The collapse of the Second International
Why did socialist parties that had repeatedly resolved to stop a war each back their own government’s war in August 1914?
The Second International resolved at Stuttgart in 1907 and Basel in 1912 to stand against war. But after Jaurès was assassinated in July 1914, German and French socialist deputies voted for war credits on 4 August and international solidarity collapsed. An anti-war minority gathered around Liebknecht’s dissenting vote and the Zimmerwald conference of 1915, and Lenin’s Zimmerwald Left called for a new International.
The pledge against war: from Stuttgart to Basel
The Second International was a federation of socialist and labour parties founded in Paris in 1889. Its parties were autonomous, and the International had no central leadership that could give them orders. International congresses held every few years adopted resolutions, and the International Socialist Bureau in Brussels kept up contacts between congresses. The party with the greatest weight in organisation and theory alike was the Social Democratic Party of Germany (SPD). After the Russo-Japanese War and the Russian Revolution of 1905, preventing war became the International’s central task, and it came to be seen as the world’s most important anti-militarist political force. 1 5
At the Stuttgart congress of 1907 four positions clashed over how to stop a war. The Frenchman Hervé wanted to answer any war with strikes and insurrection in the army; Guesde held that class struggle would abolish war in the end, so no special action was needed. Bebel and the German leadership argued for parliamentary pressure and for militias in place of standing armies; Jaurès and Vaillant were ready to use the mass strike. The compromise resolution ended with an amendment that Luxemburg moved, prepared together with Lenin and Martov: if war broke out, socialists were to use the crisis to “hasten the abolition of capitalist class rule”. The resolution also bound each party’s deputies to refuse military budgets. But as the historian Georges Haupt put it, “each protagonist could regard the Stuttgart resolution as his victory”. Everyone was satisfied, and nothing was settled about what to do once a war began. 1 2
At the Copenhagen congress of 1910 Keir Hardie of the British Labour Party and Vaillant of France proposed naming a general strike in the arms industries as the means to prevent war. After a tired debate the question went to the Bureau and the decision was put off to a Vienna congress in 1914. The socialist women’s conference held alongside it proposed an international day of action for women’s suffrage on the model of May Day, which became International Women’s Day. 1 46
Meanwhile the colonial rivalry of the powers kept producing war scares. In the First Moroccan Crisis Wilhelm II landed at Tangier on 31 March 1905 and declared his support for the sovereignty of the Sultan of Morocco, challenging French control; the Algeciras Conference of 1906 confirmed French control, but the crisis worsened German relations with Britain and France and strengthened the Entente Cordiale. In the Second Moroccan or Agadir Crisis Germany sent the gunboat Panther to the port of Agadir on 1 July 1911; after a warning speech by the British Chancellor Lloyd George, Franco-German negotiations resolved it in November. During this crisis Rosa Luxemburg clashed again with the party leadership over what she saw as its passive and inadequate response to the threat of imperialist war. 52 53 54
In November 1912, as the Balkan Wars threatened to become a European war, an extraordinary congress met in Basel. Mass anti-war demonstrations in the major European cities preceded it, and the delegates marched to the cathedral behind children singing socialist songs, while its bells rang in welcome. The congress unanimously adopted a manifesto reaffirming the Stuttgart resolution. Jaurès declared the International “strong enough to speak in this tone of command to those in power”. The historian James Joll called Basel “the high point of the International’s optimistic self-confidence”. Many leaders left convinced that the strength of the socialist movement was a guarantee of peace. 1 3 4
The resolutions set out no concrete measure that would actually stop a war. And German Social Democracy carried an old proviso about a “defensive war”. Bebel had told the Reichstag in 1904 that if Germany were attacked he too would shoulder a rifle to defend the fatherland, and at the Essen party congress of 1907 he added that this held all the more if the attacker were Russia. Since Marx, tsarist Russia had been for German socialists the bastion of European reaction. In August 1914 that proviso became the decisive pretext. 31
The proviso showed again in 1913. On 3 July the Reichstag voted an army increase of 117,000 men in peacetime strength and, the same day, enacted a one-off levy on large fortunes and incomes, the "defence contribution" (Wehrbeitrag), of about one billion marks to pay for it. The SPD opposed the army increase, but since the levy fell on the propertied rather than the workers, a majority of its deeply divided parliamentary group voted for it, though it was clear that the money would in practice fund the increase. 55
