Socialist Realism
사회주의 리얼리즘
The official creative doctrine of the Soviet Union, first proposed in 1932 and adopted at the First Congress of Soviet Writers in 1934. Its core principle required 'a truthful, historically concrete depiction of reality in its revolutionary development,' mandating that art serve the building of socialism and the ideological education of working people. Spanning all genres (painting, literature, music, sculpture, film), it functioned as the dominant aesthetic regulating cultural production in the USSR and aligned socialist states from the Stalin era through the late Perestroika period.
In depth
Establishing the doctrine
Socialist Realism was proposed in 1932 and formally adopted at the First Congress of Soviet Writers in 1934. Its adoption ran together with the process by which the 1932 resolution "On the Restructuring of Literary and Artistic Organizations" dissolved the existing literary groups and established a single Writers' Union. Organizational unification and the establishment of an aesthetic doctrine were one operation.
The core formulation required a truthful, historically concrete depiction of reality in its revolutionary development. The point of the formulation is that the demand for truthfulness extends beyond depicting reality to indicating the direction of its development: not only present facts but the future growing within them were to be shown.
Working criteria
In practice the doctrine operated through several working criteria. Party-mindedness required that a work accord with the party's political standpoint; popular character required forms the mass audience could understand; typicality required that individual characters represent social types. A requirement of the positive hero operated alongside, so that the resolution of conflict and the presentation of prospects entered the structure of narrative.
These criteria had the effect of excluding experimental form. That is why the denunciation of formalism proceeded in the same years, and after 1936 the anti-formalism campaign functioned as the enforcement of the boundaries of Socialist Realism.
Spread and dissolution
The doctrine spread through the USSR and the allied socialist states and became the standard regulating creative work in every genre: painting, literature, music, sculpture, and film. Reception differed from country to country, and Yugoslavia formally abandoned the doctrine in the 1950s.
Interpretation widened during the thaw after Stalin's death. Works treating inner life and the conflicts of everyday experience became possible, and through the 1960s and 1970s the formal maintenance of the doctrine coexisted with an actual diversification of practice. In the glasnost period of the late 1980s it lost its official standing.
Assessment divides. A view that treats the doctrine as an apparatus of political control over art stands against one that treats it as a movement in twentieth-century art with specific aesthetic achievements, the latter taking in particular the painting, film, and architecture of the 1930s as material for reassessment.
What exactly was the official definition?
The term "socialist realism" was first put forward by Ivan Gronsky, chairman of the organising committee of the Soviet Writers' Union, in Literaturnaya Gazeta on 23 May 1932, and Gronsky and Valery Kirpotin, head of the Central Committee's literature section, spread it widely in 1932–1933. The statute of the Writers' Union adopted at the First Congress of Soviet Writers in 1934 defined it as follows: socialist realism, as the basic method of Soviet literature and literary criticism, demands of the artist a truthful, historically concrete depiction of reality in its revolutionary development, and this truthfulness and historical concreteness must be combined with the task of ideologically remoulding and educating the working people in the spirit of socialism. This definition became the starting point of all interpretations until the 1980s.
Социалистический реализм, являясь основным методом советской художественной литературы и литературной критики, требует от художника правдивого, исторически-конкретного изображения действительности в её революционном развитии.
At the same congress Andrei Zhdanov tied the method to the writer's task: "Comrade Stalin has called our writers 'engineers of human souls'." He explained that this title means above all depicting reality "in its revolutionary development", and, breaking with the old romanticism, included as part of the method a romanticism that shows the future: "only it is a romanticism of a new type, revolutionary romanticism."
Where did party-mindedness and narodnost come from?
Each of the principles supporting the doctrine had an earlier history. Party-mindedness came from Lenin's "Party Organisation and Party Literature" of 1905. In 1947 the Great Soviet Encyclopedia wrote that the principles of socialist realism were a further development of Lenin's teaching on the party-mindedness of literature (see this dictionary's entry "Party-mindedness in literature"). Narodnost was a concept handed down from nineteenth-century Russian criticism, and in official textbooks it meant literature that ordinary people could understand and that used the people's turns of speech and proverbs (see this dictionary's entry "Narodnost"). To these two principles were added ideological content and historical concreteness.
Before the doctrine settled there were struggles with several currents of the 1920s. Proletkult, which rejected the classical heritage, the Russian avant-garde and the Left Front of the Arts, which sought to move art into production, vulgar sociology, which reduced works to class interests, and Russian formalism, which looked only at the form of works, all became targets of criticism. The defence of classical realism by Mikhail Lifshitz and György Lukács in the 1930s overlapped with this doctrine without being the same as it (see this dictionary's entry "Literaturny Kritik and the 'Current'").
What were the criticisms, then and later?
Criticism came from the time the doctrine was settling. Leon Trotsky, in exile, wrote in a letter of June 1938, published that year in the American journal Partisan Review, that in official Soviet painting realism was an imitation of provincial daguerreotypes of the mid-nineteenth century, and its "socialist" character lay in depicting events that never happened with the techniques of posed photographs. He said: "The art of the Stalinist epoch will remain the most graphic expression of the profoundest decline of the proletarian revolution."
Искусство сталинской эпохи останется наиболее наглядным выражением глубочайшего упадка пролетарской революции.
During the Thaw criticism came from within the Soviet Union too. The writer Andrei Sinyavsky, in the essay "What Is Socialist Realism?", published in the West under the pseudonym Abram Tertz, argued that the style actually had nothing to do with "real" realism and was a Soviet version of classicism. In the 1960s a major debate broke out over proposals within the Western European communist parties to widen the bounds of realism to include modernism (see this dictionary's entry "1960s Soviet modernism debate").
From the late 1980s interpretations appeared that asked afresh about the relation between socialist realism and the avant-garde. In The Total Art of Stalinism (1988) the émigré Soviet philosopher Boris Groys read socialist realism not as a retreat to mass taste but as the party's taking over and realising the avant-garde's demand that art remake the whole of life: where Trotsky saw the decline of the revolution, Groys saw the fulfilment of the avant-garde project. In Culture Two (1985) the architectural historian Vladimir Paperny modelled the culture of the 1930s to 1950s as a "Culture Two" that hardened in the direction opposite to the "Culture One" of the 1920s. The two interpretations are treated in "The Total Art of Stalinism" and "Culture Two".
Related terms
Related people
Related historical events
Sources
- Wikipedia (RU) Russian Wikipedia: comprehensive article on history, characteristics, principles and definition of Socialist Realism as the official artistic method of the USSR
- Wikipedia (EN) English Wikipedia: development, characteristics, and history of Socialist Realism as official cultural doctrine from 1932 to 1988
- Wikipedia (RU)
- Wikipedia (RU)
- hist.msu.ru
- korean.go.kr
- culturematters.org.uk
- monoskop.org
- books.yandex.ru
- Marxists Internet Archive