György Lukács

Lukács György
Party of Communists in Hungary (KMP) Western Marxism Hungary Hungary 1885.4.13.–1971.6.4. ○ Lung cancer

Founder of Western Marxism: the Hungarian thinker who reoriented 20th-century Marxist philosophy with History and Class Consciousness

“Now, after the collapse of actually existing socialism, his questions look like the only surviving form of Marxism.” — from a late-life interview

Hungarian Marxist philosopher who founded Western Marxism with History and Class Consciousness (1923), establishing the concepts of reification and class consciousness. Served as commissar/minister of culture in the 1919 Hungarian Soviet Republic and the 1956 Imre Nagy government.

Also known as: Georg Bernard Lukács von Szegedin · Bernát György Löwinger

Activities and affiliations

Career Timeline

Related historical events

Reification and Class Consciousness — History and Class Consciousness (1923)

Lukács's major work History and Class Consciousness, a collection of eight essays published in German in 1923, is widely regarded as the founding text of Western Marxism. Expanding Marx's concept of commodity fetishism, Lukács formulated 'reification' (Verdinglichung) as the universal structure of capitalist society: human social relations appear as relations between things, and the products of labor confront their creators as an autonomous 'second nature' governed by its own laws. He argued that reification penetrates far beyond the economic sphere: into law, administration, philosophy, and even the consciousness of the proletariat itself.

Against this, Lukács advanced the method of 'class consciousness' and 'totality.' The proletariat occupies a unique dual position in capitalist society as both subject and object; the moment it grasps its own situation, it can apprehend the truth of the whole. Totality, for Lukács, is not the empirical sum of isolated facts but a dialectical method that mediates between part and whole. He famously declared: 'Orthodox Marxism does not imply uncritical acceptance of Marx's results. It refers exclusively to method.'

The book drew fierce condemnation from the Comintern as 'revisionist,' and Lukács himself later repudiated it publicly. Yet its influence proved immense, shaping the Frankfurt School, Guy Debord's Situationism, and later thinkers from Lucien Goldmann to Slavoj Žižek. A defensive manuscript Lukács wrote in 1925–26, Tailism and the Dialectic, remained unpublished until 1996, revealing that his self-criticism was likely a strategic gesture rather than a genuine retraction.

Kafka or Thomas Mann: what did Lukács fight over after the Hungarian Revolution?

When the Hungarian Revolution broke out on 23 October 1956 and Imre Nagy became prime minister again, Lukács served for a few days as minister of popular education and was taken into the Central Committee of the Communist Party. After Soviet forces crushed the revolution he and his wife were deported to Snagov in Romania and held there, returning to Budapest only in April 1957; German sources give 10 April, Hungarian sources 11 April.

The manuscript whose preface he completed after his release and sent abroad appeared in 1958 with Claassen in Hamburg as Wider den mißverstandenen Realismus (The Meaning of Contemporary Realism). In this book, based on lectures given in Berlin, Warsaw, Budapest and Vienna in 1955, Lukács grouped modernist literature from Kafka to Beckett as "decadent avant-gardism": its writers, he argued, made the anxiety and loneliness of modern man into an unalterable "condition humaine" instead of linking them with the historical process of capitalist decline. Against it he set the "critical realism" of Thomas Mann, who placed the same darkness within the historical situation of the twentieth-century intellectual. The title of the middle chapter, "Franz Kafka or Thomas Mann?", was a choice put to writers.

The same book turned its edge on socialist literature as well: literature sunk in agitprop leads to "simplification, vulgarisation, illustration, happy ending, conflictlessness, revolutionary romanticism". Theodor W. Adorno noted the change in Lukács, who now spoke of the crimes of the Stalin era and supported freedom to write, yet rebutted his theory of realism in "Reconciliation under Duress" in Der Monat in 1958. In the preface to the new edition of The Theory of the Novel, written in July 1962, Lukács retorted that Adorno had taken up residence in the "Grand Hotel Abyss".

The British historian David Caute relates that Lukács, held at Snagov and treated one day as a visiting dignitary and the next as a criminal, remarked: "So Kafka was a realist after all!" The remark is not attested in Lukács's own writings. The book is treated under "The Meaning of Contemporary Realism", Adorno's reply under "Reconciliation under Duress", and the later dispute over Kafka under "Liblice Kafka Conference".

The Late Lukács on Knowledge: Reflection and the Ontology of Social Being

After History and Class Consciousness Lukács changed the starting point of his theory of knowledge. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy notes that his 1924 study of Lenin already came down on the side of Lenin's conception of the party as a vanguard, anticipating the more traditional Marxism he held for the rest of his life. In 1930 he worked at the Marx–Engels Institute in Moscow, where he read unpublished manuscripts of Marx. That story and the self-criticism of the 1967 preface are treated in the entry "History and Class Consciousness".

From the 1930s he laid the foundations of a Marxist aesthetics with the theory that literature reflects social relations by giving them form in their totality. In the 1960s, retired from all academic posts, he wrote a large two-volume aesthetics and the Ontology of Social Being, which grew out of a plan for a Marxist ethics and remained unfinished in his lifetime.

In the ontology he divided being into three levels: inorganic being, organic life and social reality. On every level things appear as fixed objects, but their essence is interrelated, irreversible processes. Social reality differs from the other two levels in containing "teleological positing". In labour people handle natural causal processes while positing in advance the goal they mean to reach, and so they can tell success from failure. Lukács held that values enter the world in this way, and he placed labour at the foundation of all social and normative phenomena. His remark in the 1967 preface that even primitive man picking up stones presupposes a correct reflection of reality belongs to the same scheme.

Judgements differ. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy considers the general ontology underdeveloped and little informed by contemporary philosophy, but finds his theory of social reality still relevant, and it notes that even his own students found the account too unclear to solve the problem of normativity for Marxism.