The July crisis of 1914
When the Balkan Wars did not become a general war, optimism spread through the International in 1913. A Franco-German parliamentary conference met in Bern in May 1913, and international arbitration received new emphasis. Kautsky and others argued that the great powers’ economic interdependence made war irrational — the theory of “ultra-imperialism”. Jaurès and the revolutionary left were more cautious, but the mood of early 1914 was confidence that the strategy of prevention was working. 1
When Archduke Franz Ferdinand was assassinated in Sarajevo on 28 June 1914, socialist leaders did not at once grasp how serious the crisis was, and many left for their summer holidays. Austria’s ultimatum to Serbia on 23 July caught them off guard. On the 25th the SPD leadership published an appeal in its paper Vorwärts declaring that “no drop of a German soldier’s blood must be sacrificed to the Austrian despots’ lust for power”, but offered no concrete plan of action. At this point the SPD leaders believed the German government wished to avoid war and blamed the Austrian government. Anti-war demonstrations followed in Europe’s major cities in the last days of July: 20,000 marched in Hamburg alone on the 28th, and in Paris the General Confederation of Labour (CGT) held a mass demonstration on the boulevards on the 27th. 1 31 15 34
On 29 July the International Socialist Bureau met in emergency session in Brussels: Jaurès, Victor Adler of Austria, Hugo Haase of Germany and Hardie of Britain. Adler confessed that “the war is already with us” and that his party could do nothing; Haase was confident that German workers, fresh from huge anti-war demonstrations, could be mobilised. The Bureau unanimously appealed for stronger demonstrations against the war and decided to move the Vienna congress forward to Paris on 9 August. That evening Jaurès gave his last speech for peace at a rally in the Cirque Royal. Back in Paris the next day, he persuaded the CGT leader Léon Jouhaux to move the union’s anti-war demonstration from 2 August to the 9th, the day of the congress — a way of showing the labour movement’s strength without paralysing the government. 1 5 6 35
When Russia began general mobilisation on 30 July, the outlook of German Social Democracy shifted too. On the 31st Vorwärts began to speak of a defensive war against Russian aggression. The same day the German government declared a “state of imminent danger of war”. 31 1
The murder of Jaurès and 4 August
Jaurès had led a socialist delegation to Prime Minister Viviani on the evening of 30 July; on the 31st he tried to see him again but met only the under-secretary for foreign affairs. That evening he was dining at the Café du Croissant near the offices of his paper L’Humanité. At 9.40 p.m. Raoul Villain, a 29-year-old member of a nationalist student league devoted to recovering Alsace-Lorraine, fired from behind the curtain of the open window and killed him. The International lost its most powerful anti-war leader. Fearing riots in the big cities, the government held back in Paris two cavalry regiments due to leave for the frontier, but the leadership of the Socialist Party (SFIO) let it be known that it would not call demonstrations. On 1 August the interior minister Malvy telegraphed the prefects not to use the “Carnet B”, the list of anti-war activists to be arrested on mobilisation, judging that the labour movement would cooperate with the war. Villain was acquitted at his trial after the war, in 1919. 35 34 36 7
On 1 August Germany declared war on Russia and France and Germany mobilised. Hermann Müller, sent by the SPD to Paris, found the French socialists, bereaved of Jaurès and facing German invasion, unwilling even to consider voting against war credits. So ended the last attempt at international coordination. 1
War credits were the loans a government raised to pay for a war, which parliament had to authorise. Germany raised 98 billion marks through nine war loans between 1914 and 1918, covering some 60 per cent of its war costs. Socialist deputies had long made it a principle to vote against military budgets, so the credits vote became the plainest test of whether a party supported this war. 33 2
In Germany the matter was settled within three days. On 2 August the General Commission, the central body of the Social Democratic free trade unions, declared that there would be no wage campaigns or strikes during the war. The same day the parliamentary group’s executive decided by four votes to two to approve the credits, and on the 3rd, after Eduard David spoke for and Haase against, the group voted 78 to 14 in favour. Right-wingers such as David, Wolfgang Heine, Albert Südekum and Ludwig Frank pushed the decision through in those few days. Bound by party discipline, the fourteen opponents also voted yes in the chamber, Liebknecht among them. 31 32 19
