Mikhail Alexandrovich Bakunin

Михаил Александрович Бакунин

Marx's greatest rival: founder of collectivist anarchism, at the center of the First International's great split

At the 1869 Basel Congress: 'Take the most fervent revolutionary and give him absolute power — within a year he'll be worse than the Tsar' — cited in Statism and Anarchy

A Tver nobleman, founder of collectivist anarchism. He opposed Marx's statism in the First International, was expelled at the 1872 Hague Congress, and codified stateless federalism in Statism and Anarchy (1873).

Also known as: Jules Elizard · Jules Elysard

Activities and affiliations

Career Timeline

Related historical events

How did a young Tver nobleman cross from Hegel's philosophy to revolution?

Mikhail Bakunin was born on 30 May (18 May Old Style) 1814 at Priamukhino, the family estate in Tver Governorate north-west of Moscow, which had more than five hundred serfs. His father Alexander, a former diplomat who had served in Italy, married the much younger Varvara Muravyova and raised their ten children on Rousseau's educational model. Mikhail, the eldest son, grew up reading languages, literature and philosophy, and later remembered his childhood as idyllic and sheltered from Russian realities. His close bond with his brothers and sisters became the model of the "free community" he dreamed of all his life.

As a young teenager he entered the St Petersburg Artillery School, but a soldier's life did not suit him. Commissioned in 1833, he enjoyed the capital's social life yet found it empty, and for neglecting his studies he was sent in early 1834 to Belarus and Lithuania, where he read philosophy. In 1835 he deserted his post and escaped arrest only through family influence; discharged at the end of the year, he went to Moscow over his father's protests, meaning to become a mathematics teacher.

In the Moscow of the 1830s German Romantic literature and idealist philosophy held the intelligentsia in thrall. In Nikolai Stankevich's circle Bakunin read Kant, Fichte and Hegel and translated them into Russian; he produced the first Russian translation of Hegel and by 1837 was regarded as the foremost Russian expert on him. In these years he befriended the critic Vissarion Belinsky, the poet Nikolai Ogarev, the novelist Ivan Turgenev and the writer Alexander Herzen. When Herzen helped fund his study at the University of Berlin in 1840, he still intended to return to Moscow as a professor.

In Berlin he drew close to the Young Hegelians, who gave Hegel's philosophy a radical reading, and through them was drawn into politics. In early 1842 he moved to Dresden and met the Left Hegelian Arnold Ruge, whose journal carried his first original work, "The Reaction in Germany", under the pseudonym Jules Elizard. Steeped in Hegelian language, it called for carrying the spirit of the French Revolution to the rest of Europe and to Russia, and it ended with a famous line: "The passion for destruction is a creative passion, too." It marked the moment the philosopher became a revolutionary.

In October 1842 he wrote to his brother: "After long reflection I have decided never to return to Russia. I am not fit for the Russia of today; but here I feel that I still want to live, that I can act here." In early 1843 he left Prussia for Zurich with the revolutionary poet Georg Herwegh and met the early communist Wilhelm Weitling. When Weitling's arrest drew the Russian government's suspicion onto him, he refused an order to return, and in 1844 the Russian Senate stripped him in absentia of his noble status and all rights and sentenced him to penal labour in Siberia should he ever return.

From the barricades of 1848 to escape from Siberia, how did Bakunin become a European legend?

From 1844 to 1847 Bakunin lived mostly in Paris, where he grew close to Proudhon and met Karl Marx, with whom he would later clash. After meeting the Polish revolutionary exile Joachim Lelewel in Brussels he became absorbed in the Polish question. On 29 November 1847, invited to a banquet in Paris commemorating the Polish uprising of 1830, he called on the Poles to overthrow tsarism in alliance with Russian democrats. The speech made him known throughout Europe, and at the Russian ambassador's request he was expelled from France.

