Anti-Imperialist, Anti-Monopoly
반제·반독점
A line formulated in the South Korean progressive movement of the 1980s that posed the national contradiction (imperialist subordination, above all to the United States) and the class contradiction (monopoly capital and the chaebol) as contradictions to be resolved together. Its full name is the Anti-Imperialist, Anti-Monopoly People's Democratic (Revolution), used as the program and factional shorthand of the anti-monopoly PD current (the neo-colonial state monopoly capitalism thesis) within the People's Democracy (PD) faction. The rival anti-fascist PD current used 'anti-imperialist, anti-fascist people's democracy', while the National Liberation (NL) faction used its own separate name, the National Liberation People's Democratic Revolution (NLPDR). Broadly, "NLPDR" also names the parent current of NL and the anti-monopoly PD, which in that sense is one of its branches.
In depth
Name and factional distinctions
The Anti-Imperialist, Anti-Monopoly People's Democratic (Revolution) was the program and shorthand of the anti-monopoly PD current within the People's Democracy (PD) faction. Within the same PD faction, the anti-fascist current used 'anti-imperialist, anti-fascist people's democracy', while the National Liberation (NL) faction used its own separate name, the National Liberation People's Democratic Revolution (NLPDR). The People's Democratic Revolution thesis (PDR) split into the anti-monopoly PD and the anti-fascist PD; the former took the working class as its main force and the urban poor and poor peasants as allies, seeking to overthrow imperialism, monopoly capital and the existing government at once, establish a people's democratic republic and then socialize by a 'continuous one-stage, two-process' course.
Sources draw the roots of the two branches differently. The Korean Wikipedia article on the student movement divides the lineage of the 1980s student movement by three social formation debates: in the first (1984-1985, the C-N-P debate) the National Democratic Revolution (NDR) line became the majority; the second (1986-1987) was fought between the two factions within NDR, the NLPDR line and the constituent assembly (CA) line; and the third (1988-1990) between the two factions within NLPDR, NL and the anti-monopoly PD. In this lineage "NLPDR" names not only NL's revolutionary theory but the parent faction that held both NL and the anti-monopoly PD, of which the anti-monopoly PD was one branch. The anti-fascist PD, by contrast, was a minority current inside the CPA/CA lineage that stressed the class contradiction, upheld the 'neo-colonial fascist system thesis' and strongly opposed the Democratic People's Republic of Korea. The Encyclopedia of Korean Culture, speaking of the PD faction as a whole, writes that the group existing from 1984 had mostly worked as a subgroup of the NDR faction before rising to prominence, and that in the factional genealogy it was formed by those left over when the faction demanding a constituent assembly or a People's Constituent Congress split and part of it was absorbed into NL. 'People's Democracy' commonly refers to the anti-monopoly PD.
Formation and theory
The group that analyzed South Korea as a neo-colonial state monopoly capitalist society and advocated people's democratic revolution as the immediate revolution existed from 1984, but the name 'People's Democracy faction' first appeared in the movement from early 1988. The theoretical core of the anti-monopoly PD current was the neo-colonial state monopoly capitalism thesis, which defined South Korea as a 'neo-colonial society' unlike the Japanese colonial period. The thesis's germ is found in the C.N.P (civic democratic transformation-national democratic transformation-people's democratic transformation) debate inside the Korean Youth League for Democracy in the 1980s, and Park Hyun-chae's paper in the 1985 issue 57 of Changjak kwa Bipyeong is assessed as the starting point of the state monopoly capitalism thesis. The neo-colonial thesis did not simply continue Park's argument, however; it was refined in criticism of his state monopoly capitalism thesis, as in Lee Jin-kyung's Social Formation Theory and Social Science Methodology (1987). A neo-colonial society was seen as producing capitalist development grounded in 'deepened subordination' and reaching the monopoly capitalist stage already in the 1980s, while the national contradiction still remained.
