Chief theoretician of orthodox Marxism in the Second International, founding editor of Die Neue Zeit, editor of Marx's Capital Vol. IV
"Socialism as a means to the emancipation of the proletariat, without democracy, is unthinkable." — The Dictatorship of the Proletariat (1918)
Leading Marxist theoretician of the Second International. He authored the Erfurt Programme, refuted Bernstein's revisionism, and after the Russian Revolution critiqued Bolshevik rule, creating the defining point of divergence between social democracy and Leninism.
Also known as: Pope of Marxism · Karl Johann Kautsky
Activities and affiliations
-
1883–1917
Social Democratic Party of Germany (SPD)Main
Scholarship and theory -
1917–1919
Independent Social Democratic Party of Germany (USPD)
Scholarship and theory -
1918–1919
Germany state institutionsAssistant in the Foreign Office
Diplomacy and international organization -
1922–1938
Social Democratic Party of Germany (SPD)
Scholarship and theory
Career Timeline
- 1875.01Joined the Austrian Social Democratic Workers’ Party.
- 1880–1882Worked for Karl Höchberg in Zurich, befriended Eduard Bernstein and began studying Marxism.
- 1881Met Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels in London.
- 1883–1917Founded and edited the Marxist theoretical journal Die Neue Zeit.
- 1885–1890Lived in London as a close friend of Engels.
- 1891Wrote the theoretical section of the SPD’s Erfurt Program and published his commentary, The Class Struggle, the following year.
- 1903Emerged in the party as the leading critic of Bernstein’s revisionism.
- 1909Published The Road to Power.
- 1910Opposed Rosa Luxemburg’s revolutionary strategy in the mass-strike debate.
- 1917.04Co-founded the Independent Social Democratic Party (USPD) and lost the editorship of Die Neue Zeit.
- 1918Published The Dictatorship of the Proletariat criticizing Bolshevik rule, provoking Lenin’s polemical reply.
- 1918.11–1919As the Council of the People’s Deputies’ representative, became an assistant (Beigeordneter) in the Foreign Office, studying the 1914 documents, and chaired the first Socialization Commission.
- 1919Left the USPD after becoming isolated as it moved to the left.
- 1922Rejoined the SPD.
- 1925Co-authored the SPD’s Heidelberg Program.
- 1938.10.17Died in Amsterdam, where he had fled after the Anschluss.
Related historical events
- 1893–1896The Early Disputes of the Second InternationalEditor of Die Neue ZeitHaving printed Luxemburg's articles on Poland in 1896, he replied that the International could not adopt independence but Polish socialists were entitled to demand it.
- 1907–1919The collapse of the Second InternationalUltra-imperialism theorist, later USPDVoiced pre-war optimism and joined the opposition from 1915.
- 1912–1913The Balkan WarsTheorist of "ultra-imperialism"When the Balkan Wars did not spread, advanced the theory of ultra-imperialism, that the economic interdependence of the powers made war irrational, feeding the optimism of 1913.
- 1914–1918First World WarAnti-war socialistIn 1917, he left the SPD over opposition to the war and co-founded the USPD.
- 1917.10–1918.01The October RevolutionChief theoretician of the Second International · international criticIn 1918 he published The Dictatorship of the Proletariat, criticising Bolshevik one-party rule and terror from an orthodox Marxist standpoint; Lenin replied with The Proletarian Revolution and the Renegade Kautsky. This debate became the defining point of divergence between social democracy and Leninism in the international socialist movement.
- 1918.10–1919.08The German Revolution of 1918–1919Member of the Socialisation CommissionUSPD theorist on the Socialisation Commission, which produced no result.
- 1919–1921The founding of the CominternCritic of the Bolshevik dictatorshipAttacked the Bolsheviks in The Dictatorship of the Proletariat and clashed with Lenin.
How did the son of a Prague theatre family become a Marxist?
Karl Kautsky was born in Prague, then in the Austrian Empire, on 16 October 1854, the eldest son of Johann Kautsky, a Czech stage designer, and Minna, an actress and writer. The family moved to Vienna in 1863. Although his memoirs later hinted at humble origins, the household was comfortably middle class, with at least two servants. His mother, who would later win a name for socialist novels, was his first intellectual companion; the two read Darwin and Haeckel together.
As a teenager he was drawn to Czech nationalism, but the Paris Commune of 1871 turned him towards socialism. The short-lived self-government of the Paris workers showed him an ideal of direct democracy and common ownership. At the same time he found in Darwin a way to explain the origins of human society and morality without God, and this "natural-scientific" outlook coloured his Marxism for the rest of his life. He entered the University of Vienna in 1874 to study history and philosophy but never took a degree. In January 1875 he joined the young Austrian Social Democratic Workers' Party and wrote for socialist papers under the pen name "Symmachos".
