Karl Berngardovich Radek

Karol Radek
Comintern Left critics Soviet Union Poland 1885.10.31.–1939.5.19. ✕ Killed in prison

The polemicist who survived trial only to die in prison

"Do you know the difference between Stalin and Moses? Moses led the Jews out of Egypt, but Comrade Stalin led them out of the Politburo." — Radek to Boris Bazhanov, after Trotsky and Zinoviev were expelled from the Politburo.

A Polish-born Jewish journalist and diplomat who moved between the international social-democratic and communist movements. A close associate of Lenin, he participated in the Brest-Litovsk negotiations and the founding of the Comintern, serving on the Bolshevik Central Committee and as Comintern secretary. Renowned for his sharp polemics and biting wit, he led the Left Opposition before recanting publicly in 1930 and rejoining the Party. During the Great Purge he became the central defendant at the Second Moscow Trial, delivering theatrical confessions that earned him a 10-year sentence; in 1939 he was killed in prison on Stalin's orders.

Also known as: Karol Sobelsohn

Activities and affiliations

Career Timeline

Related historical events

How did a Jewish boy from Galicia become a polemicist of Polish and German social democracy?

Karl Radek was born Karol Sobelsohn on 31 October 1885 in Lemberg, Austria-Hungary (now Lviv, Ukraine). His father, a post office clerk, died early, and he was raised by his mother, a teacher. The family was Jewish, but he had no religious upbringing; his native language was Polish and he regarded himself as a Pole. He grew up in the Galician town of Tarnów, was twice expelled from the gymnasium for agitating among workers, and organised an underground circle of radical youth. He took the name Radek from Andrzej Radek, a character in Stefan Żeromski's novel The Labours of Sisyphus.

He joined the Polish Socialist Party (PPS) in 1902 and moved in 1904 to the Social Democracy of the Kingdom of Poland and Lithuania (SDKPiL), led by Rosa Luxemburg and Leo Jogiches. The difference between the two parties lay in whether Polish independence came first or the joint overthrow of tsarism with the Russian working class. In the 1905 Revolution he ran the party paper Czerwony Sztandar (The Red Banner) in Warsaw; in 1906 he was arrested together with Jogiches and Luxemburg and spent half a year in prison. Arrested again in 1907, he left for Germany.

In Germany he worked on Social Democratic (SPD) papers in Leipzig and Bremen and made his name as a sharp writer of the party's left, joining the 1912 attacks on Karl Kautsky's analysis of imperialism. But he was also caught up in the "Radek affair". When members of the PPS accused him in 1910 of stealing books, clothes and money from comrades, Luxemburg and Jogiches defended him, seeing an antisemitic attack on the SDKPiL. The next year, however, Jogiches clashed with Lenin, and Radek sided with the younger pro-Lenin members around Hanecki (Ganetsky); Jogiches then revived the theft charges. In August 1912 a party court expelled him, and the 1913 SPD congress retroactively applied a rule that no one expelled from a sister party could join another party of the International. Liebknecht and Pannekoek, as well as Trotsky and Lenin, opposed the decision.

When the First World War broke out he took an internationalist stand against the war, moved to Switzerland and grew close to Lenin. He acted as the link between Lenin and the Bremen Left in Germany and at the 1915 Zimmerwald Conference, the international meeting of anti-war socialists, he sided with the left. He did not always agree with Lenin: Lenin hailed the 1916 Easter Rising in Ireland as a blow to British imperialism, while Radek dismissed it as a petty-bourgeois affair in his article "The End of a Song". His nimble prose, quick shifts of position and biting jokes were already his reputation.

Why did he go into the middle of the German revolution after the Russian one?

After the February Revolution of 1917 Radek helped arrange the return of Lenin and his comrades to Russia through Germany and himself rode with them on the "sealed train". That enemy Germany let the revolutionaries pass in wartime was later used again and again to brand the Bolsheviks as German agents. He was, however, refused entry to Russia and stayed in Stockholm as a member of the Bolsheviks' foreign representation. With Jakub Hanecki he published the German-language bulletins Russische Korrespondenz-Pravda and Bote der Russischen Revolution, spreading Bolshevik documents and news across Europe.

After the October Revolution he came to Petrograd, became head of the foreign relations department of the All-Russian Central Executive Committee, and from December 1917 took part in the Brest-Litovsk peace talks as a member of the collegium of the People's Commissariat for Foreign Affairs. He was also responsible for spreading Bolshevik propaganda among German troops and prisoners of war. When the party split over peace with Germany, he was among those, with Bukharin, who called for a revolutionary war: rather than sign a humiliating peace, revolutionary Russia should fight on and kindle revolution in Europe.

