avant-garde · 1900s–1930s

Avant-garde

아방가르드

The collective name for the art movements in early twentieth-century Europe and Russia that set out to change not only the forms of painting and poetry but the place art holds in society. The French word for an army's "advance guard" first came to mean the vanguard of politics in the nineteenth century and then passed into art. Futurism, Dada, Surrealism and Constructivism are typical currents: they issued manifestos, moved as groups and picked fights with museums, audiences and tradition. The word is often used as a synonym of modernism, but critics such as the Italian Renato Poggioli, the German literary scholar Peter Bürger and the Romanian-born Matei Calinescu each defined the relation between the two differently.

In depth

"The streets are our brushes": what did the avant-garde set out to do?

On 7 December 1918 the first issue of the weekly Art of the Commune appeared in Petrograd. Published by the fine arts department of the People's Commissariat for Education and edited by Osip Brik among others, it carried on its front page, where an editorial would stand, Vladimir Mayakovsky's poem "Order to the Army of Art". The poem is written as a military order.

"Enough of marching, Futurists, leap into the future!"

Довольно шагать, футуристы,
в будущее прыжок!

After calling for pianos to be dragged into the street and drums to be hauled out of the windows, the poem declares:

"The streets are our brushes. The squares are our palettes."

Улицы — наши кисти.
Площади — наши палитры.

Its last line reads: "To the streets, Futurists, drummers and poets!" Almost everything the word "avant-garde" refers to is in this short poem. The artists saw themselves as a detachment marching ahead. Their enemy was not only old forms but the very condition of art shut up in frames and exhibition halls, and they wanted to drag that art out into streets and squares, into the middle of people's lives. The paper ran until April 1919, and the Futurists used its pages to promote their views on art.

There were similar scenes elsewhere at the same time. In 1915 Kazimir Malevich hung his "Black Square", which represents nothing, in the corner of the room where icons used to hang (see "Russian avant-garde" and "Suprematism"); in 1917 in New York a urinal attributed to Marcel Duchamp, "Fountain", signed "R. Mutt", was submitted to an exhibition (see "Theory of the Avant-Garde"). What ties these scenes together is that they tried to change not the craft or beauty of a single picture but what counts as art and where art belongs.

In this dictionary "avant-garde" means art movements of this kind. They usually had three features. First, they did not merely revise the previous generation; they declared a break with it. Second, they moved not as lone geniuses but as groups that issued manifestos and took names, that is, as "movements". Third, they tried to cross the wall between art and life, art and politics. How one reads this third feature decides how one answers the question of the avant-garde's relation to modernism.

How did a military term become the name of an art?

The French word avant-garde was originally a military term for the reconnaissance unit that scouted the terrain ahead of the main force. During the French Revolution it became a revolutionary metaphor and entered the title of a Jacobin paper in 1794, and from then on the political sense began to push out the military one. In nineteenth-century French politics "avant-garde" meant the left-wing reformers who agitated for radical change in society.

The first to apply the word to artists were the utopian socialists. At the end of Opinions littéraires, philosophiques et industrielles, a book published in 1825, the year Henri de Saint-Simon died, stands a dialogue, "The Artist, the Scientist and the Industrialist". In this text, usually credited to Saint-Simon's disciple, the mathematician Olinde Rodrigues, the artist, one of three men who are to form the new leadership of society, speaks:

"It is we, artists, who will serve as your avant-garde: the power of the arts is indeed the most immediate and the swiftest. We have weapons of every kind."

C’est nous, artistes, qui vous servirons d’avant-garde : la puissance des arts est en effet la plus immédiate et la plus rapide. Nous avons des armes de toute espèce

The artist is to carve new ideas in marble and on canvas and spread them through poetry, song and the stage, standing at the head of social reform. The "avant-garde of art" here did not mean formal novelty but art in the service of political progress. Renato Poggioli cited a passage from the Fourierist Gabriel-Désiré Laverdant's On the Mission of Art and the Role of Artists (1845), which saw art as the forerunner of social progress, to argue that the image of the avant-garde at first remained subordinate, even within art, to the ideals of a radicalism that was political rather than cultural.