The NLPDR lineage's revolutionary theory defined South Korea as a 'colonial fascist system of US imperialism', treated the constitutional amendment struggle as part of the anti-fascist struggle, was presented and established as the transformation theory of the student and social movements from late 1985 through the first half of 1986, became the mainstream of the 1986 student movement, and led the amendment struggle in the first half of 1987 by advocating a direct presidential election. Its intellectual summation drew on colonial and semi-colonial revolutionary experience going back to the 1940s: Eastern Europe's 'people's democratic revolution', North Korea's 'anti-imperialist anti-feudal democratic revolution' and China's 'new democratic revolution'.
According to the Encyclopedia of Korean Culture, the People's Democracy faction was made up, in the student movement, of those students who in the mid-1980s had joined the Anti-Imperialist, Anti-Fascist National Democratic Struggle Committee (Minminthu) and demanded a constituent assembly (CA), those who separately demanded a People's Constituent Congress (CPC), and the young activists and graduates and expelled students working in factories who shared their line, insofar as they held to the orthodox Marxist-Leninist line to the end. In this account the People's Democracy faction branched off from the constituent assembly (CA) current.
Divergence of the two camps
The NL-PD split proceeded as disillusionment with the US attitude to the Gwangju Uprising of May 18 brought a vogue for Marxist currents, a view of Korea as a US colony, and the social formation debate. PD challenged the domination and monopoly of large corporations from a class and labor movement standpoint, while NL argued in a left-nationalist vein for resistance to US imperialism. The People's Democracy side analyzed South Korea as a state economically and militarily subordinated to the United States but politically enjoying considerable autonomy, one in which the direct agent of repression against the people was the South Korean government rather than the United States, and whose capitalist economy had developed to a high level in the form of state monopoly capitalism. This contrasts with the colonial semi-feudal thesis, which viewed South Korea as a colonial semi-feudal society, and formed one axis of the social formation debate.
In the third social formation debate (1988-1990) the anti-monopoly PD was the minority against NL, and the Seoul Institute of Social Sciences was its organization at the time. The anti-monopoly PD theory belonged to NLPDR in the broader sense, but it also had some influence on activists of currents outside it.
Debate and assessment
Some scholarly accounts assess that in this revolutionary theory anti-imperialism was presented as the solution to the national contradiction wrought by US and Japanese imperialism, anti-monopoly as the solution to the class contradiction aimed at transforming the chaebol's exploitative economic structure, and its core as ending the military-fascist system and restoring genuine democracy. This, however, is an interpretive assessment by the labor-movement commentator Yun Hyo-won rather than neutral factual description.
Lineage and present
The PD current thought from the standpoint of class struggle centered on the labor movement and held that the working class must hold the leadership of a South Korean revolution, which put it at odds with the national liberation camp. It later formed the majority of the Korean Socialist Party and part of the Democratic Labor Party; the equality faction of the anti-fascist PD current in the Democratic Labor Party left in 2008 to found the New Progressive Party, which was dissolved in 2012, and its members split between the Justice Party, social-democratic in orientation, and the Labor Party, which retained the anti-fascist PD character. This lineage concerns PD as a whole and the anti-fascist PD, not the anti-monopoly PD.
After the collapse of the Soviet Union the anti-monopoly PD theory formed part of the Institute for Labor and Social Sciences, the Progressive Party and the People's Democracy Party. From the late 1990s the vocabulary of the social formation debate fell out of use, yet the line continued to be upheld by a minority of left-wing parties and organizations and its tasks are described as ongoing, so no closing year can be fixed.
Related terms
Sources
- Wikipedia (KO) NL faction article documents 반제반파쇼, 반미 자주화 as NL's core line and the NL-PD distinction
- Wikipedia (EN) Documents PD/NL factional divide; PD prioritized working class and anti-monopoly struggle; NL foregrounded anti-imperialist national liberation
- labortoday.co.kr Detailed exposition of 반제반독점민중민주주의혁명: 반제 addresses national contradiction (US imperialism), 반독점 addresses class contradiction (chaebol monopoly), 민중민주주의 is the post-revolutionary political form
- Wikipedia (KO)
- Wikipedia (KO)
- konas.net
- Wikipedia (KO)
- encykorea.aks.ac.kr
- laborsbook.org
- Wikipedia (EN)
- labortoday.co.kr
- Wikipedia (KO)
- weekly.khan.co.kr