Erkenntnistheorie / epistemology (그리스어 ἐπιστήμη 지식 + λόγος 논의) / гносеология, теория познания · Concept

Epistemology

인식론

The branch of philosophy that asks what we can know, how we come to know it, and what entitles us to say that we know. It studies the nature, sources and limits of knowledge. Rationalism and empiricism divide over the sources of knowledge, scepticism and agnosticism over its limits, and Marxist epistemology treats cognition as a process within social practice.

In depth

What question does epistemology answer?

The display at the bus stop says "arriving in 3 minutes". You believe a bus is coming, and three minutes later one comes. Did you know it was coming? Suppose the display had broken and was showing yesterday's figure, and it happened to be right. Your belief turned out true, yet calling it knowledge feels wrong. As soon as we ask which news to trust, why a scientific experiment is more reliable than a hunch, or how we know the sun will rise tomorrow, we are doing epistemology.

Epistemology asks three main things. What is it to know? Where does knowledge come from? Are there limits to what we can know? This entry surveys the positions on these questions and points to the entries that treat each in detail.

What is it to know?

Plato's dialogue Theaetetus is among the oldest texts to take up the question directly. Near its end Theaetetus recalls something he once heard: "true belief accompanied by an account is knowledge".

τὴν μὲν μετὰ λόγου ἀληθῆ δόξαν ἐπιστήμην εἶναι

From this came the standard modern definition. To know something is to believe it, for the belief to be true, and to be justified in holding it ("justified true belief"). The bus display goes to the weak point of that definition. In a three-page paper of 1963 the American philosopher Edmund Gettier presented cases of belief that is justified and happens to be true but cannot be called knowledge. The "Gettier problem" then became a central topic of Anglo-American epistemology.

What justification is remains disputed. Asked why you believe it will rain tomorrow, you cite the forecast. Asked why you trust the forecast, you cite the weather service's observations. Somewhere this questioning must stop. Foundationalism holds that beliefs are stacked like a building, with basic beliefs at the bottom justified without the help of any others. Coherentism holds that beliefs support one another like a net, with no bottom layer.

Another division concerns whether justification is settled inside one's head. Internalism holds that the believer must be able to cite grounds on reflection. Externalism holds that it is enough for the process producing the belief to be reliable in fact. Someone with accurate vision knows the tree in front of her with no idea how vision works. This position is called reliabilism, and it is also used as an answer to scepticism.

Where does knowledge come from, and how far does it reach?

You know what you ate this morning by memory, whether you are hungry now by introspection, whether it is raining by looking, what 2 plus 2 makes by reasoning, and the distance to the moon by reading it. Epistemology thus lists perception, introspection, memory, reason and testimony as sources of justification. The position that any of them can err, so that knowledge is never certain, is called fallibilism.

The great dispute of modern philosophy concerned the source of knowledge. Rationalism, represented by Descartes, Spinoza and Leibniz, grounded knowledge in rational inference and innate ideas. Its strong case was mathematics, whose theorems are proved by thought and not by any amount of measuring. Empiricism, running through Bacon, Locke, Berkeley and Hume, held that all knowledge comes from sensory experience. Locke compared the mind to a sheet of blank white paper.

In the Critique of Pure Reason (1781) Kant tried to join the two camps: "Though all our cognition begins with experience, it does not on that account all arise from experience."

Wenn aber gleich alle unsere Erkenntnis mit der Erfahrung anhebt, so entspringt sie darum doch nicht eben alle aus der Erfahrung.

Frameworks such as space, time and cause and effect belong to our own cognitive faculty, and we order experience through them. The price was a boundary: we know only what appears, and the thing-in-itself cannot be known.

Are there limits to what we can know? Scepticism tests the very possibility of knowledge. How do you know you are not dreaming now? The ancient Pyrrhonists set an equally strong counterclaim against every claim, suspending judgement in order to reach peace of mind. Agnosticism says something narrower: what lies beyond experience (God, ultimate reality) cannot be known. The English biologist Thomas Huxley coined the word in the nineteenth century.

Is knowledge gained alone? How does Marxist epistemology differ?

