Пролеткульт · 1917–1932

Proletkult

프롤레트쿨트

A mass proletarian cultural-educational organization that existed from the Russian Revolution through the early Soviet period. A portmanteau of 'proletarskaya kultura' (proletarian culture), it rested on Alexander Bogdanov's theory that the working class must create a distinct class culture independent of bourgeois cultural heritage. At its peak in 1920, Proletkult counted roughly 84,000 members across 300 local branches plus 500,000 casual participants, but its demand for autonomy from the state brought it into conflict with the Party and Narkompros. Lenin's criticism and the November 1920 Central Committee resolution subordinated it to the People's Commissariat of Education, after which it declined; it was formally dissolved by the April 1932 CC resolution "On the Restructuring of Literary and Artistic Organizations".

In depth

Bogdanov's theory

Proletkult is a contraction of proletarian culture, and the organization rested on the theory of Alexander Bogdanov. His argument was that it was not enough for the working class to take power in politics and the economy: it had to create for itself a culture of its own class, distinct from the bourgeois inheritance. What characterizes the theory is that autonomous development in the cultural field is set as a task equal in standing to political revolution.

Organizational autonomy followed from this view. Because proletarian culture forms through the creative activity of workers themselves rather than through direction by state or party, cultural organization had to be independent of state institutions.

Scale and work

The organization grew quickly after the revolution. At its peak in 1920 it had some 84,000 members in 300 branches with around half a million casual participants, and it ran literary circles, theatre companies, art workshops, and publishing. Direct participation by workers in creative work was the core of its activity.

Results were most visible in literature and theatre. Work by poets of worker origin was published, theatre activity spread at factory level, and many of the forms of mass participation that later Soviet cultural policy addressed were first attempted in this period. Internal argument continued at the same time over what the content of proletarian culture was to be.

Conflict with the party

The demand for autonomy became the cause of conflict. Lenin criticized the view that a proletarian culture could be constituted without inheriting the achievements of earlier culture and argued that cultural work belonged under the direction of the People's Commissariat of Education. His long-standing philosophical opposition to Bogdanov also bore on the criticism.

A Central Committee resolution of November 1920 subordinated Proletkult to the education commissariat. The organization lost funding, staff, and influence afterwards, and it was formally dissolved by the Central Committee resolution "On the Restructuring of Literary and Artistic Organizations" of April 1932.

The questions Proletkult raised did not disappear. Whether the culture of a new society is an inheritance from or a break with what preceded it, and whether the subject of cultural creation is the professional artist or the mass itself, returned repeatedly in later phases of Soviet cultural policy and in twentieth-century debates in cultural theory.

What did Lenin demand of Proletkult in 1920?

At the First All-Russian Congress of Proletkult, held in Moscow in October 1920, the Bolshevik faction remained in the minority. The People's Commissar of Education Anatoly Lunacharsky was reported as saying in his speech to the congress that Proletkult must be guaranteed a special position and "complete autonomy". Lenin, seeing this report, at once wrote the draft resolution "On Proletarian Culture" (8 October 1920). Its core was this: "Marxism has won its historic significance as the ideology of the revolutionary proletariat because, far from rejecting the most valuable achievements of the bourgeois epoch, it has, on the contrary, assimilated and refashioned everything of value in the more than two thousand years of the development of human thought and culture."

Марксизм завоевал себе свое всемирно-историческое значение как идеологии революционного пролетариата тем, что марксизм отнюдь не отбросил ценнейших завоеваний буржуазной эпохи, а, напротив, усвоил и переработал все, что было ценного в более чем двухтысячелетием развитии человеческой мысли и культуры.

The draft went on to reject both attempts to invent a separate "culture of one's own" and autonomy within the Commissariat of Education, and defined Proletkult organisations as auxiliary bodies of the Commissariat. This line was fixed by the Central Committee resolution "On the Proletkults" of 10 November 1920 and the Central Committee letter printed in Pravda on 1 December. Lunacharsky later recalled that he had deliberately given an evasive and conciliatory speech at the congress and had been sharply reprimanded by Lenin.

How did other Bolsheviks see it?

Opinion within the party was not single either. Lunacharsky tried to shield Proletkult, while Leon Trotsky held in Literature and Revolution that a "proletarian culture" as such could not come into being: the dictatorship of the proletariat was a short transition, and what would follow was the culture of a classless humanity. Aleksei Gastev, an ideologist of Proletkult, later founded the Central Institute of Labour to study the scientific organisation of work. From about 1922 Proletkult's activity withered, and its place was taken by various associations of proletarian writers and artists.

The questions Proletkult raised also carried over into other currents. The experiments of the Russian avant-garde, production art and the Left Front of the Arts, which sought to move art into production and everyday life, quarrelled with Proletkult but shared its concern with a break from the old culture. Conversely, the socialist realism of the 1930s and the defence of the classical heritage by Lifshitz and Lukács continued the "inheritance" side put forward in Lenin's 1920 draft.

Related people

Sources

  1. Wikipedia (RU) full history: founding (September 1917 conference), peak membership (80,000 in 1920), Bogdanov/Gastev/Pletnev ideology, 1920 CC subordination, 1932 dissolution resolution
  2. Wikipedia (EN) English-language confirmation: 84,000 members/300 branches/500,000 casual at peak (1920), Bogdanov-Lenin conflict, Narkompros relationship, Kerzhentsev quotation on independent proletarian culture
  3. Wikipedia (RU)
  4. ru.wikisource.org
  5. hist.msu.ru