Not everyone liked the metaphor. In the notebooks of the 1860s published as My Heart Laid Bare, Charles Baudelaire mocked the French love of military metaphors and wrote:

"Poets of combat. Avant-garde men of letters. These habits of military metaphor betray minds that are not militant but made for discipline, that is, for conformity."

Les poètes de combat. Les littérateurs d’avant-garde. Ces habitudes de métaphores militaires dénotent des esprits non pas militants, mais faits pour la discipline, c’est-à-dire pour la conformité

According to Poggioli, the word began to designate a cultural and artistic avant-garde separately from the political one around the war with Prussia and the Paris Commune of 1870–1871, when for an instant the two avant-gardes seemed to march together; Rimbaud carried the insurgents' weapons during the Commune. In 1885 the French critic Théodore Duret gave a collection of art criticism the title Critique d'avant-garde. In Russia the artist and critic Alexandre Benois, reviewing an exhibition in the spring of 1910, divided the painters into an avant-garde, a centre and a rearguard, and ironically called a group of young Moscow painters around Mikhail Larionov the "avant-garde". According to the art historian Irina Vakar, the name took hold only many years later.

Is the avant-garde of art the same word as the vanguard of politics?

It is the same word. In French, in Russian (авангард) and in German (Avantgarde) the "avant-garde" of art and the "vanguard" of a revolutionary party are one word. Korean usually separates them, rendering the political sense as jeonwi ("vanguard", "vanguard party") and the art movements as abangareudeu. This entry is about the art movements.

The idea of a political vanguard ran long through Marxism. The Communist Manifesto defined the communists as follows:

"The Communists, therefore, are practically the most resolute and ever-advancing section of the working-class parties of every country, and theoretically they have the advantage over the rest of the proletariat of insight into the conditions, the course and the general results of the proletarian movement."

… der entschiedenste, immer weitertreibende Teil der Arbeiterparteien aller Länder; sie haben theoretisch vor der übrigen Masse des Proletariats die Einsicht in die Bedingungen, den Gang und die allgemeinen Resultate der proletarischen Bewegung voraus.

In What Is to Be Done? (1902) Lenin put the word at the centre of his theory of party organisation. Criticising the journal of the "economists", he wrote:

"It is not enough to call ourselves the 'vanguard', the advance detachment; we must act so that all the other detachments see and are obliged to admit that we are marching ahead."

Мало ведь назвать себя «авангардом», передовым отрядом, — надо и действовать так, чтобы все остальные отряды видели и вынуждены были признать, что мы идем впереди.

In the same passage Lenin mocked his opponents: "Do they not perhaps confuse the word vanguard with the word rearguard?" The Marxism-Leninism that followed understood the communist party as the "vanguard of the working class". Lenin's argument that workers left to their own efforts reach only trade-unionist consciousness justified the party's claim to leadership, and was later criticised as grounding a dictatorship of the party over the workers.

Because the avant-garde of art and the vanguard of politics came from the same root, they attracted each other but often clashed. The Russian Futurists greeted the October Revolution as the revolution of their own art, and in January 1927 five French Surrealists, among them André Breton and Louis Aragon, joined the French Communist Party. Yet the party that claimed to be the political vanguard often did not welcome artists' claims to march ahead of the masses. Poggioli observed that Russian Marxist criticism nearly always condemned the avant-garde en bloc, and that, aware of the appeal the word held for radical rhetoric, it avoided the term and used names such as "bourgeois art" instead. Only exceptionally, he thought, did someone like Trotsky, ideologically but not culturally orthodox, leave concrete criticism.

How does the avant-garde differ from modernism?

The two words often refer to the same works, but the boundary moves a great deal depending on the criterion. There are roughly four usages.

The first treats the words as synonyms. Academic dictionaries and encyclopaedias commonly identify them, and Russian-language surveys of the debate note that opinions on their relation range from complete opposition to complete interchangeability. When the American critic Clement Greenberg in "Avant-Garde and Kitsch" (1939) called "avant-garde" the art that rejected the artifice of mass culture and withdrew into its own medium, the painters he named, Picasso, Braque, Mondrian and Kandinsky, are those usually classed as modernists today.

