Georgi Valentinovich Plekhanov

Георгий Валентинович Плеханов

The father of Russian Marxism: against his own pupils’ revolution

After the October 1917 seizure of power, Plekhanov said: "Russian history has not yet ground the flour from which the wheat pie of socialism will be baked."

He began as a Populist and transplanted Marxism into Russia: Lenin’s whole generation learned from his books. But returning in 1917 after thirty-seven years abroad, he condemned the October rising as premature, a violation of history’s stages. He died of tuberculosis under the regime his pupils had built, and his funeral became a half-opposition demonstration.

Activities and affiliations

Career Timeline

Related historical events

How did a Tambov landowner's son become a Populist leader and then an exile?

Georgi Plekhanov was born on 11 December (29 November Old Style) 1856 in the village of Gudalovka in Tambov Governorate in central Russia, into a family of minor nobility of Volga Tatar descent. His father Valentin, a soldier who had served in the Crimean War and in the suppression of the 1863 Polish uprising, was a stern and sometimes violent landowner with some fifty serfs. Though he opposed the emancipation of 1861, which cost him half his estate, he tried to adapt to the new capitalist conditions. His mother Maria, a distant relative of the literary critic Vissarion Belinsky, taught the children to read and instilled in Georgi a sense of altruism and justice.

Sent at ten to the Voronezh Military Academy, he learned from the liberal educator N. F. Bunakov a love of literature and a sense of responsibility to the Russian people, and read radical critics such as Belinsky and Nikolay Chernyshevsky. In these years he abandoned his mother's Orthodox faith and became an atheist. In 1873 he entered the Konstantinovskoe Military School in St Petersburg, but left after one semester for the Mining Institute, reflecting the radical respect for natural science of the 1860s and 1870s.

He arrived in the capital just as the Populist (Narodnik) movement was rising. The Populists saw the peasant commune as the seed of a future socialist Russia, and were divided between followers of Bakunin, who believed the peasants could be called to revolt at once, and followers of Lavrov, who argued for a long period of propaganda first. In the winter of 1875–1876 Pavel Axelrod, who had returned from abroad and was in hiding, drew him into the movement, and as his revolutionary work grew he was expelled from the Mining Institute. In the autumn of 1876 he joined the secret society Land and Liberty, and on 6 December he gave a speech denouncing the autocracy at a demonstration in front of the Kazan Cathedral in St Petersburg, which made him a wanted man.

After a brief flight abroad he returned in mid-1877 and worked among peasants, students and factory workers in Saratov and St Petersburg. He carried brass knuckles, slept with a revolver under his pillow, wrote inflammatory leaflets and agitated among strikers. When he was arrested at a strike at a spinning mill near the Obvodny Canal in March 1878, papers passed to him by his comrade N. S. Tyutchev let him hide his identity and escape penal labour.

From 1878 a current advocating political terror, a response to government repression and the failure of rural agitation, grew within Land and Liberty. Plekhanov became the leading spokesman of those who wanted to continue mass work in the countryside. He did not reject violence as such, but argued that a focus on assassination would divert the movement from the more important task of building a mass movement and would only provoke harsher repression. When Andrei Zhelyabov and others proposed a campaign to kill Tsar Alexander II at the Voronezh Congress in June 1879, he walked out in protest. In October the organization split into the terrorist People's Will and Plekhanov's Black Repartition. Black Repartition failed to attract recruits, and sociological studies showing that the peasant commune was decaying shook his Populist faith. In January 1880, to escape arrest, he left for Geneva, the start of an exile that would last thirty-seven years.

Geneva, 1883: Founding the Emancipation of Labour Group

In September 1883, in Geneva, Georgi Plekhanov founded the Emancipation of Labour group together with fellow exiles Pavel Axelrod and Vera Zasulich. It was the first Russian Marxist organization. A former leader of the populist Land and Liberty, he had broken with terrorist tactics and with faith in the peasant commune, concluding that Russia's future lay with its growing working class.

That year he wrote Socialism and the Political Struggle, followed in 1885 by Our Differences, criticizing populism and laying the theoretical foundations of Russian Social Democracy. He translated Marx and Engels into Russian, including the Communist Manifesto, and his pamphlets, smuggled into Russia, nourished the country's first Marxist circles. Lenin later judged his philosophical writings the best in the entire international Marxist literature and urged young communists to study them.

In the spring of 1895 the twenty-five-year-old Lenin travelled to Geneva to meet him. Out of that almost teacher-and-pupil encounter grew the later alliance of the Iskra editorial board. The partnership between the father of Russian Marxism and the generation of his sons, however, was not destined to last.

How did Plekhanov become the "defender of Marxist orthodoxy", and why did he break with Lenin?

