Menshevizing Idealism
멘셰비키화하는 관념론
An ideological stigma coined by Stalin in 1930. It targeted the Deborin school for allegedly divorcing theory from practice, equating Hegelian and Marxist dialectics, and underestimating Lenin's philosophical contribution. Deborin lost the editorship of the journal Under the Banner of Marxism at the end of 1930, and after the Central Committee resolution on that journal of 25 January 1931 he was also removed from the leadership of the Institute of Philosophy, with the Mitin–Yudin alliance installed as the new leadership of Soviet philosophy. The label functioned as a political purge disguised as philosophical debate, marking the watershed moment when Soviet philosophy was forcibly realigned into Stalinist doctrine.
In depth
The Deborin school
Soviet philosophy in the 1920s was structured by a dispute between two currents. On one side the mechanists sought to reduce philosophy to a generalization of natural science; on the other the dialecticians around Deborin stressed the materialist appropriation of Hegelian dialectics. Until 1929 the Deborin school held the upper hand in this dispute and controlled the Institute of Philosophy and the principal journals. Deborin himself had been a Menshevik from 1907 to 1917, joined the All-Union Communist Party only in 1928, and was elected a full member of the Academy of Sciences in 1929. Colleagues and pupils such as Nikolai Karev, Jan Sten, Ivan Luppol and Boris Hessen were the polemicists of the "dialecticians".
What characterized the school was making the systematic study of Hegel's logic the foundational work of Marxist philosophy. The approach treated philosophy as a relatively autonomous theoretical field and did not require a direct connection to immediate political tasks.
The turn of 1930
In 1930 a new generation of philosophers attacked the Deborin school. The criticism led by Mitin and Yudin advanced three charges: separation of theory from practice, identification of Hegelian with Marxist dialectics, and underestimation of Lenin's philosophical contribution. When Stalin supplied the name menshevizing idealism the criticism became the official line.
The name itself compresses the structure of the dispute. Idealism was the charge against the study of Hegel, while menshevizing was a political charge against an attitude that separated theory from practice. In combining the two, a difference of philosophical position was converted into a matter of political deviation.
What happened over the year 1930?
The starting point was Stalin's speech "Concerning Questions of Agrarian Policy in the USSR" to the conference of Marxist agrarians in December 1929. Stalin said that theory was lagging behind the successes of practice. Asked whether philosophy too was lagging, Deborin said no, but the party bureau of the philosophy department of the Institute of Red Professors, led by Mitin and Yudin, who had just graduated from it, said yes and demanded a sharp turn on the philosophical front. From the spring of 1930 people from the party Central Committee intervened in the debate, Emelyan Yaroslavsky first among them.
On 7 June 1930 Pravda printed an article by the three authors Mitin, Raltsevich and Yudin with a note saying that "the editors agree with the basic propositions of this article". This "article of the three" became the turning point of the debate. The Deborinites answered with an "article of the ten" warning against dissolving philosophy in the political slogans of the day. The enlarged session of the Presidium of the Communist Academy, held from 17 to 20 October, turned in effect into an all-Moscow meeting and was the climax of the debate. Around then a resolution of the Institute of Red Professors labelled the Deborinites' views a "formalist deviation".
On 9 December 1930 Stalin met the bureau of the party cell of the Institute of Red Professors of Philosophy and Natural Science. No transcript was ever published, but from what the participants reported it became known that Stalin had named the Deborinite current "menshevizing idealism". According to a Soviet history of philosophy, Stalin explained that "menshevizing" meant that the separation of theory from practice cultivated by Menshevism had revived in Deborin and his pupils, and "idealism" that they had brought Hegel's idealist dialectics close to Marx's materialist dialectics. He set the task of raking over everything the Deborinites had written. A resolution of the cell bureau on 29 December followed this up, rewriting the label "formalist deviation" as too academic and vague: the formalist distortion of materialist dialectics was in essence an idealist revision of Marxism. On 1 January 1931 Mitin gave a report "On the Results of the Philosophical Discussion", saying that just as the god Deborin had been overthrown on the philosophical front, so the god Isaak Rubin had been overthrown in political economy.
The decree and its effects
After the Central Committee decree of 25 January 1931, On the Journal Under the Banner of Marxism, Deborin was removed from the leadership of the Institute of Philosophy (he had already given up the editorship at the end of 1930, remaining only on the editorial board), and the leadership of Mitin and Yudin was established. The decree named as the journal's most important task the elaboration of the Leninist stage of dialectical materialism and merciless criticism of all anti-Marxist, and therefore anti-Leninist, positions in philosophy, the social sciences and the natural sciences, however masked, and told it to develop materialist dialectics in close connection with the practice of socialist construction and world revolution. With this decree the name "menshevizing idealism" became an official verdict. Mitin was the journal's editor-in-chief from 1931 to 1944. Deborin himself kept his academy membership after self-criticism but lost influence, and several members of the school were arrested during the 1930s. Karev was expelled from the party in 1933, exiled to Ufa in 1935, rearrested in May 1936 and shot on 11 October 1936. Sten was shot on 20 June 1937. Luppol and Hessen too were arrested and lost their lives, and even Raltsevich, co-author of the "article of the three", was later arrested and died. Deborin survived, working in the Academy of Sciences from 1935, and died in 1963.
The episode changed the character of Soviet philosophy. The task of philosophy was redefined as supplying philosophical grounds for the party line, and with the establishment of Dialectical and Historical Materialism as the standard text in 1938 the space for dispute disappeared altogether. Hegel scholarship contracted for decades and recovered only in part after the late 1950s. The Deborin affair is treated as a case of political removal conducted in the form of a philosophical debate.
How is it assessed?
The official Soviet view long regarded the criticism as a legitimate philosophical struggle. The Short Philosophical Dictionary of 1954 stated that the menshevizing idealists denied Leninism as the creative development of Marxism and also rejected the thesis of the partisanship of philosophy. The 1971 Short Outline of the History of Philosophy gave as an example Deborin's statement in Lenin as a Thinker (1926) that Marxism was a philosophical, historical and economic theory, while Leninism was Marxist politics and tactics.
Research since perestroika sees it differently. The historian of philosophy Alexander Ogurtsov (1989) wrote that it was not a matter of deepening philosophical research or raising its theoretical level but of the "bolshevization of philosophical theoretical work", that is, a course of complete politicisation of theory, turning it into the ideology of an authoritarian power and driving out the older philosophers. Yehoshua Yakhot (1991) saw the aim of the anti-Deborin campaign as the Stalinisation of philosophy: by the end of 1929 Stalin had made himself the sole authority in political struggle, but ideological fields such as literature, philosophy and political economy still lay outside his direct control. Yakhot also relates that after Stalin's death Anastas Mikoyan repeatedly asked philosophers what "menshevizing idealism" meant and never received an intelligible answer. Batygin and Devyatko (1993) summed up that the defeat of 1931 opened a whole period in the history of Soviet philosophy and set up a new philosophical leadership, the Mitin–Yudin alliance.
Related terms
Related people
Sources
- Wikipedia (RU) Russian Wikipedia: full definition, Stalin's coinage in 1930 conversation with Institute of Red Professorship party bureau, the 25 January 1931 CC VKP(b) resolution, and the political nature of the campaign
- Wikipedia (EN) English Wikipedia: definition, Stalin's authorship, and core charges (identifying Marxist dialectics with Hegel's, divorcing theory from practice, underestimating Lenin)
- Wikipedia (EN)
- Wikipedia (RU)
- Wikipedia (RU)
- Wikipedia (RU)
- Wikipedia (RU)
- Wikipedia (RU)
- scepsis.net
- scepsis.net