Debate on the Nature of Chinese Society
중국 사회성질 논전
The controversy of 1928 to 1937 in which Chinese intellectuals argued over what kind of society China then was and therefore what kind of revolution it needed. The name covers three linked debates: on the nature of Chinese society, on Chinese social history, and on the nature of rural society. The Communist side held that China was a semi-colonial, semi-feudal society calling for a democratic revolution against imperialism and feudal forces; Trotskyists and writers close to the Kuomintang answered that capitalism already prevailed or that feudalism had ended long before. It established Marxist historiography in China, and Mao Zedong's essay of 1939 summed up the Communist conclusion.
In depth
The controversy grew out of the defeat of 1927. Once the first united front had broken and the revolution had collapsed, the left had to decide why it had lost and whom the next revolution should strike, and the answer depended on how Chinese society was defined. Within the Comintern leadership Stalin and Bukharin held that feudal forces still prevailed in China, so that the task was a democratic revolution against feudalism and imperialism; Trotsky and Radek held that China was already led by capitalism, so that the overthrow of capitalism belonged among the aims. On 9 July 1928 the Sixth National Congress of the Chinese Communist Party, meeting near Moscow, resolved that China was a semi-colonial, semi-feudal society and that its revolution was a bourgeois-democratic one. Chen Duxiu and the other Trotskyists in the party objected at once. The party's resolution of 1945 later summed up their view as holding that China after 1927 was "a society in which capitalism predominates and will develop peacefully".
Three groups took part. The Communist cadres of the New Thought group (Wang Xuewen, Pan Dongzhou, Zhang Wentian writing as Liu Mengyun, He Ganzhi and others) wrote in the journal Xin sichao; the Trotskyist Dongli group (Yan Lingfeng, Ren Shu) in Dongli; and the Kuomintang Reorganisation faction's New Life group (Tao Xisheng, Zhou Fohai and others) in Xin shengming. The starting point is usually put at Tao Xisheng's article of October 1928, "What Kind of Society Is Chinese Society After All?"
In the 1930s the argument widened from the present to the whole of Chinese history. In his Studies in Ancient Chinese Society (1930) Guo Moruo argued that China too had passed through a slave society, and he treated the centuries from Qin and Han to Qing as feudal. His opponents, borrowing from Radek and Bogdanov, called China after Qin and Han not feudal but a "commercial capitalist" or "pre-capitalist" society. The debate peaked in 1932 and 1933, when the Dushu zazhi edited by Wang Lixi published four special issues on the "Chinese social history controversy". Three questions were at stake: what the Asiatic mode of production was, whether China had known a slave society, and what marked Chinese feudalism and the society that followed Qin and Han.
From 1935 the countryside became the issue. The "Chinese Economy" group around Wang Yichang faced the "Chinese Countryside" group of Qian Junrui, Xue Muqiao and Sun Yefang, who argued that feudal relations of production still made up the main part of rural life and that imperialist penetration had not changed them. The outbreak of full-scale war with Japan in 1937 brought the debate to a close, and in that year He Ganzhi published the first book to survey it.
The Communist conclusion was set down in The Chinese Revolution and the Chinese Communist Party, which Mao Zedong wrote with party theorists in 1939.
After the Opium War of 1840 China gradually changed into a semi-colonial and semi-feudal society. Since the Incident of September 18 1931, when the Japanese imperialists started their armed aggression, China has changed further into a colonial, semi-colonial and semi-feudal society.
That definition became the ground of the theory of New Democratic revolution. Who won as scholarship is less clear. The historian Arif Dirlik judged that it is hard to name a winner and that the revolutionary strategy which finally triumphed was not backed by the most satisfying historical analysis. Chinese scholars also disagree over whether this was a debate inside Marxist historiography at all.
The controversy was not China's alone. Its frame came from the factional struggle in Moscow, and in the Soviet Union the China specialists who thought old Chinese landholding had resembled the Asiatic mode of production were accused of Trotskyism, after which discussion of the concept was in effect banned from 1931. Guo Moruo, wanted by the Nationalist government, crossed to Japan in February 1928 and wrote his book in exile there while studying oracle-bone and bronze inscriptions. Japan had its own debate on Japanese capitalism in the same years, in which the Kōza faction stressed a semi-feudal absolutist emperor system and argued for a two-stage revolution while the Rōnō faction treated the Meiji Restoration as a bourgeois revolution. The structure was the same, a definition of society standing for a strategy of revolution, and in Japan it was tied to the Comintern's 1927 and 1932 Theses. In Korea Paek Nam-un published his Socio-Economic History of Korea in 1933 and his Feudal Socio-Economic History of Korea in 1937, arguing on historical-materialist lines that Korean history too had its slave and feudal stages and rejecting the colonial historians' thesis of stagnation. Whether Asian societies had passed through the universal stages of world history was a question Marxists of all three countries worked on together.