Dialectics without Dogma?
『교조 없는 변증법?』
The book collecting the philosophy lectures given by the East German chemist Robert Havemann at Humboldt University in the winter semester of 1963–64, published in West Germany in 1964. It reread determinism and freedom in the light of modern physics and criticized the official doctrine that philosophy directs science. Soon afterwards Havemann was expelled from the Socialist Unity Party and driven from teaching.
In depth
What question does the book try to answer?
When you throw a die, is the face that will come up already settled? The old textbook materialism tended to hold that everything in the world is strictly fixed by causes. But if everything really is fixed, what does it mean to say we choose? And if society moves to socialism under a law, what is left for people to do except obey the party that claims to know the law?
Robert Havemann brought this question out of the physicist's classroom. He was a communist who had survived a Nazi death sentence, and director of the physical chemistry institute at Humboldt University. From 18 October 1963 to 31 January 1964 he gave 14 lectures and seminar talks under the name "Scientific Aspects of Philosophical Problems". Later the West German publisher Rowohlt issued them, with his Leipzig speech of 1962, as Dialectics without Dogma? Natural Science and Worldview. The question mark in the title holds the point of the book: can dialectics avoid becoming dogma? An enlarged edition appeared in Berlin in 1990.
What did Havemann argue?
The starting point is the relation of philosophy to science. Official doctrine set philosophy above science to direct it. Havemann saw it the other way round. In 1956 he had already said that philosophy had never been the original source of new knowledge, and at the end of his 1962 speech he said that narrowness and sterility in philosophy would be overcome once philosophers too felt the greatest happiness when something was discovered in reality that conflicted with their previous opinions. His bad example was the rejection of Linus Pauling's resonance theory by leading Soviet scientists. They dismissed resonance structures as unreal and hence against materialism; Havemann called this vulgar mechanical materialism.
The central argument comes from quantum mechanics. Where an electron will be found can be stated only in probabilities. Does that mean there is no law? Havemann rejected the old rigid split between determinism and indeterminism and put forward the dialectical connection of chance and necessity. He regarded the Copenhagen interpretation as incomplete too. Here he changed the meaning of the word law: "Laws do not say what really happens and will happen; they only state what can happen."
Die Gesetze besagen also nicht, was wirklich geschieht und geschehen wird, sie geben nur an, was geschehen kann.
Returning to the die, the law tells us that one of the numbers one to six will come up but does not fix the next throw. Carried over to society the logic grows in meaning. The laws of history state the range of what can happen; they do not decide for people what they will do. In this place he set freedom, and he accepted both the spontaneity of human action and a goal-directed aspect of life processes. The former was near taboo in a tradition that put party consciousness first, the latter in a materialism that admitted only causes.
He did not abandon materialism for this. He kept Lenin's definition of matter as objective reality independent of our consciousness, and tried to refine reflection theory rather than discard it. Concepts at first reflect what is useful to us, and as knowledge rises they go beyond that point of view of use. Commentators such as Peter Christian Ludz hold that he remained in essence a supporter of dialectical materialism.
Why was it such a problem?
The course was titled natural science, but the conclusions he drew were political. Havemann argued that socialism could not be realized without democracy, and he stood for freedom of information. Helga Grebing holds that the attempt to bring physics and philosophy into harmony was not itself the stumbling block; in the final dispute Hager too admitted that philosophical problems of natural science had not been handled at the proper level. The clash came from Havemann's consistently extending the discussion to society and party.
The party's criticism had philosophical content too. It charged that Havemann called for "doubt about all the basic positions of our philosophy", leaving the ground of a firm worldview and opening the door to scepticism and agnosticism. In the party's eyes this threatened the basic substance of the doctrine.
How was he driven out?
At the start of February 1964 the Socialist Unity Party attacked the lectures sharply. On 6 March Havemann talked with the West German lawyer Karl-Heinz Ness, and the record appeared on 11 March in a Hamburg paper in the form of an interview. Havemann denied the interview form. On 12 March an extraordinary meeting of the Humboldt University party organization resolved on his expulsion, on the ground that "under the flag of the struggle against dogmatism" he had departed from the line of Marxism-Leninism. The same day the state secretariat for higher education withdrew his right to teach. Grebing's study gives 13 March for the expulsion. The difference may be between resolution and announcement, but this could not be established.
Kurt Hager summed the matter up in a speech to the Politburo's Ideological Commission on 19–20 March, printed in issue 4 of Einheit for 1964. The fellow philosopher Wolfgang Heise was relieved that year of his post as vice-rector for defending Havemann. In December 1965 Havemann was also dismissed from the Academy's photochemistry research group, and on 1 April 1966 his name was struck from the Academy's list of members. From then on he lived as a legal oppositionist speaking through the West German press.
How is it judged?
In West Germany the book was read as a document of reform Marxism inside the East German system. Grebing judges Havemann's criticism immanent as such: he attacked how dialectical materialism was used, not its validity. Taken as philosophy, as the Hegel-Institut study remarks, their overall design has a positivistic tendency, so that the positive references to Hegel seem surprising at first.
A further fact casts a shadow over the judgement. A 2005 study by the federal Stasi records agency shows that from 1946 to 1963 Havemann worked with the KGB, the Stasi and East German military intelligence, and under the code name "Leitz" supplied information incriminating others, up to the very year these lectures began. That the author of the lectures that became a symbol of dissent had been an informer for the system until just before does not refute the book's arguments, but it does make one reread the road by which he came there.