Founder of Marxist revisionism and evolutionary socialism, author of The Preconditions of Socialism
"I have extraordinarily little interest in what is called the 'final goal of Socialism.' This aim, whatever it be, is nothing to me, the movement everything." — Response to critics (1899)
German SPD theorist and politician. Engels's literary executor and editor of Der Sozialdemokrat, Bernstein began as an orthodox Marxist before his 1899 The Preconditions of Socialism challenged Marx's predictions of capitalist collapse, class polarization, and revolutionary necessity. His dictum "the goal is nothing, the movement everything" laid the foundation for social democracy's reformist, parliamentary turn, creating the schism between revolutionary socialism and evolutionary social democracy. He broke with the SPD's pro-war majority to co-found the anti-war USPD during World War I, and spent his final years defending Weimar parliamentary democracy, dying six weeks before Hitler took power.
Also known as: Leo
Activities and affiliations
-
1875–1932
Social Democratic Party of Germany (SPD)
Scholarship and theory -
1917–1919
Independent Social Democratic Party of Germany (USPD)
Scholarship and theory
Career Timeline
- 1872Joined SDAP (Eisenachers); delegate to 1875 Gotha unification congress
- 1881–1890Editor of Der Sozialdemokrat in exile (Zurich, then London); close collaborator of Engels
- 1891Co-drafted Erfurt Programme with Kautsky; named Engels's literary executor (1895)
- 1899Published The Preconditions of Socialism — launched revisionism debate that divided the international socialist movement
- 1902–1928Reichstag deputy (Breslau-West, later Potsdam II) — specialist in taxation, trade, and constitutional law
- 1915–1917Turned against war credits; issued peace manifesto with Haase and Kautsky; co-founded the anti-war USPD
- 1918–1928Assistant secretary in Weimar Treasury; defended parliamentary democracy; died 1932
Related historical events
How did a Berlin engine driver's son enter the socialist movement?
Eduard Bernstein was born in Berlin on 6 January 1850, the seventh of fifteen children in a Jewish family. His father Jakob was a railway engine driver; the family had been secular for two generations and kept Christmas as a German rather than a religious holiday. Their income placed them in the "genteel poverty" of the lower middle class. His uncle Aaron Bernstein was a well-known liberal journalist and author of popular science books. Bernstein formally left the Jewish community in 1877, but wrote about Jewish questions all his life.
At sixteen, because of the family's finances, he left the Gymnasium without finishing and became a bank apprentice, working as a bank clerk until 1878. His real education came from reading theatre, poetry and philosophy on his own. His political awakening came with the Franco-Prussian War of 1870–1871. At first a patriot, he came to sympathise with August Bebel and Wilhelm Liebknecht, who had opposed the war and been charged with treason.
In 1872, after reading Lassalle and being impressed by a speech by the agitator Friedrich Fritzsche, he and his friends joined the Social Democratic Workers' Party (SDAP), known as the "Eisenachers". He quickly became a skilled speaker, undertaking gruelling speaking tours and debating the rival Lassallean General German Workers' Association. The two books that influenced him most were Marx's The Civil War in France, a celebration of the Paris Commune, and Eugen Dühring's Critical History of National Economy and Socialism, a blend of positivism and idealism. His enthusiasm for Dühring was so great that he introduced Bebel to him; it faded only when he read Engels's reply, Anti-Dühring.
Under government harassment and internal divisions, the two workers' parties saw the need to unite. In 1875 the twenty-five-year-old Bernstein was a delegate to the preliminary conference for the unification congress at Gotha. The Socialist Workers' Party formed there would rename itself the Social Democratic Party (SPD) in 1890. Marx savaged the Gotha Programme as a muddled compromise between Marxism and Lassalleanism, and Bernstein later admitted that the Eisenachers, himself included, had understood little of Marx's theory at the time.