In the early 1890s the atmosphere in Russia changed. The famine of 1891–1892 exposed the government's incompetence and indifference and awakened a new sense of social responsibility among the intelligentsia, while rapid industrialization produced a working class and waves of strikes. A new generation including Lenin, Julius Martov and Pyotr Struve turned to Marxism and looked up to Plekhanov as its "master theoretician". The breakthrough came in 1895 with On the Development of the Monistic View of History, published legally in Russia under the pseudonym N. Beltov. A systematic exposition of the materialist conception of history aimed against the Populists, it sold out in under three weeks. The brief period in which the government, more afraid of Populism, tolerated Marxist publications is known as the era of "Legal Marxism".

In the late 1890s the first great controversy arose within Russian Marxism. The "Economists" argued that Social Democrats should concentrate on the workers' economic struggle over wages and conditions rather than on the political struggle to overthrow the autocracy. Plekhanov saw this as the Russian version of Eduard Bernstein's "revisionism", which had just emerged in German Social Democracy and held that socialism could be reached through gradual reform rather than revolution. For him the task of Social Democrats was not to follow the workers but to lead them, raising trade-union consciousness to socialist consciousness. In 1900 he published his blistering Vademecum for the Editors of Rabochee Delo. His polemical style was notoriously harsh: Lenin recalled Plekhanov advising him about one critic of Marxism, "First, let's stick the convict's badge on him, and then after that we'll examine his case."

To unite the party against Economism, Lenin, Martov and Alexander Potresov planned the newspaper Iskra, and in August 1900 Lenin came to Geneva to negotiate with Plekhanov. The first meeting was stormy: in a "Jacobin" mood after his battles with the Economists, Plekhanov suspected Lenin's draft editorial policy of being too conciliatory. In the end a six-member board was formed of three veterans (Plekhanov, Axelrod, Zasulich) and three young men (Lenin, Martov, Potresov), and Plekhanov's hard line of drawing "lines of demarcation" between the orthodox and their opponents went into the editorial statement.

When Lenin and Martov split over Paragraph 1 of the party rules at the Second Congress in 1903, Plekhanov, to the surprise of many, sided with Lenin, arguing that Martov's broad definition of membership would let in the "bourgeois individualism" of the intelligentsia and every kind of opportunism. At this congress he made a speech that would haunt him for years: "If, for the sake of the success of the revolution, it were necessary temporarily to restrict this or that democratic principle, it would be criminal to stop short of such a restriction." The success of the revolution was the highest law, and if necessary even universal suffrage could be limited.

The alliance did not survive the year. Afraid of a new split, he broke with Lenin in October 1903 and brought the old Menshevik editors back onto Iskra, and in November he joined the Mensheviks, calling Lenin a "Robespierre". He charged that Lenin's organizational scheme confused the dictatorship of the proletariat with a "dictatorship over the proletariat" and slid into "Bonapartism" and "Blanquism". The critique was sharp and prophetic, but it also showed that Plekhanov had embraced the elitist and centralist logic of the Iskra period only to recoil when Lenin carried it to its conclusion.

What did Plekhanov's philosophy, history and aesthetics leave behind?

Plekhanov was one of the few followers of Marx and Engels who took philosophy as seriously as politics. He saw Marxism as a complete materialist worldview whose philosophical foundations were indispensable to the socialist movement. In his account, the eighteenth-century French materialists d'Holbach and Helvétius defended materialism but could not explain historical development, while Hegel supplied dialectics, the method of grasping history through motion and contradiction, but remained an idealist. Marx and Engels, combining the materialism of thinkers such as Feuerbach with Hegel's dialectics, created "dialectical materialism". Plekhanov is credited as the first to use that term for Marxist philosophy as a whole.

A recurring problem in his philosophy is the tension between determinism and free will. He insisted that the historical process follows laws, independent of human will, much as nature does, yet he recognized individual action and "passion" as an "indispensable link" in the chain of historical necessity. His 1898 essay On the Role of the Individual in History is the classic treatment of this question: an outstanding individual can change the particular shape of events, but not the general direction of social development. His own passionately political life, however, sat uneasily with pure determinism, and he never fully resolved the contradiction.

His main historical work was the unfinished History of Russian Social Thought. He portrayed pre-Petrine Russia as an "Oriental despotism" in which the state controlled the means of production and reduced every class to utter dependence, and argued that Peter the Great's reforms began a process of "Europeanization" that brought in capitalism and created the bourgeoisie, the proletariat and the intelligentsia. That these new forces would eventually challenge the old despotic order was the theoretical underpinning of his two-stage theory of revolution.

With Franz Mehring and Paul Lafargue he is counted among the founders of Marxist literary criticism. He held that art, like other forms of social thought, reflects the economic and social conditions of its time and expresses the ideals and feelings of a particular class. He proposed a two-step method: first translate the idea of a work from the language of art into the language of sociology to find its "sociological equivalent", then evaluate its aesthetic merit. He regarded "art for art's sake" and Impressionism as signs of bourgeois decadence.