When the February Revolution of 1848 toppled King Louis Philippe, he hurried back to Paris. In June he attended the Slavic Congress in Prague, convened to defend the rights of the Slavic peoples, and joined the Prague uprising against the Habsburgs. After its defeat he fled to Germany and wrote his "Appeal to the Slavs", which called on the Slavic peoples to rise against the Austrian, Prussian, Ottoman and Russian governments and form a free federation of European republics; it was widely read and translated.

In May 1849 he became one of the leaders of the uprising in Dresden, the capital of the Kingdom of Saxony. Arrested in Chemnitz after its defeat, he was sentenced to death by a Saxon court. He refused to sign a petition for the king's pardon, but the sentence was commuted to life imprisonment. Saxony handed him over to Austria, where a court sentenced him to death again in 1851 for his part in the Prague rising. Finally he was handed over to Russia and held in solitary confinement in the Alexeyevsky Ravelin of the Peter and Paul Fortress in St Petersburg from 1851 to 1854, and in the Shlisselburg Fortress from 1854 to 1857.

In the fortress, at the demand of Emperor Nicholas I, he wrote his Confession, an autobiographical and self-abasing account of his views on the revolutionary movement and the Slavic question addressed to the tsar. Its discovery some seventy years after his death caused controversy, and whether it was sincere repentance or a strategy for survival is still argued over; it did not, in any case, improve his conditions. Prison wore down his health but not his revolutionary zeal.

In 1857, after persistent petitions from his family and a doctor's warning that heart disease might soon kill him, Emperor Alexander II allowed him to be transferred to permanent exile in Siberia. Settling in Tomsk, he married Antonia Kwiatkowska, the daughter of a neighbouring Polish nobleman and twenty-six years his junior, and with the help of a relative who was governor-general of Eastern Siberia he moved to Irkutsk. In 1861 he escaped to Japan and travelled on via San Francisco, Panama, New York and Boston, reaching London by the end of the year. He landed in America just as the Civil War broke out; he sympathized with the North, yet pointed to the hypocrisy of invoking slave emancipation while forcing the South to remain in the Union. Sentenced to death in three countries, held in fortresses, exiled to Siberia and escaping around the globe, he became a living legend among European revolutionaries.

How did Bakunin go from Slavic liberation to anarchism in London and Italy?

In London Bakunin rejoined his old friends Herzen and Ogarev and worked with them on their Russian-language paper Kolokol (The Bell), but his revolutionary fervour outran their moderate, reformist agenda. In an appeal "To Russian, Polish and all Slavic friends" he called for dismantling states held together only by force, such as Austria, the Ottoman Empire and Russia, and for a federation of Slavic peoples formed freely from below. In his 1862 pamphlet The People's Cause: Romanov, Pugachev or Pestel? he argued that if the tsar would become a "people's tsar" and summon a national assembly, the people would follow him more willingly than the rebel Pugachev or the Decembrist Pestel, while warning that otherwise a bloody revolt would come.

When the January Uprising broke out in Russian Poland in 1863, he joined an expedition to bring armed volunteers. Arriving in Stockholm on 24 February, he helped prepare a landing near Palanga on the Baltic coast, but the expedition failed. After that failure he turned from national liberation to social emancipation, and in 1864 he went with his wife to Italy, living in Florence and then Naples.

In Italy, now past fifty, Bakunin worked out the core of his anarchist thought: all existing states had to be destroyed and replaced by a free federation of voluntarily associated producers. This also set him against the Christian republicanism of the Italian nationalist Giuseppe Mazzini. In 1864–1865 he formed the secret International Brotherhood and in 1865–1866 wrote its programme, the "Revolutionary Catechism", a different document from the Catechism of a Revolutionary that Nechaev wrote in 1869. His secret societies existed mostly on paper and never took revolutionary action, but they served as a personal network for spreading his ideas.

In 1867 he moved to Switzerland, where publishing was freer, and spoke as a vice-president at the Geneva congress of the democratic League of Peace and Freedom. He argued that peaceful union was impossible among existing states founded on violence and centralization, which had to be dissolved and replaced by free autonomous communities organized "from below upward". That year he first called himself an anarchist. "Federalism, Socialism and Anti-Theologism", written for the congress, is a key statement of his ideas.