The united party grew quickly, and so did the state's alarm. When attempts on the Emperor's life followed one another in 1878, Bismarck used them as a pretext to prepare a law banning the whole socialist movement. For Bernstein, twenty-eight years old and combining his bank job with party work, the law became a crossroads that would cost him both his livelihood and his home. Until then he had been a passionate agitator rather than a theorist; his ideas took shape only in the twenty-odd years of exile that followed.
How did an editor in exile become Engels's heir?
In 1878, after two attempts on the life of Emperor Wilhelm I, Bismarck enacted the Anti-Socialist Laws, banning socialist organisations, meetings and publications. Just before the law took effect, Bernstein accepted a post as private secretary to Karl Höchberg, a wealthy socialist patron, and left for Zurich in October 1878. What he expected to be a short stay became an exile of more than twenty years.
His start in Zurich was not smooth. In 1879 an anonymous article in a yearbook financed by Höchberg criticised the SPD for its "hatred of the bourgeoisie". Marx and Engels were furious, believing a bourgeois clique was taking over the party's press, and Engels named Bernstein as one of the "trio of Zurichers". Around this time Bernstein read Anti-Dühring, which "converted" him to Marxism, and he became close friends with another exile, Karl Kautsky, studying the Marxist classics with him.
In September 1879 the SPD founded its illegal organ Der Sozialdemokrat in Zurich; smuggled across the border into Germany, it held the banned party together. In December 1880 Bernstein went to London with Bebel and cleared up the misunderstanding with Marx and Engels, beginning a friendship with Engels that lasted for the rest of Engels's life. In January 1881 he became the paper's editor, writing as "Leo" and taking frequent advice from Engels, who called it "unquestionably the best newspaper this party has ever had".
In 1888, under pressure from Bismarck, the Swiss government expelled the paper's staff, and Bernstein moved to London, where he kept the paper going until the law lapsed in 1890. Still under indictment in Germany, he could not go home, and earned his living as London correspondent for the party's new daily Vorwärts and for Die Neue Zeit. He wrote the practical section of the 1891 Erfurt Programme. In the British Museum reading room he wrote Socialism and Democracy in the Great English Revolution (1895), a social and economic study of the English Revolution that rediscovered the communist thinker Gerrard Winstanley, and a critical biography of Lassalle that set out to dismantle the Lassalle legend.
When Engels died in August 1895 he named Bernstein one of his literary executors, a mark of complete trust. But London was changing Bernstein's mind. He saw at close quarters a stable, prosperous capitalist society with strong democratic traditions and a labour movement that chose reform over revolution, and he mixed with Fabians such as George Bernard Shaw and Sidney and Beatrice Webb. He denied that Fabianism was the direct source of his views, but their gradual, empirical socialism clearly reinforced the direction of his thinking. Only after Engels's authority was gone did he begin openly to question the orthodoxy he had inherited.
What did Bernstein want to "revise" in Marxism?
Between 1896 and 1898 Bernstein published a series called "Problems of Socialism" in Die Neue Zeit, and in 1899, at Kautsky's suggestion, he gathered his arguments in The Preconditions of Socialism and the Tasks of Social Democracy. His starting point was that the reality of capitalism had moved away from Marx's predictions, so socialists had to "moult" and bring their theory into line with the facts. The book immediately caused a storm in the international socialist movement.
In economics he tried to refute three Marxist predictions with statistics. First, capital was not concentrating in fewer hands: thanks to joint-stock companies the number of property owners was growing, and small and medium firms were not disappearing. Second, the credit system, cartels and a developed world market gave capitalism the flexibility to make general crises less and less likely (his critique of the collapse theory). Third, workers in the advanced countries were living better, and a "new middle class" of white-collar staff and technicians meant society was not polarising into two classes (his critique of the immiseration theory). The labour theory of value, he said, was a "key" with which Marx had uncovered how capitalism worked, but a mental model that broke down beyond a certain point.