These disputes usually assume an individual sitting alone and looking at the world. Today social epistemology studies how knowledge arises and passes within communities, naturalised epistemology draws on the methods and findings of the empirical sciences to explain knowledge, and feminist epistemology asks how gender affects it.

Marx had shaken that assumption long before, in the Theses on Feuerbach: "The question whether objective truth belongs to human thinking is not a question of theory but a practical question."

Die Frage, ob dem menschlichen Denken gegenständliche Wahrheit zukomme - ist keine Frage der Theorie, sondern eine praktische Frage.

People do not only watch the world. They change it by working, producing and fighting, and cognition arises within that activity and is tested by it. In Ludwig Feuerbach and the End of Classical German Philosophy Engels made the question of which comes first, thinking or being, the basic question of philosophy, divided philosophers into the two camps of materialism and idealism, and answered the agnosticism of Hume and Kant with experiment and industry. In Materialism and Empirio-criticism (1909) Lenin systematised this line against Mach and Bogdanov. From it came reflection theory, for which sensation and consciousness reflect a reality outside consciousness, an account of truth for which our knowledge is relative yet approaches objective truth, and practice as the criterion of cognition. He insisted that knowledge not be taken as ready-made: "In the theory of knowledge, as in every other field of science, one must think dialectically."

В теории познания, как и во всех других областях науки, следует рассуждать диалектически

What was disputed within this tradition?

Disputes continued inside Marxist epistemology. The notes Lenin himself later made while reading Hegel put far more weight on the activity of cognition. In the 1920s USSR the mechanists, who sought to reduce philosophy to natural science, faced the Hegel-trained Deborinites. The Deborinites won in 1929 but were pushed aside in 1930–1931 under the charge of "Menshevizing idealism". In 1947 Zhdanov, on the party's commission, led a philosophical discussion of Alexandrov's History of Western European Philosophy, and the journal Questions of Philosophy was founded the same year.

In the Thaw Ilyenkov and Lifshitz worked together on the ideal, and Lifshitz later set out reflection theory at length in Dialogue with Ilyenkov. In East Germany Georg Klaus brought modern logic and cybernetics into philosophy.

The Western critique went deeper. In Marxism and Philosophy (1923) Korsch attacked as an abstract, metaphysical dualism the treatment of consciousness as a mere reflection of material process. In History and Class Consciousness Lukács objected that Engels mistook experiment and industry for practice in the dialectical sense. Althusser insisted on a break between science and ideology (the epistemological break). Feminist standpoint theory from the 1970s developed the idea that social position shapes what one can see, and Sandra Harding argued for "strong objectivity", the notion that the perspectives of the oppressed can help create more objective accounts of the world.

Where should I start reading?

If you want to ask See
Is the basis of the world matter or mind? Materialism, Idealism, the basic question of philosophy
Does knowledge come from reason or from experience? Rationalism, Empiricism
Can we really know anything? Scepticism, Agnosticism, Thing-in-itself
How does cognition reflect the world and how is it tested? reflection theory, the criterion of practice, objective, relative and absolute truth
What was Lenin fighting? Materialism and Empirio-criticism, Empirio-criticism, Empiriomonism
Where do the forms of thought come from? Dialectics, Dialectical logic, The Ideal (Ilyenkov)
How are society and knowledge entangled? base and superstructure, ideology, Reification, Critical Theory

Related people

Sources

  1. Wikipedia (EN)
  2. raw.githubusercontent.com
  3. Wikipedia (EN)
  4. plato.stanford.edu
  5. Wikipedia (EN)
  6. Wikipedia (EN)
  7. gutenberg.org
  8. gutenberg.org
  9. Wikipedia (EN)
  10. mathcs.clarku.edu
  11. web.archive.org
  12. web.archive.org
  13. leninism.su
  14. de.wikipedia.org
  15. Wikipedia (EN)
  16. Wikipedia (EN)
  17. Wikipedia (RU)
  18. Wikipedia (RU)
  19. Wikipedia (EN)
  20. Wikipedia (RU)
  21. Marxists Internet Archive
  22. Marxists Internet Archive