“Freedom is always the freedom of the one who thinks differently”
On 14 January 1919, the day after the Spartacist uprising fell, Luxemburg's final article appeared in Die Rote Fahne. To the victors' cry of 'Order prevails in Berlin!' she answered: 'I was, I am, I shall be!' Arrested that night, murdered the next day.
Polish-born German revolutionary, and the Bolsheviks' sharpest comradely critic. From prison she defended the Russian Revolution while warning against the dissolution of the Constituent Assembly and the suppression of the press. Murdered by Freikorps troops during the January 1919 Berlin rising.
Activities and affiliations
-
1893–1918
Social Democracy of the Kingdom of Poland and Lithuania (SDKPiL)
Political and party leadership -
1898–1917
Social Democratic Party of Germany (SPD)
Political and party leadership- Lecturer at the SPD central party school1907–1914Education
-
1916–1918
Spartacus League (Spartakusbund)
Political and party leadership -
1917–1918
Independent Social Democratic Party of Germany (USPD)
Political and party leadership -
1918
Spartacus League (Spartakusbund)Editor of Die Rote Fahne
Ideology and propaganda -
1918–1919
Communist Party of Germany (KPD)Main
Social movements and organizing
Career Timeline
- 1893.08Co-founded the Social Democracy of the Kingdom of Poland (SDKP, later SDKPiL) with Leo Jogiches and others.
- 1898.05Moved to Berlin and joined the Social Democratic Party of Germany (SPD).
- 1899Published Reform or Revolution, her reply to Bernstein's revisionism.
- 1906.03Arrested in Warsaw, where she had gone to join the 1905 revolution; after her release she published The Mass Strike, the Political Party and the Trade Unions.
- 1907.10–1914Taught political economy and economic history at the SPD central party school.
- 1913Published The Accumulation of Capital.
- 1914.02Sentenced in Frankfurt to a year in prison for urging soldiers to refuse orders.
- 1914.08Gathered the party's war opponents into the Gruppe Internationale after the SPD voted for war credits.
- 1915.02–1918.11Imprisoned and held in protective custody for anti-war work; wrote the Junius Pamphlet and her critique of the Russian Revolution in prison.
- 1916–1918Led the Spartacus group with Liebknecht and co-edited the Spartacus Letters.
- 1918.11.09Released from Breslau prison, came to Berlin and became editor-in-chief of the Spartacus paper Die Rote Fahne.
- 1918.12.30–1919.01.01Presented the programme at the founding congress of the Communist Party of Germany (KPD), which adopted her Spartacus programme.
- 1919.01.15Murdered with Liebknecht by officers of the Guards Cavalry Rifle Division after the January rising was crushed.
Related historical events
- 1893–1896The Early Disputes of the Second InternationalSDKP theorist, delegate of Sprawa RobotniczaHer mandate was rejected at Zurich in 1893; in 1896 she fought the PPS resolution on Polish independence in Die Neue Zeit and at the London congress.
- 1900.12.24–1905.05.10The Second Congress of the RSDLP and the Bolshevik–Menshevik SplitCritic of Lenin's organisational viewsIn "Organisational Questions of the Russian Social Democracy" (1904) she attacked the "ultra-centralism" of One Step Forward, Two Steps Back and set against it the "self-centralism" of the working class.
- 1905–1907The Revolution of 1905International revolutionaryShe slipped into Warsaw in December 1905 to join the revolution, was arrested the following year, and out of the experience wrote The Mass Strike.
- 1907–1919The collapse of the Second InternationalGerman anti-war left, Junius PamphletPosed “socialism or barbarism” and led the anti-war left from prison.
- 1914–1918First World WarAnti-war activistShe was imprisoned from 1915 to 1918 for anti-war work.
- 1918–1923The aftermath of the First World War: peace treaties and the revolutionary waveFounder of the KPDMurdered by the Freikorps in the suppression of the January 1919 uprising.
- 1918.10–1919.08The German Revolution of 1918–1919Spartacus League, founder of the KPDWrote the KPD programme, thought the January rising premature and was murdered after it.
Against Polish nationalism: the break with the PPS
In 1893, the 22-year-old Rosa Luxemburg gathered with Polish socialist exiles in Zurich to found the Social Democracy of the Kingdom of Poland (SDKP). The programme she drafted squarely rejected the central demand of the Polish Socialist Party (PPS): Polish national independence. Her argument was that the partitioned Polish lands had already been organically integrated into the Russian, German and Austrian empires, and that capitalist development had rendered the nation-state an economic anachronism.
