A Soviet European who excavated dialectical logic from Marx's Capital
“Idealism is not the elementary error of a naive schoolboy imagining a ghost. Idealism is a speculative interpretation of the objectivity of the ideal form — the fact of its existence in the space of human culture, independent of the will and consciousness of individuals.” — Dialectics of the Ideal, 1976
The most original thinker in Soviet Marxist philosophy. He formalized the dialectical method of ascent from the abstract to the concrete as the core logic of Marx's Capital, and argued in his landmark 1962 article 'The Ideal' that ideal forms exist objectively in culture, language and signs, not as products of individual brains, igniting a lasting philosophical controversy. His ideas provided the foundation for V.V. Davydov's developmental education theory and for Meshcheryakov's Zagorsk experiment in deaf-blind education. His magnum opus Dialectical Logic (1974) expanded Marxist dialectics from epistemology into a philosophy of culture and mind.
Activities and affiliations
-
1950–1979
Soviet Communist Party and Bolsheviks
Ideology and propaganda -
Soviet Union state institutionsIdeology and propagandaMain
Ideology and propaganda
Career Timeline
- 1942–1945Artillery lieutenant, 1st and 2nd Belorussian Fronts, fought to Berlin
- 1950Graduated Moscow University philosophy faculty with distinction; aspirantura
- 1953Researcher, Institute of Philosophy, USSR Academy of Sciences (for life)
- 1955Banned from teaching at Moscow University for 'Hegelianism'
- 1960Published The Dialectics of the Abstract and the Concrete in Marx's 'Capital'
- 1962Published 'The Ideal' in the Philosophical Encyclopedia
- 1968Defended doctoral dissertation; published On Idols and Ideals
- 1974Published magnum opus Dialectical Logic: Essays in History and Theory
Related historical events
The Gnoseological Theses Affair of 1954–1955
Ilyenkov joined the dialectical materialism sector of the Institute of Philosophy of the USSR Academy of Sciences in November 1953 and stayed there for life; he also taught in the philosophy faculty of Moscow University. In April 1954 he and Valentin Korovikov put out theses, "On the interconnection of philosophy and knowledge of nature and society in the process of their historical development". They argued that philosophy cannot solve the problems of the special sciences in their place and can only be a theory of knowledge. The formula of the theses reads: "philosophy is the science of scientific thought, of its laws and forms."
«философия есть наука о научном мышлении, о его законах и формах»
A discussion of the theses was held that May, and the circle of Alexander Zinoviev, Grushin, Shchedrovitsky and Mamardashvili took final shape about this time.
In February and March 1955 a commission of the Central Committee's department of science and culture inspected the faculty. Its report judged the theses a "relapse into the long-since routed Menshevizing idealism condemned by the party".
«рецидив давно разгромленного и осуждённого партией меньшевиствующего идеализма»
The faculty's academic council took up the theses on 25 and 29 March, and the two were accused of Hegelianism. Korovikov received a party reprimand and was dismissed from the university; Ilyenkov had to give up teaching. His post at the Institute of Philosophy, however, remained. At the core of the dispute was whether to narrow philosophy's object to the theory of knowledge or to establish dialectical materialism as an ontology, and his opponents later called his position "gnoseologism". The Italian Communist leader Togliatti defended him, and his first article, on the dialectics of the abstract and the concrete, appeared in Italian in 1955.
The Book on Capital: Cut by More Than a Third
In 1956 Ilyenkov wrote a manuscript titled "The dialectics of the abstract and the concrete in scientific-theoretical thought". In preparing it for publication the leadership of the Institute of Philosophy demanded corrections, and the manuscript shrank by more than a third. The book appeared in 1960 from the Academy of Sciences publishing house with its title changed as well. Its argument is set out in the entry "The Dialectics of the Abstract and the Concrete in Marx's Capital". He became a senior researcher in 1961, and the same year the institute sent him to work on the draft Programme of the CPSU, in the subgroup on questions of science and public education.
"The Ideal" in the Philosophical Encyclopedia and the 1960s
In the first half of the 1960s Ilyenkov wrote for the Philosophical Encyclopedia, and in the second volume, as editor of the dialectical materialism section, he published seven articles at once. "The Ideal" appeared in that volume in autumn 1962. Its meaning is treated in the entry "The Ideal (Ilyenkov)". In August and September 1964 he attended the International Hegel Congress in Salzburg. In 1965 the Presidium of the USSR Academy of Sciences gave him the Chernyshevsky Prize "for a cycle of works on the history and theory of dialectics".
«за цикл работ по истории и теории диалектики»
In 1968 he published On Idols and Ideals with Politizdat, and on 26 November that year he defended his doctoral thesis.
The Zagorsk Experiment: Deaf-Blind Education and the Formation of Mind
The most dramatic practical embodiment of Ilyenkov's philosophy took place at the Zagorsk boarding school for deaf-blind children near Moscow (now Sergiev Posad). Founded in 1963 by Alexander Meshcheryakov on the tradition of Ivan Sokolyansky's typhlosurdopedagogy, the school sought to answer a fundamental question: could children who lost both sight and hearing develop full human consciousness and personality? Ilyenkov provided the philosophical foundation for Meshcheryakov's work, and from the early 1970s he participated directly in the experiment.
In 1971, Meshcheryakov selected four graduates of the boarding school (Alexander Suvorov, Yuri Lerner, Natalia Korneeva, and Sergei Sirotkin) to undertake higher education at Moscow University's psychology faculty. Known as the 'Zagorsk experiment' and supported by Dean Alexei Leontiev, the project ran from 1972 to 1977. The four deaf-blind students completed a full psychology curriculum using specially designed Braille and tactile materials, mediated by dedicated teachers. Ilyenkov went beyond theoretical advice: he led seminars and, after Meshcheryakov's death in 1974, informally took over the mentorship of the four students.
The experiment was an empirical test of Ilyenkov's core philosophical thesis: that the human mind is not spontaneously generated inside individual brains, but formed socio-historically through cultural tools, signs, and joint activity. The fact that children born without sight and hearing could, with adequate educational mediation, develop full consciousness powerfully vindicated Ilyenkov's theory that the 'ideal' exists not as a product of individual psychology but as an objective form of culture. All four students earned their psychology degrees; Suvorov went on to earn a doctorate in psychology, becoming the world's only deaf-blind psychologist. The experiment drew international attention as a unique case in which Soviet philosophy, psychology, and pedagogy combined to address a fundamental problem of human development.
Dialectical Logic and the Last Years
In 1974 Ilyenkov published Dialectical Logic: Essays in History and Theory. Its arguments are treated in the entry "Dialectical Logic". From 1975, at the invitation of Dean Alexei Leontiev, he led a scientific seminar in the psychology faculty of Moscow University. The Dialectics of the Ideal, written in spring 1976, did not appear in Russian in his lifetime. In his last years he thought much about imagination and creative fantasy.
He took his own life on 21 March 1979 after a long depression. The manuscript he left came out the next year as Leninist Dialectics and the Metaphysics of Positivism. In 1980 Mikhail Lifshitz began a text setting out their differences, and this dialogue continues in "Ilyenkov-Lifshitz debate on the ideal".