27年テーゼ · 1927

1927 Theses (Japan)

27년 테제

The common name of the Comintern's "Theses on the Japanese Question" of 1927. It criticised both Hitoshi Yamakawa's change-of-direction thesis (Yamakawaism) and Kazuo Fukumoto's separation-and-unity line (Fukumotoism), saw the Japanese state, feudal relics and all, as the concentrated expression of Japanese capitalism, and set as the immediate goal a bourgeois revolution led by the proletariat and peasantry, with the abolition of the monarchy among its tasks. By accepting it the Japanese Communist Party abandoned Fukumotoism.

In depth

Why was it issued?

The Japanese Communist Party, founded in 1922, dissolved itself in 1924 and was rebuilt in December 1926 (the "second" party). Inside the rebuilt party the theory of Kazuo Fukumoto (Fukumotoism) had overwhelming support. Fukumoto treated the emperor as an absolute monarch and argued for a radical two-stage revolution, and he was fiercely attacking the line of Hitoshi Yamakawa (Yamakawaism), who had earlier led the move to dissolve the party.

In February 1927 the new leaders of the rebuilt party, Kyūichi Tokuda and Kazuo Fukumoto among them, visited Moscow and were told that the party's line was fundamentally mistaken. The Comintern under Nikolai Bukharin rejected Fukumoto's position outright and removed him and Tokuda from the central committee. A new Comintern line was then laid down for a leadership without the two men: the 1927 Theses. Masanosuke Watanabe, sent to the Soviet Union, took part in drafting them.

What did it say?

The theses had four main points.

  • The Japanese state keeps its feudal attributes and relics, but the bourgeoisie already holds power and the state is the most concentrated expression of Japanese capitalism.
  • The monarchy is to be abolished. The term "emperor system" (tennōsei) appears not here but in the 1932 Theses.
  • The immediate revolution is a bourgeois-democratic one, and it will grow very rapidly into a socialist revolution.
  • The hegemony in that revolution, however, belongs to the proletariat and the peasantry.

The theses rejected two lines at once: Yamakawa's as "dissolutionism", an attempt to do away with the party, and Fukumoto's as "sectarianism" that cut the party off from the masses. From this point the two-stage theory, under which Japan had first to complete a bourgeois-democratic revolution before it could move on to a socialist one, was the party's strategy.

How did the Japanese movement split?

By accepting the theses the Japanese Communist Party gave up the independence that Fukumotoism had sustained, and Fukumoto dropped out of the party mainstream for good. Yamakawa and his associates refused the analysis. In December 1927 they launched the journal Rōnō (Labour-Farmer), from which the Rōnō-ha took its name; in February 1928 the party resolved to expel Yamakawa and Kanson Arahata. This quarrel between the party and the Rōnō-ha over the character of the Japanese revolution is the starting point of the debate on Japanese capitalism in its broad sense.

The theses also opened a crack inside the party. Shigeo Mizuno, arrested in the March 15 incident of 1928, argued from prison that the slogan of abolishing the monarchy should be withdrawn and ties with the Comintern cut; behind this, it is said, lay the way the Fukumotoism he and his comrades believed in had been dismissed out of hand by the 1927 Theses and the Fukumoto leaders swept away. The thinking of this "dissolutionist faction" was carried on in the tenkō statement of Manabu Sano and Sadachika Nabeyama in 1933.

In 1931 a "Draft Political Theses" written by Georgy Safarov and others of the Comintern's Far Eastern Bureau redefined the coming revolution as a proletarian one, but it was discarded when Safarov fell. What replaced it was the 1932 Theses, which went back to the two-stage theory of 1927.

How was it tied to Korea, Taiwan and China?

Late in the year the theses appeared, the Comintern instructed the Japanese communists to draft political and organisational charters for a "Japanese Communist Party, Taiwanese National Branch". On that basis the Taiwanese Communist Party was formed in the French Concession of Shanghai on 15 April 1928. Seven Taiwanese, among them Xie Xuehong and Lin Mu-shun, attended the founding meeting together with a representative of the Chinese Communist Party and the Korean communist Lyuh Woon-hyung. The programme, drafted by the Japanese party and approved by the Chinese party, called for "the independence of the Taiwanese nation" and "the building of a Republic of Taiwan". The party in the metropole was thus given the abolition of the monarchy as its task, and its branch in the colony was given independence.

Under the Comintern's rule of "one country, one party" the Taiwanese party was to be led by the Japanese Communist Party, but the March 15 incident destroyed the Japanese leadership right after the founding and that guidance never came. Masanosuke Watanabe, who had helped draft the theses, became chairman of the party's central committee in March 1928; that autumn he crossed to Shanghai, and on 6 October he landed at Keelung on his way home through Taiwan and died there.

Related people

Related historical events

Sources

  1. ja.wikipedia.org
  2. ja.wikipedia.org
  3. Wikipedia (EN)
  4. ja.wikipedia.org
  5. ja.wikipedia.org
  6. ja.wikipedia.org
  7. ja.wikipedia.org
  8. Wikipedia (EN)
  9. ja.wikipedia.org
  10. zh.wikipedia.org
  11. Marxists Internet Archive