In philosophy he wanted to discard Hegel's dialectic as the "Blanquist element" in Marxism, a fantasy of violent upheaval, and return to Kant's critical philosophy and ethics under the slogan "Kant wider Cant" (Kant against cant). Socialism, in his view, was not a necessity produced by historical laws but an ethical ideal to be striven for in the name of justice and equality. His most famous line, written in reply to his critics, was: "What is generally called the final goal of socialism is nothing to me; the movement is everything." He explained that he did not mean abandoning principles, but that the democratic and ethical process mattered more than any predetermined outcome.
In politics he demanded that the party, already reformist in practice, should "dare to appear what it is today: a democratic-socialist party of reform". Democracy was both the means of winning socialism and the form in which socialism would be realised, "means and end at once". He valued trade unions and cooperatives as democratic elements in industry and rejected the dictatorship of the proletariat as a barbaric, atavistic idea.
The reaction was fierce. Rosa Luxemburg's Social Reform or Revolution? accused him of sacrificing the goal of socialism to bourgeois reform, and Kautsky answered him with Bernstein and the Social Democratic Programme. The party formally rejected revisionism at the Hanover congress in 1899 and at Dresden in 1903. Bebel considered having him expelled but gave up the idea because Bernstein had won so many followers that a split was feared. Bernstein explained the uproar by saying that "for the first time a socialist belonging to the Marxist school had criticised a number of Marxist propositions themselves". His opponents said he had left Marxism and become a bourgeois democrat; he never accepted that.
What course did the returning revisionist take in the Reichstag and the party?
In February 1901, after the warrant for his arrest lapsed, Bernstein returned to Germany for the first time in twenty-three years. He was now the intellectual leader of a controversial but significant current in the party and was in constant demand as a speaker. In 1902 he was elected to the Reichstag for Breslau-West with broad support from across the party. He held a seat until the 1907 election, and again in 1912–1918 and 1920–1928, specialising in taxation, international trade and constitutional law. When the SPD lost ground in the 1907 election to the government's nationalist and colonialist appeal, he named that appeal as one cause of the defeat, though a secondary one.
His return revived the debate. At the 1903 Dresden congress, on Kautsky's motion, the party again condemned revisionism and reaffirmed the revolutionary aims of the Erfurt Programme. Yet the SPD's day-to-day practice remained largely reformist, and his ideas found wide if unacknowledged support among trade union leaders and the party's South German branches. He remained a loyal if critical member, arguing for democratic reform and alliances with progressive sections of the bourgeoisie. At the 1907 Essen congress he proposed an elaborate system of alliances with the Progressives, the Centre Party and the National Liberals to win franchise reform.
In foreign affairs he set a "politics of peoples" against the "politics of states". He supported democratic control of foreign policy, open diplomacy, free trade and international bodies such as a "league of peoples" to prevent war, and spoke of a democratic, republican patriotism distinct from aggressive nationalism. His attitude to colonialism, however, drew sharp criticism from the party's left. He condemned the exploitation and oppression of colonial rule, but held that under certain democratic conditions colonialism could have a "civilising mission". At the Second International's Stuttgart Congress in 1907 he led the majority of the German delegation in arguing that the congress did not reject colonial policy in principle and for all time, since under a socialist regime it could be a civilising factor.
On practical questions he was often more radical than the party leadership. From 1910 to 1919 he sat on the town council of Schöneberg, where he lived, and in 1913 he voted in the Reichstag with the left of the parliamentary group against the army expansion bill. He accused the leadership and Kautsky of using radical language in theory while acting as reformists in practice. Officially defeated, his revisionism is often credited for exactly this reason with being the most honest account of the road the party was actually travelling.
Why did a revisionist who voted for the war turn against it?
On 4 August 1914 Bernstein voted with the SPD parliamentary group for war credits. He accepted the argument that Germany was fighting a defensive war against Tsarist Russia, and he was bound by party discipline. He had also been shaken by the assassination, just before the war, of his friend the French socialist leader Jean Jaurès, which he wrongly believed Russian agents had arranged.