The conflict erupted at the Third Congress of the Second International in Zurich that same year. The PPS delegation challenged Luxemburg's mandate as the delegate for the SDKP newspaper Sprawa Robotnicza. Small and frail, she climbed onto a chair to make herself seen. Witnesses recalled 'magnetism in her eyes and such fiery words' as she defended her cause. The congress voted to reject her mandate, but the moment registered as something larger: a clash not over procedure but over principle: internationalism versus nationalism.
For Luxemburg, the demand for Polish independence was a trap that divided the working class. She insisted Polish workers must struggle together with Russian workers, and that national liberation would come only with the abolition of capitalism. This position brought her into tension not only with the PPS but also with Russian Marxists. Even Plekhanov and Engels looked askance at her uncompromising hostility to the Polish national cause.
The dispute flared again before the London congress of 1896. Luxemburg published "Social Patriotism in Poland" and other articles in Die Neue Zeit, and in July "The Polish Question at the International Congress in London" appeared simultaneously in Sprawa Robotnicza no. 25 and the Italian Critica Sociale. Her target was the resolution prepared by the PPS organisation abroad, which would have declared that, since the tsarist autocracy was a permanent threat to the international labour movement, the independence of Poland was "an imperative political demand" for the Polish proletariat and the international labour movement as a whole. Her rebuttal ran on two lines. First, tsarism drew neither its inner strength nor its external weight from ruling Poland; it rested on Russia's own social structure and the interests of its nobility and bourgeoisie. Second, the general truth that national subjugation profits only capitalists and despots led to no practical conclusion, and the resolution kept "a deep silence" on how Poland could be freed, so its demand was no more than "a pious wish". Such a resolution, she warned, would encourage nationalist organisation in Poland and elsewhere and turn back an international movement that was organising by political, not national, units. Why not, then, the liberation of the Czechs, Ireland and Alsace-Lorraine?
The London congress never put the PPS motion to the vote and instead unanimously adopted a general resolution for the full right of all nations to self-determination. Luxemburg held that by setting Poland on a level with all other oppressed peoples the congress had ruled "precisely to the contrary" of what the PPS wanted. But Karl Kautsky, editor of Die Neue Zeit, replied that while the International could not make Polish independence part of its programme, Polish socialists were entitled to demand it. Eighteen years later Lenin cited the same resolution to argue that her view, that Polish socialists should not demand independence, had "in essence" been "defeated in the International".
The 'national question' dispute followed her for life. Even after joining the German SPD, her internationalism rested on the foundation laid in those Polish years: that national independence was a romantic delusion. When she wrote, 'I have no special corner of my heart for the ghetto. I feel at home wherever there are clouds and birds and human tears,' it was not merely a personal confession but a political declaration. Internationalism was not an abstract ideal for her: it was the product of the first political battle she fought and lost, as a young Polish exile who refused to put nation before class.
On the left of German Social Democracy (1898–1913)
On 19 April 1898 Luxemburg contracted a marriage of convenience with Gustav Lübeck, the 24-year-old son of her Zurich host family, to obtain German citizenship. From 12 May she lived in Berlin and at once joined the SPD. When Parvus, editor of the Sächsische Arbeiterzeitung, was expelled on 25 September 1898, she moved to Dresden at his request and took over as editor-in-chief, and at the Stuttgart party congress in October she entered the Bernstein debate for the first time. The series of articles that followed later became Social Reform or Revolution?. A quarrel with her fellow editors over her editorial rights led her to offer her resignation on 2 November, and the party press commission, prompted by Bebel, sided with her colleagues. At the congresses of 1898, 1899 and 1901 she took on not only the revisionists but also the party leadership, and she condemned the French socialist Millerand's entry into a bourgeois cabinet in 1899 as a "rotten compromise".
During the 1903 Reichstag campaign Wilhelm II claimed to understand German workers better than any Social Democrat; she answered that "the man who speaks of the good and secure existence of German workers has no idea of the facts". For this speech she was sentenced in July 1904 to three months for insulting the monarch. She began the sentence at the end of August in Zwickau and was freed after six weeks, on 15 October, by an amnesty for the coronation of the new King of Saxony. On 28 December 1905 she travelled to Warsaw on false papers as "Anna Matschke" and threw herself into the revolution with Jogiches, but on 4 March 1906 they were arrested and she was held for four months. Released on bail on 28 July, she spent several weeks with Lenin and other Bolsheviks at Kuokkala in Finland, where she wrote The Mass Strike, the Political Party and the Trade Unions. At the 1906 Mannheim congress she pressed the lessons of Russia against the trade union leaders around Carl Legien, but the congress passed a resolution that in effect gave the unions a veto over any mass strike.