The second is the Italian critic Renato Poggioli's Teoria dell'arte d'avanguardia (book 1962, English translation The Theory of the Avant-Garde 1968). He treated the avant-garde not as a style but as a social and psychological form, the "movement", and divided the attitudes that make it up into four: activism, the joy of movement for its own sake; antagonism towards the public and tradition; nihilism, which delights in tearing down every barrier; and agonism, which accepts even its own ruin as a sacrifice to future movements. He traced the roots of the avant-garde to nineteenth-century Romanticism and treated everything from Symbolism to Futurism and Dada broadly as avant-garde. For Poggioli the avant-garde and modernism were not two sharply separate things but different faces of the same modern art.

Poggioli drew a political conclusion too. Avant-garde art, he held, can exist only in a society that is liberal-democratic politically and bourgeois-capitalist socio-economically. In Soviet Russia the avant-garde vanished most abruptly because the communists had cut their ties to the previous society more thoroughly than any other regime; the same thing happened, less radically, in Fascist Italy, Nazi Germany and Franco's Spain. He agreed with left-wing critics that the relation existed, but added that it need not be subjected to any value judgment, positive or negative.

The third is the German literary scholar Peter Bürger's Theory of the Avant-Garde (1974), which drew the sharpest line. For him modernism renews form within an "autonomous" art detached from life, while the "historical avant-garde" of Dada, Surrealism and the Russian avant-garde attacked the "institution of art" that guarantees that autonomy, trying to sublate art into the practice of life. On this criterion Joyce and Schoenberg are modernists, while Duchamp, who brought a urinal into the gallery, and Mayakovsky, who went out into the street, are avant-garde. Bürger thought the attempt failed, and he criticised the post-war "neo-avant-garde" for bringing avant-garde devices into the institution and so losing their critical force. See "Theory of the Avant-Garde".

The fourth is Faces of Modernity (1977) by the Romanian-born critic Matei Calinescu, who worked in the United States, and its revised version Five Faces of Modernity (1987). The book is a set of "biographies" tracing how the meanings of five words, modernity, avant-garde, decadence, kitsch and postmodernism, have changed. Calinescu held that modernity split in two, the modernity of bourgeois civilisation with its faith in progress, reason and utility, and an aesthetic modernity that since Baudelaire has rebelled against it (the chapters "The Two Modernities" and "Baudelaire and the Paradoxes of Aesthetic Modernity"), and he treated the avant-garde as the most militant face of that aesthetic modernity. He devoted separate chapters to how the word passed in the Romantic era from politics to the politics of culture, and to the attraction and repulsion between the political and the artistic avant-garde.

None of these usages has been settled as the correct one. But when reading the debates of Marxist aesthetics one must always check who means what. The Kafka, Joyce and Beckett whom György Lukács called "avant-gardism" in The Meaning of Contemporary Realism (Wider den mißverstandenen Realismus, 1958) belong to modernism by Bürger's criterion. Soviet art scholarship until the late 1980s grouped modernism and the avant-garde together as "anti-realism". For the modernist side see "Modernism (arts)", and for the social experience it answered see "Modernity".

What did the avant-garde demand in Russia and the Soviet Union?

The Russian avant-garde artists did not call themselves "the avant-garde". They were called Futurists, Suprematists, Constructivists or "left" artists. The Left Front of the Arts (LEF), in which former Futurists gathered around Mayakovsky from late 1922, regarded itself as the only true representative of revolutionary art and competed for that place with the proletarian writers' groups.

Their demands went beyond changing the subject matter of art. The LEF theorist Nikolai Chuzhak put forward the theory that "art is life-building" (iskusstvo — zhiznestroenie), which reduced the artist's function to the production of "things". The call of "Production art" and "Constructivism (art)" to design fabrics, furniture, posters and houses instead of painting pictures pointed the same way. In "Order No. 2 to the Army of the Arts" (1921) Mayakovsky told artists to throw away rhymes, arias and rose bushes, and ended:

"Comrades, give us a new art, one that will drag the republic out of the mud."