The turning point came in Zurich in January 1880. Many German Social Democrats were living there in exile under Bismarck's Anti-Socialist Laws, and a wealthy sympathiser, Karl Höchberg, gave Kautsky work. There he became close friends with Eduard Bernstein, and the two worked through Engels's Anti-Dühring together; it was this book that made them Marxists. In the spring of 1881 he went to London and met Marx and Engels for the first time. Marx thought him a "mediocrity", but Engels valued his eagerness. Engels complained that university had left him with a "frightful mass of nonsense" and a habit of hasty judgement, while acknowledging his efforts to unlearn it. When an editor was needed for the party's exile paper, Bebel and Engels chose Bernstein instead, judging Kautsky better suited to theoretical work.
In 1883 he founded the theoretical journal Die Neue Zeit (The New Age) with the Stuttgart publisher Dietz. Asking Engels for an opening article on Darwin, he wrote that "the name alone is already a programme". Built on the twin pillars of Marx and Darwin, the journal became, under his editorship until 1917, the most authoritative forum of international Marxism, and Russian Social Democrats used it as their school of theory. From 1885 to 1890 he lived in London, studying in the British Museum reading room and seeing Engels often. His Karl Marx's Economic Doctrines (1887) from these years became the standard popular introduction to Capital.
Why did the Erfurt Programme become the textbook of a generation of Marxists?
When the Anti-Socialist Laws lapsed in 1890, the Social Democratic Party of Germany (SPD) became legal again, and late that year Kautsky settled in Stuttgart, where Die Neue Zeit was published. The party needed a new programme. The Gotha Programme of 1875, written when the Lassalleans and Eisenachers merged, was a compromise that Marx had already attacked. In January 1891 Kautsky published in Die Neue Zeit Marx's unpublished Critique of the Gotha Programme, which Engels had sent him. Party leaders such as Wilhelm Liebknecht were angered by its attack on Lassalle, but the text made clear which way the new programme should go.
In October the Erfurt Congress adopted a programme based on Kautsky's draft. He wrote the theoretical part, with its long-term forecast that capital would concentrate in fewer hands, the middle strata would decline and society would split into two classes, and its call for the socialisation of the means of production. Bernstein wrote the practical part, with immediate demands such as universal suffrage, the eight-hour day and progressive taxation. It was the first mass-party programme built strictly on Marxist principles. Its double structure, a programme that spoke of revolution while the party built up reforms in parliament and the unions, was for decades both the SPD's identity and a source of tension.
The party leadership asked him to write a commentary, and the result was Das Erfurter Programm (1892), known in English as The Class Struggle. In plain language he explained the rise of capitalism, the outline of a socialist society and the tactics of a workers' party. He argued that modern parliamentarism was indispensable for governing a large state and that a genuine parliamentary republic could serve as the instrument of a "dictatorship of the proletariat" just as it served the bourgeoisie. Translated into many languages, the book was read by a generation of Marxists, Lenin among them, as the standard definition of social democracy, and after Engels's death in 1895 Kautsky came to be called the "Pope of Marxism".
In the mid-1890s, when part of the party, led by Georg von Vollmar in South Germany, wanted an agrarian programme to win peasant votes, Kautsky objected. Promising to protect smallholders, he argued, contradicted the class-struggle principle and meant dearer food for urban workers. At the 1895 Breslau Congress his resolution rejecting the draft agrarian programme passed by 158 votes to 63. He set out these ideas in The Agrarian Question (1899), arguing for the superiority of large-scale farming and the decline of the small peasant; Lenin called it the most important contribution to economic literature since Capital. Later scholars have criticised it for underestimating the staying power of the peasantry.
What was Kautsky defending in the Bernstein revisionism debate?
From 1896 Eduard Bernstein published a series called "Problems of Socialism" in Die Neue Zeit, and in 1899 his book The Preconditions of Socialism and the Tasks of Social Democracy attacked Marx's theory of value, dialectics and the collapse thesis, arguing instead for an ethical foundation of socialism and gradual reform. Capital was not concentrating, small businesses were surviving and workers' conditions were improving, he argued, so the party should drop its revolutionary language and admit that it was a "democratic-socialist party of reform".
