Mass Strike
대중파업
The mass strike is not a single narrow action but a total process of working-class struggle in which a substantial portion of workers across multiple industries strike simultaneously at a city, regional, or national level. In her 1906 booklet The Mass Strike, the Political Party and the Trade Unions, Rosa Luxemburg analyzed the 1905 Russian Revolution and argued that the mass strike is not 'called' by party or union leadership but emerges from the spontaneous, creative movement of the working masses, integrating economic and political struggles into a living whole. The concept triggered fierce debate (the Mass Strike Debate) within the German Social Democratic Party and deeply influenced both revolutionary syndicalism and the communist movement.
In depth
1905 and Luxemburg's formulation
The Russian revolution of 1905 showed strikes spreading and taking on a political character. Strikes that began over wages ran across whole cities and turned into political demands, and in the course of it a new organization, the soviet, was formed. Luxemburg analysed this experience in The Mass Strike, the Political Party and the Trade Unions (1906).
Her argument was that the mass strike is not a tactical instrument a leadership proclaims. It is not a single action but a process in which strikes in many sectors follow and overlap one another, a movement in which economic and political demands convert into each other. The conclusion followed that the role of a leadership lies in giving political direction rather than in commanding the process.
The dispute in German Social Democracy (1905–1913)
The German mass strike debate was set off in 1905 by the strike of at least 200,000 miners in the Ruhr and by the Russian revolution. That year the trade-union congress at Cologne resolved by an overwhelming majority that "the general strike as advocated by anarchists and people without any experience in the field of economic struggle" was not open to discussion, and warned the workers not to let such ideas distract them from the daily work of strengthening their organisations. The party congress at Jena the same year, by contrast, adopted a motion that valued the mass strike as an effective weapon for warding off political attacks on the working class while not regarding it as a revolutionary weapon. The resolution was a consensus of the party's currents: Rosa Luxemburg as spokeswoman of the resolute left, the centre around Bebel and the revisionists around Eduard Bernstein all voted for it.
If party and unions were not to break apart, the two decisions had to be reconciled. At the Mannheim party congress of 1906 Bebel said plainly, "Above all we want to bring about peace and harmony between party and trade unions", and the congress adopted the executive's motion that political actions without active backing from the unions could have no prospect of success. What came to be called the Mannheim Agreement redefined the roles of party and unions well beyond the mass strike question.
In the Prussian suffrage struggle of 1910 the dispute flared up again as a polemic in print between Luxemburg and Kautsky. After Luxemburg had put the mass strike up for discussion in an article, "What Next?", in the party paper at Dortmund, Kautsky in "What Now?" distinguished the two strategies of modern military science: the strategy of overthrow, which seeks to strike the enemy down with decisive blows, and the strategy of attrition, which avoids decisive battle and wears the enemy down by constant exhaustion. Under an absolutist police state that ruled out parties and legal influence, he argued, the strategy of overthrow had been the only one open to a revolutionary class, but the whole practice of German Social Democracy since the end of the 1860s had been a strategy of attrition. Luxemburg replied that this logic left nothing but parliamentarism and ruled out every mass action, and Kautsky answered her again in "A New Strategy". In the movement itself, however, the subject largely remained a "desk debate", and the party congress of 1913 confirmed the line of 1906.
Influence
The concept was inherited in two directions. Revolutionary syndicalism developed a strategy making the general strike the central means of overthrowing capitalism, while the communist movement treated it as the joining of mass mobilization to the creation of political crisis.
Mass strikes recurred through the twentieth century in many settings. The British general strike of 1926, the French May of 1968, the Gdansk shipyard strike in Poland in 1980, and the Great Workers' Struggle in South Korea in 1987 showed similar patterns of spread under different conditions. These cases repeatedly display the features Luxemburg identified: economic demands converting into political ones, and spread that escapes the control of existing organizations.
Related terms
Related people
Related historical events
Sources
- Wikipedia (EN) core source: Luxemburg's 1906 booklet, its argument that mass strike is a spontaneous, living totality integrating economic and political struggle
- Wikipedia (EN) historical context: definition of general/mass strike, its role in syndicalism and early 20th-century labor movements, the debate within the Second International
- Wikipedia (KO) Korean Wikipedia: 대중파업 논쟁 (Mass Strike Debate) within SPD, 1905–1906, Luxemburg's central role
- de.wikipedia.org
- Marxists Internet Archive
- Marxists Internet Archive
- Marxists Internet Archive