gender abolitionism · 1970–present

Gender abolition

젠더 폐지론

Gender abolitionism names positions holding that the division into men and women is itself a form of oppression, so the aim is not to equalise the gender hierarchy but to abolish the distinction. In The Dialectic of Sex (1970) Shulamith Firestone set the goal of feminist revolution as the elimination not just of male privilege "but of the sex distinction itself"; the French materialist feminists Monique Wittig and Christine Delphy treated "women" and "men" as classes created by oppression that must disappear along with it. Today the phrase points in opposite directions. Gender-critical feminists see gender as oppressive norms imposed on biological sex and would abolish gender while keeping sex. Trans Marxists and family abolitionists target the family and labour regimes that enforce gender, in the name of "gender freedom". Some trans writers call abolitionism a threat to trans lives.

In depth

Where does the idea of "abolishing gender" come from?

Its roots are in 1970s radical and materialist feminism. Firestone traced women's subordination to the biological division of humans by reproductive role and set the goal of revolution as

not just the elimination of male privilege but of the sex distinction itself

so that genital differences would no longer matter culturally; she imagined a "cybernetic communist" society in which artificial wombs would free women from childbearing (see "Sex Class"). Wittig held that "women" and "men" are classes that exist only within heterosexuality as a political regime, and that, as there are no slaves without masters, the class "women" will disappear once the class "men" disappears. Delphy, arguing that gender precedes sex and that anatomy is only the marker of a division created by oppression, concluded that revaluing the feminine or equalising the gendered division of labour was not enough: the principle of division into two groups, gender itself, had to be attacked and "non-gender" imagined (see "Materialist feminism"). English-language writers also place in this lineage "postgenderism", which would use technology to remove the limits of sex, and the "xenofeminism" of the mid-2010s.

The Marxist counterpart is family abolition. Answering the charge that communists wanted to abolish the family, Marx and Engels wrote in the Communist Manifesto that the bourgeois family rests on capital and private gain and will vanish with capital (Chapter II of the site's Korean translation).

How do gender-critical feminists use the phrase?

Gender-critical feminism emerged from fringe currents of second-wave radical feminism, mainly in the United States, and gained global prominence in the 2010s and 2020s. For it, "gender" is a system of social norms that oppresses women on the basis of their sex. Women's oppression is rooted in being female; sex is biological and cannot be changed. Gender, meaning sex roles and stereotypes, should therefore be abolished, while sex is a reality to be defended. The American writer Lierre Keith described femininity as "ritualized submission" and gender as "not an identity but a caste position", and argued that theories of gender identity are an obstacle to the abolition of gender. The philosopher Holly Lawford-Smith summed up the focus of the position:

Gender critical feminism is not 'about' trans. It is about sex.

Defending "sex-based rights" and women-only spaces becomes the central task. Janice Raymond's The Transsexual Empire (1979) is counted a classic of the lineage. Critics argue that the current rejects transgender and non-binary identities and returns to biological essentialism. The label "TERF" (trans-exclusionary radical feminist) was popularised in 2008 by the blogger Viv Smythe; it began as a neutral shorthand, but those it names say it is used to "denigrate women's ideas" and prefer "gender critical".

How do trans Marxists and family abolitionists read it differently?

For those who theorise trans liberation in Marxist terms, "abolition" is also a key word, but with another meaning. In Family Abolition: Capitalism and the Communizing of Care (2023) M. E. O'Brien analyses the family as a "private household, a unit of privatized care" and argues that "so long as the private household is maintained, no revolutionary process can overcome class society." Abolition here is the Hegelian-Marxist Aufhebung: not simply destroying the family but preserving what is crucial to it, love, connection and care, while freeing these from the particular form of the household. The book reads Marx and Engels as family abolitionists but criticises their picture of what comes after the bourgeois family as universal heterosexual monogamy. Sophie Lewis's Abolish the Family (2022) belongs to the same current. This current targets not the defence of biological sex but the family and labour regimes that enforce and reproduce gender norms, and often names its aim "gender freedom", as in the title of Michelle O'Brien's essay in Transgender Marxism (see "Transgender Marxism").

The same phrase thus serves one side as grounds for rejecting trans identities and the other as the horizon of trans liberation.

What criticism has come from trans writers?

The transfeminist Julia Serano argued that the goal of an "end of gender" harms transgender people: they are held up as "undermining the gender system" on one hand and criticised for reinforcing gender stereotypes on the other. Feminism, she argued, should fight for the "end of sexism" rather than the "end of gender", and she asked: "Who gets to decide what is gender and what is not?" The philosopher Matthew J. Cull examined several formulations of gender abolitionism and argued that they are uniformly transphobic and imperil trans lives.

Related people

Sources

  1. Wikipedia (EN)
  2. fr.wikipedia.org
  3. Wikipedia (EN)
  4. Wikipedia (EN)
  5. spectrejournal.com
  6. theanarchistlibrary.org
  7. fr.wikipedia.org
  8. Wikipedia (EN)
  9. Wikipedia (EN)
  10. tempestmag.org
  11. Wikipedia (EN)