Ideologie · 1845–present

Ideology (Marxism)

이데올로기 (마르크스주의)

In Marxism, the inverted consciousness that arises when people's ideas are explained apart from their material situation, or a system of thought expressing the position and interests of a social group. In The German Ideology Marx and Engels said that the ideas of the ruling class are the ruling ideas of an epoch, and in an 1893 letter to Mehring Engels spoke of a "false consciousness" in which a thinker does not know the real motive forces of his own thought. After Lenin it was also used neutrally for a class's worldview in general, hence "socialist ideology". Althusser later redefined it as a practice within institutions.

In depth

Why is "ideology" a problem?

Someone sees a person long out of work and says, "They're just lazy." The speaker believes this is a plain statement of fact. What goes unasked is why that belief is so widespread in that society and whom it benefits. The critique of ideology starts from such questions. It does not only ask whether an idea is true or false; it asks why just that idea looks natural to just those people at just that time.

In everyday use "ideology" often means a political creed, and political camps throw it at one another. This entry covers how the word was used in the Marxist tradition. There is no single fixed meaning, and at least three strands can be told apart.

The origin of the word and The German Ideology

The word is older than Marx. The French philosopher Destutt de Tracy coined it in 1796 for a "science of ideas". Napoleon then disparaged his opponents as "ideologues", attaching the bad sense of idle theorists out of touch with reality.

Marx and Engels took up that critical sense in the 1845–46 manuscript The German Ideology, aiming at the Young Hegelians, who believed that criticizing old ideas would change the world. The two saw this belief as itself the result of mistaking thought for the master of history, and turned it over: "It is not consciousness that determines life, but life that determines consciousness."

Nicht das Bewußtsein bestimmt das Leben, sondern das Leben bestimmt das Bewußtsein.

Comparing it to the inverted image on the retina, they said that if in ideology people and their relations appear "upside down as in a camera obscura", this phenomenon also arises from their historical life process. They saw the inversion not as an individual's mistake but as something produced socially. A camera obscura is a dark box that lets light in through a small hole and casts an inverted image on the opposite wall.

Wenn in der ganzen Ideologie die Menschen und ihre Verhältnisse wie in einer Camera obscura auf den Kopf gestellt erscheinen

Another famous thesis from the same manuscript asks who holds the means of producing ideas. "The ideas of the ruling class are in every epoch the ruling ideas." The class that owns the means of material production also commands the means of mental production.

Die Gedanken der herrschenden Klasse sind in jeder Epoche die herrschenden Gedanken

Whose phrase is "false consciousness"?

Ideology is often summed up as "false consciousness", but Marx never used the phrase. Its source is one passage in a letter from Engels to Franz Mehring of 14 July 1893, ten years after Marx's death. "Ideology is a process accomplished by the so-called thinker consciously, it is true, but with a false consciousness. The real motive forces impelling him remain unknown to him; otherwise it would simply not be an ideological process."

Die Ideologie ist ein Prozeß, der zwar mit Bewußtsein vom sogenannten Denker vollzogen wird, aber mit einem falschen Bewußtsein. Die eigent­lichen Triebkräfte, die ihn bewegen, bleiben ihm unbekannt; sonst wäre es eben kein ideologischer Prozeß.

Read closely, this differs from the usual modern sense. Engels is talking about a "thinker", not a deceived worker. What is wrong is not the whole content of the thought but the thinker's self-understanding of where it comes from: he believes it derives from pure thought while it is actually bound up with social interests. The philosopher Joseph McCarney reads this as one individual's failure of self-awareness. The broader sense, a subordinate class adopting the ideas of the ruling class, was developed by later theorists from the 1920s on.

The epistemological question here is sharp. Does an impure origin make an idea false? Engels's letter does not say so. To expose an ideology is not directly to refute its content but to explain why the thought takes itself to be independent. That separates this critique from an ad hominem attack on someone's background.

Why did Lenin use it positively?

The second strand came from Russian Marxism. Lenin used ideology as a neutral word for a class's worldview, as when What Is to Be Done? sets bourgeois ideology against socialist ideology. Materialism and Empirio-criticism ties the word directly to the problem of truth: "Every ideology is historically conditional, but it is unconditionally true that to every scientific ideology (as distinct, for instance, from religious ideology) there corresponds an objective truth, absolute nature."

исторически условна всякая идеология, но безусловно то, что всякой научной идеологии (в отличие, например, от религиозной) соответствует объективная истина, абсолютная природа.

The sentence is aimed at Bogdanov, who invoked the historical conditioning of every ideology to reject objective truth, while Lenin distinguished historical conditions from the objectivity of truth. Ideology here is not false in itself: some ideologies can be scientific and some cannot. Official Soviet usage followed this road and spoke of "scientific ideology", and the ideological work of socialist states used the word too.

Where did Western Marxism and sociology take it?

The third strand widened the word to the way a whole society works. Lukács in History and Class Consciousness (1923) explained ideological blindness as an effect of the "reification" produced by commodity society. Horkheimer and Adorno carried the critique on and found the sources of this blindness in commodity fetishism and the principle of exchange. For them ideology is less the content of thoughts than the way of thinking produced by social structure.

Karl Mannheim reached a different conclusion in Ideology and Utopia. He saw the Marxist concept of ideology as "total", since it explains an opponent's whole thought by social position, but "special", since it does not apply this to itself, and widened it into a "general" concept covering all thought including Marxism. That squarely raises the question of whether all knowledge is tied to position, and it is one of the starting points of today's sociology of knowledge.

Louis Althusser saw ideology not as an illusion in the head but as a practice carried out in institutions such as schools and churches, discussed in detail under "Ideological state apparatus". From this standpoint the very idea of escaping ideology becomes suspect, and where to draw the line between knowledge and ideology becomes a problem again.

Does the critique of ideology apply to itself?

Anyone using the concept has to face this. Can Marxism expose the social roots of other thought and exempt itself? The answers within the tradition are broadly three. Lenin's road answers that a thought can be class-bound and contain objective truth at once (see "Partisanship in philosophy"). Lukács's road answers that a particular position in history, that of the proletariat, makes it possible to see society as a whole, and later standpoint theory extended this idea to the knowledge of women and subordinated groups. Mannheim's road begins from the tie of all thought to position and looks for a synthesis of perspectives. None has convinced everyone, which is why the concept is still at issue in epistemology.

Related people

Sources

  1. mlwerke.de
  2. mlwerke.de
  3. leninism.su
  4. Wikipedia (EN)
  5. de.wikipedia.org
  6. Wikipedia (EN)
  7. Wikipedia (EN)