Theory of the Avant-Garde
아방가르드의 이론 (뷔르거)
A book published in 1974 by the German literary scholar Peter Bürger. It defined the "historical avant-garde" of the early twentieth century, Dada and Surrealism among it, not as a new style but as an attack on the "institution of art" itself, an attempt to reunite art with the praxis of life. That attempt failed, Bürger argued, but it revealed what function the autonomy of art performs in bourgeois society; and he criticised the post-war neo-avant-garde for taking avant-garde devices into the institution and so stripping them of their critical force.
In depth
When a urinal entered the gallery, what was under attack?
In April 1917 an ordinary porcelain urinal was submitted to the first exhibition of the Society of Independent Artists in New York. It was signed "R. Mutt". This is Fountain, the readymade attributed to Marcel Duchamp. It has neither beauty nor craftsmanship, yet art historians and theorists of the avant-garde count it as a major landmark of twentieth-century art. Why? Because what the urinal attacked was not a particular style of painting but the very frame, exhibitions, museums and signatures, that decides what counts as art.
Peter Bürger's Theory of the Avant-Garde gave this "frame" a name. He characterised the avant-garde movements of the first half of the twentieth century as an attack on the "institution of art", aimed at merging art with the praxis of life. Published in 1974 as a paperback in Suhrkamp's series, the book became one of the most important works of the decade and is still debated today.
How does the avant-garde differ from modernism?
Avant-garde and modernism are often used interchangeably. Bürger separated them. For him avant-gardism rejects the institution of art and challenges social and artistic values, and so necessarily involves political, social and cultural factors. Experimenting with new and difficult forms does not by itself make a work avant-garde. Following this distinction, the composer and musicologist Larry Sitsky classes Schoenberg, Webern and Stravinsky as modernist composers who do not qualify as avant-gardists.
This avant-garde intention showed itself above all in the production of "inorganic" works. Unlike the organic work, in which parts and whole blend seamlessly, such works leave their seams showing. This invites comparison with the "Expressionism debate", where Lukács condemned the montage of avant-garde literature as formalism that merely mirrors a heterogeneous, disconnected reality.
What is the autonomy of art, and why is it a problem?
For Bürger, the function of art as an institution in bourgeois society is determined by the principle of autonomy. As art detaches itself from the praxis of life, it becomes able to oppose society, but for that very reason it surrenders its ability to act on society. A painting in a museum, however sharply it criticises society, cannot touch reality once it is enjoyed as "art". The institution of art neutralises the political content of the individual work.
This view connects with earlier critical theory. In "On the Affirmative Character of Culture" (1937) Herbert Marcuse wrote that autonomous art lets people taste happiness only through beauty and so compensates for real misery (see "The Aesthetic Dimension"). Theodor W. Adorno prized art's autonomy as the ground of its antithesis to society (see "Aesthetic Theory (Adorno)"). Bürger, a follower of Adorno's critical theory, held that autonomy should not be taken as a given but analysed as an institution that arose in history. At the same time he criticised Adorno for excluding Brecht and Sartre because of his theoretical verdict against committed literature.
Did the avant-garde fail?
Bürger's conclusion is double. The avant-garde failed in its aspiration to unite art and life: the urinal ended up in the museum as a costly work of art. Yet Bürger granted the avant-garde the place of a fundamental break in the development of modern art. Its historical importance lies in having made visible the normative frame of art as an institution and its decisive influence on the social import of artworks. After the avant-garde, aesthetic theory cannot take the autonomy of art for granted, but must analyse the function each individual work performs in bourgeois society precisely by virtue of that autonomy.
What made the book famous was its sharp critique of the post-war neo-avant-garde, which, Bürger argued, institutionalised avant-garde strategies and thereby divested them of their original critical substance. From a completely different starting point from Mikhail Lifshitz, who in The Crisis of Ugliness criticised post-war modern art for becoming an object of speculation on the art market, Bürger too took issue with revolt absorbed by the institution.
Who wrote it, and how has it been read?
Bürger was born in Hamburg in 1936, took his doctorate at Munich in 1959 and his habilitation at Erlangen in 1970. In 1971 he was appointed one of the first professors at the University of Bremen, teaching Romance literature, and he died in Berlin in 2017. He was a follower of Adorno's critical theory and counted among the leading sociologists of art and culture in West Germany. Before this book he wrote French Surrealism (1971); later works included On the Critique of Idealist Aesthetics.
Theory of the Avant-Garde is still a standard reference for distinguishing the avant-garde from modernism. Its verdict on the neo-avant-garde has also drawn replies: in Neo-Avantgarde and Culture Industry (2000) the art historian Benjamin H. D. Buchloh argued for a dialectical approach to the political stances of avant-garde artists. Compared with Clement Greenberg, who in "Avant-Garde and Kitsch" (1939) saw the avant-garde as the last bastion of autonomous art, the same word here names almost the opposite.