His legacy is still read in different ways. Lenin, though his political opponent, esteemed his philosophical writings highly, and the Soviet Union honoured him as the father of Russian Marxism. Some see him as a democratic, orthodox Marxist alternative to Leninism; others stress the theoretical ground he prepared for the Bolsheviks.

Why did Plekhanov become isolated in the 1905 revolution and the World War?

The 1905 revolution put Plekhanov's theory of revolution to the test. He saw it as the "bourgeois revolution" he had foretold twenty years earlier. His view of revolution had two stages: first the bourgeoisie and proletariat together would overthrow the autocracy and set up a democratic republic, and only after capitalism had matured would a socialist revolution follow. In his article "March Separately, Strike Together", published in Iskra in February 1905, he called for careful preparation of an armed rising and above all for agitation in the army. Yet he stayed abroad throughout the revolution and remained on the sidelines of the actual events.

As the revolution unfolded, the contradictions of his strategy came into view. Frightened by the militancy of the workers, the bourgeoisie proved a timid and unreliable ally, while the workers would not settle for the role of junior partner. When the December rising in Moscow, led by Social Democrats, was crushed, he declared: "They should not have taken to arms." The remark was held against him for years. In 1906–1907 he argued that Social Democrats should take part in the elections to the Duma and form an electoral bloc with the liberal Constitutional Democrats (Kadets).

This stance alienated him from both factions. The Bolsheviks rejected his insistence on an alliance with the bourgeoisie and called for a "revolutionary-democratic dictatorship of the proletariat and the peasantry"; even the Mensheviks, who broadly shared his strategy, recoiled from what they saw as his "opportunistic", "Kadet-like" tactics. He became more a "historic monument" than an active leader. From 1905 to 1912 he published his own journal, Diary of a Social Democrat, in Geneva, and also wrote for the all-party paper and for the Bolshevik paper Zvezda.

When the World War broke out in 1914 he adopted "defensism", supporting the Allies against Germany. He saw the war as a struggle between the democratic nations of the West and Germany's imperialist and reactionary regime; a German victory would be a disaster for socialism, while an Allied one would advance democracy in Russia and Europe. It was a complete reversal of the internationalist position he had taken in the Russo-Japanese War, when he had hoped for Russia's defeat, and it separated him from most of the international socialist movement, including his old comrades Axelrod and Martov, who opposed the war. He founded the defensist Social Democratic group Yedinstvo (Unity).

His biographer Samuel Baron sees this defensism as an extreme development of the nationalist and state-centred tendencies latent in the Marxism of the Second International, and also as a sign of Plekhanov's growing alienation from the revolutionary movement. He had come to regard the political and cultural achievements of the "bourgeois" West as worth defending, and in his wartime writings he began to praise the ethics of Kant, a thinker he had once condemned as the epitome of bourgeois hypocrisy. The isolation that awaited him on his return to Russia in 1917 had already begun.

Why Was Plekhanov's Orthodoxy "More Uncompromising" than Lenin?

In his 1967 essay "Lunacharsky", Mikhail Lifshitz reversed a common view. Leninism is often understood as a stricter correction of Plekhanov's orthodoxy, but he wrote that in a certain sense Plekhanov as a theorist was more uncompromising than Lenin.

As evidence he cites 1900. According to Lenin's note "How the Spark Was Nearly Extinguished", Lenin proposed a more lenient attitude to Struve, whose early deviations had never met comradely criticism, while Plekhanov suspected Lenin's delegation of a whiff of opportunism. Lifshitz held that this intransigence produced Plekhanov's tragic isolation and later led him into the worst, undialectical compromises.

His summary reads: "Apt, logical, uncompromising, but far from always historically concrete." The critique of Narodism was right and sharp but missed its democratic-peasant side, and the 1905 revolution was judged simply as bourgeois, without its actual driving forces, workers and peasants. He also judged that the so-called dogmatism of the 1930s and 1940s, while often criticizing Plekhanov unjustly, in fact revived a schematized Plekhanovite understanding of dialectics.

1917–1918: The Revolution Outgrows Its Teacher

In April 1917 Plekhanov returned to Petrograd after thirty-seven years of exile, but the Russia he returned to was no longer his. Convinced that the country was not yet mature enough for a socialist revolution, he supported the defensive war against Germany and dismissed Lenin's April Theses as ravings. Yedinstvo, the newspaper of the man who had once taught all of Russian Marxism, now spoke for a small minority.

Immediately after the October insurrection (25 October Old Style, 7 November New Style) he published an Open Letter to the Petrograd Workers, arguing that the proletariat had seized power prematurely. Yet he flatly refused to stand with the counterrevolution. When he was asked to head a government against the Bolsheviks, he answered that after forty years of fighting alongside the proletariat he would not raise a gun against the workers.

His tuberculosis worsened, and he died on 30 May 1918 in a sanatorium at Terijoki in Finland. The Bolshevik government he had criticized did not disown his legacy: his works were published throughout the Soviet era, and Lenin wrote that no one could become a conscious communist without studying everything Plekhanov had written on philosophy.