On 4 August Kaiser Wilhelm II addressed the Reichstag deputies at the palace and added that he no longer knew any parties, only Germans. In the Reichstag that day the SPD co-chairman Haase had to explain in the party’s name a decision he had opposed. The declaration named imperialism and the arms race as the causes of the war and laid the responsibility on “the promoters of this policy”. But it warned that a victory of “bloodthirsty Russian despotism” would threaten the free future of the German people and declared: “In the hour of danger we will not abandon our own fatherland.” The SPD deputies voted unanimously for the credits. The “Burgfrieden” that began here took its name from the old rule of a truce inside a besieged castle: for the duration of the war, party strife and industrial disputes were to be suspended. 31 32 8
The same thing happened in Paris that day. At Jaurès’s state funeral in the morning, the CGT general secretary Jouhaux denounced the emperors of Germany and Austria who had made the war and called the workers to arms. In the afternoon Prime Minister Viviani read the Chamber a message from President Poincaré: before the enemy, the sons of France would stand in a “sacred union” (Union sacrée). The phrase became the name of the arrangement under which every party from left to right set aside its quarrels to support the war. Two days earlier Vaillant, the veteran of the Paris Commune, had said that the socialists would do their duty “for the fatherland, for the Republic, for the International”. The socialist deputies voted for the credits, and on 26 August Jules Guesde and Marcel Sembat entered the Viviani government. 35 34 9 10
Most socialists in the other belligerent countries also rallied to their governments. In Belgium Émile Vandervelde, chairman of the International Socialist Bureau, entered the cabinet as minister of state. In Austria parliament had been suspended since before the war, so there was no vote at all, but Victor Adler publicly backed the government’s decision for war. The British Labour Party also supported the government. Only in Serbia and Russia were votes cast against. 1 11 6 43
Social patriots and dissenters
The majority of the socialist parties in the belligerent countries backed their own governments’ war, and their opponents called them “social patriots”: socialists in name who in practice served their country’s war. The opposing minority ranged from pacifists to revolutionaries. 1
When the British Labour Party backed the government’s request for £100 million in war credits, Ramsay MacDonald resigned the party chairmanship and Arthur Henderson took over. Hardie, Labour’s founder, held to his opposition to the war until his death in 1915. 12 13
Italy stayed out of the war until May 1915, and the Italian Socialist Party (PSI) was the European exception, opposed to the war as a whole. Benito Mussolini, editor of the party paper Avanti!, wrote an editorial headed “Down with the war” on 26 July 1914, but on 18 October he came out for intervention with an article titled “From absolute to active and working neutrality”. When the party rejected the new line he resigned the editorship two days later; with money from industrial backers he launched Il Popolo d’Italia on 15 November and was expelled from the party on 29 November. After Italy entered the war, the party held together on the formula of its secretary Costantino Lazzari: “neither support nor sabotage”. 44 14 15
In France opposition grew slowly. Hervé, the most extreme anti-militarist before the war, rallied in 1914 to “the fatherland in danger” and in 1916 renamed his paper La Victoire. The metalworkers’ leader Alphonse Merrheim later recalled that anyone resisting the war at the time might have been shot by French workers before the police got to him. From the autumn of 1914 opposition began to gather around Merrheim’s metalworkers’ federation, but at the CGT’s national conference of August 1915 an anti-war resolution was defeated by 79 votes to 26. 45 15
Plekhanov, the father of Russian Marxism, backed national defence. The American Socialist Party opposed US entry into the war to the end, and its leader Eugene Debs, after urging resistance to the draft in a speech at Canton in June 1918, was convicted of sedition and sentenced to ten years. 15 16
Responses to the defeat diverged. The Dutchman Troelstra held that the International had merely been too weak to stop the war and was still alive. Luxemburg said that “everything is lost, all that remains is our honour”; Trotsky called the Second International a “rigid shell” from which socialism must be freed. Lenin denounced it as a “stinking corpse”. In theses written at the outbreak of war he branded the conduct of the German Social Democratic leaders “sheer betrayal of socialism”, and the theses found their way into the resolution of the Swiss and Italian socialists’ conference at Lugano on 27 September. The Bolshevik Central Committee’s manifesto of November raised the slogan of turning the imperialist war into a civil war, and from early 1915 Lenin called for founding a new, Third International. 15 17 18
Why did the votes against come from Serbia and Russia?