Товарищи,
дайте новое искусство —
такое,
чтобы выволочь республику из грязи.

How these demands ended is told in "Russian avant-garde". The Central Committee resolution of 1932 dissolved the independent art groups, "Socialist Realism" became the official method in 1934, and the avant-garde fell under the stigma of "formalism". Poggioli wrote of this ending that Russian avant-gardism died with the suicide of Yesenin and was buried with the suicide of Mayakovsky.

At the end of the 1980s an interpretation appeared that challenged this long-standing narrative head-on. In Gesamtkunstwerk Stalin, first published in German in 1988, the philosopher Boris Groys, who had emigrated from the Soviet Union, argued that there was no break between the Russian avant-garde and the Stalinist regime but a continuity, and that Stalin's politics carried on the aesthetics of the avant-garde in a radical way: the avant-garde's demand to remake the whole of life through art was realised by a regime that organised the whole of society as a single work. This provocative thesis is historically much disputed. How it stands against the narrative of the avant-garde as victim, and against Poggioli's judgment that the avant-garde cannot survive under a totalitarian state, is discussed in "The Total Art of Stalinism"; another reading of the same period through architecture is in "Culture Two".

What currents made up the historical avant-garde, and what came after?

The currents usually counted as the early twentieth-century avant-garde include Cubism, Cubo-Futurism, Vorticism, Constructivism, Suprematism, Dada, Surrealism and Expressionism. This dictionary treats them one by one:

  • German-speaking lands: "Expressionism (art)", from Die Brücke and Der Blaue Reiter to Expressionist theatre and film, and "Bauhaus", the school that sought to unite art, technology and production.
  • Italian and Russian Futurism: "Futurism (Italy)", which glorified speed, machines and war and joined hands with Fascism, and "Russian Futurism", which broke language apart and welcomed the revolution.
  • In the midst of war and revolution: "Dada", begun in Zurich in 1916, which mocked meaning itself, and "Surrealism", which championed dreams and the unconscious and drew close to and then away from the Communist Party.
  • Russia and the Soviet Union: Malevich's "Suprematism", Tatlin's and Rodchenko's "Constructivism (art)", and "Russian avant-garde", which surveys the whole.

The avant-garde did not always stand on the left. Scholars have drawn attention to the ties that leading avant-garde figures such as the Italian Futurist Marinetti, the American poet Ezra Pound and the Englishman Wyndham Lewis formed with authoritarian politics and fascism. In post-revolutionary Mexico, the mural movement fused art with political agitation.

After the Second World War the devices of the avant-garde were taken up by museums and the market. Bürger saw this as the problem of the neo-avant-garde, and Guy Debord in The Society of the Spectacle (1967) criticised the absorption of the avant-garde into a commodity of capitalism. The "Situationist International", founded in 1957 by a handful of small avant-garde groups, set out to go beyond the revolutionary attempts of Dada and Surrealism. The debate from the 1960s on about whether an avant-garde is still possible and what comes after it is discussed in "Postmodernism".

Related people

Sources

  1. ru.wikisource.org
  2. Wikipedia (RU)
  3. Wikipedia (RU)
  4. Wikipedia (EN)
  5. Wikipedia (EN)
  6. Wikipedia (RU)
  7. Wikipedia (EN)
  8. archive.org
  9. Wikipedia (EN)
  10. monoskop.org
  11. fr.wikisource.org
  12. aladin.co.kr
  13. de.wikipedia.org
  14. leninism.su
  15. Wikipedia (EN)
  16. it.wikipedia.org
  17. Wikipedia (EN)
  18. cca.qc.ca
  19. goodreads.com
  20. Wikipedia (RU)
  21. Wikipedia (RU)
  22. Wikipedia (EN)
  23. ru.wikisource.org
  24. de.wikipedia.org
  25. Wikipedia (EN)
  26. fr.wikipedia.org
  27. Wikipedia (EN)
  28. Wikipedia (EN)
  29. Wikipedia (EN)
  30. Wikipedia (EN)
  31. Wikipedia (EN)