From October 1907 until 1914 she taught political economy and economic history at the SPD's new central party school in Berlin; the lectures became the basis of Introduction to Political Economy and The Accumulation of Capital (1913). In 1910 a government bill to amend the Prussian three-class franchise that still refused equal suffrage set off mass demonstrations and strikes. In a speaking tour and in articles beginning with "What Next?" (Was weiter?, Dortmunder Arbeiterzeitung, 14–15 March 1910) she urged the party to escalate the struggle with the mass strike and republican agitation. Kautsky, now the advocate of a "strategy of attrition", refused to print her article in Die Neue Zeit; the public polemic that followed ended their long friendship and partnership. Her mass strike resolution was defeated at the Magdeburg congress that year, and she became the leader of a small radical opposition cut off from the party centre.
War and prison (1914–1918)
On 25 and 26 September 1913, at meetings in Bockenheim and Fechenheim near Frankfurt, Luxemburg declared: "If they expect us to raise the weapons of murder against our French or other foreign brothers, we say: 'No, we will not do it!'" Charged with inciting disobedience to the laws and to the orders of the authorities, she was sentenced to prison by the Frankfurt court in February 1914. She turned her defence into an indictment of militarism and toured the country speaking while her appeal was pending; the speech was later published as Militarism, War and the Working Class.
When the SPD parliamentary group voted for the war credits on 4 August 1914, she founded the "Gruppe Internationale" the next day with Mehring, Pieck, Marchlewski, Eberlein and others, and Karl Liebknecht soon joined it. On 18 February 1915 she entered the Barnimstrasse women's prison in Berlin to serve the one-year sentence from the Frankfurt trial. There, between February and April 1915, she wrote The Crisis of Social Democracy and had it smuggled out; it appeared in Zurich in 1916 under the pseudonym "Junius" and was distributed illegally in Germany. Treating the war as an imperialist war for which all belligerents were responsible and indicting the party's betrayal, it spread the slogan "socialism or barbarism" and became the guiding statement of the Gruppe Internationale, later the Spartacus League.
Released in February 1916, she was re-arrested on 10 July and held in "protective custody" without trial. Moved from Barnimstrasse to the tiny dark cells of the Alexanderplatz police headquarters, the fortress of Wronke near Posen and the town prison of Breslau, she kept in touch with the outside world through Mathilde Jacob, and her friends smuggled out and illegally published what she wrote in prison. Between 1915 and 1918 she spent three years and four months in prison in all. She was released from Breslau in the revolution on 9 November 1918 and reached Berlin the next day.
"Freedom is always the freedom of the one who thinks differently" — a warning from prison
In the autumn of 1918 Rosa Luxemburg sat in Breslau prison, her third year of confinement for anti-war work. From there she wrote the sharpest comradely critique the Russian Revolution ever received.
From the summer she had been writing critical pieces on events in Russia and smuggling them out of prison. "The Russian Tragedy", printed in Spartakus No. 11 in September 1918, treated the Treaty of Brest-Litovsk as the capitulation of the revolutionary Russian proletariat to German militarism; the editors, Paul Levi among them, printed it reluctantly with a cautionary note and refused a sharper piece. Levi visited her in prison to dissuade her from publishing such attacks, arguing that the enemies of the revolution would misuse them. After a long discussion she agreed, but felt she had to make her position clear, and in September and October she began the longer manuscript. Sending a draft to Levi she wrote: "I am writing this pamphlet for you and if I can convince you then the effort isn't wasted."
Fiercely defending the Bolshevik seizure of power, she nonetheless turned on Lenin's and Trotsky's measures. The dissolution of the Constituent Assembly risked not proletarian dictatorship but 'the dictatorship of a handful.' The suppression of the press was unacceptable because 'freedom is always the freedom of the one who thinks differently.' Distributing land to the peasants would strengthen private smallholding, not socialist agriculture.
The manuscript was never finished. Released in November 1918, she was murdered in January 1919 without completing it, and it first appeared only in January 1922, when Levi, who had stepped down as chairman of the Communist Party the year before, published it as The Russian Revolution: A Critical Appreciation. Under Stalin it was banned; Cold War liberals brandished it against the USSR. Yet her text resists easy appropriation by either side. It remains uncomfortable because the person who loved the Bolsheviks most asked them the sternest questions.
'Socialism without the participation of the whole proletarian mass, run by decrees from a handful, is not socialism.'