In the summer of 1914 the only socialist deputies to vote against war credits were in Serbia and Russia. Serbia was the country that had received Austria’s ultimatum and been invaded, which made its socialists’ refusal all the more striking. The Serbian Social Democratic Party, founded in 1903 and led by men such as Tucović and Lapčević, had long called for a socialist federation of the Balkan peoples. Dragiša Lapčević, a deputy from 1912 to 1919, won an international reputation by voting against war budgets both before the Balkan Wars and in 1914. The party was badly weakened by the Austro-German occupation of October 1915, but its deputy Triša Kaclerović attended the Kienthal conference in 1916 and signed the Zimmerwald Left’s draft resolution. 37 38 39 28
In the Russian State Duma the Social Democratic deputies refused to vote for the war credits and, to make their protest the plainer, walked out of the chamber. The price was high. In November 1914 five Bolshevik deputies — Badayev, Petrovsky, Muranov and others — were arrested with six other party members, Kamenev among them, while holding a secret conference near Petrograd. At their trial in February 1915 they were all sentenced to life exile in Siberia, and Petrovsky was sent to Turukhansk. Lenin criticised the defendants for not standing firm enough in court, calling it inexcusable in particular that Kamenev had distanced himself from the Central Committee by pleading solidarity with a defencist. Yet he wrote that the trial had shown, at a time when nearly all Europe’s “socialist” deputies had turned chauvinist, a model of a parliamentary group bound to the working masses. 18 41 42
Bulgaria entered the war only in October 1915, but the Bulgarian Narrow Socialists led by Blagoev also opposed it and backed the left at Zimmerwald. 40
Several explanations have been offered for why the opposition came from small parties in eastern Europe. By 1914, one argument runs, the large labour movements of western Europe were in many ways integrated into the capitalist system: while preaching revolution, they had in practice worked to enlarge the workers’ share within that society, and support for the war followed from this. In Russia, by contrast, tsarism was so plainly counter-revolutionary that defending the fatherland could not be separated from defending the regime. At Zimmerwald in 1915 the Menshevik Axelrod said that of all Europe’s socialist movements only Russian Social Democracy was united against the war, and explained it in just these terms. 15
The split in German Social Democracy
On 2 December 1914 Karl Liebknecht cast the only vote in the Reichstag against the second war credits. He issued a statement that this was not a defensive but an imperialist war; the president refused to enter it in the record, and it circulated as an illegal leaflet. At the third vote, on 20 March 1915, Otto Rühle voted against with Liebknecht, while thirty deputies including Haase walked out. 19 20 31 32
The left outside the leadership began to gather too. The radicals around Luxemburg, Liebknecht, Mehring and Zetkin brought out the journal Die Internationale in April 1915 and became known as the International Group, the future Spartacus League. In the Junius Pamphlet, written in prison, Luxemburg quoted Engels: bourgeois society stood at the crossroads of “transition to socialism or regression into barbarism”. 15 21
Opposition in the centre widened as well. Bernstein, who had voted for the credits on 4 August out of party discipline, published with Haase and Kautsky the manifesto “The Demand of the Hour” in the Leipziger Volkszeitung on 19 June 1915, attacking the government’s expansionist war aims. By November the opposition within the parliamentary group had grown past forty. On 21 December Haase gave up the group’s chairmanship and, with nineteen others, voted against the credits in the chamber for the first time; twenty-two more walked out. 22 32
On 24 March 1916, when Haase spoke against the emergency budget for the opposition, the Reichstag erupted. Scheidemann and Ebert hurled insults at him, and the parliamentary group voted 58 to 33 to expel Haase and seventeen others for “breach of faith”. Haase also resigned the party chairmanship, and the expelled deputies formed the Social Democratic Working Group. On 1 May Liebknecht was arrested while leading an anti-war demonstration in Berlin and sentenced to four years and one month. In April 1917 the opposition founded the Independent Social Democratic Party (USPD) at Gotha, with the Spartacus League inside it. The majority under Ebert and Scheidemann kept supporting the war. 32 19 23
Zimmerwald and Kienthal
