German Communist who abstained on the Comintern’s founding at its first congress and was later shot in the Great Purge
At the 1919 Comintern founding congress, Eberlein conveyed Luxemburg and Jogiches’s mandate against immediate foundation. Lenin persuaded him personally, but he followed the mandate and abstained rather than vote against.
A draughtsman from Saalfeld, he joined the SPD and during the war co-founded the Spartacus League with Luxemburg. As the KPD’s delegate to the Comintern’s founding congress in March 1919 he abstained on the founding vote, as Luxemburg and Jogiches had advised, believing a premature International would be dominated by the Bolsheviks. Afterwards he did organisational and financial work for the Comintern and the German party and sat in the Prussian Landtag. He fled to the Soviet Union in 1933, was arrested in 1937 and was shot in Moscow in October 1941.
Activities and affiliations
-
1906–1917
Social Democratic Party of Germany (SPD)
Social movements and organizing -
1916–1918
Spartacus League (Spartakusbund)Main
Social movements and organizing -
1917–
Independent Social Democratic Party of Germany (USPD)
Social movements and organizing -
–1929
Communist Party of Germany (KPD)
Political and party leadership
Career Timeline
- 1916Helped organize the Spartacus League as an underground political organization.
- 1918Helped found the Communist Party of Germany (KPD).
- 1919Attended the Comintern’s founding congress as the KPD delegate and abstained on its founding vote.
- 1921Elected to the Prussian Landtag.
- 1937Arrested and imprisoned in the Soviet Union.
- 1941Shot in Moscow.
Related historical events
Mandate and vote in the Comintern founding debate
In January 1919 the Communist Party of Germany received an invitation from Moscow to send a delegate to discuss founding a new International. In his 1929 recollection, Eberlein said Rosa Luxemburg supported founding the Comintern in principle but opposed doing so prematurely, before Communist parties and revolutionary mass movements had emerged across Europe. She proposed first establishing a commission of representatives from different countries and holding the founding congress between Easter and Whitsun. After Luxemburg and Karl Liebknecht were killed, Eberlein reported their last discussion at a meeting with Leo Jogiches and others and received an unconditional mandate to present Luxemburg and Jogiches’s position.
In Moscow Eberlein met Lenin and described the situation in Germany and the Spartacus League’s organization. According to his recollection, Lenin argued that immediate foundation was necessary to lead and coordinate the international revolutionary movement, while also regarding it as difficult to found the International without the German party’s agreement. At the March 1919 congress, Eberlein presented the Central Committee’s opposition; in his later account, he said Lenin’s arguments persuaded him personally and that, had he been free to vote as he wished, he would have supported founding the Comintern. He registered the difference between his mandate and his personal view by abstaining rather than voting against. He recalled that he did not oppose the founding resolution and stated that the Spartacus League recognized the need for the Comintern. The contemporary printed congress report and his later account differ over the wording and substance of his speech; Eberlein argued that the report, reconstructed without stenographic notes, did not accurately record his remarks.