Geschichte und Klassenbewußtsein. Studien über marxistische Dialektik · 1923

History and Class Consciousness

역사와 계급의식

A collection of essays published in Berlin in 1923 by the Hungarian philosopher György Lukács. It located the core of Marxism not in particular conclusions but in a method that grasps society as a whole, and put forward the theory of reification, by which the commodity form hardens people's consciousness into something thing-like, and a theory of proletarian class consciousness. The Comintern and Soviet philosophers attacked the book as idealism and Lukács himself distanced himself from it from the 1930s, yet it is counted as the starting point of Western Marxism. In a new preface written in 1967 Lukács named the book's philosophical errors himself.

In depth

Can one drop all the conclusions and still be a Marxist?

Suppose someone reads Marx carefully and concludes that several of his economic predictions were wrong. Can that person still call himself a Marxist? History and Class Consciousness, published in 1923 by the Malik-Verlag in Berlin, answered this boldly in its first essay, "What is Orthodox Marxism?": one could discard every one of Marx's particular theses and still be orthodox. Lukács wrote: "Orthodoxy in questions of Marxism relates rather exclusively to method."

Orthodoxie in Fragen des Marxismus bezieht sich vielmehr ausschließlich auf die Methode.

Lukács put the book together in Viennese exile after serving in 1919 as deputy people's commissar for education in the Hungarian Soviet Republic. It contains eight essays: on orthodox Marxism, on Rosa Luxemburg as a Marxist, "Class Consciousness", the longest essay "Reification and the Consciousness of the Proletariat", the changing function of historical materialism, legality and illegality, remarks on Luxemburg's critique of the Russian Revolution, and the methodology of the problem of organisation. This entry concentrates on the question the book put to epistemology: how society and history can be known, and who knows them. Reification itself is treated in the entry "Reification", and the key concept of the theory of class consciousness in "Imputed consciousness".

What is the method, and why "totality"?

At the centre of the method stood totality. "The category of totality, the all-round, determining domination of the whole over the parts, is the essence of the method," Lukács wrote, a method Marx took over from Hegel and transformed into the basis of an entirely new science.

Die Kategorie der Totalität, die allseitige, bestimmende Herrschaft des Ganzen über die Teile ist das Wesen der Methode

In everyday terms: "facts" such as the unemployment rate, share prices or wages can each be measured separately. For Lukács, however, such facts show what they are only when placed as moments of the whole process of capitalism. The empirical scientist's habit of gathering facts one by one in fact accepts at face value the appearance capitalism itself produces. The idea connects with the second of Marx's Theses on Feuerbach, the thesis that whether thought has objective truth is a practical question. For Lukács, knowing history was not observation from outside; it could not be separated from the act that changes history.

Is there dialectics in nature too?

The point where the book clashed most sharply with Soviet philosophy was a footnote. Lukács argued that dialectics must be confined to historical and social reality: "This limitation of the method to historical-social reality is very important."

Diese Beschränkung der Methode auf die historisch-soziale Wirklichkeit ist sehr wichtig.

He went on to criticise Engels for extending dialectics to the knowledge of nature, following Hegel's mistaken example, since the decisive determinations of dialectics, the interaction of subject and object and the unity of theory and practice, are absent from the knowledge of nature. In the same book he wrote that nature, too, is a "social category". He also questioned reflection theory: if, as Engels said, the world is a complex of processes rather than of finished things, "if there are no things, what is 'reflected' in thought?"

Wenn es aber keine Dinge gibt — was wird, im Denken »abgebildet«?

From the standpoint of dialectical materialism this shook the foundation of materialism, the idea that nature exists outside consciousness and is known regardless of human practice. Together with Karl Korsch's Marxism and Philosophy, which appeared the same year, the book opened a current that reread Marxism not as a worldview modelled on natural science but as the theory of revolutionary practice.

Who criticised it, and why?

The criticism came at once. Grigory Zinoviev condemned the book in his opening address to the Fifth Congress of the Comintern in June 1924, and in the same year the Soviet philosopher Abram Deborin published "Lukács and his Critique of Marxism" in the Viennese journal Arbeiterliteratur. The charge was idealism and, politically, ultra-leftism. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy observes that since the book rejected the materialism and scientism endorsed by Soviet party intellectuals, its condemnation by the party orthodoxy was unsurprising.

Around 1925 Lukács wrote a reply to his critics, "Tailism and the Dialectic", but did not publish it. The manuscript lay buried for more than seventy years and appeared only in 1996, leaving open whether his public self-criticisms matched his real views. From the 1930s Lukács left the book out of his work and refused to have it reprinted.

What did the 1967 preface confess?

Lukács wrote a new preface in Budapest in March 1967 and reissued the book in 1968 as the second volume of his German collected works. According to the preface, the turning point came in 1930. Working at the Marx-Engels Institute in Moscow, he read the fully deciphered manuscript of Marx's Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts and began a lifelong friendship with Mikhail Lifshitz. "In reading Marx," he wrote, "all the idealist prejudices of History and Class Consciousness collapsed."

In der Marx-Lektüre brachen alle idealistischen Vorurteile von »Geschichte und Klassenbewußtsein« zusammen.

The errors the preface names can be summed up as three. First, following Hegel, the book equated alienation with objectification in general; Lukács wrote that this "fundamental and crude error" had contributed much to the book's success. This is treated in the entries "Reification" and "Alienation". Second, by treating nature only as a social category, it missed labour, the metabolism between humans and nature. Third, it grasped practice abstractly and idealistically and threw out reflection theory. He now wrote: "Even the most primitive labour, even primitive man's gathering of stones, presupposes a correct reflection of the reality immediately concerned."

Die allerprimitivste Arbeit, schon das Steineauflesen des Urmenschen, setzt eine richtige Widerspiegelung der hierbei unmittelbar in Betracht kommenden Wirklichkeit voraus.

The preface, too, is open to interpretation. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy judges that some of its self-criticisms appear unjustified and externally motivated, while finding real substance in its distinction between objectification and alienation.

What did the book leave behind?

Despite official condemnation and its author's distance, the book did not disappear. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy writes that it had a decisive influence on the early Frankfurt School, and English Wikipedia sums up that it helped to create Western Marxism. In Negative Dialectics (1966) Theodor Adorno called it an "important book" and needled the functionaries who had branded Lukács a heretic over the reification chapter more than forty years earlier, while adding that dialectics cannot be reduced to the single category of reification.

The questions the book raised went on in several directions. The idea that knowledge of society as a whole is tied to a particular social position passed through Lucien Goldmann's sociology of literature into feminist standpoint theory. The dispute over the dialectics of nature recurred in the philosophy of praxis, in the Yugoslav Praxis school, and in East German and Soviet philosophical debates. A Korean edition has appeared under the title 『역사와 계급의식』.

Related people

Sources

  1. archive.org
  2. de.wikipedia.org
  3. Wikipedia (EN)
  4. plato.stanford.edu
  5. archive.org
  6. de.wikipedia.org