The Bureau moved to The Hague in the neutral Netherlands and convened the neutral parties in Copenhagen in January 1915, without result. The belligerent parties met separately by camp: the Allied socialist parties in London in February, those of the Central Powers in Vienna in April. At the London conference the Bolshevik delegate Litvinov read a declaration denouncing the German socialists’ betrayal while rejecting the Allied parties’ support for the war as well, and walked out. 1 51
The first to meet across the front lines were the women. The International Socialist Women’s Conference met in Bern on 26–28 March 1915. Under wartime conditions only about thirty delegates could reach Switzerland. Seven German delegates under Clara Zetkin came in defiance of a ban by their party leadership; Louise Saumoneau of France, delegates of the British Independent Labour Party, and the Bolsheviks Inessa Armand and Nadezhda Krupskaya also attended. The conference unanimously protested against the persecution of Luxemburg and of the Russian Duma deputies, but on the war resolution the Bolshevik delegates, following Lenin, clashed with the majority. 46 24
Robert Grimm of Switzerland prepared an independent anti-war conference with the Italian Socialist Party. The thirty-eight delegates who gathered in Bern on 5 September 1915 rode in four coaches to Zimmerwald, a small village south of the city. According to Trotsky they joked that half a century after the First International all Europe’s internationalists could still fit into four coaches. From Italy came Lazzari, Serrati, Morgari, Balabanova and Modigliani; from France Merrheim and Bourderon of the CGT. From Germany came SPD minority deputies such as Ledebour and Adolph Hoffmann, and Bertha Thalheimer and Ernst Meyer of Luxemburg’s group. From Russia came Lenin and Zinoviev for the Bolsheviks, Martov and Axelrod for the Mensheviks, and Trotsky for Nashe Slovo; Rakovsky of Romania and Kolarov of Bulgaria were also there. Liebknecht, unable to come, sent a letter calling for “civil war, not civil peace” and for a new International to rise from the ruins of the old. 1 24 15 25
The heart of the debate was the movement’s goal. Lenin and Radek argued that peace could come only through revolution, and that socialists must break with the existing organisations and found a Third International. Merrheim answered Lenin: “You are not motivated by a striving for peace, but by the desire to set up a new International. This is what divides us.” When Lenin proposed calling on the parties to vote against war credits, Ledebour threatened that the Germans would leave. The manifesto, drafted by Trotsky, blamed the war on reactionary capitalist governments and called for peace without annexations or indemnities, but left out Lenin’s demands — voting against war credits, a new International. A motion to send the left’s draft resolution to committee was defeated 19 to 12, and the left too voted for the joint manifesto. The conference set up an International Socialist Commission in Bern, run by Grimm and Balabanova. 15 26 47 48
Lenin, Radek and Zinoviev formed the “Zimmerwald Left”. At the second conference, held at Kienthal on 24–30 April 1916, the left gained some ground. The resolution condemned Vandervelde, chairman of the Bureau, for sitting in a belligerent cabinet and making the Bureau a tool of an “imperialist coalition”. Serrati, Kaclerović of Serbia and others signed the left’s peace resolution. But the majority still hoped to revive the old International, and the split deepened. 27 28
1917 and the road to a new International
In The Collapse of the Second International (1915) Lenin located the cause not in individual leaders’ treachery but in opportunism. Part of the superprofits the imperialist countries drew from colonies and foreign investment, he argued, had bought off the upper layer of workers — a labour aristocracy — and the party and union bureaucracy, who had then joined hands with their own bourgeoisie. In Imperialism (1916) he worked the idea into a theory. 29 30 50
On 21 October 1916 Friedrich Adler — Victor Adler’s son and a spokesman of the party’s left — shot dead the Austrian prime minister, Count Stürgkh, in a Vienna hotel dining room. Stürgkh had kept parliament from meeting since before the war. At his trial in May 1917 Adler defended the deed as a revolutionary act against his party’s support for the war. 43
After the February Revolution neutral socialists and the Petrograd Soviet tried to gather every socialist party in Stockholm in 1917 to broker peace, but the Allied governments refused passports to the delegates and the conference collapsed. Grimm, chairman of the Zimmerwald movement, had to step down that year over the Grimm–Hoffmann affair, in which he and the Swiss foreign minister sounded out a separate Russo-German peace. 1 25