When revolution broke out in Germany in November 1918, the Soviet government tried to send him with Joffe, Bukharin, Rakovsky and others to the German Congress of Workers' and Soldiers' Councils. The delegation was turned back at the border, but Radek alone slipped across in December and reached Berlin; too late for the congress, he took part in the founding congress of the Communist Party of Germany (KPD). After the Spartacist rising in Berlin was crushed in January 1919 and Rosa Luxemburg and Karl Liebknecht were murdered by right-wing Freikorps troops, he was arrested on 12 February on charges of organising the rising and held in Moabit prison. The investigators had no concrete documents proving his involvement. Liebknecht had arranged to meet Radek at the safe flat to which he had moved with Luxemburg, and the killers later burst into that very flat. On that basis Liebknecht's brother Theodor accused Radek of betraying the two, but no evidence for this was produced.

While he was in prison the German government's attitude changed. As the idea of an alignment of the losers of Versailles, Germany, Russia and Turkey, gained ground in Berlin, his cell became in effect a political salon. Visitors included Walther Rathenau, later foreign minister, Enver Pasha, the former Ottoman war leader, and the German Communist Ruth Fischer. These conversations are counted among the background to the rapprochement that led to the German-Soviet Treaty of Rapallo in 1922. He was released in January 1920 and returned to Moscow.

What strategy did he pursue as the Comintern's man for Germany, and why did the 1923 German rising fail?

Back in Moscow, Radek became secretary of the Comintern (the Communist International) in 1920 and then, as a member of its Executive Committee, handled mainly German affairs. From 1919 to 1924 he sat on the Central Committee of the Russian Communist Party and was a leading writer for Pravda and Izvestia. During the Polish-Soviet War of 1920 he was co-opted to the Central Committee's Polish Bureau, sent to the Western Front, and took part in the peace talks with Poland.

On Germany he stood for a comparatively realistic line. He backed the KPD in opposing an invitation to the Communist Workers' Party of Germany, an ultra-left split that rejected parliamentary work, to the Comintern's Second Congress, which brought him into conflict with the Executive and cost him the secretaryship. He also took up the Stuttgart communists' slogan of a united front with other workers' organisations, which later became the basis of the Comintern's united front strategy: with the revolutionary tide receding, communists were to win the masses through joint action with Social Democratic workers. In 1922 he sent the Dutch communist Henk Sneevliet to China to advocate what later became the First United Front.

When France occupied the Ruhr in 1923 over unpaid reparations, German nationalist feeling boiled over. In June that year, at an open session of the Comintern Executive, he gave the speech "Leo Schlageter: The Wanderer into the Void". Schlageter was a Freikorps officer executed for sabotage against French troops in the Ruhr. Under the guise of honouring him, Radek explained why young men like him were drawn to the far right by national grievance and appealed for that anger to be channelled not into chauvinism but towards the labour movement and the Communists. The "Schlageter line" was controversial at the time and has been criticised ever since as an instance of communists courting nationalism.

On 23 August 1923 he proposed to the Politburo that an armed rising be organised in Germany. Stalin was sceptical, but a preparatory committee was formed under Radek. That autumn, however, after a conference at Chemnitz, the KPD leadership judged the situation unfavourable and called off the rising at the last moment. Radek was not present but afterwards approved and defended the decision. Zinoviev made Radek and the KPD leader Brandler the scapegoats for the defeat; Radek was removed from the Comintern Executive at the Fifth Congress in 1924 and dropped from the party Central Committee the same year. He set down his experience and views of the period in books such as The German Revolution (1925) and The German November (1927).

Why did Trotsky's ally capitulate to Stalin, and what did it bring him?

From 1923 Radek belonged to the Left Opposition, the Trotsky-led opposition to bureaucratisation of the party and to the Stalin leadership. Early that year, shortly after Lenin's stroke, he wrote "Leon Trotsky: Organiser of Victory", hailing Trotsky as the architect of victory in the Civil War. In summer 1925 he became rector of the newly founded Sun Yat-sen University of the Toilers of China in Moscow. At this school for cadres of the Chinese revolution he collected information on China from students for the opposition and cautiously began to question the Comintern's China policy. As his lover, the writer Larisa Reisner, was dying in 1926, he threw off his inhibitions and publicly criticised Stalin's doctrine of "socialism in one country" at the Communist Academy. He was dismissed from the university in May 1927.