In 1868 he left the League, joined the First International (the International Workingmen's Association) and organized the International Alliance of Socialist Democracy, which he tried to bring into the International. In 1869 his Russian translation of Marx and Engels's Communist Manifesto was published. Ironically, the man who first brought Marx's manifesto to Russian readers was about to become Marx's greatest opponent inside the International.

The Nechaev Affair: Revolutionary Fanaticism and Bakunin's Crisis

In the spring of 1869, during his Geneva exile, Bakunin met a young Russian revolutionary named Sergei Nechaev and embraced him enthusiastically, calling him 'my boy.' Nechaev falsely claimed to have escaped from the Peter and Paul Fortress, and Bakunin saw in him the authentic voice of Russian youth: 'the most revolutionary in the world.' Together with Nikolai Ogarev, they launched a propaganda campaign into Russia financed by the Bakhmetiev Fund. Nechaev's Catechism of a Revolutionary, which declared the revolutionary a 'doomed man' with no private interests, feelings, property, or even name, acting on the principle that the ends justify the means, was long misattributed to Bakunin himself.

In November 1869, Nechaev and several comrades beat, strangled, and shot Ivan Ivanov, a fellow member of the secret 'People's Reprisal Society' who had questioned his methods, dumping the body through a hole in the ice. The murder became the inspiration for Dostoevsky's novel Demons. After fleeing back to Geneva, Nechaev began stealing letters and private papers to blackmail Bakunin and the other exiles. Bakunin broke with him, writing that Nechaev was 'nearer to the Jesuits than to us,' a fanatic whose blindness was 'a great and fatal weakness.' But the damage was done: at the 1872 Hague Congress, the Marx faction used the Nechaev affair, together with Bakunin's secret 'International Brotherhood,' as the principal grounds for expelling him from the International. The Nechaev affair endures as a historical touchstone exposing the tension between anarchist ethics, which reject unlimited means, and revolutionary Machiavellianism.

The Marx-Bakunin Split: State, Inheritance, and the Direction of Revolution

At the heart of the split that tore the First International apart was the question: what replaces the old order after revolution? Bakunin fused Proudhon's federalism with his own collectivism, advocating collective ownership of land and means of production organized into a free federation of self-governing workers' communes, built from below. Where Marx treated the abolition of inheritance as a natural consequence of abolishing private property, Bakunin regarded inheritance law as a legal mechanism that perpetuated class inequality and demanded its immediate, total abolition. At the 1869 Basel Congress, Bakunin's resolution on abolishing inheritance received 32 votes to 23, short of the required majority. But Marx's General Council counter-proposal for higher inheritance taxes was crushed 19 to 37, marking a symbolic victory for the Bakuninist camp.

The deeper fault line was state power. Marx held that the dictatorship of the proletariat was an unavoidable transitional phase from capitalism to socialism. Bakunin, in Statism and Anarchy (1873), warned that 'the people's state imagined by Marx would in essence be nothing but the dictatorship of a privileged minority ruling over the masses.' He argued that state power, whatever ideology it wore, inherently reproduces a new ruling class, and that revolution must bypass state capture entirely: moving directly to the dissolution of the state into a federation of autonomous communes. On organization, where Marx's supporters emphasized disciplined party-led political struggle, Bakunin defended direct mass action by workers and peasants and the sovereign autonomy of the International's sections. At the 1872 Hague Congress, Bakunin was expelled on grounds of maintaining the secret 'International Brotherhood' and complicity in the Nechaev affair, a decision that effectively dissolved the International. This split became the archetypal fault line defining all subsequent genealogies of socialist, communist, and anarchist movements.

From the Lyon rising to his death in Bern, what did the late Bakunin leave behind?