The first post-war conference met in Bern in February 1919. The former neutral and Allied parties came, as did the German Majority Socialists and the USPD, but the Belgians refused to sit with the Germans, and parties that had backed the Zimmerwald Left, among them the Italian and Swiss, stayed away. After a quarrel over war guilt ended in a compromise resolution, the conference condemned the Bolshevik dictatorship and endorsed parliamentary democracy. A month later, in March, the Communist International was founded in Moscow on a total rejection of the Second International’s “social patriotism”. 1
The reconstituted Second International shrank further at its conferences in Lucerne in 1919 and Geneva in 1920. In February 1921 the German USPD, the French Socialist Party, the British Independent Labour Party, the Austrian Social Democrats and others, critical of both Internationals, founded the “Two-and-a-half International” in Vienna. In May 1923 the two bodies merged at Hamburg into the Labour and Socialist International, and Friedrich Adler, secretary of the Vienna Union, became the new International’s secretary-general. 1 49 43
Explaining the collapse
Against Lenin’s thesis of betrayal, historians such as Georges Haupt saw the collapse as the outcome of the International’s long-standing contradictions. Its anti-war strategy was built for prevention and useless once war was declared; a federation of autonomous parties had no means of enforcing joint action; and its leaders underestimated how far mass patriotism could outweigh class loyalty and how fast mobilisation would move. Even so, the International left the traditions of mass social democracy — May Day, International Women’s Day, “The Internationale”. 1 29
The collapse separated two currents that had long coexisted in the International. Reformists saw the existing democratic state as a neutral instrument the majority could capture and use; revolutionaries saw it as an organ of class rule to be overthrown. Among the revolutionaries, too, the SPD mainstream expecting revolution after long preparation parted from the left of Lenin and Luxemburg, who expected capitalism’s imminent breakdown through war or crisis. 1914 exposed these differences in a single choice — the vote on war credits — and that line became the post-war boundary between social democracy and communism. 1
Consequences
Most socialist parties in the belligerent countries backed their governments throughout the war, while the anti-war minority split off into the German USPD and the Zimmerwald movement. The founding of the Communist International in 1919 institutionalised the split between social democracy and communism.
Timeline & Map
- 11907.08Stuttgart congress
The International's congress adopted its resolution on militarism, binding deputies to refuse military budgets and calling on socialists to use a war crisis to hasten the end of capitalist rule.
- 21910.08Copenhagen congress
Hardie and Vaillant proposed naming a general strike in the arms industries as the means to stop war, but the congress put the question off to the Vienna congress of 1914.
- 31912.11Basel extraordinary congress
As the Balkan Wars threatened a European war, the congress unanimously adopted an anti-war manifesto reaffirming Stuttgart.
- 1914.07.25SPD appeal for peace
The SPD leadership declared in Vorwärts that not a drop of German soldiers' blood must be sacrificed to the Austrian despots.
- 41914.07.29Emergency ISB meeting in Brussels
The Bureau appealed for stronger anti-war demonstrations and moved the Vienna congress forward to Paris on 9 August. That night Jaurès gave his last speech for peace.
- 51914.07.31Jaurès assassinated
The nationalist Raoul Villain shot Jaurès dead at the Café du Croissant in Paris.
- 1914.08.03SPD group votes 78 to 14
The SPD Reichstag group voted 78 to 14 to approve the war credits, and the minority agreed to follow discipline.
- 61914.08.04SPD votes for war credits
Haase read the declaration that the party would not abandon the fatherland in the hour of danger, and the SPD deputies voted unanimously for the war credits. French socialists voted for credits the same day.
- 1914.08.05MacDonald resigns
When the Labour Party backed the government's request for war credits, Ramsay MacDonald resigned the chairmanship and Arthur Henderson took over.
- 1914.08.08Social Democrats walk out of the Duma
The Social Democratic deputies in the Russian Duma refused to vote for the war credits and walked out in protest.
- 1914.08.26Guesde and Sembat join the government
In a reshuffle of the Viviani government Jules Guesde became minister of state and Marcel Sembat minister of public works.
- 1914.11Bolshevik Duma deputies arrested
Five Bolshevik Duma deputies and six other party members, Kamenev among them, were arrested at a secret conference near Petrograd.
- 1914.11.29Mussolini expelled
The Italian Socialist Party expelled Mussolini, who had turned to intervention and launched Il Popolo d'Italia.
- 1914.12.02Liebknecht votes no
Karl Liebknecht cast the only vote in the Reichstag against the second war credits.
