Community Wealth Building · 2005–present

Community Wealth Building

커뮤니티 웰스 빌딩

A local-government-led economic development model that transforms local economies by placing communities in direct ownership and control of wealth and assets, structurally addressing economic inequality. It systematically combines redirecting procurement spending of anchor institutions (universities, hospitals, municipalities) into the local economy, adopting living wage policies, fostering cooperatives, and establishing community banking. First articulated by The Democracy Collaborative in the United States in 2005, it gained its most prominent application in Preston, UK, building on the earlier Cleveland Model.

In depth

Framing

Community wealth building starts from the problem that wealth produced in a local economy does not stay there. When large retailers and outside firms transfer revenue out of the area and public procurement is awarded to non-local corporations, the local circulation of income is broken. From this diagnosis, placing the ownership and control of wealth locally becomes the policy objective.

The approach differs from attracting growth. Where development strategies based on inward investment and subsidies depend on the decisions of outside capital, this model starts from redeploying the institutions and assets a place already has.

Components

Four instruments combine. First, shifting the procurement of anchor institutions: large purchasers fixed in place, such as universities, hospitals, and municipalities, create stable demand when they direct procurement to local suppliers. Second, living wage policy, which raises wage standards in the public sector and among contractors and so increases local spending. Third, fostering cooperatives and social enterprises, which places the ownership structure itself locally. Fourth, local banking and public financial institutions, so that credit circulates within the area.

The combination was formulated by The Democracy Collaborative in the United States in 2005, with the Cleveland Model as an early application. Preston in the United Kingdom afterwards applied it systematically at local-government level and became the most widely cited case, using procurement analysis to identify spending that had been leaking out of the area and redirecting it to local suppliers.

Assessment and questions

Assessment of results varies with the indicator. Improvement is reported in direct measures such as the local share of procurement and wage levels, while some assessments find little change in aggregate measures such as employment and poverty. It is also noted that applicability varies considerably with a local authority's fiscal capacity and the scale of its procurement.

The theoretical question concerns the character of the model. A criticism that it is a reform operating inside capitalism and cannot change the structure stands against the reply that, because it turns on altering ownership, it is distinct from simple redistribution. Erik Olin Wright's work on real utopias took the second view and treated the model as a case of a non-capitalist economic form arising inside capitalism. The argument is the contemporary form of the question the free association of producers raised: how the forms of ownership and control are to be designed.

What actually changed in Preston?

In 2012 to 2013 Preston City Council began by turning the purchasing of anchor institutions, such as the council, university, police and housing provider, toward the area. An anchor institution is a large organization that stays and works in a place. Councillor Matthew Brown led this with the Centre for Local Economic Strategies (CLES), drawing on examples from Cleveland in the United States and Mondragon in Spain.

According to results compiled by a Welsh public-policy centre, anchor institutions in 2016/17 spent £74 million more within Preston and £200 million more in Lancashire than in 2012/13. The locally retained share of spending rose from 5 percent to 18.2 percent in Preston and from 39 percent to 79.2 percent in Lancashire. Four thousand more employees earned the Real Living Wage, and unemployment fell from 6.5 percent in 2013 to 3.1 percent in 2017.

The same centre added, however, that there is still little UK evidence on the impact of community wealth building or local procurement. Critics argue that local procurement merely takes a share from other areas, a zero-sum game, and point out that Preston's employment still relies heavily on multinational companies. The leader of the council's Liberal Democrat group called the model a "marketing gimmick".

What was the Cleveland Model?

The Evergreen Cooperatives at the centre of the Cleveland Model are a connected group of cooperatives owned by their workers. Where Preston began by changing the direction of public purchasing, Cleveland put its weight on creating worker-owned enterprises that keep jobs in the area.

How does it fit economic history and political economy?

The model looks new but has a long lineage in Britain. The term municipal socialism runs from the municipalization of gas and water in 1870s Birmingham, through the Fabians who led the London County Council from 1889, to the "new urban left" of the 1980s, such as the Greater London Council, resisting the Thatcher government's curtailment of local powers. The British press has treated Preston as a revival of this current. The Thatcher-era clash shows why such local policy cannot avoid questions of revenue and authority.

Advocates say that growth reliant on exports and outside investment has failed to provide for all communities. Critics reply that this path remains the surest route to prosperity.

The question about the limits of cooperatives is older still. In the Inaugural Address of the International Workingmen's Association in 1864, Marx rated co-operative labour as excellent in principle and useful in practice, but wrote that kept within the narrow circle of the casual efforts of private workmen it would never arrest the growth of monopoly. Co-operative labour therefore "ought to be developed to national dimensions" and fostered by national means. The clash between the criticism of reform within capitalism and the defence that the model alters ownership touches this point.

Related historical events

Sources

  1. Wikipedia (EN) definition, Cleveland/Preston origins, anchor institution mechanism, municipal socialism framing
  2. democracycollaborative.org 2005 articulation by The Democracy Collaborative, five-pillar framework, global movement context
  3. Wikipedia (EN)
  4. wcpp.org.uk
  5. Wikipedia (EN)
  6. Wikipedia (EN)
  7. Marxists Internet Archive