But as evidence emerged about Germany's war aims and its violation of Belgian neutrality, he changed his position. He later called the day he voted for the credits the "darkest day" of his political life. His articles against German chauvinism and annexationism ended his long collaboration with the revisionist journal Sozialistische Monatshefte and his ties with former right-wing allies who now backed the war. With Rosa Luxemburg he was one of the few German politicians to protest publicly against the Ottoman genocide of the Armenians. On 20 March 1915 he left the chamber rather than vote for further credits, and in June he joined Karl Kautsky and Hugo Haase in issuing "The Demand of the Hour", a manifesto denouncing the war as an imperialist venture.
When Haase and the other anti-war deputies were expelled from the SPD parliamentary group in March 1916, Bernstein left with them, and in April 1917 he helped found the anti-war Independent Social Democratic Party (USPD). Unlike the USPD's left wing, he and Kautsky advocated a negotiated peace, and he had at first been sceptical about forming a separate party.
When revolution broke out in November 1918 he became an assistant in the Treasury of the provisional government, the Council of the People's Deputies, and he was one of the few USPD members to stay in post after the SPD–USPD coalition collapsed in December. Arguing that the split over the war was now obsolete, he urged the reunification of the socialist movement, and on 24 December he rejoined the SPD while still a USPD member, becoming a one-man unity campaign. During the Spartacist uprising in January 1919 he narrowly escaped injury in heavy fighting near the Treasury. He grew increasingly frustrated with the USPD's radical wing and its embrace of Bolshevism. When the USPD banned dual membership he left it in March 1919 with an open letter titled "Auf Wiedersehen!" ("Farewell!"). His path, from voting for the war, to being among the first revisionists to turn against it, to returning to the SPD amid the revolution, shows a consistent preference for democracy and the unity of the socialist movement over doctrine.
What did Bernstein try to defend in the Weimar Republic?
At the SPD congress of June 1919 Bernstein challenged the nationalist mood in the party, insisting that Germany, and especially the Kaiser and the military, bore heavy responsibility for the war and that the Treaty of Versailles had to be accepted, harsh as it was. Most of the leadership did not want to hear it. From March 1920 he sat as an expert on Anglo-German relations on the subcommittee on the origins of the war of the inquiry set up by the Weimar National Assembly, where, as one of the few members to acknowledge German responsibility, he stood against the majority from the bourgeois parties.
He sat in the Reichstag for Potsdam II from 1920 to 1928. In the summer semester of 1921 he lectured at the University of Berlin, a marked change from 1907, when a request for him to speak there had been refused; the lectures appeared the next year as Socialism Then and Now. That same year his The German Revolution warned against both Bolshevik-style putsches and right-wing reaction. He played a large part in drafting the markedly revisionist Görlitz Programme of 1921, but after the party reunited with the remaining USPD in 1922 it returned in 1925 to the more orthodox Heidelberg Programme.
He opposed Bolshevism consistently as a "brutalised", dictatorial perversion of Marxism, warning that its methods were functionally indistinguishable from those of rising fascism. In the Weimar years he joined the Reichsbanner Schwarz-Rot-Gold, the organisation formed to defend the republic, and, as campaigns against Zionism mounted, he took part in several pro-Palestine committees, including one "for working Palestine".
As the republic faltered he became increasingly isolated. The party leadership, absorbed in its own version of realpolitik, paid little heed to his warnings about the twin dangers of right-wing reaction and communism. On leaving the Reichstag in 1928 he issued a manifesto with Kautsky urging the party to guard against "the deadly enemies of the republic": the great landowners, the captains of industry and the Communists. He died in Berlin-Schöneberg on 18 December 1932, aged eighty-two, and his funeral became a mass demonstration against the Nazis. Six weeks later Hitler became chancellor.
Officially rejected, his ideas anticipated the road the SPD actually took. When the party broke with Marxism in its 1959 Godesberg Programme, few remembered the connection. In 1964 Carlo Schmid declared that "Eduard Bernstein has won all along the line". To revolutionary socialists he remains the father of revisionism, who traded the goal of socialism for reform; to social democrats he is the honest theorist who held to the principle that socialism without democracy is a betrayal.