- 1915.02Allied socialists meet in London
The Allied socialist parties met in London; the Bolshevik Litvinov read a declaration condemning chauvinism on both sides and walked out.
- 71915.03.26Bern socialist women’s conference
About thirty socialist women met at a conference organised by Clara Zetkin and protested the persecution of Luxemburg and the Russian Duma deputies.
- 81915.09.05Zimmerwald conference
Thirty-eight anti-war socialists met at Zimmerwald and adopted a manifesto calling for peace without annexations or indemnities; the left's resolution for a new International lost 19 to 12.
- 1915.12.21Twenty SPD deputies vote no
Haase and nineteen other SPD deputies voted against the war credits in the chamber for the first time; twenty-two more walked out.
- 1916.03.24SPD opposition expelled
The SPD group voted 58 to 33 to expel Haase and seventeen others who had opposed the emergency budget; they formed the Social Democratic Working Group.
- 1916.04.24Kienthal conference
The Zimmerwald movement's second conference met at Kienthal and condemned Vandervelde's Bureau as a tool of an "imperialist coalition".
- 1916.05.01Liebknecht arrested
Liebknecht was arrested leading a May Day anti-war demonstration in Berlin and later sentenced to four years and one month.
- 1916.10.21Friedrich Adler kills the prime minister
Friedrich Adler of the Austrian party's left shot dead Prime Minister Stürgkh in a Vienna hotel dining room.
- 91917.04.06USPD founded
The anti-war deputies expelled from the SPD founded the Independent Social Democratic Party (USPD) at Gotha, with Haase as chairman.
- 1917Stockholm conference fails
Neutral socialists and the Petrograd Soviet tried to convene all socialist parties in Stockholm to broker peace, but the Allied governments refused their delegates passports and it never met.
- 1919.02Bern conference
The first post-war socialist conference met in Bern and condemned the Bolshevik dictatorship while endorsing parliamentary democracy.
- 1919.03Communist International founded
The Communist (Third) International was founded in Moscow on a rejection of the Second International's social patriotism.
- 101923.05Labour and Socialist International formed
The reconstituted Second International and the Vienna "Two-and-a-half International" merged at a Hamburg congress into the Labour and Socialist International.
Related people 47
Social-patriotic majority14
Leadership3
Led the International and joined the Belgian government in 1914.
Leader of Austrian Social DemocracyVictor Adler1852–1918Confessed his party’s powerlessness in Brussels and backed the war.
SPD co-chairmanFriedrich Ebert1871–1925Led the majority in continued support for the war.
Participants11
Led the pro-war line alongside Ebert.
French minister of stateJules Guesde1845–1922The veteran of French Marxism entered the Union sacrée government.
Editor of Avanti!Benito Mussolini1883–1945Was expelled from the Italian Socialist Party for advocating intervention.
Russian defencistGeorgi Plekhanov1856–1918The father of Russian Marxism backed national defence.
French syndicalist who abandoned the antiwar lineLéon Jouhaux1879–1954In 1914, he abandoned the antiwar general-strike line and accepted the union sacrée.
Defensist opposing anti-war internationalismAlexander Potresov1869–1934He opposed the Zimmerwald movement’s anti-war internationalism.
French Minister of Public WorksMarcel Sembat1862–1922Entered the Union sacrée government with Jules Guesde in August 1914.
SPD right wing, led the case for the creditsEduard David1863–1930Spoke for the credits at the group meeting of 3 August and pushed the decision through.
From anti-militarist to patriotGustave Hervé1871–1944The most extreme anti-militarist before the war, he rallied to national defence in 1914.
Labour Party chairmanArthur Henderson1863–1935Led Labour in support of the war after MacDonald resigned.
SPD envoy to ParisHermann Müller1876–1931Sounded out joint action with the French socialists in Paris on 1 August, without success.
Anti-war internationalists32
Leadership7
Gave his last speech for peace on 29 July and was assassinated two days later.
SPD co-chairman, later USPD chairmanHugo Haase1863–1919Read the pro-credits declaration on 4 August despite opposing them, then led the anti-war opposition.
Leader of the Zimmerwald LeftVladimir Lenin1870–1924Called for turning the imperialist war into civil war and founding a new International.