At first Kautsky was reluctant to attack his old friend, who was still in exile. He even defended him at first against the British socialist Ernest Belfort Bax. But as Bernstein's views became more explicit, and pressed by Bebel and by Russians such as Plekhanov, for whom the issue was especially sensitive, he produced the most systematic reply that same year, Bernstein und das sozialdemokratische Programm. It critiqued revisionism on three fronts: method, programme and tactics. Kautsky argued that Bernstein confused dialectics with mechanical determinism and that his theory of capitalist adaptation concealed the deepening of class antagonisms. Analysing the German industrial censuses of 1882 and 1895, he showed that the concentration of capital and the decline of small enterprise were really under way, and he put forward the idea of relative immiseration: even if workers lived better, their share of the national income fell. He rejected the "collapse theory" Bernstein attributed to him and wrote that the party must be ready for "crisis as with prosperity, reaction as with revolution, catastrophes as with slow peaceful development".
The book became the orthodox camp's core arsenal in the four-day debate opened by Bebel's six-hour report at the 1899 Hanover Party Congress, and the party formally condemned revisionism at Hanover and again at Dresden in 1903. Lenin, then in Siberian exile, reviewed it at length to introduce Kautsky's arguments to Russian readers.
Kautsky's defence had limits. He tolerated Bernstein's continued membership, and he never answered in practice Bernstein's point that the party's everyday work was already reformist. He was later criticised by Luxemburg and Lenin for "centrist passivity" on imperialism and the mass strike. The quarrel also did lasting damage to the two men's friendship. Kautsky later came to see revisionism as a "renaissance of bourgeois radicalism" tied to the decline of the petty bourgeoisie. Nevertheless, the revisionism debate was the defining theoretical moment of Second International Marxism and became, for more than a century, the reference point for the divide between social democracy and revolutionary socialism.
Why did Kautsky become a "centrist" after 1905?
The Russian Revolution of 1905 showed Western European socialists the weapon of the mass strike. Kautsky was one of the first Western Marxists to analyse it. Russia, he wrote, had become the "torch-bearer" of world revolution, and the East was opening the revolutionary road for the West. Yet he saw it as a democratic revolution led by the proletariat rather than a socialist one, and he judged that the Russian peasantry, unlike Germany's, had revolutionary potential.
As strikes spread in Germany too, the SPD argued over the mass strike. Trade union leaders feared the costs and employer retaliation; Rosa Luxemburg and Karl Liebknecht saw it as a way to revive the party and win democratic reform. The 1905 Jena Congress ambiguously accepted the mass strike as a defensive weapon, but a secret agreement between the party and union leaders the following year effectively shelved it. Kautsky proposed that party members be bound by congress decisions in their union work, and lost at the 1906 Mannheim Congress.
After this defeat he worked out what became known as his centrist position, a search for the "true" course between reformism and radicalism. The Road to Power (1909) predicted that sharpening class and international conflicts were bringing an "era of revolutions", but it treated revolution as a product of capitalist development that could not be artificially provoked, leaving the party the role of keeping its oppositional integrity and waiting. Even so, its radical tone alarmed the party executive, which refused to publish it under the party imprint and, after the first 5,000 copies sold out, blocked a second printing. With the help of Clara Zetkin on the party's control commission, he forced the executive to give way.
In 1910, during the fight for reform of the Prussian franchise, Luxemburg called for mass action and a republican slogan; Kautsky refused to publish her article, and the two broke for good. In Germany, where the state was far stronger than in Russia, he argued, a "strategy of overthrow" aimed at a single knockout blow would be suicidal; the right course was a "strategy of attrition", wearing the enemy down through parliamentary struggle, demonstrations and strikes. The SPD, in his formula, was "a revolutionary party, but not a revolution-making party".
In the same years he consistently opposed colonial policy as exploitative and racist, but as war loomed he came to treat imperialism not as a necessary stage of capitalism but as one policy finance capital might choose, and speculated that a phase of "ultra-imperialism", in which international cartels jointly exploited the world in peace, was possible. From 1915 Lenin attacked this theory fiercely as reformism that concealed imperialism's contradictions. To his supporters Kautsky's centrism was a realistic strategy for protecting the party's organisation against a powerful state; to his critics on the left it was passivity dressed in revolutionary rhetoric.
Why did Kautsky break with the Bolsheviks in the years of war and revolution?
When war broke out in August 1914, Kautsky, though not a deputy, was invited to the SPD parliamentary group's meeting on war credits. With Hugo Haase he drafted a statement refusing them; when a majority leaned towards approval he urged abstention, and when the group voted 78 to 14 for the credits he tried, and failed, to add a clause against annexations and violations of neutrality. The party accepted the Burgfrieden, the "civic truce" with the government. The party's left, Liebknecht, Luxemburg and Zetkin among them, broke with him completely at this point for failing to resist strongly enough.
