submitted a broad list of medical conditions that would allow legal abortion, to widen access to safe procedures and cut illegal ones, which drew Stalin's disapproval. Later that year a bulletin prepared for the Second Congress of Neurologists and Psychiatrists branded three named scientists as "pseudoscience" linked to fascism and racism; Kaminsky had it withdrawn and proposed Levit, recently expelled from the party, for the congress praesidium. Pravda attacked him for this on 26 December 1936. In an unpublished speech he held that Levit could still serve science outside the party and warned: "If you declare people to be fascists, you need to know that this threatens them with prison." Levit was arrested and shot in 1938. Kaminsky also protested against suppressing information about epidemics. At the same time he was among those who in 1936 denounced Alexei Rykov on the charge of having prepared an attempt on Stalin in 1932.
When Grigory Ordzhonikidze, whom he had known since Azerbaijan in 1920, killed himself in February 1937, Kaminsky had to sign the official medical report that gave the cause of death as heart failure. English-language scholarship suggests this may have moved him to take a stand against the spreading terror. His speech at the June 1937 Central Committee plenum was not stenographed and is known only from hearsay. Robert Conquest was told that he indicted Nikolai Yezhov and his methods calmly and firmly, and that when he said "the NKVD is still arresting honest people," Stalin replied that they were enemies of the people and he was a bird of the same feather. Bukharin's widow Anna Larina heard that he had spoken against her husband's arrest. He stated that Lavrentiy Beria, then party leader in Transcaucasia, had worked for the counter-intelligence of the Musavat regime in Azerbaijan. In his report to the 20th Party Congress in 1956 Nikita Khrushchev confirmed this, saying that Kaminsky was arrested and shot before the plenum had even ended and that Stalin never checked his statement.