German anti-war left, Junius PamphletRosa Luxemburg1871–1919Posed “socialism or barbarism” and led the anti-war left from prison.
Sole vote against war creditsKarl Liebknecht1871–1919Cast the lone vote against war credits in December 1914 and was jailed for an anti-war demonstration in 1916.
Organiser of the Zimmerwald conferenceRobert Grimm1881–1958Organised the Zimmerwald conference and chaired the International Socialist Commission.
Leader of Siberian ZimmerwaldismIrakli Tsereteli1881–1959He led Siberian Zimmerwaldism from 1915 to February 1917.
Participants25
Voiced pre-war optimism and joined the opposition from 1915.
SPD revisionist, later USPDEduard Bernstein1850–1932Voted for the credits out of discipline, then turned against them in 1915.
Labour Party chairmanRamsay MacDonald1866–1937Resigned the chairmanship when Labour backed war credits.
Founder of the Labour PartyKeir Hardie1856–1915Proposed the anti-war general strike and held to opposition until his death in 1915.
Organiser of the socialist women’s anti-war conferenceClara Zetkin1857–1933Organised the 1915 women’s anti-war conference and was arrested several times.
Menshevik internationalistJulius Martov1873–1923Urged and attended the Zimmerwald conference.
Nashe Slovo delegateLeon Trotsky1879–1940Called the Second International a “rigid shell” and attended Zimmerwald.
Zimmerwald Left bureauGrigory Zinoviev1883–1936Led the Zimmerwald Left with Lenin.
Drafted the Zimmerwald Left manifestoKarl Radek1885–1939Wrote the left’s draft manifesto and joined its bureau.
Italian Socialist Party, Zimmerwald preparatory meetingAngelica Balabanova1878–1965Attended the Zimmerwald preparatory meeting.
Romanian Social Democratic delegateChristian Rakovsky1873–1941Attended Zimmerwald for the Balkan socialists.
Bulgarian Narrow Socialist delegateVasil Kolarov1877–1950Attended Zimmerwald for the Bulgarian Narrow Socialists.
American Socialist leaderEugene V. Debs1855–1926Opposed the war and was jailed in 1918.
Zimmerwald movement participantGiacinto Menotti Serrati1872–1926During the war, he joined the Zimmerwald movement.
Zimmerwald movement participantFritz Platten1883–1942He joined the Zimmerwald movement.
Siberian ZimmerwaldistAbram Gots1882–1940In Usolye, he joined the Siberian Zimmerwaldists in anti-war internationalist activity.
Anti-war internationalistAlfred Rosmer1877–1964He was an anti-war internationalist from the first day of the war in August 1914.
Menshevik centrist internationalistPavel Axelrod1850–1928He took part in the Zimmerwald movement but opposed Lenin's Zimmerwald Left, and with Martov secured the formula of peace without annexations or indemnities.
Anti-war socialistArthur Crispien1875–1946He opposed the German Social Democratic Party's support for the war.
Socialist who backed the Zimmerwald positionFernand Loriot1870–1932He opposed the war and backed the Zimmerwald position.
Deputy who voted against the creditsOtto Rühle1874–1943In March 1915 joined Liebknecht in voting against the war credits.
SPD minority, Zimmerwald delegateGeorg Ledebour1850–1947At Zimmerwald threatened that the Germans would leave if a call to vote against credits were included.
Serbian Social Democratic deputyDragiša Lapčević1867–1939Voted against war budgets in the parliament of invaded Serbia.
Bolshevik Duma deputyGrigory Petrovsky1878–1958After refusing the credits he was arrested in November 1914 and sentenced to life exile in Siberia.
Bolshevik delegate at the London conferenceMaxim Litvinov1876–1951At the Allied socialist conference of February 1915 condemned chauvinism on both sides and walked out.
Related terms
Sources: reference 1reference 2reference 3reference 4reference 5reference 6reference 7reference 8reference 9reference 10reference 11reference 12reference 13reference 14reference 15reference 16reference 17reference 18reference 19reference 20reference 21reference 22reference 23reference 24reference 25reference 26reference 27reference 28reference 29reference 30reference 31reference 32reference 33reference 34reference 35reference 36reference 37reference 38reference 39reference 40reference 41reference 42reference 43reference 44reference 45reference 46reference 47reference 48reference 49reference 50reference 51reference 52reference 53reference 54reference 55