agnosticism (Huxley 1869) / Agnostizismus / агностицизм (그리스어 ἀ + γνῶσις) · Concept

Agnosticism

불가지론

The position that what lies beyond experience, especially the existence of God or the ultimate nature of the world, is unknown or unknowable. The word was coined by Thomas Huxley in 1869. In everyday use it mainly concerns religion, but in Marxist philosophy it names theories of knowledge, such as Hume's and Kant's, that limit the possibility of knowing the world.

In depth

What question does agnosticism answer?

If you answer the question "Do you believe in God?" with "I don't know, and I think no one can", you are close to an agnostic. Theism, which asserts that God exists, and atheism, which asserts that God does not, both claim more than the evidence supports. This not-knowing about religion is what people usually mean by agnosticism.

In philosophy, however, the question is broader. What if all we can know is the phenomena before us, and what lies behind them can never be known? How could I check that my senses convey the world correctly, when I have no yardstick other than the senses? So agnosticism is a problem of theology and of epistemology alike.

Why did Huxley coin the word?

The English biologist Thomas Henry Huxley championed Darwin's theory of evolution and was called "Darwin's bulldog". Among the philosophers and theologians gathered at the Metaphysical Society in London in 1869, he felt that everyone else was some sort of "-ist" while he alone lacked a name. As he later recalled, he made up a new word by twisting the ancient Gnostics (the "knowers").

So I took thought, and invented what I conceived to be the appropriate title of "agnostic."

For him agnosticism was not a creed but a method: do not put forward as certain any conclusion that lacks logical support. Herbert Spencer, at about the same time, built a system meant to reconcile science and religion, calling the ultimate reality behind phenomena "the Unknowable".

The name was new but the thought old. Hume distrusted inference about what lies beyond experience, and Kant, dividing phenomena from the thing-in-itself, said that God, the soul and the world as a whole cannot be objects of cognition. By this, he declared, he meant to "make room for faith". This is the difference between agnosticism and scepticism. Scepticism doubts even everyday knowledge, whereas agnosticism accepts knowledge of the phenomenal world that science deals with and draws its line beyond that.

How did Engels criticise agnosticism?

Engels took the word out of theology and put it on the map of philosophy. In Ludwig Feuerbach he treats the question of whether thought can know being as the other side of the basic question of philosophy, and names Hume and Kant as those who deny the possibility of knowing the world, or at least of knowing it exhaustively. His answer points not to argument but to practice: "The most telling refutation of this, as of all other philosophical crotchets, is practice, namely experiment and industry."

Die schlagendste Widerlegung dieser wie aller andern philosophischen Schrullen ist die Praxis, nämlich das Experiment und die Industrie.

If we can make a natural process ourselves, as alizarin, the red dye once obtained only from the madder root, came to be synthesised from coal tar, then our knowledge of that process is proved right. The Copernican system too was a hypothesis for three hundred years, until Le Verrier calculated the position of Neptune and Galle actually found it.

In the introduction to the English edition of Socialism: Utopian and Scientific (1892) he went a step further for his British readers.

What, indeed, is agnosticism, but, to use an expressive Lancashire term, "shamefaced" materialism? The agnostic's conception of Nature is materialistic throughout.

The agnostic too holds that all of nature is governed by law and excludes intervention from without, adding only that the existence of a Supreme Being beyond it can be neither proved nor disproved. To doubts whether we know things as they are, Engels replied that people acted before they argued, and that in using things we put our senses to the test.

Why did Lenin take issue with agnosticism?

Materialism and Empirio-criticism places agnosticism midway between materialism and idealism. Lenin writes: "We materialists, following Engels, call the Kantians and Humeans agnostics, because they deny objective reality as the source of our sensations."

Мы, материалисты, вслед за Энгельсом, называем кантианцев и юмистов агностиками за то, что они отрицают объективную реальность как источник наших ощущений.

For him agnosticism was a wavering between materialism and idealism, in practice between materialist science and clericalism. His wariness was that as soon as one admits a point where knowledge stops, the place passes to faith. He also divided the critics of Kant into left and right. The materialist grants the thing-in-itself and says it can be known, while the Machist abolishes it and moves further toward agnosticism. He criticised Helmholtz's "theory of symbols" in the same context: if sensations are only signs and not copies of things, the door to agnosticism opens.

This criticism has been answered within Marxism itself. In the section "The Antinomies of Bourgeois Thought" in History and Class Consciousness Lukács corrected Engels, calling it a misreading of Kant's epistemology to treat the thing-in-itself as a barrier to the expansion of knowledge. Kant built his theory on Newtonian astronomy, and his critique is that even complete knowledge of all phenomena would still be only knowledge of phenomena. Lukács adds that Kant himself dealt with agnosticism and Hume in the Refutation of Idealism. Huxley's agnosticism too, far from demeaning science, stood with science and took aim at the doctrines of the Church.

What does agnosticism mean today?

Today the word mainly concerns religion. Philosophers separate strong agnosticism, "it can never be known", from weak agnosticism, "for now there are no grounds to decide". Because Lenin's broad sense differs from the narrow everyday one, readers of Marxist literature should note that the word there concerns not matters of faith but the limits of cognition in general.

Related people

Sources

  1. Wikipedia (EN)
  2. Wikipedia (EN)
  3. mathcs.clarku.edu
  4. web.archive.org
  5. gutenberg.org
  6. web.archive.org
  7. leninism.su
  8. Wikipedia (RU)
  9. Wikipedia (EN)
  10. gutenberg.org
  11. Marxists Internet Archive
  12. leninism.su