Agreed Framework (1994)
제네바 기본합의 (1994)
The nuclear agreement signed in Geneva on 21 October 1994 by Robert Gallucci for the United States and Kang Sok-ju for the Democratic People's Republic of Korea. The DPRK would freeze and later dismantle its graphite-moderated reactors and related facilities at Yongbyon; the United States would organise an international consortium to provide light-water reactors of about 2,000 MW(e) by 2003 and meanwhile supply 500,000 tons of heavy oil a year. It ended the first nuclear crisis but collapsed in 2002 over suspicions of uranium enrichment.
Primary text
Geneva, October 21, 1994
Delegations of the Governments of the United States of America (U.S.) and the Democratic People's Republic of Korea (DPRK) held talks in Geneva from September 23 to October 21, 1994, to negotiate an overall resolution of the nuclear issue on the Korean Peninsula.
Both sides reaffirmed the importance of attaining the objectives contained in the August 12, 1994 agreed statement between the U.S. and the DPRK and upholding the principles of the June 11, 1993 joint statement of the U.S. and the DPRK to achieve peace and security on a nuclear-free Korean Peninsula. The U.S. and DPRK decided to take the following actions for the resolution of the nuclear issue:
I. Both sides will cooperate to replace the DPRK's graphite-moderated reactors and related facilities with light-water reactor (LWR) power plants.
1) In accordance with the October 20, 1994 letter of assurance from the U.S. President, the U.S. will undertake to make arrangements for the provision to the DPRK of a LWR project with a total generating capacity of approximately 2,000 MW(E) by a target date of 2003.
- The U.S. will organize under its leadership an international consortium to finance and supply the LWR project to be provided to the DPRK. The U.S., representing the international consortium, will serve as the principal point of contact with the DPRK for the LWR project.
- The U.S., representing the consortium, will make best efforts to secure the conclusion of a supply contract with the DPRK within six months of the date of this document for the provision of the LWR project. Contract talks will begin as soon as possible after the date of this document.
- As necessary, the U.S. and the DPRK will conclude a bilateral agreement for cooperation in the field of peaceful uses of nuclear energy.
2) In accordance with the October 20, 1994 letter of assurance from the U.S. President, the U.S., representing the consortium, will make arrangements to offset the energy foregone due to the freeze of the DPRK's graphite-moderated reactors and related facilities, pending completion of the first LWR unit.
- Alternative energy will be provided in the form of heavy oil for heating and electricity production.
- Deliveries of heavy oil will begin within three months of the date of this document and will reach a rate of 500,000 tons annually, in accordance with an agreed schedule of deliveries.
3) Upon receipt of U.S. assurances for the provision of LWR's and for arrangements for interim energy alternatives, the DPRK will freeze its graphite-moderated reactors and related facilities and will eventually dismantle these reactors and related facilities.
- The freeze on the DPRK's graphite-moderated reactors and related facilities will be fully implemented within one month of the date of this document. During this one-month period, and throughout the freeze, the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) will be allowed to monitor this freeze, and the DPRK will provide full cooperation to the IAEA for this purpose.
- Dismantlement of the DPRK's graphite-moderated reactors and related facilities will be completed when the LWR project is completed.
- The U.S. and DPRK will cooperate in finding a method to store safely the spent fuel from the 5 MW(E) experimental reactor during the construction of the LWR project, and to dispose of the fuel in a safe manner that does not involve reprocessing in the DPRK.
4) As soon as possible after the date of this document, U.S. and DPRK experts will hold two sets of experts talks.
- At one set of talks, experts will discuss issues related to alternative energy and the replacement of the graphite-moderated reactor program with the LWR project.
- At the other set of talks, experts will discuss specific arrangements for spent fuel storage and ultimate disposition.
II. The two sides will move toward full normalization of political and economic relations.
1) Within three months of the date of this document, both sides will reduce barriers to trade and investment, including restrictions on telecommunications services and financial transactions.
2) Each side will open a liaison office in the other's capital following resolution of consular and other technical issues through expert level discussions.
3) As progress is made on issues of concern to each side, the U.S. and DPRK will upgrade bilateral relations to the ambassadorial level.
III. Both sides will work together for peace and security on a nuclear-free Korean Peninsula.
1) The U.S. will provide formal assurances to the DPRK, against the threat or use of nuclear weapons by the U.S.
2) The DPRK will consistently take steps to implement the North-South Joint Declaration on the Denuclearization of the Korean Peninsula.
3) The DPRK will engage in North-South dialogue, as this agreed framework will help create an atmosphere that promotes such dialogue.
IV. Both sides will work together to strengthen the international nuclear non-proliferation regime.
1) The DPRK will remain a party to the Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons (NPT) and will allow implementation of its Safeguards Agreement under the Treaty.