During the war he distinguished between the legitimate defence of a "national state" and the aggressive "nationalistic state", attacked the annexationism of the party majority, and drew close again to his former opponent Bernstein. In June 1915 he, Haase and Bernstein issued an appeal against the government's war aims. He at first opposed founding a separate party, but after the anti-war deputies were expelled from the parliamentary group he took part in founding the Independent Social Democratic Party of Germany (USPD) at Gotha in April 1917 and wrote its manifesto. The price was the editorship of Die Neue Zeit, which he had held for thirty-four years.
When revolution came in November 1918, he entered the Foreign Office as the representative of the Council of the People's Deputies and studied the documents of July 1914. His report found that the German government bore a large share of the blame, but Chancellor Scheidemann blocked its publication for fear of weakening Germany at the Versailles negotiations, and the documents appeared only at the end of 1919. He also chaired the first Socialization Commission, planning a gradual socialisation with compensation. Workers' councils, he held, were useful in the economy but should not become permanent political bodies; only a National Assembly elected by universal suffrage could be the legitimate foundation of a democratic state.
He was an early critic of the October Revolution. In The Dictatorship of the Proletariat (1918) he argued that the dictatorship of the proletariat Marx had in mind was a "condition", the democratic rule of a working-class majority as in the Paris Commune, not a "form of government" that stripped opponents of the vote and of freedom of the press and association. The dictatorship of one party rather than of a proletarian majority became a dictatorship of workers over workers, and a minority dictatorship that lost majority support would lean on the army and end in civil war. The Bolsheviks' dispersal of the Constituent Assembly and abolition of elections, he predicted, would produce a "new class of bureaucratic exploiters" no better than the Tsar's officials.
Lenin replied with The Proletarian Revolution and the Renegade Kautsky, accusing him of worshipping a classless "pure democracy" and declaring that "proletarian democracy is a million times more democratic than any bourgeois democracy". Trotsky answered him in Terrorism and Communism. The exchange became the most famous dividing line between communism and social democracy. The communist tradition remembers him as a "renegade" from Marxism, but many scholars, such as his biographer Massimo Salvadori, see his critique of Bolshevism as a consistent application of the democratic conception of the state he had held since the 1890s. At home his insistence on parliamentary democracy put him at odds with the USPD as it moved left, and when it endorsed council dictatorship in 1919 he effectively broke with the party.
Where did Kautsky stand in his last years, and what did he leave behind?
When the majority of the USPD went over to the Communist Party of Germany (KPD) in 1920, Kautsky argued that the remaining USPD should reunite with the SPD, and when that happened in 1922 he returned to the SPD. In 1920 he visited the Menshevik-led Democratic Republic of Georgia, and the following year his Georgia: A Social-Democratic Peasant Republic condemned the Red Army's invasion. He co-wrote the SPD's Heidelberg Programme of 1925, which, after the reform-minded Görlitz Programme of 1921, again stressed the party's opposition in principle to capitalism. Yet he never felt at home in the increasingly pragmatic party of the Weimar years.
In 1924 he moved to Vienna at the invitation of the Austrian Social Democrats, in effect retiring from party politics. He devoted himself to theory and to the critique of Bolshevism. His major work, The Materialist Conception of History (1927, two volumes), sought to explain the development of human society through the interaction of technology and environment. He described the Soviet system as a kind of state capitalism ruled by a bureaucratic "new class", and Stalinism as a counter-revolution worse than Bonapartism. He corresponded closely with exiled Mensheviks and urged them to prepare for the regime's collapse; men like Axelrod and Dan regarded him as almost their only steadfast supporter on the international stage.
Faced with fascism and Nazism, his judgement faltered. He saw them as counter-revolutionary movements in which post-revolutionary despair and economic crisis drew in an insecure petty bourgeoisie and peasantry, and he was confident that in developed industrial countries they could be no more than an "interlude". This "optimistic fatalism" is still often criticised. From Vienna he watched Hitler come to power and Austrian Social Democracy crushed in the civil war of 1934.
After Germany annexed Austria in March 1938, he and his wife Luise fled by aeroplane to Amsterdam with the help of the Czechoslovak embassy. He died there on 17 October 1938, the day after his eighty-fourth birthday. Luise later died in Auschwitz; their son Benedikt survived Buchenwald. Through his wife his papers went to the International Institute of Social History in Amsterdam.
His legacy is still argued over. Leszek Kołakowski called him the "chief architect and, so to speak, the embodiment of Marxist orthodoxy", the man who did most to create the evolutionist, determinist image of Marxism. The Leninist tradition branded him a "renegade", and critics on the left faulted revolutionary rhetoric that was never matched by action. Others now reread his consistent insistence that socialism cannot be achieved without democracy as a source of modern democratic socialism. His formula that socialist consciousness must be brought into the workers' movement from outside passed directly into Lenin's What Is to Be Done?.