When the French Empire collapsed in the war with Prussia in September 1870, Bakunin hurried to Lyon, arriving around 14 September, and joined the rising known as the Lyon Commune. On 17 September he and members of the International's Lyon section founded the Committee for the Salvation of France, on a programme of mass levy and revolutionary war in the spirit of 1792–1793. On the morning of 28 September, the day chosen for the rising, a red poster appeared on the walls: the manifesto of the Revolutionary Federation of Communes, signed by 26 people including Bakunin. Its first article declared that "the administrative and governmental machinery of the state, having become powerless, is abolished". It suspended the criminal and civil courts in favour of the people's justice, suspended taxes and mortgage payments in favour of contributions from the federated communes levied on the rich, replaced all municipal bodies with Committees for the Salvation of France under the people's direct control, and summoned delegates of the departmental committees to a Revolutionary Convention for the Salvation of France at the Lyon city hall. At noon several thousand workers with red flags filled the Place des Terreaux, and about a hundred of the committee's militants, Bakunin among them, entered the city hall and held the mayor and the prefect. But the hoped-for rising did not spread, and the National Guard of the workers' district of La Croix-Rousse did not move. Surrounded in the city hall, the revolutionaries negotiated their withdrawal; as repression began, Bakunin fled to Marseille and then retreated to Switzerland. From this time he began longer works such as The Knouto-Germanic Empire and the Social Revolution, most of which he never finished; part of the manuscript was published after his death as God and the State (1882), which became the most widely translated anarchist classic.

At the Hague Congress of 1872 the struggle with Marx's supporters over the International came to a head. Bakunin could not reach the Netherlands and was absent; he was expelled for maintaining a secret organization within the International. His supporters, however, among them the Spanish, the Italians and the watchmakers of the Swiss Jura Federation, founded the Anti-Authoritarian International at Saint-Imier in Switzerland that same year. It was the moment Marxism and anarchism parted into separate movements.

In 1873 he published Statism and Anarchy anonymously in Russian to stir the revolutionary underground in Russia. He portrayed the German Empire as the most centralized state standing against European anarchism and linked Marx to German authoritarianism, warning that Marx's "dictatorship of the proletariat" would become rule by a minority that held power in the proletariat's name for its own benefit. "Liberty without socialism is privilege and injustice," he wrote, "and socialism without liberty is slavery and brutality." In the same book he sharply criticized Pan-Slavism as an instrument of state policy. An initial run of 1,200 copies was printed in Switzerland and smuggled into Russia. In its appendix he told Russia's revolutionary youth to establish, at all costs and by every possible means, a vital line of revolt between the isolated rural communities, and warned that the people would accept the young intellectuals only if they shared their life, their poverty, their cause and their desperate revolt. The next spring, 1874, students and intellectuals poured into the villages of some forty provinces, mainly along the Volga and in the south, in the movement of going to the people; many of the young participants were inspired by Bakunin's call for an immediate rising. The peasants did not respond, and by 1877 more than 4,000 people had been arrested, 193 of whom stood in the Trial of the 193.

From 1872 he lived in poverty in Lugano and Locarno in Switzerland. His Italian follower Carlo Cafiero bought him a small villa, but he spent his energy planning revolutionary attempts. The last was the Bologna rising of 1874, planned with his Italian followers. Its failure dealt the Italian anarchist movement a heavy blow, and, his health broken, he returned to Switzerland in disguise. He died in Bern on 1 July 1876.

His legacy is judged in different ways. He was not a systematic thinker, and his writings were prolific but fragmentary. Yet his warning that state power, whatever ideology it wears, produces a new ruling class was read again after the experience of the Soviet system, and he influenced anarchists such as Peter Kropotkin and Errico Malatesta, the Industrial Workers of the World and the anarchists of the Spanish Civil War. His idea of an "invisible dictatorship", a secret network of revolutionaries influencing the masses without official power, remains disputed: historians such as Peter Marshall see in it a potential for greater tyranny than a Blanquist or Marxist party, while the anarchist writer Iain McKay argues it was only a network for spreading propaganda under conditions of illegality.