In 1927 he was expelled from the party for organising, with Zinoviev in Leningrad, an independent opposition demonstration on the tenth anniversary of the October Revolution. In early 1928, when opposition leaders were scattered to remote places, he was sent to Tobolsk and a few months later to Tomsk; the Russian-language account records a four-year exile imposed by the OGPU Special Board.

In exile he changed his mind. When Stalin broke in 1928-1929 with Bukharin and the "Right" and turned to forced industrialisation and the collectivisation of agriculture, Radek concluded that the left turn the opposition had demanded had come. On 10 July 1929, with Ivar Smilga and Yevgeni Preobrazhensky, he signed a capitulation to Stalin and declared his "ideological and organisational break with Trotskyism". Around this time Yakov Blumkin, who had brought a secret letter from the exiled Trotsky in Turkey, visited Radek and was then arrested and shot; suspicion that Radek had given him away made him especially despised among oppositionists.

Readmitted to the party in 1930, he was one of the few former oppositionists to receive a prominent post. He headed the Central Committee's International Information Bureau, lived in a flat in the Government House, wrote columns on foreign affairs for Izvestia and in 1932 published a series of articles titled "Hitler". At the First Congress of Soviet Writers in 1934 he gave the report on foreign literature, denouncing Proust and Joyce as exemplars of decadence. He also took part in drafting the 1936 Soviet Constitution. At the same time he favoured close relations with Germany, and there is testimony that in a 1934 conversation with a German figure he said there were "some fine lads" in the SA and SS.

He was also credited with inventing many of the jokes about Stalin. Boris Bazhanov, once Stalin's secretary, says he heard them from Radek himself: after Stalin removed Trotsky and Zinoviev from the Politburo, Radek asked him the difference between Stalin and Moses: "Moses led the Jews out of Egypt, and Stalin out of the Politburo." Contemporaries remembered him as intellectually brilliant but indifferent to moral principle and quick to change sides. That wit and that record of capitulation came to a tragic end when he was arrested again in 1936.

What did he confess at the Second Moscow Trial, and how did he die in prison?

Radek was expelled from the party again in 1936 and arrested on 16 September. After two and a half months of interrogation he became the central defendant at the January 1937 trial of the "Parallel Anti-Soviet Trotskyist Centre", the Second Moscow Trial. He gave the prosecution the detailed accounts it wanted of the "conspiratorial activity" of himself and the other defendants, and he denied that torture had been used during the investigation.

The German writer Lion Feuchtwanger, who attended, wrote that the defendants did not look exhausted; they wore good suits and were calm. To him Radek seemed "a little posing, slightly mocking the other defendants, showing an actor's superiority: haughty, sceptical, nimble, literarily educated". Radek pushed Pyatakov away from the microphone and took his place, struck the rail with a newspaper, and sipped tea with a slice of lemon in it while recounting "monstrous deeds". The theatricality of the courtroom only deepened suspicion that the confessions were a performance of a script, not the truth.

On 30 January 1937, contrary to everyone's expectations, he was sentenced not to death but to ten years. Many interpret the lenient sentence as a bid to obtain further testimony against Bukharin and others for the coming Third Trial; he was indeed confronted with Bukharin. After the trial he was sent to the Verkhneuralsk political isolator in the Urals.

He died there on 19 May 1939. The prison's official report stated that he had been beaten and strangled by "the Trotskyist prisoner Varezhnikov". But in the 1956-1961 investigation by the Central Committee of the CPSU and the KGB, former NKVD officers testified that the murder, like that of Sokolnikov two days later, was organised under the NKVD secret political department's operative Pyotr Kubatkin, who carried out the direct orders of Beria and Kobulov, who in turn acted on Stalin's instruction. When the first prisoner brought in picked a fight but failed to kill Radek, another man was brought in a few days later under the name "Varezhnikov"; he was in fact I. I. Stepanov, a former NKVD commandant of the Chechen-Ingush Autonomous Republic. Stepanov was freed that November, and Kubatkin was promoted to head of the NKVD of Moscow Region.

His family suffered too. His wife Roza was exiled to Astrakhan in 1938, rearrested and died in the Potma camps; his daughter Sofia passed through exile and camps and only returned to Moscow in 1961. His son-in-law Viktor Sidorov was shot in 1938. Radek was posthumously rehabilitated and restored to party membership in 1988, under Gorbachev.