福本イズム · 1924–1927

Fukumotoism

후쿠모토주의

The Marxist theory and organisational doctrine put forward by Kazuo Fukumoto when the Japanese Communist Party was being rebuilt in the mid-1920s. It argued for "separation before unity": true Marxists had first to be separated out through theoretical struggle before they could be united in a vanguard party. Attacking Hitoshi Yamakawa's line as eclecticism and trade-unionism, it became the dominant theory of the party re-established in 1926, but it was criticised in the Comintern's 1927 Theses and lost its influence.

In depth

Where did it come from?

Kazuo Fukumoto graduated from the law faculty of Tokyo Imperial University in 1920, became a higher-school teacher, and from 1922 spent two and a half years in Britain, Germany and France as an overseas researcher of the Ministry of Education. In Germany he studied Marxism at the Institute for Social Research of the University of Frankfurt under the Hungarian philosopher György Lukács and the German thinker Karl Korsch. Most Japanese communists of the day read and argued about Marx in translation; he is said to have read the originals.

When he came home in September 1924 the Japanese Communist Party had dissolved itself under repression, and a bureau of those who remained was publishing a legal theoretical journal, Marxism (Marukusu-shugi). Writing there under the pen name Kazuo Hōjō, Fukumoto criticised the earlier students of Capital, Tokuzō Fukuda, Hajime Kawakami and Motoyuki Takabatake, and was noticed at once. In 1925 he joined the bureau for rebuilding the party that Manabu Sano had formed.

What did it argue?

Its target was the "change of direction" thesis of Hitoshi Yamakawa (Yamakawaism), then a great influence on the movement. In the February and May 1926 issues of Marxism Fukumoto published "We must begin by changing Mr Yamakawa's theory of the change of direction". He attacked Yamakawa's line as eclecticism and trade-unionism that failed to distinguish the economic movement from the political one. To raise the movement to political struggle, he said, a sharply defined vanguard party was needed that would wage theoretical struggle and bring Marxist consciousness to the workers from outside.

The organisational doctrine that followed was "separation before unity". True Marxists were first to be separated from false ones, and the true ones were to concentrate on theoretical struggle. It was a call for a small, ideologically pure vanguard party keeping a strict separation from other progressive movements, and so it stood against Yamakawa's more pragmatic, mass-based approach. On the Japanese state, Fukumoto treated the emperor as an absolute monarch and argued for a radical two-stage revolution. In 1926 alone he published The Structure of Society and the Process of Its Change, Historical Materialism and the Centrist View of History, The Method of the Critique of Political Economy, and Theoretical Struggle.

Why did it spread so widely?

His prose, full of abstract and difficult turns such as "to process the process", quickly won a following among students and intellectuals. When the party was rebuilt at its third congress, held in secret at Goshiki hot spring in December 1926 (the "second" party), Fukumoto joined, became a standing committee member and head of the political department, and his theory, now called Fukumotoism, gained overwhelming influence among party members and the activists around the party. Yamakawa's side had at first cooperated with Marxism, but as the attacks sharpened it replied openly and broke with the journal.

How did it end?

When Fukumoto, Kyūichi Tokuda and the other new leaders went to Moscow in February 1927, the Comintern under Nikolai Bukharin rejected Fukumoto's position outright and removed the two men from the central committee. The 1927 Theses of that year criticised Yamakawa's line as "dissolutionism" and Fukumoto's as "sectarianism" together; the Comintern's view was that an excessive focus on theory was isolating the party from other left-wing groups. By accepting the theses the Japanese Communist Party abandoned Fukumotoism, and Fukumoto lost his influence in the party. Arrested in June 1928 in connection with the March 15 incident, he spent fourteen years in prison, until 1942.

The traces lasted. Fukumoto's influence is judged to have remained strong in the party afterwards. Most of the "dissolutionist faction" around Shigeo Mizuno, who argued from prison in 1929 that the slogan of abolishing the monarchy should be dropped, had been shaped by Fukumotoism, and the way the theory they believed in was dismissed out of hand by the 1927 Theses is said to lie behind their move. English-language accounts find Fukumoto's main contribution in strengthening the theoretical foundation of the party and the revolution.

How did it touch the Korean movement?

In 1925 and 1926, the years when Fukumotoism swept the Japanese left, a Korean socialist group, the Irwolhoe (January Society), was active in Tokyo. Founded in January 1925 by An Gwang-cheon, Yi Yeo-seong, Ha Pil-won and others, it wrote into its programme that it would "set out rigorous theory and offer it to the people's movement". In June 1926 it founded the newspaper Daejung Sinmun to wage theoretical struggle, and it held social-science classes together with Japanese socialists. An Gwang-cheon returned to Korea in the summer of 1926, joined the Communist Party of Korea in September, and on 15 November drafted the Jeongwuhoe Declaration, which called for a change of direction from economic to political struggle and for a national united front. The Irwolhoe members merged with the Leninist League and others to form the ML faction, which became the main force of the third Communist Party of Korea. "Theoretical struggle" and "change of direction" were the very words over which Fukumoto and Yamakawa were then fighting in Japan.

In proletarian literature too, the Korea Artista Proleta Federacio (KAPF) raised its own "change of direction" in 1927, from spontaneous to purpose-conscious literature, and the Third Front group in Tokyo pushed it closer to political struggle.

Related people

Related historical events

Sources

  1. ja.wikipedia.org
  2. ja.wikipedia.org
  3. ja.wikipedia.org
  4. Wikipedia (EN)
  5. Wikipedia (EN)
  6. ja.wikipedia.org
  7. encykorea.aks.ac.kr
  8. encykorea.aks.ac.kr
  9. encykorea.aks.ac.kr
  10. encykorea.aks.ac.kr
  11. encykorea.aks.ac.kr