2) Upon conclusion of the supply contract for the provision of the LWR project, ad hoc and routine inspections will resume under the DPRK's Safeguards Agreement with the IAEA with respect to the facilities not subject to the freeze. Pending conclusion of the supply contract, inspections required by the IAEA for the continuity of safeguards will continue at the facilities not subject to the freeze.
3) When a significant portion of the LWR project is completed, but before delivery of key nuclear components, the DPRK will come into full compliance with its Safeguards Agreement with the IAEA (INFCIRC/403), including taking all steps that may be deemed necessary by the IAEA, following consultations with the Agency with regard to verifying the accuracy and completeness of the DPRK's initial report on all nuclear material in the DPRK.
Kang Sok Ju
Head of the Delegation of the Democratic People's Republic of Korea, First Vice-Minister of Foreign Affairs of the Democratic People's Republic of Korea
Robert L. Gallucci
Head of the Delegation of United States of America, Ambassador at Large of the United States of America
In depth
Background
The Democratic People's Republic of Korea joined the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty in 1985 but concluded its safeguards agreement with the International Atomic Energy Agency only in January 1992. When declarations and inspection findings diverged and the IAEA demanded a special inspection, the DPRK announced on 12 March 1993 that it would leave the NPT. A US–DPRK joint statement of 11 June suspended the withdrawal, but in spring 1994, after the DPRK unloaded the fuel rods of its 5 MW reactor without IAEA monitoring, the United States weighed strikes on Yongbyon. Jimmy Carter's visit to Pyongyang in June, where Kim Il Sung agreed to a freeze, opened the way to negotiation; after Kim's death in July, an agreed statement of 12 August was followed by talks in Geneva from 23 September to 17 October.
Content
The agreement has four parts. First, the DPRK's graphite-moderated reactors are to be replaced with light-water reactor power plants. Under the President's letter of assurance of 20 October 1994, the United States will lead an international consortium to provide light-water reactors of about 2,000 MW(e) by a target date of 2003, and until the first is complete will supply heavy oil for heating and electricity at up to 500,000 tons a year. The text states the DPRK's obligation thus:
3) Upon receipt of U.S. assurances for the provision of LWR’s and for arrangements for interim energy alternatives, the DPRK will freeze its graphite-moderated reactors and related facilities and will eventually dismantle these reactors and related facilities.
The freeze is to be completed within a month of signature under IAEA monitoring, and the spent fuel of the 5 MW experimental reactor is not to be reprocessed in the DPRK. Second, the two countries will ease restrictions on trade and investment, open liaison offices in each other's capitals and move toward relations at ambassadorial level. Third, the United States will give formal assurances against the threat or use of nuclear weapons, and the DPRK will implement the Joint Declaration on the Denuclearisation of the Korean Peninsula and engage in North–South dialogue. Fourth, the DPRK will remain a party to the NPT and, when a significant portion of the reactor project is complete but before delivery of key nuclear components, come into full compliance with its IAEA safeguards agreement.
Implementation
In March 1995 the United States, South Korea and Japan founded the Korean Peninsula Energy Development Organization (KEDO), with South Korea and Japan bearing most of the reactor cost. The agreement froze the 5 MW reactor and reprocessing plant at Yongbyon and the 50 MW and 200 MW reactors under construction, halting plutonium production. But the Republican Party, which took control of Congress in the 1994 election, opposed the agreement, and funding for the heavy oil was often late or short. The 1998 Taepodong launch and the Kumchang-ri suspicions strained relations, and construction of the first reactor began only in August 2002.
The reactor project and who bore what
KEDO was founded on 15 March 1995 by the United States, South Korea and Japan, and was later joined by Australia, Canada and New Zealand (1995), Argentina, Chile and Indonesia (1996), the European Union and Poland (1997) and others. The reactor site was at Kumho, north of Sinpo in South Hamgyong, where the Soviet Union had promised reactors in the 1980s. Ground was broken on 19 August 1997, but financing was hard to arrange, formal invitations to bid were issued only in 1998, significant spending began in 2000, and the first concrete was poured on 7 August 2002. Some Republican senators regarded the agreement as appeasement, and KEDO's first director, Stephen Bosworth, recalled that it was "a political orphan within two weeks after its signature." Since the reactors were to be of South Korean design, the project was also seen as an opening for inter-Korean economic cooperation.
Collapse
In October 2002 the United States announced that the DPRK had admitted to a highly enriched uranium programme. When KEDO stopped oil shipments in November, Pyongyang announced in December that it would restart the frozen facilities, expelled the IAEA inspectors and on 10 January 2003 again announced its withdrawal from the NPT, arguing that its 1993 notice, suspended one day before taking effect, already satisfied the three-month requirement. KEDO suspended reactor construction in November 2003, with the project about 30 percent complete, and announced its termination in January 2006. Supporters of the agreement hold that without it the DPRK would have built many more weapons by 2003; opponents that Pyongyang cheated from the start.