Basis und Überbau · 1859–present

Base and superstructure

토대와 상부구조

Marx's metaphor likening society to a building. The sum of the relations people enter into in production forms the economic structure of society, the "base"; on it rises a legal and political "superstructure", to which definite forms of consciousness correspond. The classic statement is the 1859 preface to A Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy, and in his last years Engels added in letters that the economy determines not as the only cause but "in the last instance". How far this is a metaphor and how far a causal explanation is still disputed within and beyond Marxism.

In depth

Why compare society to a building?

Ask why an age has the laws and morals it has. In medieval Europe it was lawful for a lord to make serfs perform labour services; today that is illegal. Is that because people have become kinder? Marx's answer is to look first at how the people of that society make their living. A society working the land as lords and serfs and one working in factories for wages need different laws and different morals.

Base and superstructure is a metaphor putting this thought as a picture of a building. The economy stands below, law and politics rise on it, and forms of consciousness such as religion and philosophy are paired with them. It proposes to turn over the old belief that ideas move the world, and it serves as a research rule: when explaining ideas and institutions, first look for the relations of production that give rise to them and sustain them.

What exactly did Marx write?

The classic passage is in the 1859 preface to A Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy. Marx presented it as the "general result" of his studies, the thread that guided them. "The sum total of these relations of production forms the economic structure of society, the real basis, on which rises a legal and political superstructure and to which definite social forms of consciousness correspond."

Die Gesamtheit dieser Produktionsverhältnisse bildet die ökonomische Struktur der Gesellschaft, die reale Basis, worauf sich ein juristischer und politischer Überbau erhebt und welcher bestimmte gesellschaftliche Bewußtseinsformen entsprechen.

Immediately after comes the sentence most often quoted in connection with the theory of knowledge. "It is not the consciousness of men that determines their being, but, on the contrary, their social being that determines their consciousness."

Es ist nicht das Bewußtsein der Menschen, das ihr Sein, sondern umgekehrt ihr gesellschaftliches Sein, das ihr Bewußtsein bestimmt.

The details differ from later textbooks. Marx's superstructure is "legal and political", and forms of consciousness are noted separately as "corresponding" to it. When developing productive forces collide with the old relations of production, he adds, an "epoch of social revolution" begins, and people become conscious of this conflict and fight it out in the ideological forms of law, politics, religion, art and philosophy. So ideas are recognized as a field of battle. Where the metaphor ends and the theory of social change begins is best read together with "Historical materialism".

Why did Engels have to explain himself in his last years?

After Marx's death young socialists often applied the formula mechanically, and critics attacked the theory for seeing only the economy and treating everything else as shadow. In his last years Engels returned to the problem in several letters. On 21 September 1890 he wrote to Joseph Bloch: "According to the materialist conception of history, the ultimately determining moment in history is the production and reproduction of real life. More than this neither Marx nor I have ever asserted."

Nach materialistischer Geschichtsauffassung ist das in letzter Instanz bestimmende Moment in der Geschichte die Produktion und Reproduktion des wirklichen Lebens.

The same letter says that anyone who twists this into the claim that the economic moment is the only determining one turns it into a "meaningless, abstract, absurd phrase", and admits that Marx and he were partly to blame when the young laid too much weight on the economic side: they had to stress the main principle their opponents denied, and there was not always time, place or opportunity to do justice to the other moments in the interaction. A letter to Borgius of 25 January 1894 is plainer still: "It is not that the economic situation is the cause, alone active, and everything else only passive effect."

Es ist nicht, daß die ökonomische Lage Ursache, allein aktiv ist und alles andere nur passive Wirkung.

Citing protective tariffs and state finances acting back on the economy, he summed up that interaction takes place on the ground of an economic necessity that asserts itself in the last instance.

How was it used in the Soviet Union and China?

Plekhanov and Kautsky of the Second International adopted a broad model that put art and philosophy too into the superstructure. Plekhanov divided the layers further with social psychology as a link between the economic base and the "higher" ideologies. Bernstein read Engels's letters as a flexible theory admitting many non-economic factors; Antonio Labriola criticized such a "theory of factors" for breaking living society up into separate forces.

In the Soviet Union the scheme became official doctrine. Stalin's "Marxism and Problems of Linguistics" (1950) held that language is neither base nor superstructure, and defined the superstructure as society's political, legal, religious, artistic and philosophical views and the institutions corresponding to them. Critics read his writing, in which ideas seem to come first and produce institutions, as an inversion of Marx's logic.

Mao moved the relation from another side. On Contradiction (1937) grants that the economic base generally plays the principal and decisive role, then says that under certain conditions matters reverse: "It must also be admitted that aspects such as the relations of production, theory and the superstructure, under certain conditions, turn round and show themselves to play the principal and decisive role." The sentence was later often drawn on for the priority of politics and ideology in the Cultural Revolution, though the essay itself does not deny the general primacy of the economic base.

生产关系、理论、上层建筑这些方面,在一定条件之下,又转过来表现其为主要的决定的作用,这也是必须承认的。

Why did Western Marxists try to revise the metaphor?

Many twentieth-century theorists were uneasy with the layered picture itself. Lukács, Korsch and Gramsci revived the standpoint of "totality", which sees society as one whole rather than as storeys. Gramsci's "historical bloc" described a dialectical unity of economy, politics and culture. Louis Althusser accepted Engels's "last instance" while stressing the relative autonomy of politics and ideology, and spoke of "overdetermination" in the sense that historical events arise from contradictions at several levels at once. For him ideology is not an upper-floor shadow but a practice that reproduces society, a thought continued under "Ideological state apparatus".

In Britain Raymond Williams and E. P. Thompson went further, treating the metaphor as radically defective. Williams criticized it for giving a rigid, abstract, static picture: culture and law are part of production from the start and cannot be split into upper and lower.

There was reconstruction in the opposite direction as well. In Karl Marx's Theory of History (1978) G. A. Cohen formulated the relation as functional explanation. That the superstructure strongly conditions the base does not contradict the claim that the base explains the superstructure: if the superstructure has its present form because that form is useful for maintaining the base, then the direction of explanation lies in the base while the direction of influence can run downward from above. Critics called this reconstruction technological determinism.

How does this connect to the theory of knowledge?

The metaphor is hot in epistemology because it places knowledge in the building too. If social being determines consciousness, one can ask who needs a theory and why before asking whether it is true. But if all knowledge reduces to class position, Marxism itself would be only one class's standpoint, and even the content of the natural sciences would have to be explained by social position. This puzzle receives different answers under "Ideology (Marxism)", "Objective, relative and absolute truth" and "Partisanship in philosophy".

Related people

Sources

  1. mlwerke.de
  2. mlwerke.de
  3. mlwerke.de
  4. mlwerke.de
  5. Marxists Internet Archive
  6. Wikipedia (EN)
  7. de.wikipedia.org
  8. Wikipedia (EN)