Boris Mikhailovich Hessen

Борис Михайлович Гессен
Soviet Union state institutions Marxism–Leninism Soviet Union Russia 1893.8.28.–1936.12.20. ✕ Executed

The Marxist historian of science who revealed the socio-economic roots of Newton's mechanics; first dean of MSU physics

In London 1931, Hessen quoted Pope from the podium — 'God said, Let Newton be! and all was light' — then countered: Newton's Principia was no act of divine revelation but a product of 17th-century commerce, industry, and war. The hall stirred.

Soviet physicist and historian of science. His 1931 London paper demonstrating that Newton's mechanics was shaped by 17th-century technical and economic needs inaugurated the externalist tradition in the sociology of science. First dean of MSU's physics faculty and a key defender of relativity and quantum mechanics within Soviet philosophy.

Also known as: Gessen

Activities and affiliations

Career Timeline

Related historical events

Philosophical Defense of Modern Physics: The Struggle for Relativity and Quantum Mechanics

Though best known as a historian of science, Hessen devoted half his working life to defending relativity and quantum mechanics within the framework of Soviet philosophy. His 1928 book The Basic Ideas of the Theory of Relativity was both an accessible introduction to Einstein and a brief for the theory against charges of 'bourgeois idealism.' In a long preface to the Russian translation of Arthur Haas's Matter Waves and Quantum Mechanics (1930), he went further, arguing that the probabilistic character of quantum mechanics did not contradict dialectical materialism's concept of causality but rather represented a higher form of causality that had overcome mechanistic determinism.

This was not abstract philosophy but an existential struggle. Moscow University physicist Arkady Timiryazev and philosopher Aleksandr Maksimov denounced relativity and quantum mechanics as 'reactionary science in the service of imperialism' and demanded a return to a Newtonian worldview. Hessen represented Soviet theoretical physicists, above all his close friend Igor Tamm, in resisting these attacks, striving to persuade both colleagues and Party authorities that the new physics was not merely compatible with dialectical materialism but mutually enriching. In 1931 his outdated article on 'ether' in the Great Soviet Encyclopedia drew a famous mocking letter from a group of young Leningrad theorists, Landau, Gamow, Bronstein, Ivanenko and others, who illustrated their note with bottles labeled 'Ether' and 'Phlogiston.' They treated Hessen as a relic, yet he was the more consistent defender of the new physics in the Soviet Union. By the mid-1930s this philosophical front had acquired lethal political stakes, and Hessen himself would not escape them.

The Socio-Economic Roots of Newton's Mechanics: The 1931 London Paper and Its Transformation of the History of Science

In June 1931, at the Second International Congress of the History of Science held at London's Science Museum, Hessen, a member of the Soviet delegation led by Nikolai Bukharin, delivered 'The Socio-Economic Roots of Newton's Principia.' The paper changed the course of the history of science.

Hessen's thesis was clear and provocative. Newton's mechanics was not the isolated product of pure genius but a response to the technical demands of 17th-century English commercial capitalism: ephemerides for ocean navigation, pumps for mine drainage, ballistics for artillery, hydrodynamics for canal construction. Tracing the physical themes of the Principia one by one to contemporary technical problems, Hessen argued that the content of science itself is rooted in the material conditions of production. This was a direct challenge to the tradition, dominant since Whewell, of treating the history of science as a genealogy of great individuals.

The lecture deeply influenced a generation of younger scholars including Joseph Needham, J.D. Bernal, and Robert K. Merton, and became the founding moment of the 'externalist' tradition in the sociology of science, the approach that explains scientific content through its socio-economic context. Hessen embedded a further strategic argument in the paper: if Newtonian physics, born of bourgeois conditions, was indisputably valid science, then relativity and quantum mechanics could not be dismissed merely as 'bourgeois science.' More than eighty years after his death, the paper remains an indispensable classic in debates over the methodology of the history of science.

Last Years, Execution and Rehabilitation

Hessen became a corresponding member of the USSR Academy of Sciences on 1 February 1933 and, from the creation of Moscow University's physics faculty until December 1934, was its first dean. On 22 June 1934 he spoke at the Institute of Philosophy's session on the twenty-fifth anniversary of Lenin's Materialism and Empirio-Criticism. From 1935 he was both director of the university's physics research institute and deputy director of the Lebedev Physical Institute. Alexander Pechenkin counts him among the authorities on the ensemble side of quantum mechanics, a current that leads into the "Soviet debate on the interpretation of quantum mechanics".

On 22 August 1936 he was arrested on charges of belonging to a counter-revolutionary terrorist organisation and preparing terrorist acts. On 20 December the Military Collegium of the USSR Supreme Court sentenced him to be shot, and the sentence was carried out the same day. The school teacher A. O. Apirin, arrested two months earlier in the same case, was also shot. The Academy expelled him posthumously on 29 April 1938. The Military Collegium rehabilitated both men on 21 April 1956, and the Academy restored his standing on 5 March 1957.